Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL crisis - moving away

336 replies

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 15:55

I moved to London for University with every intention of moving back home near my family once I'd finished... Alas, met a boy, fell in love, got married and for the past 11 years, have found myself living closer and closer to DH's family in Kent. One DD later (3) and another on the way, I've found myself becoming more and more depressed that I'm going to be expected to live here for the rest of my life and quite recently had a bit of a breakdown to DH about it. He is entirely happy to move back to my "home" and sees it as I've paid my dues living here so long already. We will be 1.5-2 hours drive away from where we are now and it will not impact jobs etc. However MIL is acting like someone's died and has locked herself in her room crying since she found out. She won't really talk to me but is being incredibly nasty to my DH saying things like "Don't take my grandchildren away from me" and "Can't you just wait until I die?" Whilst I sympathise that she will miss my DD (she looks after her once a week), I'm so scared my relationship with her is going to be ruined forever because I am getting more and more angry at how she's behaving towards us, when we should be able to move to the other side of the world should we want to! I already resent her for me living here so long already (we've both been too scared to broach the subject with her for years) and ironically, would make more of an effort to see them, if we didn't live round the corner, which I hate! Please help me to help her... before she ruins our relationship for good...

OP posts:
babyproblems · 31/01/2024 17:12

She sounds dramatic but equally I think she’s had your DD one day a week.. that’s a huge commitment for her (and your DD) and I wonder if you entered into that arrangement because it was conviennent for you maybe without thinking that actually it means they have a really close bond. And I am not surprised therefore your MIL is really upset about that changing. Yes it’s not too far but it’s not going to be the same for her. If you weren’t that close I’d say she’s being over the top but I can see why she is hurt.

Wednesdaysphiltrum · 31/01/2024 16:50

Why in threads about the south do people from the north randomly get triggered? Doesn’t seem to happen the other way. 😵‍💫

Wintersgirl · 31/01/2024 16:46

MagpiePi · 31/01/2024 09:45

I live in a city in the north and think it is the best place to raise children. Good schools, national parks and outdoor spaces on the doorstep, cheaper housing and cost of living, miles from dirty, crowded, expensive London. I wouldn't move south if you paid me.

Works both ways, doesn't it?!

There's more to the South of England than London don't you know? I'm down South and I have the same as you, good schools, National park on my doorstep and I wouldn't move up North if you paid me, so there you go😀

Serpentiner · 31/01/2024 16:44

Do all these granny’s and nans realise that knew the kids hit 13 they will rarely see them.!

LanaL · 31/01/2024 16:33

I can understand it must be very sad for her . My husband comes from a lovely area about an hours drive away and although I have a lot of ties here and couldn’t move , I wouldn’t mind living over that way . It’s never been a real prospect because I do have so many ties here and I wouldn’t want to move the children’s schools etc . However , I think if we ever did it would be my one child’s Nan that would be affected most and I don’t think I could do it to her. She looks at my child like her own - she does all school pick ups and drop offs to help me with work and she is amazing . She would be heartbroken and it would be such an upheaval for her and so distressing ( for my child too ) so I do understand how heartbreaking it must be for grandparents .

However , ultimately it’s your life! You are away from all your family and your child is young - moving now would be much less unsettling that having her start school and make friends and then move . As sad as it is for your MIL you have to think of your little family. She would get used to it.

I do think locking herself in a room and crying is very OTT and also unfair - sounds like emotional blackmail

Sceptical123 · 31/01/2024 15:28

It may be a big deal, but she’s had OP’s only child all to herself for years where own mother hasn’t. Another one is on the way now and ppl are saying poor MIL missing out on the new baby - what about the OTHER DGM?! She’s been in this boat since the 1st DC was born - and it may have been her only DGC. Why the double standards? If MIL gets to dictate everything based on being old and possible poor mental health in the future, she’s been extremely lucky to get her own way for so long. She was most probably an insufferable spoilt child and learned this behaviour back then. Where will it end? What about OP’s mental health, her DH’s and her DM’s??

Nonplusultra · 31/01/2024 15:28

It’s quite clear that the only way this will go smoothly is if you murder her. Assuming you’re not up for that option, it would be best if you could find a way to put it out of your head altogether. This is energy you don’t need to waste

You know the alcoholics prayer? This is one of those things that you cannot change.

How far along are your plans? I wouldn’t be sharing them stage by stage. Just get a move on. And say as little as possible between now and moving day.

Capkayser · 31/01/2024 14:44

OP, first off, are you sure you are not romanticising “home” - yes being close to your parents is nice, but if you have lived in a place for 11 years, your kids are there and you have presumably made friends, neighbours etc, what exactly is it that you are looking for in this “home” apart from your DP being close? Things may not be how you remember them.

Second, I do feel sorry for your MIL, though I understand your family choices should be yours as well. If your MIL is very close to your DD, and her reason of existence is the grandchildren, this may have a terrible effect on her mental health. My MIL died , yes, died, a few months after people dependent on her died (not us, other members of the family). It was almost as if she had nothing to live for anymore.... I dont want to catastrophise either, but just to let you see that sometimes, it really is a big deal for some elderly grandmothers...Difficult.

Jelouscat · 31/01/2024 14:22

It’s sad for her but she’s being dramatic and unfair. 2 hours isn’t horrifically far away. Could she still do some childcare if she stayed overnight once a week? Or you could commit to spending the day with her in the first Saturday of every month. Maybe you could send her a message along the lines of this like ‘we know you are going to miss us and DD. We’ll have her booked into nursery every Thursday but any time you want to you can come stay over Wednesday night and have her for the day on Thursday’

Kdtym10 · 31/01/2024 13:34

BorgQueen · 30/01/2024 16:04

She doesn’t sound ‘nuts’,
she sounds absolutely bereft, she must have a close bond with her Grandaughter if she has her one day a week.
I would be devastated if my DD decided to move a couple of hours away with my Grandson, I have him before and after school 4 days a week, after having him every week day from 9 months to 2 years.

She’ll get over it but give her a bit of bloody time and sympathy ffs.

She sounds like she’s throwing a tantrum. Absolutely she might be upset, but your job as a parent is to support your child (however old they are) in the choices that they make that will enhance their lives as they see it.

By all means be upset but don’t try and curtail your childs life to get your own way. This is one solid way to drive your child away (as is happening here)

Rubyupbeat · 31/01/2024 13:32

She is not nuts, she is heartbroken, BUT, she should never voice these things to you both and try to guilt trip, that is so wrong.
Tbh, if I was her, I would move to be nearer to your new home.

MrsSkylerWhite · 31/01/2024 13:27

MrsSkylerWhite · Today 13:26

Whoknows101 · Today 11:21

From another perspective you've been very happy to take the free childcare for a day every week & now this is no longer needed are also quite happy to drop your MIL a stone.....”

OP didn’t need or particularly want it. She allowed in to basically keep MIL happy.

I’m a MIL and a granny. I would be ashamed of myself if I had behaved as OP’s MIL has.

MrsSkylerWhite · 31/01/2024 13:26

Whoknows101 · Today 11:21

From another perspective you've been very happy to take the free childcare for a day every week & now this is no longer needed are also quite happy to drop your MIL a stone.....”

OP didn’t need or particularly want it. She allowed in to basically keep MIL happy.

I’m a MIL and a granny. I would be ashamed of myself if I had behaved as OP’s MIL has.

Ladychris · 31/01/2024 13:25

Its your live your choice, but id make it clear she could visit you

Viviennemary · 31/01/2024 13:24

You must live your life as you choose. And don't be emotionally blackmailed by this selfish woman. Fair enough she is sad you are moving further away but trying to stop you by these methods is totally out of order.

longtompot · 31/01/2024 13:08

My dhs grandma used to get the train from Cheshire to visit us in Wiltshire and didn't stop doing so until her late 70's! She'd get a taxi from her house to the station and from our station to our house, and then do it all again to get home.
I understand your mil is sad you are moving away, but you aren't going anywhere that's hard for her to get to.
Every generation, usually, hopes their children do better than they did. It sounds like you have a great opportunity to have an even better life, so absolutely go for it. Is there a room in the house that you can make as a bedroom just for them when they come to visit, just so she still feels included?

Waffle19 · 31/01/2024 12:53

My MIL was the same when we moved half an hour away….. yes half an hour! She still has digs now and doesn’t like to visit us as it’s too far. Sadly I do think it’s impacted on her relationship with our DC but that’s on her rather than us. You are absolutely making the right decision and sounds like you’ll be much happier.

Nambypambypoo · 31/01/2024 12:41

@AnonRR my in laws said similar, your parents have more time left than we do. It really annoyed me actually because why shouldn’t both sets of grandparents get to spend time with their grandchildren at every age and stage. They may be getting older every day but so are the children. It doesn’t matter who has more time left.

VampireWeekday · 31/01/2024 12:39

I understand OP, my mum would feel the same. She has always (literally, since I was 18 years old) gone on about how she wants grandchildren. She looks after DC one day a week, this is by her request, it would actually be easier and more reliable for me to have an extra nursery day (btw - it's strange to me how people on these forums assume family childcare is a massive favour, rather than a mutually enjoyable way for grandparents and grandkids to develop a relationship). She is in my opinion over the top with my DC, but it's just from a place of love. Doesn't have many close relationships in her life, loved being a mum when I was a child. She would be devasted if we moved. But I am pretty sure that she wouldn't try to manipulate us or behave like that. It isn't the feelings that are the problem, it's the way she's acting.

BlastedPimples · 31/01/2024 12:39

I think it's unfair and really selfish of any grandparent to expect their dcs and dgcs to plan their lives to live near them.

I'd hate for my dcs to feel they had to take my feelings into account when planning their lives and where they wish to reside.

They'll never know if I feel sad or upset about their choices.

Snugglemonkey · 31/01/2024 12:38

JudgeJ · 31/01/2024 12:35

I thought that the MN mantra is that 'home' is where the 'little family' lives not where either set of parents live.

When we lived abroad but came to UK during the holidays it drove me mad when my mother would insist to the children, both born overseas, that England was 'home' when they talked about going home to Germany!

Home is wherever you decide it is.

JudgeJ · 31/01/2024 12:35

Snugglemonkey · 30/01/2024 22:22

Why? Op wants to go home.

I thought that the MN mantra is that 'home' is where the 'little family' lives not where either set of parents live.

When we lived abroad but came to UK during the holidays it drove me mad when my mother would insist to the children, both born overseas, that England was 'home' when they talked about going home to Germany!

JudgeJ · 31/01/2024 12:30

ScribblingPixie · 30/01/2024 19:41

Just get on with it, OP. You're only moving 2hrs away. It's a change but it'll be fine. You're obviously not in the best place yourself, so try not to let your MIL's upset get to you. Maybe ask your DH to deal with her and not pass on to you every remark she makes. He's not helping by doing that.

On MN 1 1/2 - 2 hours away is considered the end of the earth whereas for some people it's their daily commute!

ladyvimes · 31/01/2024 12:28

She’s nuts! We live miles away from my in laws and see them loads. My kids have a wonderful relationship with them and we are all close. It’s been hard for my dh being so far away from them but has been what’s best for us as a family and my in laws totally support that! My in laws would love us to be closer but we make the most of the time we have together and really the amount of time we spend with them is probably the same as my family if you average it out over the year!

Chickenkeev · 31/01/2024 12:26

AnonRR · 31/01/2024 11:52

FIL often pops round on his own to do odd jobs at our house, because it's a much nicer environment. And he is more than welcome. It's my biggest concern when we move... leaving him to deal with the inevitable fall out. FIL, MIL and BIL live in a big house and no one talks to each other. Another reason why I feel so uncomfortable taking DD there... they swamp her like she's their only source of happiness and we genuinely think it's the only time they're all in the same room together! I say to my DH all the time, I'm not comfortable with them using DD in this way, and I didn't have her to fill some void they all have in their own lives.

Your H has no boundaries. His parents have none either. You're going to have to stand up for yourself here.