Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are less spontaneous now than they used to be

62 replies

LittleMissUnreasonable · 30/01/2024 17:35

I was born in the 80s, grew up in 90s and this is something I've just realised. People seemed to have much more time back then than they do now. Previously if you wanted to chat to someone, you'd give them a call on the landline, no scheduled "are you free next week for a call".
People would pop around and 9/10 someone would be in to offer a cuppa and a chat. Even meeting up, it was a case of "shall we meet in town at 12 on Saturday?" Now it's hard arranging to meet friends with a month's notice as everyone seems to be busy

What happened? I know I'm probably looking back on the 90s with misty eyes, but things just seemed a lot more..social

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 01/02/2024 12:49

Yes I was thinking of primary age and TBF DS was friendly with a child in our cul de sac and they would just pop round each other's houses . School friends though was always pre-arranged as they would go back to each other's house after school. Think they got their own phones Y6 (so 10 years ago)

GingerIsBest · 01/02/2024 12:22

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 01/02/2024 11:30

As a child (1970s) we would just turn up at a friend's house 'can Julie play?'. No pre-arranged play dates.

Sure, if your friend lives on the same street and/or when you were older. DS was lucky enough to have two friends in our very close neighbourhood. They would just turn up to play or he'd pop over there. DD on the other hand, doesn't have any friends that are close enough for her just to wander over and hang out.

DS is now 12, he travels quite far to hang out with friends and ditto them to come to ours. They organise it themselves.

StrawberrySquash · 01/02/2024 12:06

I think some of it is that we live further from the people we socialise with. My ex boyfriend had family nearby and they would drop in lots. My aubts an uncles were all miles away so it was totally different.

And if it's a neighbour dropping in it's not a big deal if you are busy. If the people have to travel it is. So people plan more. And hence the social norm shifts more towards planning.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 01/02/2024 11:32

I think the restaurants wanting bookings even though they have empty tables is around staffing levels .

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 01/02/2024 11:30

As a child (1970s) we would just turn up at a friend's house 'can Julie play?'. No pre-arranged play dates.

GingerIsBest · 01/02/2024 11:15

I think there's a bit of misty-eyed glow going on here in terms of how great it was or how common. Although I think some of the more spontaneous stuff probably did happen, but I think there were a lot of reasons that are less realistic today.

For example, I think people's communities were physically smaller. My friends now are quite spread out - I wouldn't just drive by Friend A's house because frankly, it's too far. Similarly, we don't all meet at the pub on a Friday because we'd be coming from all over. And a similar, but slightly different version of that, is that my friends aren't all friends with each other. I can have a friend from work who lives say 25 minutes from me so we can become good enough friends to meet up on weekends, but she's not popping down to my local on a Tuesday night spontaneously. Our networks are all bigger and there's less overlap basically - when I first moved to London, I moved to an area with lots of my uni and school friends had congregated so yes, we regularly would spontaneously meet up at the pub across the road. Because we'd all just walk down and it was good to have other randoms turning up. But those same friends have now moved further away and it becomes more complicated.

I also think finances were different. On the one hand, people didn't have a lot of "Stuff" or whatever, but I think there was a bit more disposable income. DH and I don't pop down for a pub lunch on a Sunday with the kids and hope to see other local families there because frankly, a pub lunch for the four of us at our local would cost a minimum of £30 a head. £120 is more than half my weekly shop. And we're not exactly on the breadline - money is a bit tight at times but overall, we're living a pretty good life and not massively struggling.

The other thing is, I think, age. My DC are getting a bit older and I'm finding that we're slipping slightly back into a more spontaneous lifestyle. Partly because as a result of having children and living in the same area, we do actually have more local friends than a few years ago. It's also easier as we're not exhausted all the time and we can bring the DC or leave them at home easier. So these days, it's not entirely uncommon for me to randomly ring a mate and suggests her and her family come over to ours for a spontaneous Friday night BBQ or for someone to contact me and ask if I want to go for a drink that night and I can just go, in a way I couldn't when the DC were smaller.

phoenixrosehere · 01/02/2024 10:59

CaramelMac · 01/02/2024 08:04

I do agree with this.

The internet has changed our lives completely but I’m not convinced the good outweighs the bad. I’m so glad it wasn’t around when I was a teenager.

I grew up with the beginnings of social media. MySpace was the first social media for us in secondary. We would go to the school computer lab and spend our time talking and discussing what we were putting on our MySpace pages not knowing we were learning to code. Facebook came out my first year of uni. Mates and I would go to parties from other unis to meet new people and socialise (we were at a smaller, private uni). I remember what life was like before social media and like a pp said, if you’re someone into niche things, especially as a teenager it was great to find like-minded individuals to discuss such things without being dubbed weird, awkward, or in other words, not normal which is isolating.

I’m glad I grew up having it the way I did than not having it at all or only knowing of its existence.

I still rather have it than not. I wouldn’t have learned half the things I know now which would have been time-consuming and costly to learn by travelling somewhere else.

The only things that has changed really imo is expectations and people being more honest about them whether people like it or not.

KreedKafer · 01/02/2024 10:15

WaterHound · 30/01/2024 19:01

The 90s were great OP - no fucking internet to speak of and no crappy social media. The world was better for it.

Edited

I was a teenager in the 90s and I actually think the internet would have made me a lot happier.

If you're the sort of kid who (like me) has fairly niche interests that aren't really shared by their school friends etc, the internet is really the only place you can immerse yourself, talk to likeminded people, feel like you're part of a community etc. One of my hobbies as a teenager was writing horror fiction and I had nowhere to talk about that, learn, get feedback etc. I was also really into old cult tv shows and films and stuff which none of my friends (lovely though my friends were/are) were interested in. There are a couple of Facebook groups I'm in now and YouTube channels I follow related to hobbies and interests that would have been absolutely brilliant for me when I was a teenager.

TheBayLady · 01/02/2024 09:53

I think a some of the scheduling is down to people pretending they are soo busy and are so important that they need to book things weeks in advance, while in reality they are so bloody anxious they can't step out the door unless they have 72 hours notice.

CaramelMac · 01/02/2024 08:04

WaterHound · 30/01/2024 19:01

The 90s were great OP - no fucking internet to speak of and no crappy social media. The world was better for it.

Edited

I do agree with this.

The internet has changed our lives completely but I’m not convinced the good outweighs the bad. I’m so glad it wasn’t around when I was a teenager.

Ap24 · 31/01/2024 22:21

None of my relatives worked as much as myself and my friends do now. I vaguely remember my uncle putting in some overtime to pay for a big holiday but his wife at the time didn't work. At the weekends I don't want to be spontaneous, I want to get on top of the housework and then get outside. I see people all week whilst being cooped up in an office.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 31/01/2024 22:07

I was born in 88 and Saturday's were spent visiting relatives some with no notice, some we'd ring a couple of hours before just to check if they were free.

TheSpruce · 31/01/2024 21:20

We've also discussed similar about travel in the last 30 years. It's become increasingly difficult to have any spontaneity - everywhere now needs tickets pre booking or reservations made. You can't just explore many places unless you've strictly planned where you need to be, what you're going to eat. Exhausting!

Tiredalwaystired · 31/01/2024 21:13

If you rang back then and they were busy or out they just didn’t pick up. You wouldn’t think anything about it. Now, they’ll pick up and tell you they’re busy or out. So it’s more obvious.

Albarinoqueen · 31/01/2024 21:04

My sister and I live 3 mins apart - we never pre arrange - knock on door - either in or out - great !!

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 31/01/2024 21:02

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 08:03

I meant in general rather than just myself. I was talking about my parents, relatives and friends parents from experience

Thinking about my parents and their generation, loads of the women didn’t work or worked part time in not terribly stressful jobs. This means they did the house stuff during the week and weren’t trying to do it all every evening/through the weekend, leaving more time for both of them. The dads all retired in their 50s as well and most of my friends had both their parents coming in days out with them with their babies or helping with some childcare. Well still both we working till we are 67 to get any sort of pension!

Wow, how old are you that dads were retiring in their 50s??? My late DF retired when he was able to claim national superannuation at 65. I'm not in the UK, but seriously doubt super was available to men in their 50s in recent times?

My late DM worked, and did housework at the weekend, but still had time to visit friends. No, she didn't have a stressful job, but surely there are still lots of women without stressful jobs - not everyone wants a career.

However, what my parents, nor I, have done is subscribe to the manic over-washing, over-cleaning, can't have anything messy for more than five minutes sort of life than many MNers seem to have (and which I haven't encountered in real life).

NeedToKnow101 · 31/01/2024 15:47

I'll have to think about that and get back to you.

Dinoland · 31/01/2024 14:43

Totally agree with what you've posted. People used to also have parties, dinner parties, people around all the time. People are generally more insular nowadays.

phoenixrosehere · 31/01/2024 14:36

EllieQ · 31/01/2024 11:16

I think this is a really important point - I grew up in the 80s/ 90s, and most of the mums I knew either didn’t work or worked part-time. My mum worked a few mornings a week in a cleaning job, so it was hard work but not stressful. She had the afternoons to keep up with housework, which meant her weekends were mostly free. Both sets of grandparents were nearby to help out/ babysit. Parents didn’t seem to be as involved in school/ activities/ play dates as they are now.

In contrast, I work five days a week and while I try to do a few bits of housework in the evenings, I tend to have to catch up at the weekends (and this is with a DH who does his share). DD has two activities at the weekend (in part because we both work so after school activities aren’t possible for half the week), so that takes up time. Parents are expected to be more involved at school etc. We don’t have any family nearby (and because we were older parents, our parents were older grandparents and have health issues or have passed away).

I also think there’s more to do - more tv to watch, new things like podcasts and social media, new/ more available leisure activities, and the expectation/ pressure (partly social media but not just that) that you will do more with your weekends. I feel that women are expected to be devoted mothers and great wives and have a busy social life and have a successful career and look great. It all creates pressure to do ‘stuff’ and be busy all the time, and even if you’re aware of these impossible expectations, it’s hard to resist the pressure.

Edited

I said similar about there usually being a parent (usually a mum) at home.

I’d also add that many people lived closer to each other. My parents and DH’s parents see friends and family all the time because they’ve lived in the same area for most of their lives. There were more opportunities there for them that by time we grew up there were little for me or for DH so we moved as teens.
I saw my own grandparents several times a week because both sets lived 5 minutes down the road from each other and were a 20 min drive from our home. My mum would drive us to her parents, have dinner there and my dad would come by from seeing some friends after work or already at his parents and take us to his parents and we would be there for a bit and be home by 8:30-9 pm for bed.

DH and I could move closer to his parents but it wouldn’t be in our best interests or our children. Our oldest is autistic and there is only one SEN school in their area and it may not meet his needs and/or like many would have a waiting list. Where we are there are four and he goes to one and does half-terms activities in the school nearest to us which we are on a waiting list for and through one from his school.

I don’t mind a bit of spontaneity but to be honest, I don’t have the energy for it with a 3 mo who is still learning to settle with DH and making sure our other two have time with me and keeping on top of their schooling and often rather use the energy I have left for some solo self-care than meeting up with others.

meganorks · 31/01/2024 14:29

I'd say a big change is that, when I was a kids, we were all just out in the street playing. But now people are too afraid to let their kids out so we all have lots of organised clubs and activities instead. So people are often busier with this at weekends.
When it comes to communication, I think that is because of mobile phones. If you call someone on a landline and they are out and busy they aren't there to answer. Whereas with a mobile you could be anywhere. And messaging is so easy you often don't need to call.
I find post covid it is generally hard to be more spontaneous as everything seems to need booking. It's annoying as I'm not always sure what time I can get somewhere. I'd much rather be able to just turn up.

RosieAway · 31/01/2024 13:47

@mitogoshi sounds lovely. Do you mind if I ask where you live?

JaneyGee · 31/01/2024 13:22

We had more time because there weren't so many people. I'm in rural Essex, and have lived in the same area all my life. My earliest clear memories are of the late 1980's. So many fields and open spaces have disappeared over the last 40 years. My local woods have been hacked down to make way for a new housing estate. And at the other end of the village a massive housing estate has been built that is more like a mini town. Everywhere you go you see disgusting rabbit hutch new builds jammed on top of one another. My local town is a totally different place. I believe the population has nearly doubled. The traffic is now so bad I feel like a prisoner. I gave up yoga, for example, because it took me too long to drive there.

When you jam too many people into one area, it has a psychological effect. People feel squeezed and pressured and rushed. And everything become more difficult – driving, parking, walking the dog, etc. If you could jump in a time machine and visit your home town in, say, 1960, the first things that would strike you would be the space, the fields, the peace, and the slower pace of life. In 1960, there were three billion human beings on Earth. Today, there are eight billion and we're heading for ten.

Crushed23 · 31/01/2024 12:38

I think it’s down to people packing in as much as they can into their lives and living life to the full.

I absolutely loathe having nothing to do on a Saturday or Sunday, even though work can be pretty full on Mon-Fri. I like to plan things in advance so that I can make the most of the weekends, bank holidays and every day of annual leave. This makes it harder to be spontaneous.

There are a lot more activities to do and places to visit, and we are more aware of them (social media). Life is busier now, definitely, but I absolutely prefer it this way.

EllieQ · 31/01/2024 11:16

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 08:03

I meant in general rather than just myself. I was talking about my parents, relatives and friends parents from experience

Thinking about my parents and their generation, loads of the women didn’t work or worked part time in not terribly stressful jobs. This means they did the house stuff during the week and weren’t trying to do it all every evening/through the weekend, leaving more time for both of them. The dads all retired in their 50s as well and most of my friends had both their parents coming in days out with them with their babies or helping with some childcare. Well still both we working till we are 67 to get any sort of pension!

I think this is a really important point - I grew up in the 80s/ 90s, and most of the mums I knew either didn’t work or worked part-time. My mum worked a few mornings a week in a cleaning job, so it was hard work but not stressful. She had the afternoons to keep up with housework, which meant her weekends were mostly free. Both sets of grandparents were nearby to help out/ babysit. Parents didn’t seem to be as involved in school/ activities/ play dates as they are now.

In contrast, I work five days a week and while I try to do a few bits of housework in the evenings, I tend to have to catch up at the weekends (and this is with a DH who does his share). DD has two activities at the weekend (in part because we both work so after school activities aren’t possible for half the week), so that takes up time. Parents are expected to be more involved at school etc. We don’t have any family nearby (and because we were older parents, our parents were older grandparents and have health issues or have passed away).

I also think there’s more to do - more tv to watch, new things like podcasts and social media, new/ more available leisure activities, and the expectation/ pressure (partly social media but not just that) that you will do more with your weekends. I feel that women are expected to be devoted mothers and great wives and have a busy social life and have a successful career and look great. It all creates pressure to do ‘stuff’ and be busy all the time, and even if you’re aware of these impossible expectations, it’s hard to resist the pressure.

Somepeoplearesnippy · 31/01/2024 10:40

It still happens IME. The only difference is in how we communicate it. I'm in my sixties - many times I've put up a message on 'crappy social media' asking is anyone up to meet at the pub in an hour and ended up having an impromptu session with friends. Similarly I have a group of people I know I can text saying "Are you free for lunch/coffee/pizza/yoga/drinks/movie later' and know there is good chance the answer will be yes. Maybe the fact that a lot of us are now retired makes this easier?

Being old I remember the times when many people didn't even have a landline so would turn up at someone's house on spec. It wasn't great tbh. You might have a wasted journey if they were out. The house might be in a mess, you might have been looking forward to a quiet night in. The worst times were when relations or acquaintances turned up when my parents were out (probably inconveniencing some other household ) and my siblings and I would have to sit making small talk and serving tea and biscuits to someone who was undoubtedly as bored by us as we were by them.