Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need a handhold - neighbour issues and selling house

170 replies

wawawawaterloo · 30/01/2024 16:54

I'm planning on moving towards the end of the year. We have neighbours with incredibly messy and rubbish filled gardens and a previous (resolved) issue of their teens/early 20's kids being loud during the summer a few years ago.

I know I need to declare a dispute, but I don't believe anyone would buy it - I wouldn't? Landlords aren't buying locally at present, so I don't think that's an option, and I cant afford to part ex for a new build.

Do you think if we market for less than market value we'd sell? I'm thinking taking the hit and marketing at around 20-30K less just to get rid.

I will obviously talk to an EA, but at present I just need reassurance that doing something like that, at worst case, will work - as I just want to start again elsewhere.

I'm not asking if you'd buy it, as I know most (so please don't put that as it will make my anxiety worse) but it will appeal to someone relatively quickly wont it if it's under market value - or am I doomed to live here upset forever?

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 31/01/2024 18:56

Daphnis156 · 31/01/2024 18:42

You said the dispute was resolved- resolved disputes do NOT need to be declared, especially if a few years old.
As for the rest, try not to be too down about it, and don't mention the mess to prospective buyers- there are honestly people who will not care much.
Go on the market for the market price, do not start out at a discount, this will lose you thousands.
Good Luck!

Sorry but this is not correct. If neighbours have resolved disputes amicably between themselves, then it doesn’t need to be disclosed, but neighbour disputes which have been reported to the authorities have to be disclosed, resolved or not. Buyers have six years from the date of sale in which to bring legal action against a seller if non disclosure causes a problem.

Keychangeoff · 31/01/2024 18:47

Serencwtch · 31/01/2024 18:36

What area are you. Around here you'd have to take off alot more than 30k. That's a pretty serious dispute if it's gone through formal council channels.
You could try 30k but to be honest any potential buyer will be advised to knock you down a lot further.

Im guessing you’re not in London ? Anti social behaviour and neighbour disputes are fairly common here and do not equate to discounted house prices.

Daphnis156 · 31/01/2024 18:42

You said the dispute was resolved- resolved disputes do NOT need to be declared, especially if a few years old.
As for the rest, try not to be too down about it, and don't mention the mess to prospective buyers- there are honestly people who will not care much.
Go on the market for the market price, do not start out at a discount, this will lose you thousands.
Good Luck!

Serencwtch · 31/01/2024 18:36

What area are you. Around here you'd have to take off alot more than 30k. That's a pretty serious dispute if it's gone through formal council channels.
You could try 30k but to be honest any potential buyer will be advised to knock you down a lot further.

BinsinBonson · 31/01/2024 18:32

Rosscameasdoody · 31/01/2024 17:57

Councils have an Anti Social Behaviour Unit and a Neighbourhood Anti Social Behaviour Unit. One deals with council tenants and the other with private tenants and owners. So if a seller has had a previous dispute with a neighbour and has lodged a complaint with the council at any time, there will be a record. If the seller doesn’t declare the dispute and there are problems with neighbours after the buyer has moved in, it’s a simple matter for them to contact the local authority and enquire as to whether there have been any neighbour disputes lodged at the address. The then have six years in which to take action against the seller for non disclosure.

Yes, I wouldn’t rely on just hoping that it doesn’t come out. When we had our NDN issues someone from the council anti-social behaviour team came out to our house and the very first thing they said was that they’d never heard of any problems with our street before. Imagine how easy it would have been for them to comment that it wasn’t the first time they’d been there if that had instead been the case!

We’ll never know if the previous owner had problems, but we know without having formally asked that he hadn’t involved the council. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said of us.

Keychangeoff · 31/01/2024 18:28

EdinGirl · 31/01/2024 17:58

Pay the neighbours a grand under the agreement they keep the garden spotless for a certain period of time??

Less money than you would lose otherwise!

This is a great idea. It might also inspire them to turn over a new leaf too. No pun intended.

Keychangeoff · 31/01/2024 18:26

Try not to panic , there is almost always at least one person willing to buy a house. Market it far and wide. You’ve already realised it’s sensible to price it realistically (most sellers do not ) It’s unlikely to not sell at all but you need patience and resolve.

Most people cannot afford to tick all their house buying boxes so have to compromise and you will find your buyers that are willing to overlook messy gardens in favour of location etc

Rosscameasdoody · 31/01/2024 18:26

RosePetals86 · 31/01/2024 18:01

I rang my council in a rage over my ndn years ago- an argument about noise. Nothing ever formal came of it, didn’t even get a log number would I have to disclose that?

Councils have a duty to investigate all complaints and they would have contacted your neighbour without disclosing who has made the complaint. You wouldn’t necessarily be advised of the outcome, as if there isn’t enough evidence to warrant further action they would close the complaint but a record would still be on file and referred back to if you made any further complaint.

pam290358 · 31/01/2024 18:18

Scousefab · 31/01/2024 16:49

Depends if any action was taken. GDPR they can only hold records for six years.

Our LA keeps records of disputes filed for six years after the resolution or closure of the dispute. But when we had a problem we were able to access information beyond that because they don’t destroy the records, they archive them.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 31/01/2024 18:06

ilovemyspace · 31/01/2024 17:59

@ButterBastardBeans This is quoted from a help and advice site and seems to sum it up best:
The most common types of disputes that would need to be declared on the SPIF are anything that involves shared house maintenance (this is usually to do with repairs to shared facilities like drains or gutters) or boundary disputes (disputes involving land or fence/hedges).

It’s also important to remember that action can be taken by buyers for years after the sale of your property has gone through.

So, even once you’ve moved out, the problem could come back to bite you if you’re not upfront and honest with buyers from the start.

On the other side of the coin, there are issues that you needn’t mention. For instance, you might have a neighbour who was once a regular holder of noisy, raucous parties, but this is now no longer a problem.

In this case, your buyer would not need to be informed. Similarly, if an issue has been dealt with amicably between you and your neighbour, there is no need to mention this to prospective buyers.

Other issues such as noise, children and pets tend to be very subjective – so, just because you’ve been driven crazy by the neighbour’s dog barking, doesn’t mean your buyers (who may have pets themselves) will think the same. In other words, you are under no obligation to inform would-be buyers of things like this.
It’s best to check with your solicitor or estate agent if you are unsure about any of this, what constitutes a dispute and what, if anything, you need to declare.

The SPIF is a legal part of the contract between you and your buyer, so it’s important to get this right to prevent any issues occurring at a later date.

Important to remember that the advice in paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 doesn’t apply if the dispute has gone beyond a private matter between neighbours. Once a dispute has been reported to the authorities it has to be disclosed, regardless of whether it has been settled or not.

RosePetals86 · 31/01/2024 18:01

I rang my council in a rage over my ndn years ago- an argument about noise. Nothing ever formal came of it, didn’t even get a log number would I have to disclose that?

ilovemyspace · 31/01/2024 17:59

@ButterBastardBeans This is quoted from a help and advice site and seems to sum it up best:
The most common types of disputes that would need to be declared on the SPIF are anything that involves shared house maintenance (this is usually to do with repairs to shared facilities like drains or gutters) or boundary disputes (disputes involving land or fence/hedges).

It’s also important to remember that action can be taken by buyers for years after the sale of your property has gone through.

So, even once you’ve moved out, the problem could come back to bite you if you’re not upfront and honest with buyers from the start.

On the other side of the coin, there are issues that you needn’t mention. For instance, you might have a neighbour who was once a regular holder of noisy, raucous parties, but this is now no longer a problem.

In this case, your buyer would not need to be informed. Similarly, if an issue has been dealt with amicably between you and your neighbour, there is no need to mention this to prospective buyers.

Other issues such as noise, children and pets tend to be very subjective – so, just because you’ve been driven crazy by the neighbour’s dog barking, doesn’t mean your buyers (who may have pets themselves) will think the same. In other words, you are under no obligation to inform would-be buyers of things like this.
It’s best to check with your solicitor or estate agent if you are unsure about any of this, what constitutes a dispute and what, if anything, you need to declare.

The SPIF is a legal part of the contract between you and your buyer, so it’s important to get this right to prevent any issues occurring at a later date.

EdinGirl · 31/01/2024 17:58

Pay the neighbours a grand under the agreement they keep the garden spotless for a certain period of time??

Less money than you would lose otherwise!

Rosscameasdoody · 31/01/2024 17:57

Maryquitecontrarymary · 31/01/2024 14:59

I'm struggling to work out how a buyer can find out about disputes. I've googled this extensively and all I can find is information about how you must declare disputes, but nothing on how a buyer could find out.
Example. Person A makes complaint to council about person B down the road about a noise nuisance issue with their alarm. Council writes to person B. Noise stops and never happens again. Person B was probably oblivious they were bothering anyone.
Person B has no idea who complained.
5 years later person A sells house and doesn't declare any dispute.
How would the buyer ever know?

Councils have an Anti Social Behaviour Unit and a Neighbourhood Anti Social Behaviour Unit. One deals with council tenants and the other with private tenants and owners. So if a seller has had a previous dispute with a neighbour and has lodged a complaint with the council at any time, there will be a record. If the seller doesn’t declare the dispute and there are problems with neighbours after the buyer has moved in, it’s a simple matter for them to contact the local authority and enquire as to whether there have been any neighbour disputes lodged at the address. The then have six years in which to take action against the seller for non disclosure.

Cerealkiller4U · 31/01/2024 17:56

Like a dispute? If the authorities like council had to get involved? Like noise disputes etc?

I might be totally wrong tho….

Cerealkiller4U · 31/01/2024 17:56

wawawawaterloo · 30/01/2024 16:58

I did, stupidly, my child was incredibly sick in and out of hospital, and I spoke to Council to as I was in fear of my childs life and couldn't face them but needed quiet for their recovery once home. I'm aware other neighbours complained too.

I did think you had to declare any issues you’ve had that are official?

my brain isn’t working tonight so if this doesn’t make any sense then I apologise
😂

user1471538283 · 31/01/2024 17:52

@ButterBastardBeans - I think a dispute to be declared if it is your neighboring property or attached to yours. You seem to be making a complaint about how land you don't own is being used and the treatment of the animals. That isn't a dispute that would affect your home if you were to sell.

pam290358 · 31/01/2024 17:51

Anononony · 31/01/2024 15:32

If it helps you feel less nervous, I wouldn't care about either issues, the rubbish isn't in my garden (can you see it when you're in your garden or is it hidden by fencing? Does it stink?) So wouldn't bother me (we've also been those people in the past so know how easy it is for it to get that way and how overwhelming it is to put right when you can't afford to hire someone to haul it all away). The noise issue is resolved and if explained then it's obviously teen noise and they have (or will soon) outgrow it.

We're not ideal neighbours ourselves (would love to live in a detached house but that's not on the cards quite yet), so having neighbours who have minor issues we could use to compromise with if they had problems would actually make me more comfortable (in terms of our kids having bricks for feet etc), as long as they're not junkies or unpleasant people.

Assuming there's no other major issues with the house then put it on at market value and expect offers under.

Does this mean though that if my mum wanted to sell she would have to declare the noise complaint she made regarding the dog across the road?

It really doesn’t matter whether you care about the issue or not. The point is, failing to disclose a dispute leaves the seller open to legal action if there’s a problem after the buyer moves in and they discover that there is non disclosure of a previous dispute - resolved or not.

EveryoneEnviesMeEverywhere · 31/01/2024 17:50

Try an auction - find out fees etc and go for oe with a big coverage - be aware of all fees, and if not sold and PUT a RESERVE price - but look out for the fees.

At the right price everything sells, trust me.

Good luck and I hope your next door end up with like-minded lot but I do feel sorry for others in your area that live near you

Scousefab · 31/01/2024 16:49

Depends if any action was taken. GDPR they can only hold records for six years.

Anononony · 31/01/2024 15:32

If it helps you feel less nervous, I wouldn't care about either issues, the rubbish isn't in my garden (can you see it when you're in your garden or is it hidden by fencing? Does it stink?) So wouldn't bother me (we've also been those people in the past so know how easy it is for it to get that way and how overwhelming it is to put right when you can't afford to hire someone to haul it all away). The noise issue is resolved and if explained then it's obviously teen noise and they have (or will soon) outgrow it.

We're not ideal neighbours ourselves (would love to live in a detached house but that's not on the cards quite yet), so having neighbours who have minor issues we could use to compromise with if they had problems would actually make me more comfortable (in terms of our kids having bricks for feet etc), as long as they're not junkies or unpleasant people.

Assuming there's no other major issues with the house then put it on at market value and expect offers under.

Does this mean though that if my mum wanted to sell she would have to declare the noise complaint she made regarding the dog across the road?

OVienna · 31/01/2024 15:31

I can't remember what is on it. We've had no disputes to declare and weren't made aware of any in properties we've bought.

OVienna · 31/01/2024 15:30

Maryquitecontrarymary · 31/01/2024 15:25

But surely if that the case, there wouldn't be any talk of buyers suing the sellers, as the issue would be brought to light pre sale?

Very true. I don't know but suspect the form is worded in such a way people feel compelled to disclose stuff which as you say isn't really discoverable in other ways, unless there's been court action. In that case, you could find a reference to it publicly.

Maryquitecontrarymary · 31/01/2024 15:25

But surely if that the case, there wouldn't be any talk of buyers suing the sellers, as the issue would be brought to light pre sale?

OVienna · 31/01/2024 15:16

Maryquitecontrarymary · 31/01/2024 14:59

I'm struggling to work out how a buyer can find out about disputes. I've googled this extensively and all I can find is information about how you must declare disputes, but nothing on how a buyer could find out.
Example. Person A makes complaint to council about person B down the road about a noise nuisance issue with their alarm. Council writes to person B. Noise stops and never happens again. Person B was probably oblivious they were bothering anyone.
Person B has no idea who complained.
5 years later person A sells house and doesn't declare any dispute.
How would the buyer ever know?

This is a good question, esp under data privacy laws. I am wondering if there is something that solicitors can do which wouldn't be available to the general public, in connection with a sale.