Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an unfair bill split?

241 replies

Willow39 · 30/01/2024 21:03

Hi all.
I am a full time student who is also working full time. I earn £1200pm after tax. I'm a trainee teacher and have to work as a TA full time during my course so I'm stuck for options work wise.

My partner and I have just moved into an apartment with rent of £1300pm. Bills are circa £400pm so £1700 all in to run it. The flat is nothing special and price is because we are in London.

I contribute £800 which is just under 50% of everything, leaving me £75 a week disposable income after my personal bills.

However, my partner earns significantly more than me at circa £3000pm

I'm in a sticky situation where I agreed to this bill share when we moved in and now I'm really left in the shit. I can just about pay for fuel and food for the week if I'm careful.

I have tried to bring this up to him and he just gets angry saying that I'm going back on everything and that it's my fault that I chose to go to university and take my career path. He told me I should get a second job to support myself but I can't manage even more hours on top of one full time job and full time university...

Any advice on how to handle it with him?

OP posts:
ellie09 · 31/01/2024 23:25

Honestly, you needed to be honest and firm from the start.

When I was with my ex, we had discussed moving in (we never did though). He basically wanted a 50:50 split as well, despite me earning around 1k less per month and having more bills (for childcare as I was a single mum)

We looked at houses hypothetically and I had a budget in mind and he kept going over it. I just kept insisting definitely NOT if it was going to be 50:50 and if he wanted that standard of living, he would need to cough up more for the privilege.

Thing is, they want a lifestyle they cannot afford and are more than happy to watch their "partner" struggle for it.

He rented somewhere significantly cheaper alone, because he and only he was responsible for the bills. Which I think spoke volumes.

He wasnt great with money either, constantly in overdraft etc.

It was one of many red flags that in the end, I ended the relationship.

WigglyVonWaggly · 31/01/2024 23:07

It is absolutely illogical for a couple in a committed relationship to split bills almost 50:50 when one person is earning 2.5x more and the other is absolutely skint from trying to matching that with their contribution. A partnership means you support each other, but he’s clearly begrudging paying £100 more and certainly will be in a strop if he’s asked to chip in another £100.

You aren’t flatmates. He should see this as a short term thing where you both invest in your joint future while you train in a profession and get career prospects. He has a very weird take on this, as if he blames you for doing a degree and working full time: somehow it’s your fault for bettering yourself - tough luck if you’re skint

If he won’t be anything other than rigid and stingy with his money then his attitude does not bode well for anything such as maternity leave or part-time work later on, if you need to do either of those things for your family. You’ll never be able to do a masters because you’ll be made to feel like a sponger.

Honestly, I have no idea if he’s great in other ways but I’d be thinking of leaving him to pay full whack in his flat given he’s on the tendency agreement. What a selfish mean guy.

rooftopbird · 31/01/2024 22:51

Not even on the tenancy? I would pack up and leave tomorrow then. Leave him to it - tell him you can’t afford to stay. Soz.

😂😂

Yeh, definitely leave the fucking bastard, I'd nick back in with your folks if I were you.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 31/01/2024 21:22

I don't think your bf is a keeper, imagine the shit you will be in of you had a baby with him.

Get yourself back to your parents till you finish your course.

NaughtybutNice77 · 31/01/2024 21:21

I think the fact that you agreed to how costs would be split before you moved in means you need to pay. If your bf offers to pay for some treats like takeaways, dates, holidays etc I'd be inclined to stay.
What was you paying before? That doesn't sound an awful lot per person and you have to live somewhere. Also have £75 left over isn't so bad. A lot of people don't have that.

Theyarehere · 31/01/2024 21:13

Just go back to your mums. See how he likes paying for a flat he can’t afford. He’s awful. He won’t understand why you have gone so be prepared for the backlash blaming you for being a selfish monster and leaving him with all the bills.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 31/01/2024 21:10

Willow39 · 30/01/2024 21:51

Can I just say that I am not actually on the tenancy agreement by the way. My boyfriend told the landlord that I wouldn't be a paying tenant because of my income. (He was just worried I'd get declined for affordability)
So I'm not on the tenancy but the landlord knows I'm here

Well this is perfect, leave ASAP!

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 31/01/2024 21:04

Assuming your parents care about you, they will absolutely want you to move back home with them rather than stay with someone who mistreats you. I moved back home when a live in relationships went wrong. It happened when my parents were away on holiday and my sister was coming home from uni so they went away leaving an empty nest and came home to the two of us moved back in😂

caringcarer · 31/01/2024 18:56

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 08:50

I have 2 years until I qualify then I'll be on 30k. Yes I can move back home but I doubt my parents would be too keen as they've finally got an empty nest and loving it... I'm talking to them today

Move back home and bin the bastard off. He doesn't love you or even like you to treat you this way.

LorlieS · 31/01/2024 18:38

@MamaAlwaysknowsbest This isn't 1900!!

SuperGreens · 31/01/2024 18:35

No one who actually loves you would see you struggle that much, even and £50/week would make the difference for you and he is not prepared to do it. I know plenty of women who support their male partners 100% through training, unemployment etc so that gender argument is nonsense. When you love someone you help them if they need it. Also I hope you are not paying 50% of the food, in my experience men eat loads (and cost) more.

But the good thing is, you know this now, before you are committed and trapped with children. If you can find cheaper acom move out, move home if that doesnt seem to bad and is possible, you could save money there. If not, then maybe carry on as you are, but know its going nowhere. Don't forget the lesson he is teaching you about him, he does not have your back.

MamaAlwaysknowsbest · 31/01/2024 18:27

I am from abroad but in all of my friends lives and my own, the man always earned more and paid the whole thing. It only makes sense you want to pay a percentage but should be the correct percentage. A man is meant to love and protect a woman with ( some say, old fashioned ) idea, one day he will be the father, you the mother of kids and you won't be able to work and pay even a percentage. The idea was ( I hope still is ), that men would love their wives and offspring and provide for them, build estate without any selfish notion

W0tnow · 31/01/2024 18:09

In what universe is 2 years ‘a relatively new couple’?

Bin him. You’ll be skint the second you go on maternity leave.

SeaglassSigil · 31/01/2024 18:04

I was in a similar situation in the past. My partner was doing teacher training and working in a school on a low wage, and I was earning more (although not what your partner is earning). We split rent costs proportionally to our income.

I didn't love it (as it was my partner's choice to do further training, and they also had a lot of holiday/short working hours and chose not to earn during these).

But, I saw it as an investment in our future whereby my partner would eventually earn more and we would adjust accordingly. I also fundamentally didn't want my partner to struggle while I had more cash. We also would not have afforded to live where we did if I didn't pay extra.

I do think that your partner was unreasonable to push you into this.

I think really you should both have either lived somewhere else where you could both easily afford half the rent, or adjust how much you each put in to make the situation workable for both of you.

I let concerns me that your partner clearly knows you can't afford this (and told the landlord this) but has pressured you into this arrangement.

You could move out tomorrow and you wouldn't be liable for rent, though! Something to consider!

StoatofDisarray · 31/01/2024 18:04

StoatofDisarray · 31/01/2024 18:03

LGB and from a fellow former nail biter, coat the ends of your fingers in anti-biting solution for a week or so until you've beaten the habit.

LTB I mean!

StoatofDisarray · 31/01/2024 18:03

LGB and from a fellow former nail biter, coat the ends of your fingers in anti-biting solution for a week or so until you've beaten the habit.

user1471538283 · 31/01/2024 18:02

If you were mine and whether or not your bf was subsidising you I would want you home. You cannot afford to live where you are and I wouldn't want you in an unequal situation with a bf.

If he won't move to somewhere you can afford speak to your DPs and go home or a house share that you can afford.

LorlieS · 31/01/2024 17:58

@Shinyandnew1 I see. Well no, if she decided on one agreement with him and now is unilaterally deciding on another that's not fair.
I'm going back to uni pt in September and certainly don't expect my husband to fund me!!

barkymcbark · 31/01/2024 17:52

He either splits the bills fairly or you leave, it's a simple as that. It's a good thing your name isn't on the tenancy as you can move out whenever you please

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 17:44

LorlieS · 31/01/2024 17:36

@Shinyandnew1 I guess things also depend on what they both agreed before they moved in together?

Well, in the OP it says that I'm in a sticky situation where I agreed to this bill share when we moved in, so I’m presuming they agreed to this before they moved in but the OP has changed her mind.

It’s ok to change your mind, but that might mean the OP has to make changes (move back home, get a higher paid job, move into a student house etc) rather than it automatically being the case that the boyfriend just ‘pays more’ as the solution.

ForgottenWhyImHere · 31/01/2024 17:41

I can see both sides of the shared finances issue.

You could get a room as a lodger for £800/month with all bills included. You could probably find somewhere for less.

On the nails, I just wanted to say that I bit mine for 30+ years. I finally stopped when I separated from my ex. I'd been biting them long before I met him, but it was only once I knew I didn't actually have to stay married to him that I managed to stop (we were together 19 years). Still have the occasional lapse, but my nails are never anything like the state they used to be.

So maybe leaving your boyfriend would help solve that issue.

LorlieS · 31/01/2024 17:36

@Shinyandnew1 I guess things also depend on what they both agreed before they moved in together?

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 17:32

I would love to see the thread when (I assume) a relatively young woman is told, when her boyfriend makes a unilateral decision to go back to study, that she should be supporting his career and goals by paying most of the bills and treating him to beauty treatments every five weeks.

Yep, it’s not going to happen, is it!

OP chose to leave the financial safety of her parents’ house to move to expensive accommodation in London whilst she worked a part-time minimum wage job and trained to be a teacher. If it’s not working out, then it’s time to either earn more, move into cheaper student accommodation or go back home. Deciding your boyfriend should just pay more, isn’t a plan. No matter if 30 people on the internet say he should/could pay more or their boyfriend paid more, he is well within his rights to say, ‘no, that’s not what we agreed’. The OP didn’t have to move in with him-nobody forced her.

Muchof · 31/01/2024 17:00

78Summer · 31/01/2024 16:36

He does not sound very nice or kind. I would question the relationship. He should be supporting your career path and goals.

I have supported my husband financially in the past and there have been other times when he has supported me, in fact he did when I went back to FT education. I totally believe in sharing finances in well established long term relationships.

I would love to see the thread when (I assume) a relatively young woman is told, when her boyfriend makes a unilateral decision to go back to study, that she should be supporting his career and goals by paying most of the bills and treating him to beauty treatments every five weeks.

78Summer · 31/01/2024 16:36

He does not sound very nice or kind. I would question the relationship. He should be supporting your career path and goals.

Swipe left for the next trending thread