Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need a handhold - neighbour issues and selling house

170 replies

wawawawaterloo · 30/01/2024 16:54

I'm planning on moving towards the end of the year. We have neighbours with incredibly messy and rubbish filled gardens and a previous (resolved) issue of their teens/early 20's kids being loud during the summer a few years ago.

I know I need to declare a dispute, but I don't believe anyone would buy it - I wouldn't? Landlords aren't buying locally at present, so I don't think that's an option, and I cant afford to part ex for a new build.

Do you think if we market for less than market value we'd sell? I'm thinking taking the hit and marketing at around 20-30K less just to get rid.

I will obviously talk to an EA, but at present I just need reassurance that doing something like that, at worst case, will work - as I just want to start again elsewhere.

I'm not asking if you'd buy it, as I know most (so please don't put that as it will make my anxiety worse) but it will appeal to someone relatively quickly wont it if it's under market value - or am I doomed to live here upset forever?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BrummiMummi · 02/02/2024 20:02

Not quite the same but we used to live on a major road, on a fast bend - lovely house but it put a lot of people off - after a while of trying to sell we marketed it in a local area that people would be aspiring to move to ours from - worked out well in the end

OldPerson · 01/02/2024 20:42

I would include neighbour dispute - because it relates to teens no longer living there. But everyone will see the rubbish next door. I sort of think people will get an idea of the area, as will estate agents. Go by their valuation. It's their job to sell the property. Anyone who takes on the property will offer less than it's advertised for anyway. Just had it over to an Estate Agent to sell. You're too emotionally drained to sell it yourself.

Sheerdetermination · 01/02/2024 19:55

Pepin83 · 01/02/2024 08:40

This happened to my parents, they sold a year or so ago at a fair market price and one they were happy with. I think sometimes the emotional weight of the dispute weighs heavily on you so you think everyone will have the same reaction. My parents buyers were also happy with the price (it was a very nice house) and have had no problems at all and are very happy there. (Information from neighbours). Market it at a fair price, take good legal advice on filling in the forms and try not to worry about it. It may take a while to sell because the market is slow generally, so think about what sort of offers you are willing to except and don't overly dwell on the neighbour issue.

This is sage advice

Sheerdetermination · 01/02/2024 19:52

I had to sell a flat with nightmare neighbours. It was a slightly different situation as I hadn’t made any formal complaint. However I don’t believe it was ‘stupid’ to do that in your circumstances- you did what you had to at the time in exceptionally difficult circumstances. The best thing you can now do is get some estate agents in. Be honest with them about the formal complaint and hint at the other issues and they will give you an expert strategy on how to present it to sellers. Mine were also great at giving advice and support through the whole process.
They'll tell you what to market it at, how to present the dispute and will help you hold steady along the way. Good luck, and don’t worry about what hasn’t happened yet. I think you’ll be fine!

Superscientist · 01/02/2024 19:31

We had issues with a neighbours teenaged daughters one summer and made complaints. They had moved out by the time we put our house on the market and the parents were kind enough to put their house on the market the same day as we did so a completely resolved issue.

I would absolutely not put it on for anything less than market value. Whenever we see anything on the market for less we assume there's something wrong with the neighbours or the house first. We did view some and if we then found reports we would assume that they were still ongoing and more of a problem than declared. So I would put it on for the market value but let your agent know what you would be willing to accept for a quick sale.

FreddieMercurysCat · 01/02/2024 19:13

I’d start at market rate. Personally speaking, I don’t give a fig about messy neighbouring gardens, only whether they’re decent people otherwise. We live next door to a home that is immaculate, but it doesn’t change the facts that the people who live there are total shitcunts who have caused us nothing but stress and grief only for the fact that they weren’t left anything in my father’s will (our house was inherited from him after he passed away). Crazy doesn’t even begin to cover it.

Elisi · 01/02/2024 18:59

@stomachameleon Most sensible reply I've read yet.

Pepin83 · 01/02/2024 08:40

This happened to my parents, they sold a year or so ago at a fair market price and one they were happy with. I think sometimes the emotional weight of the dispute weighs heavily on you so you think everyone will have the same reaction. My parents buyers were also happy with the price (it was a very nice house) and have had no problems at all and are very happy there. (Information from neighbours). Market it at a fair price, take good legal advice on filling in the forms and try not to worry about it. It may take a while to sell because the market is slow generally, so think about what sort of offers you are willing to except and don't overly dwell on the neighbour issue.

Grimbelina · 01/02/2024 08:38

I think you should check with your solicitor but probably best to say there was an issue but it was resolved.

Epidote · 01/02/2024 07:30

Market value and then negotiate.

TheRussiansAreComing · 01/02/2024 00:14

Let your EA guide you on the price and be prepared to take an offer.
You can gradually decrease the price if you’re not receiving any offers.
Make sure your EA hosts the viewings and make sure you're out. Then potential buyers can’t ask you awkward questions.

RadiatorHead · 31/01/2024 23:08

We didn’t declare a dispute over our previous next-door neighbours even though they were absolute arseholes. We just made sure to keep our distance and not report anything officially so when we got the disclosure form (or whatever it’s called) we didn’t need to put anything. A little bit immoral- yes. Do I care- no.

For all I know, they may be besties with the people living there now 🤷‍♀️

Pointerdogsrule · 31/01/2024 23:03

Haven't read through whole chain, but I purchased a property once and found out a whole list of problems with the neighbour, none of it declared, there had been complaints and disputes and lots of to and fro with the council involved.

I spoke to my solicitor about launching legal action , the thing is my solicitor found out:

Dog barking and kids noise doesn't have to be declared.
Loud parties and noise? issues has been dealt with prior to sale.

I didn't have a legal leg to stand on, if the neighbour started having parties, my seller could claim the parties had stopped for him and they've only started up again once I moved in.

Am I going to get the scuzzy neighbour to be a witness in my court case against the seller? Am I fuck?

All these posters telling you the buyer will be after you is bollocks. I tried and got nowhere. I was stuck with a flat with a horrible neighbour but got lucky when they left and got replaced by a nice family.

Anononony · 31/01/2024 22:26

pam290358 · 31/01/2024 17:51

It really doesn’t matter whether you care about the issue or not. The point is, failing to disclose a dispute leaves the seller open to legal action if there’s a problem after the buyer moves in and they discover that there is non disclosure of a previous dispute - resolved or not.

I am aware. I was simply reassuring the OP that there would be people out there that didn't mind if the neighbours were slightly chavvy 🤷

PlanningTowns · 31/01/2024 21:52

wawawawaterloo · 30/01/2024 16:59

Tried that - none are interested - easier to build cheap newbuilds at mass i guess.

It’s anctually about management, it costs them more to manage a single house rather than a cluster of houses together.

Maryquitecontrarymary · 31/01/2024 21:32

Rosscameasdoody · 31/01/2024 17:57

Councils have an Anti Social Behaviour Unit and a Neighbourhood Anti Social Behaviour Unit. One deals with council tenants and the other with private tenants and owners. So if a seller has had a previous dispute with a neighbour and has lodged a complaint with the council at any time, there will be a record. If the seller doesn’t declare the dispute and there are problems with neighbours after the buyer has moved in, it’s a simple matter for them to contact the local authority and enquire as to whether there have been any neighbour disputes lodged at the address. The then have six years in which to take action against the seller for non disclosure.

@Rosscameasdoody
Maybe once upon a time pre GDPR, but if person B contacted the council and asked if person A had ever made a complaint, the council would not be allowed to disclose this information under GDPR

Messyhair321 · 31/01/2024 21:28

StarlightLime · 31/01/2024 21:22

Yes.

I thought it was any communication with neighbours that might impact any aspect of the house now or in the future.
So if you've complained to the authority about a neighbour parking in front of your house & then they move & the issue is resolved, would you need to declare?
Or are you talking about boundaries etc directly impact on the property

StarlightLime · 31/01/2024 21:22

Messyhair321 · 31/01/2024 21:13

Is this correct anyone?

Yes.

Messyhair321 · 31/01/2024 21:13

user1471538283 · 31/01/2024 17:52

@ButterBastardBeans - I think a dispute to be declared if it is your neighboring property or attached to yours. You seem to be making a complaint about how land you don't own is being used and the treatment of the animals. That isn't a dispute that would affect your home if you were to sell.

Is this correct anyone?

TheSilentSister · 31/01/2024 21:09

I think on hearing the circumstances of your dispute, it wouldn't put me off - ill child - noisy teenagers. It was situational, not ongoing. Put it up for the market value and then be prepared to negotiate.
As for the rubbish filled garden, offer to pay to have it cleared. My neighbours fence was leaning over and looked awful. I went round and offered to go halves but would have been prepared to pay all if needs be. They accepted and were very grateful. I was honest 'I'm putting house on the market and the fence is a bit of an eyesore so I'm prepared to go halves, what do you think?'
Nothing ventured, nothing gained.

OrangeSofa1 · 31/01/2024 21:05

I sold due to horrific neighbours who had been interviewed under caution for harassing me. After the interview, they quietened down for a couple of months. I put the house on the market, said dispute had been resolved since the police involvement on said date. I couldn’t believe someone still wanted my house but it sold for close to what we wanted. People will believe they won’t have the same problems as you. Good luck.

Eastie77Returns · 31/01/2024 21:01

Sorry you are in this situation. Hopefully my experience offers some hope. I had a dreadful downstairs messy neighbour who was incredibly noisy, drank heavily and regularly fell asleep with cigarettes alight or the cooker on so fire engines were often called out. A kind of older, male Vicky Pollard. The only reason I didn’t make an official complaint was because I knew I wanted to sell.

On the day our EA arranged a series of viewings in our flat my heart sank as the neighbour was unfortunately hanging around making lots of noise and drinking cans of beer outside. Meanwhile another neighbour’s car, parked outside my property, had been set alight by rival drug dealers a few days before and the burnt out carcass obviously made a very poor impression. The flat had been marketed as in a ‘quiet, beautifully maintained building’😭

All of this obviously didn’t put people off as I received multiple offers that day and sold within a week. You really never know what will or won’t put people off if the price, location etc is right.

tachetastic · 31/01/2024 19:48

wawawawaterloo · 30/01/2024 16:54

I'm planning on moving towards the end of the year. We have neighbours with incredibly messy and rubbish filled gardens and a previous (resolved) issue of their teens/early 20's kids being loud during the summer a few years ago.

I know I need to declare a dispute, but I don't believe anyone would buy it - I wouldn't? Landlords aren't buying locally at present, so I don't think that's an option, and I cant afford to part ex for a new build.

Do you think if we market for less than market value we'd sell? I'm thinking taking the hit and marketing at around 20-30K less just to get rid.

I will obviously talk to an EA, but at present I just need reassurance that doing something like that, at worst case, will work - as I just want to start again elsewhere.

I'm not asking if you'd buy it, as I know most (so please don't put that as it will make my anxiety worse) but it will appeal to someone relatively quickly wont it if it's under market value - or am I doomed to live here upset forever?

Get a couple of estate agents around, be honest, and see what they say about the impact on the value. They are the experts. You might be pleasantly surprised, but if not you know and you don't have to use them if you do sell.

Otherwise as others have said, auction the house and set the lowest you would accept. You will still have to be honest of course.

I know you are worried about selling "below market value" but I think you need to accept that the market value for your house may be less than the market value would have been without your neighbours, just as it would be lower if you were next to the sewage works, or it would be higher if you had a sea view. The market value for a house has to take into account its location and its neighbours.

What I think you mean is the average market value for a house like yours in your neighbourhood, but not everyone gets that. That's why it's an average.

I know you are suffering from anxiety and I don't mean to be unkind. I just think it will be healthier for you in the long run to be realistic, rather than feel stressed about not being able to achieve (possibly) unrealistic goals. That way you may actually be nicely surprised by the outcome.

And good luck! My heart goes out to you.

Messyhair321 · 31/01/2024 19:08

How long ago did you complain? It might not look so bad if it was a while ago, the longer it was the better I think, have things improved at all? Point out the positives.
I have a similar situation & are considering selling but I've complained about neighbours parking being inconsiderate, but they aren't so inconsiderate with parking now (still very annoying people but you can't have everything), I'm thinking that as it's actually been resolved I'd say we had an issue but it's now resolved. Could you say that your position was that your dd was unwell & it was partially this that was making the neighbours untenable? That wouldn't be dishonest from what you've said.

m00rfarm · 31/01/2024 19:06

I would normally suggest to check out all the other houses in the area, i.e. 3 bed 1 bath, garden, driveway parking, and then pitch yours lower than all the competitor houses. You can do this fairly quickly providing the agents have listed the houses correctly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread