Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt my sister doesn't like the children in our family

115 replies

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 19:44

I feel a bit sad about this. One of my siblings has chosen not to have children, which I totally respect and understand. But the longer time goes on, the more I believe she really doesn't like her nieces and nephews, one of which is my dc. I figured not having her own would put her in the cool auntie role, but if anything she goes to lengths to avoid spending time with them. When she does spend time with them she complains about them. She perpetually talks about how seeing their behaviour makes her womb shrivel up (they really arent that terrible, jusy notmal kids). She'll make loud comments about how she must remember to take her contraceptives etc. I get she doesn't want kids, but also she says this in front of them.

If we are struggling with their behaviour she will very loudly say its our own fault for having children, she has absolutely no sympathy for us, we chose this so we shouldn't complain even though we never complain directly to her. If we talk about them with her around she'll get stroppy and say something like 'well there is nothing for me in this conversation' and withdraw. She may not glhave her own kids, but they are her family. I used to be very close to her, but I find her attitude to us as parents, and our children, really hurtful. Aibu?

OP posts:
pootlin · 30/01/2024 21:26

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 20:10

@MCOut absolutely no childcare requested of course. And we have stopped inviting her to child specific events. But then in the past have been made to feel guilty about excluding her so it's a loose loose situation apparently.

I was all set to vote YABU as I thought you were trying to set her up in an aunty role she doesn’t want.

However she sounds an absolute prat complaining about the kids and then complaining when she’s not invited..

If you’re sure there’s no fertility issues or other reason then I’d tell her straight out that if she wants to be included then she needs to nicer to the kids and not make mean comments about them or to them.

Does she ever invite you over? Invites need to be reciprocal.

sprigatito · 30/01/2024 21:26

slashlover · 30/01/2024 21:19

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!'

Don't say that, it's INCREDIBLY patronising. I've heard similar for the past 30 years and it's tiresome.

I don't think that poster was suggesting saying that to childfree women generally. Just the ones who are performatively offensive and nasty about children. If OP's sister doesn't want to be insulted, maybe she should keep a civil tongue in her head 🤷🏻‍♀️

clairelouwho · 30/01/2024 21:25

WandaWonder · 30/01/2024 21:24

I have no idea if this is the case for the auntie in the OP but people without children do spend a lot of their time talking endlessly about not having children

I have never for one second thought the world revolves around me or my child and I am prefectly happy there are people who do not have children the world does not centre on children or parents but the childfree give it a lot of head space it seems

Have you bothered to spend a second wondering why?

WandaWonder · 30/01/2024 21:24

I have no idea if this is the case for the auntie in the OP but people without children do spend a lot of their time talking endlessly about not having children

I have never for one second thought the world revolves around me or my child and I am prefectly happy there are people who do not have children the world does not centre on children or parents but the childfree give it a lot of head space it seems

OhmygodDont · 30/01/2024 21:23

I hate this oh maybe she’s so mean because she really want children.

I have children. I pretty much hate 90% of children because they are loud brats. I tolerate my own 😂 because I love them because they are mine. I like a few friends children. But my husbands sisters children make me remember whom I’d never want anymore they are horrible little brats of children. If she had of had children before
me I probably would of had none for fear they would be like that. Little feral rodents running around with a wishy washy ineffective mother and a dad who the children don’t listen to because mummy over rides. Nope not nice children and I don’t want to even be their aunt let alone a cool aunt 😂😂.

If we divorced I am not claiming them
as mine in the divorce 😅😂

notlucreziaborgia · 30/01/2024 21:20

FeliciteFaff · 30/01/2024 21:13

I am psychic as it happens 🙄

The post wasn't meant to hurt, but I go by all the bitter women I personally know who deal with kids in this way. The snarls, the comments on whether kids will be present when they visit the home, the mean behaviour towards kids, the ignoring of friendly children. There are a few childless friends I know who do - care for, adore or tolerate kids.

BUT The nastiness of OP's sister is coming from a really bad place. It's something that is wrong with her. Why else would she be so nasty that her sister had to write a post on MN

And a cod psychologist!

You may just be reading what you want to believe into her motivations. It could simply be a case that she doesn’t want children, doesn’t particularly like them, and is fending off any suggestion of being a ‘cool auntie’.

slashlover · 30/01/2024 21:19

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!'

Don't say that, it's INCREDIBLY patronising. I've heard similar for the past 30 years and it's tiresome.

FeliciteFaff · 30/01/2024 21:13

I am psychic as it happens 🙄

The post wasn't meant to hurt, but I go by all the bitter women I personally know who deal with kids in this way. The snarls, the comments on whether kids will be present when they visit the home, the mean behaviour towards kids, the ignoring of friendly children. There are a few childless friends I know who do - care for, adore or tolerate kids.

BUT The nastiness of OP's sister is coming from a really bad place. It's something that is wrong with her. Why else would she be so nasty that her sister had to write a post on MN

Teddleshon · 30/01/2024 21:11

I think she sounds like a rude and thoughtless person. Horrid to be so unkind about family members, children or otherwise.

clairelouwho · 30/01/2024 21:11

I'm child-free and I have a nephew who I love very much, but I'd also resent the assumption that if I'm not to have kids of my own, my role will automatically fall into one of "cool auntie."

I just find that there's a great assumption with women, in particular, that even if we're not having kids of our own, we must fulfil some kind of caring/service role to be of value. I'm not saying that's the case here at all-it's just an assumption I've noticed a lot.

That said, I don't think there's a need to be rude about your kids. I don't think she needs to necessarily feign interest-but being outright rude is uncalled for. Yes, people talking about their children bores me to tears sometimes-but so long as that's not all they talk about-and other people can get a word in too-I'm cool with sitting and listening.

I think it's fine if she doesn't want to have a relationship with your kids-that's up to her-and no one has the right to try and force that relationship. It sounds like it would be better all around to stop doing that.

Fact is, not everyone likes children. It's possible that she's doing this as a defence mechanism, too, though. When you actively choose to not have kids-it's very hard to convince people to take you seriously. I've had a lot of people try and change my mind. If I'm having a moment with my nephew and playing with him, people sometimes read that as some great sign that I want a kid of my own-and it's so uncomfortable because it makes me feel like I should stop interacting with him to get people to take me seriously.

Maybe that's part of it. She's trying, rather clumsily and rudely, to instil her boundaries and make sure her choice is known so no one will try and convince her otherwise. I'm just throwing ideas out with my experiences.

noodlezoodle · 30/01/2024 21:10

She's being an arse. I'm childfree by choice, and I admit that I find small children quite boring, and sometimes after spending time with children (particularly if they're being little buggers) I will say to my husband that it made me extra glad about our choice.

However. I would NEVER say that in front of my friends and family and espcially not in front of their children. That's just incredibly rude and honestly sounds pretty passive aggressive.

And of course as they grow up they get much more interesting and it's easier to build a real relationship with them. If your children are very small perhaps she might get on better with them as they get older. Nonetheless, that is no excuse to be a dick about it, and I think you'd be well within your rights to have a serious talk with her and tell her to cut it out if she wants to remain close to you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/01/2024 21:08

I have two child free younger brothers, I should add, and they weren’t remotely interested in my kids until they were 8-10 ish and there were / are things to talk to them about!

When I first had children they both were a bit fed up that not all the attention was on them I think, but mainly they just weren’t interested in babies and toddlers. Didn’t make a performance out of it like your sister though!

Boomboom22 · 30/01/2024 21:03

Sounds like she's still in a child role herself and acting like a jealous teenager.
That or she's really feeling her bio clock but has no partner etc.

I doubt she's happily child free because she wouldn't feel the need to make these comments if she was. It wouldn't be threatening to her sense of self if she was happy with her choice.

Younghearts · 30/01/2024 20:55

Some people just do not like and do not want kids. Some siblings are just not interested in being the auntie / uncle role and couldn’t really careless. I can’t remember the last time my sister asked how my baby is, yes it’s sad that they’re not more interested but if they don’t like children then I guess they can’t force themselves too.

I would let her know when she makes comments that you find it hurtful and to ask her not to say these things. I would probably step back a bit from her as well.

EdinGirl · 30/01/2024 20:52

I would love to chat about cats. I find children (including family) incredibly boring and I have no interest.

I go through the motions of course and I absolutely care about their well-being... But it is what it is.

I have two child free aunts who showed no interest in me as a child whatsoever, but we have a lovely relationship now I am an adult.

Some people aren't kid people and that is okay.

Catsmere · 30/01/2024 20:50

EbonyRaven · 30/01/2024 20:46

Methinks the lady doth protest too much... Wink

Probably wants children herself deep down. It's denial - and the hatred for children is a dead giveaway.

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!' Grin

Although, be careful. As a few posters have said, she may desperately want children but can't conceive.

Please don’t say that. Childfree women get too much of this patronising crap.

Fannyfiggs · 30/01/2024 20:47

Talk to your sister. Tell her 'that child' is the absolute love of your life. That you would die to protect them. And what she says about them and in front of them is really hurtful. You understand and support her choice to be child free and would appreciate the same from her.

EbonyRaven · 30/01/2024 20:46

Methinks the lady doth protest too much... Wink

Probably wants children herself deep down. It's denial - and the hatred for children is a dead giveaway.

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!' Grin

Although, be careful. As a few posters have said, she may desperately want children but can't conceive.

sprigatito · 30/01/2024 20:43

She sounds like a tiresome posturing prat tbh. I'd just roll my eyes and tell her to get some new material.

RedRobyn2021 · 30/01/2024 20:41

I have a good friend who's like this, it genuinely doesn't bother me. We're just different. If you didn't want children, you'd probably find some of their behaviour pretty horrifying

Pollyannamex · 30/01/2024 20:41

I’m as childfree as they come, but even I think she is being rude and the comments are unnecessary. I sometimes think those things to myself when surrounded by badly behaved children, but I’d not be as rude as to voice them.
have you tried talking to her about it? That you respect her choices so she should respect yours?

BarelyLiterate · 30/01/2024 20:40

I’m childfree by choice and I certainly never had any desire or intention to be a ‘cool auntie’. Sod that for an idea. The reality is that I didn’t particularly like children even when I was one myself, so I was never going to have any more contact or involvement with my nephews or my friends’ kids than basic politeness required.

I was polite, though. Always. I may not have wanted to spend more time with the kids than I had to, but I certainly never said anything negative about them or complained about them. I sympathise with your sister’s aversion to children, though not with her rudeness. Did she feel pressurised to have a close relationship with your children when she never wanted to be a ‘cool auntie’?

RosePetals86 · 30/01/2024 20:39

Yanbu OP your sister sounds a bit of a d!ck head to be honest!
Everyone saying she’s entitled to her opinions, well yeah ofc and not having children is her choice entirely. However imagine if OP voiced every time she was in sisters company ‘thank god I had children hey, so I don’t become bitter and rude like you?!’ I’m sure she’d be told it was uncalled for. Same way sister doesn’t need to voice of her dislike of children at every given opportunity.

Angrycat2768 · 30/01/2024 20:39

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 20:10

@MCOut absolutely no childcare requested of course. And we have stopped inviting her to child specific events. But then in the past have been made to feel guilty about excluding her so it's a loose loose situation apparently.

I wouldn't bother feeling guilty about leaving her out. She seems to have no problem upsetting you or your children. I had a friend like this. She didn't want children, fine. She was constantly rude about people who had children, even to me, after I had children. There was no need. I knew her feelings. I didn't need reminding of them every 5 minutes. She was a friend though not a relative, and we drifted apart fairly quickly.

WineMakesTheWorldGoAround · 30/01/2024 20:37

trippily · 30/01/2024 20:05

She is one of the "childfree" Internet tribe I expect. There's like a reddit community and things? Does she spend a lot of time online?

Like many special interest online groups they can get very blinkered and obsessed.

I agree with this.
There does seem to be a lot of 'performative' child free people around at the moment.
The type of person I am thinking of is like OP's sister, they can't just happily get on with their child free life, they have to make sure everyone knows about it!! It's like it becomes their entire personality.
Regardless of OP's sisters reasoning I would have cut her off a long time ago. I wouldn't let anyone openly insult my children on multiple occasions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread