Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an unfair bill split?

241 replies

Willow39 · 30/01/2024 21:03

Hi all.
I am a full time student who is also working full time. I earn £1200pm after tax. I'm a trainee teacher and have to work as a TA full time during my course so I'm stuck for options work wise.

My partner and I have just moved into an apartment with rent of £1300pm. Bills are circa £400pm so £1700 all in to run it. The flat is nothing special and price is because we are in London.

I contribute £800 which is just under 50% of everything, leaving me £75 a week disposable income after my personal bills.

However, my partner earns significantly more than me at circa £3000pm

I'm in a sticky situation where I agreed to this bill share when we moved in and now I'm really left in the shit. I can just about pay for fuel and food for the week if I'm careful.

I have tried to bring this up to him and he just gets angry saying that I'm going back on everything and that it's my fault that I chose to go to university and take my career path. He told me I should get a second job to support myself but I can't manage even more hours on top of one full time job and full time university...

Any advice on how to handle it with him?

OP posts:
OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 01/02/2024 11:57

@Willow39

You say ' I was very on edge and not sure. I said no, that I couldn't afford it and my boyfriend essentially persuaded me that I would be fine having such limited disposable income as I 'don't need that much '

So you said no, you should have said NO louder, and meant it.

You even explained why you were saying No.

He persuaded you - really ? or bullied you ?

and as for ' not needing much ' well ! that was the 2nd red flag for me - how patronising !

As for him giving you gloves - you do admit in a further update that you choose to cover your fingers in plasters and wear gloves.

I guess you are very young, 19 or so are you in your 1st year or 2nd year ?

I would move straight back home now, you can pack this evening / tomorrow evening and leave on Sat, you don't owe him a penny as you are not the tenant.

Hopefully with it being the 1st of a new month you haven't already paid him for this month's rent ?!!!

He can afford the rent on his own anyway, as he is the tenant and he is the one that the landlord would have carried out affordability checks etc.

You are your boyfriend's lodger / flatmate, your contribution to the rent and living costs provide him with a better standard of living as he has more disposable income as a result of you living with him.

Did you meet and start dating before you started studying ? as he appears resentful of you being at Uni - Did he not go ? or is he older than you and he went years ago ?

You live in London so you are ideally situated for babysitting agencies and nanny agencies, so you could if you want / need to earn extra money babysit - just one evening will earn you around £45 for a min of 4 hours, plus travel expenses. A decent agency will have a min hours and a min pay.

And you can work as either a live in or a live out nanny thru the long holidays,
or work as bank staff for a day nursery in the holidays if you don't want to be a nanny.
You can even work as a Children's Rep on a cruise ship in the summer holidays !

MorrisZapp · 01/02/2024 11:16

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 01/02/2024 09:21

You mean nobody ever agrees to anything that isn’t satisfactory? What must not be cannot be?

Well clearly the reality has proved unsatisfactory, so she won't be making the same mistake again of acting first then thinking second. She hasn't mentioned having a baby and I just naturally assumed that professional women do full financial planning before making that huge leap. If they don't then surely they bear some responsibility for that.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/02/2024 11:16

You could have chosen to stay with your parents whilst you trained, you decided to leave their house (where presumably you were paying much less) and move in with your boyfriend under this agreement. You could have said no, that’s too expensive. Unless you are in a coercive relationship, you have choices.

If you think he coerced you into moving in with him though, he probably isn’t very nice-move home.

Are you going to reply to any posts that aren’t giving you aside on nails, @Willow39 ?

Beautiful3 · 01/02/2024 11:10

He's not behaving as a partner is he? Lucky you discovered his mean streak now, before having a baby with him. When I was on maternity I hardly had any money, my husband paid for most expenses until I went back to work. I really appreciated him as I felt safe, and could rely on him. Honestly, I'd leave him. You deserve so much better.

Pinkerama · 01/02/2024 10:46

This will be an unpopular answer but I think you need to stand on your own two feet. You’ve just moved in together so it’s too soon to expect him to subsidise your living costs.

I was in a very similar situation when I moved in with my now dh two years into our relationship. I was going to uni full time and working part time, he had a good job already earning considerably more. I didn’t expect him for a second to cover any of my expenses.

Moving in together actually helped me financially as I was paying the same for half the rent on an ok flat that I would have paid for a room in a student house share. I’m sure that’s the case for you too, especially considering London prices. If he somehow forced you to sign the lease or lied about paying more than half, just tell him you can’t afford it and will be moving out.

As a student you have limited income and it is what it is until you finish your course. You need to make sure you live within your means and if he wants something extra (fancy days out, holidays etc.) he can offer to pay or you just say no if you can’t afford it.

And before anyone suggests I’m in a financially abusive relationship, dh and I now pool our income even though he is further ahead in his career and still earns a lot more than me. Our relationship just developed and we reached the stage where we were both comfortable doing that.

itsgoingtobeabumpyride · 01/02/2024 09:28

Luckily you're not on the tenancy agreement.
Speak to your parents about moving home.
I'm an empty nester and I love it but if my DD wanted to move home she'd be more than welcome, I'd probably do some internal eye rolls that my peace was about to be shattered but she would never know.
I assume when you've qualified you'll plan to move out again so it's not like it's forever.
My DD and her DP lived with me while they saved up for a deposit as it was cheaper to live with me, so hopefully it takes some of the financial strain off you.
And fgs go and get your nails done then try the "tapping" exercise

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 01/02/2024 09:21

MorrisZapp · 01/02/2024 08:49

He did offer a satisfactory arrangement, she agreed to it before moving in. Presumably having a baby would require a whole set of new arrangements which she can choose to agree with or not.

You mean nobody ever agrees to anything that isn’t satisfactory? What must not be cannot be?

fussychica · 01/02/2024 09:15

He sounds most unpleasant and unkind. This doesn't sound like a long term relationship with him is sustanable or desirable.
My DS and his partner are in a similar financial position and split the bills percentage wise rather than 50:50. He also helps her out if she has some unforseen expense that would leave her short.

SilkyMoonfaceSaucepanMan · 01/02/2024 09:13

There are two distinct parts to this:

  1. He does not owe you and he has no obligation to pay the higher percentage or subsidise your training. That’s reality. He made it clear before you moved in together that he wished to split 50%. That’s his prerogative. You agreed to that. From a purely financial point of view, you were in the wrong here. It’s okay to be wrong. You can now choose to leave.

  2. You are in a relationship, presumably with the intention to see whether it becomes more committed or long term. Moving in together as partners is a big step along this road. Whilst he is entitled to see this as a purely logistical arrangement (see point one), the reality is also that you are partners and thus you are both assessing each other and the relationship for compatibility and longevity. From this perspective, he should not be somebody you should wish to be with. He knowingly entered into a living situation that would leave you disadvantaged, he is not seeing the bigger picture or supporting your long term goals, and he is not putting the relationship as his priority. He is entitled to think this way, but it does mean that he is making it very clear that the relationship doesn’t hold the same weight for him as it does for you. This is not a man you can rely upon. Again, the conclusion should be to leave him. He’s not the right man for you.

I would add the comment that I’m the future you need to be stronger with communication. He’s not inherently wrong for thinking the way he does, either about finances or your relationship, but neither are you. You’re simply not on the same page.

Shinyandnew1 · 01/02/2024 09:09

Willow39 · 31/01/2024 08:50

I have 2 years until I qualify then I'll be on 30k. Yes I can move back home but I doubt my parents would be too keen as they've finally got an empty nest and loving it... I'm talking to them today

How did your conversation with your parents go yesterday @Willow39 ?

What did they say? Are you going to move back home?

OhamIreally · 01/02/2024 09:07

I hope your parents gave you the ok to move home OP. It will be interesting to hear what your boyfriend has to say when you tell him you're moving out.

lentilrice · 01/02/2024 08:59

I’d end the relationship. I couldn’t be with someone who resents me going to uni to train for a career and spoke to me like that. He persuaded you to move into the flat and he doesn’t think you need that much. That says everything to me, that your needs aren’t important. He’s putting his own wants and needs above yours. That isn’t a partnership I’m afraid. I’d move out.

MorrisZapp · 01/02/2024 08:49

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 01/02/2024 08:37

But he didn’t offer a satisfactory arrangement here and she did move in with him so the presumption is that this pattern will be repeated until they split up. It’s better to do that sooner rather than later.

He did offer a satisfactory arrangement, she agreed to it before moving in. Presumably having a baby would require a whole set of new arrangements which she can choose to agree with or not.

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 01/02/2024 08:41

kiwiane · 01/02/2024 06:15

A room in a shared house in London could cost as much and exclude household bills. I would stay and complete your course before leaving him, unless he’s unbearable.
You know he would be awful if you had children together; he’s not a keeper for sure.

Time is precious. This is very odd advice and not just because the OP can go home to live.

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 01/02/2024 08:37

MorrisZapp · 01/02/2024 07:49

Why is everyone going on about maternity leave? The op hasn't mentioned kids and has two years of studying before qualifying.

Presumably before having a baby she'd assess her finances and have a conversation with the baby's father about how it would all be paid for. If he wasn't offering a satisfactory arrangement then she has the choice not to do it, as she had the choice not to move in with him.

My DP earned a bit more than me in the early years, now I earn a bit more than him. We've always done fifty fifty bill split, I wouldn't enjoy spending my disposable income if it was subsidised. Everyone's different though, if you prefer a proportional split then the time to say so is before moving in.

But he didn’t offer a satisfactory arrangement here and she did move in with him so the presumption is that this pattern will be repeated until they split up. It’s better to do that sooner rather than later.

AgentJohnson · 01/02/2024 07:55

What’s happening regarding your finances is a symptom of a dynamic that is unbalanced. This is who he is, there isn’t a version of him that waiting around the corner that gives a shit about the inequality. Stop waiting for him to not be a dick and start asking yourself why you are prioritising this dick.

MorrisZapp · 01/02/2024 07:49

Why is everyone going on about maternity leave? The op hasn't mentioned kids and has two years of studying before qualifying.

Presumably before having a baby she'd assess her finances and have a conversation with the baby's father about how it would all be paid for. If he wasn't offering a satisfactory arrangement then she has the choice not to do it, as she had the choice not to move in with him.

My DP earned a bit more than me in the early years, now I earn a bit more than him. We've always done fifty fifty bill split, I wouldn't enjoy spending my disposable income if it was subsidised. Everyone's different though, if you prefer a proportional split then the time to say so is before moving in.

newnamethanks · 01/02/2024 07:23

He's not the man for you. Shout 'percentages' loudly and leave him. Rent somewhere else or your life will be a misery. Do it.

Plumtop11 · 01/02/2024 07:18

My advice would to not marry or have children with this person. When you do it to life you have to work as a team. Seeing how he is now suggests he wouldn't be financially supportive or you having maternity leave it part time working to raise any children.

When I met my husband and we moved in together we split all money and bills equally (I was the high earner then). Now we are married and have two DC he warns 5 times my salary and any money is family money.

kiwiane · 01/02/2024 06:15

A room in a shared house in London could cost as much and exclude household bills. I would stay and complete your course before leaving him, unless he’s unbearable.
You know he would be awful if you had children together; he’s not a keeper for sure.

pootlin · 01/02/2024 05:48

I’d rather live in a houseshare than subsidise this cunt to live in a flat that he bullied you into.

Please leave him, Op.

Hibye23289 · 01/02/2024 05:17

Please do not set yourself up to have a miserable life, you will be the one skint and sacrificing whilst on mat leave while he's being selfish with his money and stress free. Do not underestimate the stress financial problems cause. My exh was selfish and terrible with money and here we are

UmbrellaBees · 01/02/2024 04:49

You earn £1200 after tax. He earns around £3k - have you quote his before or after tax figure?
Do You see any further in this relationship because your inability to communicate as a couple stands out. Does he see you as trying to take advantage of him - the lack of trust this suggests is problematic too. Is he behaving like this to control you? He might not understand the significance of your feelings about your nails, he may just think you are being overly concerned about something that doesn’t matter. So many potential red flags that need to be resolved, it doesn’t bode well.

lovinglaughingliving · 01/02/2024 04:16

@Willow39 how are things? X

poppyjanie · 01/02/2024 03:06

Very much true colours. It should be based on % not split 50/50 as partners. He's leaving you in a vulnerable position.

He is treating you like the poorer flatmate. Definitely a big red flag. Imagine how it would be if you had young children and earned significantly less. Look around MN there's loads of awful situations women are in where the balance of power is off b/c of the way typically the man who earns more behaves. Now they have dc and are stuck.

As a partner of 2 years he should be supporting your goals and being fair around contributions to bills and rent. Time to make a priority of your future self and end it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread