Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt my sister doesn't like the children in our family

115 replies

Outofideas79 · 30/01/2024 19:44

I feel a bit sad about this. One of my siblings has chosen not to have children, which I totally respect and understand. But the longer time goes on, the more I believe she really doesn't like her nieces and nephews, one of which is my dc. I figured not having her own would put her in the cool auntie role, but if anything she goes to lengths to avoid spending time with them. When she does spend time with them she complains about them. She perpetually talks about how seeing their behaviour makes her womb shrivel up (they really arent that terrible, jusy notmal kids). She'll make loud comments about how she must remember to take her contraceptives etc. I get she doesn't want kids, but also she says this in front of them.

If we are struggling with their behaviour she will very loudly say its our own fault for having children, she has absolutely no sympathy for us, we chose this so we shouldn't complain even though we never complain directly to her. If we talk about them with her around she'll get stroppy and say something like 'well there is nothing for me in this conversation' and withdraw. She may not glhave her own kids, but they are her family. I used to be very close to her, but I find her attitude to us as parents, and our children, really hurtful. Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 14:27

I mean yeah she's quite clearly being rude and I doubt that anyone's going to tell you YABU to be hurt by her rudeness.

Inevitably this thread will just descend into people bashing the childless/free, though, just as the last one did.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 14:26

KimberleyClark · 31/01/2024 06:28

Have there been a few of this type of thread recently - sister/SIL doesn’t want kids and is horrible about mine? Or is it just me?

Not just you. There was one in late December about a rude SIL and one in November involving a sister who had the audacity to prefer her cat to OP's kids.

graceinspace999 · 31/01/2024 13:41

LameBorzoi · 31/01/2024 07:36

@graceinspace999 Who is suggesting that OP's sister will be pushing a pram? I acknowledge social pressures, but it sounds as OP and her family have been very aware of this.

OP's sister is deliberately being very rude and almost nasty to some of her relatives who have done nothing to deserve it. Relatives who just happen to be under the age of 18.

This was said in a previous post:

EbonyRaven · Yesterday 20:46

‘Methinks the lady doth protest too much...

Probably wants children herself deep down. It's denial - and the hatred for children is a dead giveaway.

Just say 'awww you claim you loathe children, but I know you'll be pushing a pram around the street in five years time!'

Although, be careful. As a few posters have said, she may desperately want children but can't conceive.’

abouttogetlynched · 31/01/2024 10:19

As others have said, I wouldnt be surprised if actually she can’t have children or feels she’s in a position where she never will have them. In which case its a defence mechanism whereby she’s trying to convince herself/others.
Regardless of that though it’s unfair for her to keep making the comments that she does. It’s unpleasant for the kids to hear, but also not nice for the parents - would she like you to constantly be making jibes at her for NOT having kids? I think not.
I would just say to her We get that you don’t want kids and respect that, but please can you stop with the comments. It’s unsupportive to us as parents and it’s upsetting for the kids to hear that their auntie who they love thinks that they’re a nightmare.

phoenixrosehere · 31/01/2024 10:02

BlueRidgeMountains · 31/01/2024 09:39

She sounds a nasty bit of work and probably for the best she doesn't have children.
Your children are much better off without someone as nasty and judgemental in their lives.
I always think people who act like this, whether children, dogs, cats whatever are deeply miserable and find little joy in anything, that's why they go out of their way to spoil others enjoyment.
If they see a dog running free at a park they have to complain,try and ruin it for everyone.

I definitely think it screams attention-seeking and yet OP gets guilted into accommodating her and can’t leave her out.

I would say the sister is acting like a child herself but even most children I’ve encountered don’t act like that about something they dislike.

SomeCatFromJapan · 31/01/2024 09:46

She's being a dick. I'm childfree and don't massively love being around small children but she's rude, as well as tedious making such a massive thing about it.

I wouldn't have dreamed of excluding my sublings' children, as sticky as they occasionally were, and now they're older and they're great fun so it was worth a bit of tolerance.

BlueRidgeMountains · 31/01/2024 09:39

She sounds a nasty bit of work and probably for the best she doesn't have children.
Your children are much better off without someone as nasty and judgemental in their lives.
I always think people who act like this, whether children, dogs, cats whatever are deeply miserable and find little joy in anything, that's why they go out of their way to spoil others enjoyment.
If they see a dog running free at a park they have to complain,try and ruin it for everyone.

SD1978 · 31/01/2024 09:35

I would have to pull her up,on it to be honest, or limit my contact. You all get it she doesn't want kids. You support that, because it's a choice. But I'd have to tell her the constant berating of the kids, and refusal to allow anyone to talk about them ever, is having an effect. I'd even mention that the cat is a more talked about 'family member' and you have no issue with her talking about it, so why can't you mention your kids? Yes, she's entitled not to be enamoured with them, but out and out rudeness would piss me off

mightydolphin · 31/01/2024 09:33

She might be confident in her choice to be childfree but feel insecure about the fact that you and your siblings have the experience of parenting in common. It must be hard seeing her parents and siblings all focussing on the children in the family and that might make her attention seek with these silly comments. It's not your problem and she is BU. I would probably try seeing her for a fortnightly coffee alone to rebuild the relationship if you value it. If not, reduce contact while the DC are small and see how she responds.

YuleDragon · 31/01/2024 09:26

OP, have you ever tried directly asking her if she realises what an obnoxious arse she sounds like when she goes on like that?

I would have if it was my brother... we both tell each other when we're being idiots about something.

Micsam89 · 31/01/2024 09:23

@1ittlegreen you've answered your own question "it started" as that, but there is heaps of valuable information, chats and community on here that doesn't revolve around children. I found my way here through a google search for something unrelated to kids and I stay for some of the chats, but mostly for entertainment on AIBU

nightymoose · 31/01/2024 09:20

I don't want kids (unfortunately for my two 😂) but seriously I can totally understand her feelings about kids and having been a kid herself when she was a child is bugger all to do with it. I think its great for kids, especially girls to see positive role models of childfree women, it is something I never had and I always remember when I'd hear of some poor soul who'd never had children, I a child myself at that time would think, oh how very sad for them, like it was the greatest sorrow imaginable! Now I realise that it may very well have been a choice and that they were loving their lives childfree.

Having said all that there isn't any reason to be unkind about the kids and saying things like her womb shrivelling up is just mean and inappropriate. I've lurked on some online childfree spaces and there is a lot of talk like that calling mothers mombies (like zombies) or breeders and children crotch goblins. So I wonder if she is using spaces like that and just picking up that way of talking?

It could also be that she just lacks confidence with the kids and sees no reason to attain it. I felt that way about my older siblings kids. I didn't have the confidence to look after them on my own, I didn't know what to say to make them laugh. But that changed as my nieces got a bit older and my nephew decided he loved me no matter how awkward I felt myself! Then I was foolishly seduced into having my own which is the best worst mistake I ever made!

AmazingBouncingFerret · 31/01/2024 08:37

Is she even your sister if you don’t meet her “womb shrivelling up” comments with “so it matches your head then” fight rudeness with childish rudeness, it’s what siblings are for!

Angrycat2768 · 31/01/2024 07:45

Catsmere · 30/01/2024 22:07

Oh here we go, the inevitable "they'll be wiping your arse" comment. Amazing how many people here apparently have children to make them work in aged care.

Re-reading the OP, I wonder how many nieces and nephews there are and how much time her sister has previously found herself having to spend with all of them at once? That would do my head in and her sister is presumably reacting to too many noisy children at once, and perhaps trying to prevent further exposure. Rude way to do it, but if she's at the end of her tether with other people's children, understandable.

It's also a reach to suggest she'll come looking for a relationship with them as adults. They may have nothing in common at all. Being related is a poor basis for assuming a desire for contact ime.

The OP stated that the sister makes her feel guilty if she's excluded from child related activities. In any case, the children are part of the family. Presumably she ' has' to spend time with then on family occasions, like birthdays and Christmas? If all the siblings are together that presumes a big family occasion, so either she stays away or she stops being so rude.

ArtificialElephants · 31/01/2024 07:41

When you're not around children very much/not used to them, I think their normal behaviour can be tiring, strange and annoying.

None of which excuses her comments though, as presumably she has been around PEOPLE before and knows about manners.

FloorWipes · 31/01/2024 07:40

Children are humans. Imagine if someone made comments about not wanting to be around old people or women or something. I'm not the most child oriented person. I've got one and I'm pretty clear that it's as much as I can handle! I'm mindful not to bang on about her to people who wouldn't be interested. I don't hold people's small babies as it makes me nervous but I'm happy to coo over them since people appreciate that. I'm honest that being in a room full of loud children takes a toll and imaginary play is really hard for me. And yet I'm nice to children and about children and at gatherings I will be the one going off to play with them if needed! Surely it's not hard to be civil and polite to children at least.

LameBorzoi · 31/01/2024 07:36

@graceinspace999 Who is suggesting that OP's sister will be pushing a pram? I acknowledge social pressures, but it sounds as OP and her family have been very aware of this.

OP's sister is deliberately being very rude and almost nasty to some of her relatives who have done nothing to deserve it. Relatives who just happen to be under the age of 18.

1ittlegreen · 31/01/2024 07:09

There are so many child-free women on this post that have consciously made that decision and I'm wondering, what was it that made you navigate to a site called mumsnet? It started as an invaluable place for advice about kids so what peaked your interest?

If someone commented about their 'womb shrivelling up' in front of my dc, my womb would ache. Especially if it came from my sister.

Op, I'm sorry your relationship isn't the same but the disdain she shows towards your kids is damaging for your family, and you need to tell her.

If she was saying rude things about your partner, I'm sure you would set her straight.

Jifmicroliquid · 31/01/2024 07:07

Shoppingfiend · 31/01/2024 06:51

People talking about their pet - I mean it’s so boring unless you also have a dog/cat to compare notes.
I would tell her you have no interest in her cat as she is so rude about DCs.

The same could be said for people talking about their children.

I am childfree by choice and I struggle in the company of badly behaved children, but I absolutely adore well behaved, polite children.
One of my friends has 2 children who I think most would agree are a bit wild. They scream at the top of their lungs indoors, climb on furniture, jump on people… I would never be rude to or about them to my friend but I don’t enjoy their company and find they dominate everything.

Another friend has a beautifully behaved little girl and I’d play with her all day and have all the time in the world for her.

Might your children be a little bit too boisterous for your sister? That said, she should not be rude infront of them.

paisley256 · 31/01/2024 07:06

She sounds quite childish.

Broodywuz · 31/01/2024 07:04

Maybe already mentioned but do you think there's a chance maybe she can't have kids or doesn't think she ever will if she has no partner etc and this is her way of dealing with it

Plumtop11 · 31/01/2024 06:59

Sounds as though she's trying to justify her decision not to have kids to everyone else and perhaps herself a little.

I'd just not force the relationships on her or the kids and spend less time together. I'd also have a word with her and ask her to think about she speaks in front of your children.

graceinspace999 · 31/01/2024 06:59

Maybe she’s rebelling against the idea that all women want or like kids.

Women are under pressure to have kids, sometimes it’s subtle and sometimes it’s overt.

Suggesting that she’ll be pushing a pram down the street like the rest of us are just plain rude and intrusive.

It can be tiresome being around kids when you’re not interested in them.

Maybe just meet her without kids for a child free drink or meal.

Maybe she can be the cool aunt who doesn’t want kids and be an excellent role model for choice 🤷‍♀️

Shoppingfiend · 31/01/2024 06:51

People talking about their pet - I mean it’s so boring unless you also have a dog/cat to compare notes.
I would tell her you have no interest in her cat as she is so rude about DCs.

Outofideas79 · 31/01/2024 06:47

Not to my knowledge @noexcusesforlatenessalan

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread