Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt my sister doesn't like the children in our family

115 replies

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 19:44

I feel a bit sad about this. One of my siblings has chosen not to have children, which I totally respect and understand. But the longer time goes on, the more I believe she really doesn't like her nieces and nephews, one of which is my dc. I figured not having her own would put her in the cool auntie role, but if anything she goes to lengths to avoid spending time with them. When she does spend time with them she complains about them. She perpetually talks about how seeing their behaviour makes her womb shrivel up (they really arent that terrible, jusy notmal kids). She'll make loud comments about how she must remember to take her contraceptives etc. I get she doesn't want kids, but also she says this in front of them.

If we are struggling with their behaviour she will very loudly say its our own fault for having children, she has absolutely no sympathy for us, we chose this so we shouldn't complain even though we never complain directly to her. If we talk about them with her around she'll get stroppy and say something like 'well there is nothing for me in this conversation' and withdraw. She may not glhave her own kids, but they are her family. I used to be very close to her, but I find her attitude to us as parents, and our children, really hurtful. Aibu?

OP posts:
Whaleandsnail6 · 31/01/2024 06:40

She sounds awful. Fair enough if she doesn't want to actively spend time with children (even if they are family) but there is likely to be family events where everyone is there and to be so negative is just rude.

I dont particularly enjoy conversations about my mil job or uncles fishing hobby but Id never say anything. I just smile, join in the conversation and then await a subject change.

Next time she moans she doesnt get included in something child focused, point out to her now much she complains about being around her nieces and nephews and how unpleasant her behaviour is. Make her own it instead of letting her continuously get away with being so unpleasant.

KimberleyClark · 31/01/2024 06:39

Whatineed · 30/01/2024 21:58

My ex's friend got married to an anti-child person. Really hated on kids, and how they were a drain on society, calling young kids maggots etc etc.

She tried to throw a few shitty comments like this around in front of my son, until I reminded her of who'd be spooning her soup into her gob and wiping her arse in the future.

Do these people even know how pensions work? 😅

Do you know how funding for child benefit, education etc works? Everyone pays for them, including those without children.

lifesrichpageant · 31/01/2024 06:33

ugh OP I am sorry. This would bother me a lot. She doesn't have to agree with your choices or lifestyle, but she needs to show respect to you and your family. It's just plain rude imo.
I had a friend (past tense) who once told me that she would rather 'dig my own eye out with a spoon' than attend a child's birthday party. The same person insisted that I make eye contact with her dog and greet said dog formally when we met.

KimberleyClark · 31/01/2024 06:28

Have there been a few of this type of thread recently - sister/SIL doesn’t want kids and is horrible about mine? Or is it just me?

Whatineed · 31/01/2024 06:11

"Oh here we go, the inevitable "they'll be wiping your arse" comment. Amazing how many people here apparently have children to make them work in aged care."

How ridiculously pedantic. One thing that is inevitable is that the children these people despise will play a larger and larger part in the care of an ageing population. With a decline in the UK birthrate along with a rise in the ageing population (its already moved from 16% to over 18% in two years there will be an effect.

Be that in pension changes, later retirement years for the next generation and higher amounts to pay, more taxes into elderly care and medicine, more roles in the medical sector related to elderly care, more construction related to elderly housing/care homes hospitals or directly working as care workers.

There's a lot of ways children will have to wipe our arses in the future.

The ops Sister has a choice, that's the beauty of being an adult, simply stay away from the children she can't stand, and keep snide comments for her other child hating friends.

Bex5490 · 30/01/2024 23:18

She’s being rude.

I don’t have LOADS in common with my 95 year old grandad who dribbles, moans and needs caring for. But he’s my family and he means everything to my mum so I love him mostly for her sake.

Imagine I just started loudly announcing that old people are awful…

She needs to grow up and stop being so self centred.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 30/01/2024 22:30

She perpetually talks about how seeing their behaviour makes her womb shrivel up

She sounds rude. She's entitled to not like children, and to not want to be a cool auntie and spend much time with them. But there's no need to be actively rude. They've not done anything to her except exist. It's like a sibling's partner who you don't like - you don't need to like them, or spend much time with them, but if they've not actually done anything wrong, don't be a dick about it.

noexcusesforlatenessalan · 30/01/2024 22:25

Didn't you post exactly the same thing a few weeks back?

Thulpelly · 30/01/2024 22:24

Children are people. It’s like hating people.
And an especially vulnerable group of people.

Thulpelly · 30/01/2024 22:19

Don’t force the relationship, for your kid’s sake. ‘Don’t like kids’ people are weird.

Catsmere · 30/01/2024 22:07

Oh here we go, the inevitable "they'll be wiping your arse" comment. Amazing how many people here apparently have children to make them work in aged care.

Re-reading the OP, I wonder how many nieces and nephews there are and how much time her sister has previously found herself having to spend with all of them at once? That would do my head in and her sister is presumably reacting to too many noisy children at once, and perhaps trying to prevent further exposure. Rude way to do it, but if she's at the end of her tether with other people's children, understandable.

It's also a reach to suggest she'll come looking for a relationship with them as adults. They may have nothing in common at all. Being related is a poor basis for assuming a desire for contact ime.

MrsToothyBitch · 30/01/2024 22:04

She sounds just plain rude but if your "cool auntie plans were shared aloud" she may also be seeking to disabuse you. Weird and PA and performative way to do it though, when she could've just said once that she doesn't think she is cut out to be a hands on auntie. Has she made it a personality trait or feels pigeon holed in your family now so is performing accordingly? I'm not very keen on babies despite really liking children. I only play it up and act all Cruella if someone has an issue with it, as a wind up.

People usually only need telling once, too. No one tries to foist their babies on me for a hold after the first "that's very kind but no thank you". So I find it odd that she feels the need to hammer her dislike home. If she's definitely happy in her choices, who's she trying to convince ?

MissingMoominMamma · 30/01/2024 22:01

“Sis, we all know that you don’t like children- you’ve reminded us at every opportunity, but please remember that these are people I love dearly, and I’d really rather you weren’t rude to, or about them.”

Whatineed · 30/01/2024 21:58

My ex's friend got married to an anti-child person. Really hated on kids, and how they were a drain on society, calling young kids maggots etc etc.

She tried to throw a few shitty comments like this around in front of my son, until I reminded her of who'd be spooning her soup into her gob and wiping her arse in the future.

Do these people even know how pensions work? 😅

Wednesdaysotherchild · 30/01/2024 21:57

WineMakesTheWorldGoAround · 30/01/2024 20:37

I agree with this.
There does seem to be a lot of 'performative' child free people around at the moment.
The type of person I am thinking of is like OP's sister, they can't just happily get on with their child free life, they have to make sure everyone knows about it!! It's like it becomes their entire personality.
Regardless of OP's sisters reasoning I would have cut her off a long time ago. I wouldn't let anyone openly insult my children on multiple occasions.

Well this class of person is massively dwarfed by the huge number of women who define themselves by their status as a mother, their whole personality is subsumed by it, even in the workplace! I met a woman today at work and the first thing she said after introductions was about her daughter apropos of nothing. It’s equally tedious and performative: “as a mother…”, “as a boy mum”, “mom life”, “you’ll understand when you have your own (smug smile)” so that is just a wholly understandable reaction against this. You don’t realise how much being a women is linked to motherhood by our culture and society until you fall outside that group. It makes women angry because it is a huge invisible and alienating dividing line and sometimes, ridiculously, they are viewed as lesser. Look how patronising some of the posts on this thread are!

Oh and before you have a go - all my pregnancies died in utero so I’m not chosing this, nor am I rude to people with kids.

cheddercherry · 30/01/2024 21:56

It sounds less like she’s sharing an opinion (which could be done once in reaction to a specific situation) but instead is repeatedly being hurtful and rude in as obnoxious way as possible to maximum dramatic effect. Totally unnecessary in front of your kids and I’d tell her so to be honest. If you can dish it out you can take it back as they say.

People cant just hide the mean things they say behind “voicing my opinion”. Surely an opinion is “I’m far happier without children” whereas an insult is “your kids are so irritating I hope my womb shrivels”. There’s a difference and she’s the wrong side of rude.

Catsmere · 30/01/2024 21:55

WandaWonder · 30/01/2024 21:24

I have no idea if this is the case for the auntie in the OP but people without children do spend a lot of their time talking endlessly about not having children

I have never for one second thought the world revolves around me or my child and I am prefectly happy there are people who do not have children the world does not centre on children or parents but the childfree give it a lot of head space it seems

I would never mention children if people didn't ask "do you have kids" "why didn't you have kids" "don't you want kids" etc etc over the years. Complete randoms would bring it up. Bloody tiresome, especially (as a PP mentioned, too) I didn't like them much even when I was one.

betterangels · 30/01/2024 21:52

slashlover · 30/01/2024 21:19

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!'

Don't say that, it's INCREDIBLY patronising. I've heard similar for the past 30 years and it's tiresome.

Yeah, incredibly. It's also so predictable.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/01/2024 21:51

Tbh performative anything is very annoying, and this seems extremely performative

betterangels · 30/01/2024 21:49

notlucreziaborgia · 30/01/2024 20:16

It’s possible she knows you anticipated her taking on a ‘cool auntie’ role and the comments are designed to disabuse you of any such notions.

Probably in part it's this. She does sound rude. Not every thought we have needs to be voiced.

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 21:44

@notlucreziaborgia I obviously dismissed the cool auntie thoughts (misplaced i understand) a long time ago. Its certainly not something I force the idea of.

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 30/01/2024 21:36

And we have stopped inviting her to child specific events. But then in the past have been made to feel guilty about excluding her

Don't feel guilty about excluding her from events that the children are going to be present at. Nor do you have to listen to her bleating on about disliking kids if she comes to any event. Tell her to bore off and change the subject. If she gets huffy - win-win rather than lose-lose...

It's fine if she doesn't like kids. (Or men, or dogs, or the current weather. Whatever.) But to repeatedly voice those opinions to people who might feel hurt at hearing their loved ones slighted is not on. She should be old enough to know she needs to put a sock in it, without having to be told. If she does need to be told though, go ahead and you all do it. She's tiresome.

pootlin · 30/01/2024 21:30

sprigatito · 30/01/2024 21:26

I don't think that poster was suggesting saying that to childfree women generally. Just the ones who are performatively offensive and nasty about children. If OP's sister doesn't want to be insulted, maybe she should keep a civil tongue in her head 🤷🏻‍♀️

It’s still not a nice thing to say to someone, lots of people don’t share why they won’t have kids, whether its fertility issues or not finding the right partner or money worries.

It’s possible to challenge people without being spiteful and making snide comments about future babies that they may never have.

Passingthethyme · 30/01/2024 21:29

EbonyRaven · 30/01/2024 20:46

Methinks the lady doth protest too much... Wink

Probably wants children herself deep down. It's denial - and the hatred for children is a dead giveaway.

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!' Grin

Although, be careful. As a few posters have said, she may desperately want children but can't conceive.

Probably wants children herself deep down. It's denial - and the hatred for children is a dead giveaway

Oh puh-leeze. Children are annoying, I only like my own and a few others

BoohooWoohoo · 30/01/2024 21:26

She’s entitled to her opinion but should be old enough and smart enough to know that saying it in front of the children is terrible manners.

Swipe left for the next trending thread