Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an unfair bill split?

241 replies

Willow39 · 30/01/2024 21:03

Hi all.
I am a full time student who is also working full time. I earn £1200pm after tax. I'm a trainee teacher and have to work as a TA full time during my course so I'm stuck for options work wise.

My partner and I have just moved into an apartment with rent of £1300pm. Bills are circa £400pm so £1700 all in to run it. The flat is nothing special and price is because we are in London.

I contribute £800 which is just under 50% of everything, leaving me £75 a week disposable income after my personal bills.

However, my partner earns significantly more than me at circa £3000pm

I'm in a sticky situation where I agreed to this bill share when we moved in and now I'm really left in the shit. I can just about pay for fuel and food for the week if I'm careful.

I have tried to bring this up to him and he just gets angry saying that I'm going back on everything and that it's my fault that I chose to go to university and take my career path. He told me I should get a second job to support myself but I can't manage even more hours on top of one full time job and full time university...

Any advice on how to handle it with him?

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 16:29

I would start looking for a cheaper house share for when your lease is up.

The OP isn’t on the lease, she could leave tomorrow and live anywhere else she wants to.

What do you plan to do, @Willow39 ? Is it September 26 you would begin to earn a teacher salary? Is it a 3 year course?

Daisy12Maisie · 31/01/2024 16:27

I thought the nail thing was really unkind. I don't get my nails done but considering it stops you biting your nails and you were in pain it seems more than reasonable. Either he should have paid for them or realised you didn't have enough money for any little things you wanted/ needed because of the set up. It doesn't need to be exactly equal but it's not kind for one part of a "couple" to watch the other struggle. I would start looking for a cheaper house share for when your lease is up. Tell him you can't afford to keep living there and as he knows you have been financially struggling. Then move out. He isn't long term relationship material.

lateatwork · 31/01/2024 16:01

Yabu

You don't have shared finances or children.

It's a 50/50 split of household costs and you aren't taking on any additional responsibilities (IE child rearing ,/ household tasks).

If that leaves you with only £75 a month, then earn more, or move back home.

If you want more of a commitment as round finances, that's a different discussion.

GabriellaMontez · 31/01/2024 15:53

Leave as soon as you can afford it. Don't get pregnant. You don't want to be tied to this man. Sounds like he's positively enjoying your struggle.

Makeitmakesensetoday · 31/01/2024 15:47

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 08:50

I have 2 years until I qualify then I'll be on 30k. Yes I can move back home but I doubt my parents would be too keen as they've finally got an empty nest and loving it... I'm talking to them today

You're their child. Tell them what you've told us they'll soon want you home. He sounds awful.

WillowBarkTree · 31/01/2024 15:41

I was initially on the fence, because if you are a relatively new couple then I don’t think you need to share finances; however, I then saw you raised concerns and he pushed you to agree. You are paying half the rent and bills but not on tenancy agreement. I’m struggling to understand why you and him together would reduce affordability (most landlords like being able to go after more than one person). You would be considered a lodger and as such should be making a contribution but in my view not 50/50. He’s got to live in a flat he likes for 50%. Who does the cleaning, cooking and shopping?

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 15:34

Muchof · 31/01/2024 14:06

I honestly can’t make up my mind on this one. I am all for shared finances and me and DH have been that way for as long as I can remember. But he is your boyfriend not husband and I am not sure he should have to subsidise you at this point.

What would you do if you hadn’t met him? You would have had to work out how you would support yourself on £1200 a month in London. Presumably you would have chosen a cheaper place to live and study. I think as you are not on the tenancy you need to do that now.

I agree.

It probably doesn’t sound like he’s a keeper, but I really wouldn’t be expecting a fairly new boyfriend to support me financially for a whole degree course (is it another 2 years 8 months left?) when that clearly wasn’t what was agreed. You can’t make him pay more so you can pay less. You couldn’t have said no, and told him you’d stay living at home whilst doing your degree.

Muchof · 31/01/2024 14:06

I honestly can’t make up my mind on this one. I am all for shared finances and me and DH have been that way for as long as I can remember. But he is your boyfriend not husband and I am not sure he should have to subsidise you at this point.

What would you do if you hadn’t met him? You would have had to work out how you would support yourself on £1200 a month in London. Presumably you would have chosen a cheaper place to live and study. I think as you are not on the tenancy you need to do that now.

rosesinmygarden · 31/01/2024 13:54

YANBU the bill split is unfair.

He doesn't sound very kind.

Option 1: Find somewhere else to live.

Option 2: Earn some extra money. You could tutor a couple of hours a week and charge at least £30ph. More once you're a qualified teacher. It's very easy and much better paid than TA work or most other part time jobs. Plus, you're already DBSed which will appeal to parents.

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 13:53

SleepingBeautySnores · 30/01/2024 23:50

OP, on the subject of biting your nails, I am in my 60's and apart from a very short spell when I was younger, I have ALWAYS bitten my nails. Then, I was on MN one night, and saw a post by someone asking for help to stop biting her nails. She had posted a picture, and quite honestly her nails looked really sore, and quite revolting, just like my own. She was desperate to stop, and like you and ME, had tried EVERYTHING. There was the usual advice given, but people like you and I know that even these things that taste disgusting really don't work, as you get used to the taste, no matter how bad it is. Then someone suggested 'tapping'. I'd never heard of it as a cure for nail biting, and wondered how the hell something like that could stop you biting your nails, I even thought maybe they'd responded to the wrong post, but the reader included a link about it, and as I too was desperate to stop biting, I decided to give it a try. I'm afraid I can't find the post or the same video now, but if you Google 'tapping to stop nail biting', I'm sure you'll find lots of videos on YouTube about it. Basically the idea is that you replace the habit of nail biting with tapping. I know, it sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? But to my absolute amazement, it worked!! Initially, I just started tapping my chest every time I noticed myself biting, not quite like the video showed, but my own version of it, and over a period of weeks, my nails actually started to grow. There were no whites for a long time, as I'd bitten them so badly that I was more or less biting my fingers as there was not much left of the nail to bite. I armed myself with several glass nail files, and put one in every room, plus one in my car, and one in my bag, and every single time I felt a slight catch where my nails were starting to grow, and where previously I would have bitten them, I would file the catchy bit off, until it was smooth again. It's taken probably about 3 months, but I actually painted my nails for the second time tonight, and not just with a clear polish, but a colour that actually shows up. I am, as you can imagine, extremely proud of myself. I'd highly recommend giving it a try, after all, what have you got to lose, it doesn't cost a penny, unlike all the other methods you and I have tried over the years, and if it worked for me, it just might work for you. If so, I'd love you to DM me and let me know. Good luck.

Oh, as to the other thing, I too strongly recommend ditching this guy, and going back to live with your parents, assuming they live close enough to your current working life to make this feasible.

Thank you for this lovely message and taking the time to write it. I will try this thank you very much!

OP posts:
SinnerBoy · 31/01/2024 13:48

Bluenotgreen · Today 13:47

Well he really cocked up not putting you on the tenancy. It means you can just walk away and he will have to pay it all from his salary.

Oh yes, good point. He deserves it.

Bluenotgreen · 31/01/2024 13:47

Well he really cocked up not putting you on the tenancy. It means you can just walk away and he will have to pay it all from his salary.

Tight fisted arsehole.

Go back to your parents.

SinnerBoy · 31/01/2024 13:44

I agree, get out ASAP. As already suggested, find a house share and don't wait and dither. He's a total waste, can you imaging your situation if you decide to have kids? You'll have nothing from him and he'll blame you for needing him to pay the bills.

He's a mean, tight-fisted sponger.

longtompot · 31/01/2024 13:40

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 08:50

I have 2 years until I qualify then I'll be on 30k. Yes I can move back home but I doubt my parents would be too keen as they've finally got an empty nest and loving it... I'm talking to them today

If my child told me this was how their 'partner' was treating then, I would invite them to move back home and help them with it, until they had finished their course. I hope yours will be the same to you. I'm not saying I'd not miss having the house just to me and my dh but I wouldn't be happy knowing this was happening to one of my children.

Ponderingwindow · 31/01/2024 12:59

in hindsight, you should have insisted on finding a place you could actually afford.

I had a similar situation with a boyfriend, I made it very simple, we could live by my means for everything, or we could work out a concrete plan that let us live together closer to the level he preferred. He chose to subsidize me because he didn’t want a spartan life and I absolutely refused to stress my budget.

if your boyfriend isn’t so inclined and you aren’t on the lease, I would move back to your parents or find a house share you can actually afford.

as for your nails, I am a biter too. It’s an ASD thing for me. I just doing my nails at home to keep from biting. Never bite if my nails are done. There are many options. I personally like the nail wraps. They are cheap and easy to do. Semi-cured gel is also good, a bit more pricey, but not bad. And honestly, press on nails are back and reusable if you take care of them. My dd is all about the press on nails. She says most come with inferior glue so she buys that separately.

you already have a job and are in school. I wouldn’t be trying to add in more work. You should be focusing on your education, not trying to meet the budget set by some man who doesn’t appreciate you trying to make something of yourself.

Spacecowboys · 31/01/2024 12:56

In a relationship of two years, where you are renting and only one of you is on the rental agreement, there are no children involved and no long term relationship plans, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to have agreed to split housing costs 50/50, despite one person being a lower earner. What I find strange is that he doesn’t even feel like treating you to your nails done! He has a much higher disposable income than you and if he never wants to treat you, I’d be worried about what a potential future with him would look like. I suspect that you’d be contributing 50/50 on maternity leave. If possible I would move back to your parents and leave him with 100% of the costs.

Cosyblankets · 31/01/2024 12:38

This is absolutely something you should have discussed properly before moving in. This is one of those times you needed to sit down together with a calculator but it does look as though you felt bullied into it and i think on that basis you're not compatible

SchoolQuestionnaire · 31/01/2024 12:38

Willow39 · 30/01/2024 21:51

Can I just say that I am not actually on the tenancy agreement by the way. My boyfriend told the landlord that I wouldn't be a paying tenant because of my income. (He was just worried I'd get declined for affordability)
So I'm not on the tenancy but the landlord knows I'm here

Go back to your parents and leave him to it. He wants it all his own way.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 12:37

KreedKafer · 31/01/2024 12:30

The OP's circumstances are not the circumstances of most students, though. An 18-year-old student who goes home in the holidays, has a student loan and lives in student accommodation and has all the access to student benefits, and can probably get help from their parents in an emergency if they run out of money or have an unexpected expense, is not in the same situation as someone who is studying for a degree while working full-time in their 20s and living with their partner.

The OP will presumably have student loans as well if doing a degree. If you make the choice to move out of home and live on a TA wage, then you generally accept yes you will be skint. If you move away from home and live with quite a new boyfriend hoping he’ll pay more for your bills when that wasn’t what was agreed, then you may need to find an alternative plan.

Nevermind31 · 31/01/2024 12:34

This is interesting… if a woman came on here saying her boyfriend of two years is expecting her to pay part of his share, even though there are no children involved, the answer would be the same, LTB, what a cocklodger.
OP’s mistake was to move I to a flat that is too expensive for her. So tell him that you cannot afford it and will move out. And then cut your cloth accordingly.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 12:33

Regardless of the fact that you're studying, it is not fair to split bills things 50-50 if you earn £1,200 and he earns £3,000 each month. Your joint income each month is £4,200 and he earns just over 70% of that, therefore he should be paying 70% of the rent and bills.

The OP and her boyfriend agreed on the split when they moved in together -she would pay £800 and he pays £900. She could have said I can’t do that-I want you to pay more-or she could have said I will stay with my parents or let’s wait till I qualify when I will be earning.

If you don’t want to move back home, @Willow39, what about living in a student house where you will probably be paying a bit less for bills at least, if they are shared 5/6 ways? You’ve said you can’t work more and you can’t force him to pay more, so what else could you do?

KreedKafer · 31/01/2024 12:30

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 12:10

He's a rotter. It's cruel to make you live on £75/month spending money.

It’s £75 a week. For a student, that isn’t bad!

The OP's circumstances are not the circumstances of most students, though. An 18-year-old student who goes home in the holidays, has a student loan and lives in student accommodation and has all the access to student benefits, and can probably get help from their parents in an emergency if they run out of money or have an unexpected expense, is not in the same situation as someone who is studying for a degree while working full-time in their 20s and living with their partner.

KreedKafer · 31/01/2024 12:24

Regardless of the fact that you're studying, it is not fair to split bills things 50-50 if you earn £1,200 and he earns £3,000 each month. Your joint income each month is £4,200 and he earns just over 70% of that, therefore he should be paying 70% of the rent and bills.

I sympathise re. the nails by the way. I am also a compulsive nail biter and get my nails done for exactly the same reason as you. My fingers would be bleeding if I didn't.

CagneyAndLazy · 31/01/2024 12:19

If you were my daughter - and you might well be a similar age to DD - I'd absolutely want you back home. He's not a kind man and putting up with his behaviour is not a good start to life away from your parents.

Regardless of them being happy to have the house to themselves at the moment, they'll probably feel the same way if you tell them what's going on.

Onwards and upwards, OP. Put this one behind you.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 12:12

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 08:50

I have 2 years until I qualify then I'll be on 30k. Yes I can move back home but I doubt my parents would be too keen as they've finally got an empty nest and loving it... I'm talking to them today

Exactly 2 years? January 2025? Or is it September 2026, @Willow39 ?