Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL crisis - moving away

336 replies

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 15:55

I moved to London for University with every intention of moving back home near my family once I'd finished... Alas, met a boy, fell in love, got married and for the past 11 years, have found myself living closer and closer to DH's family in Kent. One DD later (3) and another on the way, I've found myself becoming more and more depressed that I'm going to be expected to live here for the rest of my life and quite recently had a bit of a breakdown to DH about it. He is entirely happy to move back to my "home" and sees it as I've paid my dues living here so long already. We will be 1.5-2 hours drive away from where we are now and it will not impact jobs etc. However MIL is acting like someone's died and has locked herself in her room crying since she found out. She won't really talk to me but is being incredibly nasty to my DH saying things like "Don't take my grandchildren away from me" and "Can't you just wait until I die?" Whilst I sympathise that she will miss my DD (she looks after her once a week), I'm so scared my relationship with her is going to be ruined forever because I am getting more and more angry at how she's behaving towards us, when we should be able to move to the other side of the world should we want to! I already resent her for me living here so long already (we've both been too scared to broach the subject with her for years) and ironically, would make more of an effort to see them, if we didn't live round the corner, which I hate! Please help me to help her... before she ruins our relationship for good...

OP posts:
couiza · 31/01/2024 12:19

@5YearsLeft That is very kind of you. Thanks. I'll spend a while later investigating. Oh the joys of retirement and good health to go with it mustn't be wasted!

muddyford · 31/01/2024 12:18

A friend had this with her MIL. Latter made herself so ill she ended up in a mental health unit after losing it completely and making threats. From this it was clear why the husband chose a university 200 miles away.

Lassiata · 31/01/2024 12:12

"the only life she has ever seen for herself"... wow.

You can't make life goals like that for things over which you have absolutely no control. I do feel sorry for her but she sounds very very self-centred. 1.5 to 2 hours is NOTHING too, you could be over there every other Sunday if you were so inclined!

5YearsLeft · 31/01/2024 12:12

couiza · 31/01/2024 11:55

@5YearsLeft Sorry to go off topic for a minute, but do you have any links for these over 65 trips? I feel like an adventure coming on, and would like to go on my own too! Nothing ventured.....

@couiza I absolutely do! I was raised by two grandparents who loved to travel. This is a great article that covers a lot of the options. They used Elderhostel, which according to this, is now called Roadscholar. If one company mentioned in this appeals to you, Google it and look up reviews on other sites or people who have written about it. As you can see from the selection, “senior” is mostly so you have good company; it doesn’t mean it can’t be on the more adventurous or active side, if you’re in fine health and you want a walking tour, etc.
https://www.travelandleisure.com/trip-ideas/senior-travel/best-travel-groups-for-seniors

I also mentioned river cruises which I think are great. A wonderful way to see several places with the pleasure of a cruise and without the strain of bus or air travel when trying to see seven cities in eight days, for example. The range in price and duration - some are very expensive, but some are about the price of an average all inclusive holiday which is what they are. This page shows tons that are senior-only (my grandparents mainly traveled Holland America and Viking so if you check out either of those companies specifically, I know they’ll have cruises that are “adults only” and then “seniors only”). Here’s a very wide-ranging list with a lot of river cruises that take passengers up to age 99:
https://www.tourradar.com/pa/seniors-v-river-main

And then I’ve included this list because it specifically talks about Viking and Holland America, though I know it’s a bit US centric, but a lot of European river cruises for Americans require flying to a European destination to start so you just save a lot of money:
https://travel.usnews.com/features/bucket-list-cruises-for-seniors-and-retirees

14 Best Senior-friendly Travel Groups

These senior-friendly travel companies offer tours and travel experiences as diverse as their clients.

https://www.travelandleisure.com/trip-ideas/senior-travel/best-travel-groups-for-seniors

Ohhbaby · 31/01/2024 12:06

I would just continue the same message, understanding but firm.
Like you would with a toddler.
'i can understand why you're upset, it must be hard, but it's the best thing for our family.
'we'll miss you loads too but this is the decision we've made. It wasn't easy'
And repeat.
'ahh I hear you mil, it is hard, I know you love DD. Luckily were not too far away'.
'yep, I hear you, I know you feel abandoned.'
'i totally get where you're coming from'

Just continue to empathize but that's it.
Don't get dragged into arguments, be like a stuck radio.
You can do it.

mrlistersgelfbride · 31/01/2024 12:04

My MIL would be exactly like this.
I've learnt to not tell her too much and don't explain every decision I make.
It sounds like your DH is happy to move, so go ahead with it. You do not b eed her permission and you are not responsible for your MILs happiness. It's not like you are moving to the other side of the world-but that would be fine too.

couiza · 31/01/2024 11:55

@5YearsLeft Sorry to go off topic for a minute, but do you have any links for these over 65 trips? I feel like an adventure coming on, and would like to go on my own too! Nothing ventured.....

AnonRR · 31/01/2024 11:52

5YearsLeft · 31/01/2024 11:46

You know, what struck me about this comment is how much your MIL seems to be calling everyone’s tune, even though she’s not the one paying the piper - I’m assuming you definitely would have mentioned if she were some crazy heiress and the whole family lived off her.

As that’s not the case… maybe it’s time for full-scale changes. I was saddened by what you said about your FIL, in addition to your desire to move home. First of all, there’s no question you should move home - your DH supports it, you can have a larger house, and it’s an ideal time for DC age-wise. But second of all, I don’t know if you can talk to FIL alone, but it’s time to tell him that he doesn’t have to be beholden to her either. He can still have plenty of adventures at 70, and going off to seek them is not abandoning his wife if she has an entire family around her. There are some absolutely lovely travel groups, river cruises, etc., that only accept people over 65, and some are geared toward single travelers over 65 as well. You could even consider asking him to visit you… by himself. And take him on adventures. Let MIL lock herself in the bathroom for a month over it. She’ll come out when she gets hungry enough.

FIL often pops round on his own to do odd jobs at our house, because it's a much nicer environment. And he is more than welcome. It's my biggest concern when we move... leaving him to deal with the inevitable fall out. FIL, MIL and BIL live in a big house and no one talks to each other. Another reason why I feel so uncomfortable taking DD there... they swamp her like she's their only source of happiness and we genuinely think it's the only time they're all in the same room together! I say to my DH all the time, I'm not comfortable with them using DD in this way, and I didn't have her to fill some void they all have in their own lives.

OP posts:
5YearsLeft · 31/01/2024 11:46

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 17:57

To answer some questions...

  • Incredibly close to my DP's, my DM is the closest person to me in the world and I am far closer to her than my DH is to MIL
  • MIL has chosen to not do anything with her retirement other than wait for grandchildren to appear so there has been pressure from Day Dot to give her "the only life she has ever seen for herself". This in in spite of FIL being adventurous and wanting to go on holidays etc, but she says no. We both feel incredibly sorry for him dealing with the fall out but he has been nothing but absolutely supportive of our plans
  • I actively do not use her for any childcare unless absolutely necessary. If I had my way, she wouldn't even have DD the one day a week but I have graciously accepted my DH's financial argument on this, and again, I couldn't be bothered to deal with the fall out from her if we didn't use her at least one day a week
  • Finally, some more context, my BIL lives with IL's and both DH and I are in total agreement that we do not want DD around him if we can help it. No job, gambler, drinker etc.
Edited

You know, what struck me about this comment is how much your MIL seems to be calling everyone’s tune, even though she’s not the one paying the piper - I’m assuming you definitely would have mentioned if she were some crazy heiress and the whole family lived off her.

As that’s not the case… maybe it’s time for full-scale changes. I was saddened by what you said about your FIL, in addition to your desire to move home. First of all, there’s no question you should move home - your DH supports it, you can have a larger house, and it’s an ideal time for DC age-wise. But second of all, I don’t know if you can talk to FIL alone, but it’s time to tell him that he doesn’t have to be beholden to her either. He can still have plenty of adventures at 70, and going off to seek them is not abandoning his wife if she has an entire family around her. There are some absolutely lovely travel groups, river cruises, etc., that only accept people over 65, and some are geared toward single travelers over 65 as well. You could even consider asking him to visit you… by himself. And take him on adventures. Let MIL lock herself in the bathroom for a month over it. She’ll come out when she gets hungry enough.

couiza · 31/01/2024 11:42

Her son probably hightailed it to Newcastle to escape his mother's clutches!

He did it, now you are the sole focus of her family as you are living nearby. It is understandable that she is not happy that you are going to move also. However her woe is me attitude that is very annoying.

I am nearly her age and go here, there and everywhere at home and abroad. Lucky that I can still do it, so I make the most of my still working limbs! Life is an adventure, when one door closes another opens up. It's all about attitude.

Reassure her, explain how easy will be to get to see you and vice versa. If she continues with her martyrdom, ignore it and go. But keep the doors open and encourage visits. That's as much as you can do.

It seems as if she has a good network around her anyway so it's not as if she will be alone in the back end of nowhere with no one around.

OpieMo · 31/01/2024 11:41

What a lovely woman... not.

Simply respond as you would a toddler. Breezily validate, and continue with your plans. Leave her alone unless she approaches you. If she brings it up, validate 'oh, I know you're sad about this. It's okay to feel that way, it's a big change' and then move onto something else. And continue making your plans to move. She has no power to stop you.

Aquariumcorals · 31/01/2024 11:32

Fuck her. I'm sorry but fair is fair. She didn't care about your DM being the grandma living miles away and now the shoe is on the other foot it doesn't suit. Just make sure you visit as often as possible and crack on with moving back home.

PanettonePudding · 31/01/2024 11:30

Whoknows101 · 31/01/2024 11:21

From another perspective you've been very happy to take the free childcare for a day every week & now this is no longer needed are also quite happy to drop your MIL a stone.....

Clearly the reaction you are on the recieving end of is immature, inappropriate and pathetic though.

It works both ways - you can't expect to let your MIL invest such a huge amount of time and effort (at huge convenience to you and your DH) in caring for your young children and not to have some sort of emotional response in return when you end the arrangement.

No she hasn't. OP has covered the childcare a few times now. Read the updates.

Kewcumber · 31/01/2024 11:29

My friend moved from Stoke to London and had a family here and has no plans to move back - they came to an arrangment with her month that she's come down once a week on SUnday night and go back Tuesday monring and she's do childcare for mondays. It works really well for them when the kids were in primary.

RenegadeMrs · 31/01/2024 11:24

Ugh, I hate emotional blackmailers. I do understand she is disappointed, but you have to let other people live their lives.

My MIL is slightly inclined towards attempts to control things via emotional outbursts. Fortunatly it puts my DH's back up as much as it does mine. Ignoring it isn't comfortable, but we usually just get on with what we were planning to do anyway and she comes around because she does love DH and the kids.

Whoknows101 · 31/01/2024 11:21

From another perspective you've been very happy to take the free childcare for a day every week & now this is no longer needed are also quite happy to drop your MIL a stone.....

Clearly the reaction you are on the recieving end of is immature, inappropriate and pathetic though.

It works both ways - you can't expect to let your MIL invest such a huge amount of time and effort (at huge convenience to you and your DH) in caring for your young children and not to have some sort of emotional response in return when you end the arrangement.

laveritable · 31/01/2024 11:20

I already resent her for me living here so long already??? YABU!

bakebeans · 31/01/2024 11:19

YANBU. You need to put you and your family first. I do think though that either your DH needs to have this discussion or you both tactfully have it together with her? Is she a widow? Does she have friends whom she goes out with?

Riverlee · 31/01/2024 11:10

She sounds like a spoilt toddler having a tantrum.

Do what’s best for you and your family. You are not beholden to her.

OVienna · 31/01/2024 11:05

1.5 to 2 hours away and this woman is having a breakdown? She doesn't think the OP deserves to spend some time in HER home area, just her son? Okay, then. She does sound the centre of her own universe.

stayathomer · 31/01/2024 11:03

While yes she is being ridiculous I can see where. she's coming from and would say most of us will be in this position some day-she's got to properly know her gc while your family has missed out and now it will be tough for her to know her as well as she did, she'll miss the everyday. She'll also miss the new baby. My family barely know my mum even though she only lives an hour and a half away, she's regularly in hospital and can't travel and the only times I can see her is when I drive up when they're in school. They think they only have one gm and when we visit they're shy with her. Sorry you're going through this op, I have always said the first conversation that should take place is 'where will we live in relation to gps?' Huge conversations here always, eg I regularly drop mil to hospital and doctor, my mum gets a taxi. But we couldn't afford to live in Dublin so that decision was taken from us. It's hard

PeonyBlushSuede · 31/01/2024 10:58

@oakleaffy
"I knew of an adult daughter {a relative of a friend} who emigrated to Australia, her mother never said anything, but was like a wraith when her daughter left.

When the Mother died, the greedy daughter was back to sell the house and get the inheritance.

It would have been great if the mother had left it to a charity instead."

We don't have children to insist they live how we have or how we want them to - we raise children to at some point set them free to live their own lives.

I'm not saying it wouldn't be devastating if my child moved across the world, but also it's their choice and I wouldn't let them know and wish them well on their adventure. Also making sure I have a life outside of my children so they are not my sole connection when they move out.

You call her greedy, haven't given the full story but was she greedy or just coming back to her hometown to grieve and sort affairs - someone has to sort the sale of property.

LenaLamont · 31/01/2024 10:47

This is why my parents moved 5,000 miles away from overbearing relatives. I can't say I blame them.

Newchapterbeckons · 31/01/2024 10:47

We had this with my own family when we moved. Trust me the very best thing to say after trying everything to pacify is:

Of course you are most welcome to join us MIL

There is literally nothing she can say.
On repeat ‘you are welcome to join us there’

Be prepared, we have had over a decade of this….. and counting.

Thelnebriati · 31/01/2024 10:45

People who act nice as long as they are getting their own way aren't actually nice people. Nice parents have their children's best interests at heart.

Swipe left for the next trending thread