Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL crisis - moving away

336 replies

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 15:55

I moved to London for University with every intention of moving back home near my family once I'd finished... Alas, met a boy, fell in love, got married and for the past 11 years, have found myself living closer and closer to DH's family in Kent. One DD later (3) and another on the way, I've found myself becoming more and more depressed that I'm going to be expected to live here for the rest of my life and quite recently had a bit of a breakdown to DH about it. He is entirely happy to move back to my "home" and sees it as I've paid my dues living here so long already. We will be 1.5-2 hours drive away from where we are now and it will not impact jobs etc. However MIL is acting like someone's died and has locked herself in her room crying since she found out. She won't really talk to me but is being incredibly nasty to my DH saying things like "Don't take my grandchildren away from me" and "Can't you just wait until I die?" Whilst I sympathise that she will miss my DD (she looks after her once a week), I'm so scared my relationship with her is going to be ruined forever because I am getting more and more angry at how she's behaving towards us, when we should be able to move to the other side of the world should we want to! I already resent her for me living here so long already (we've both been too scared to broach the subject with her for years) and ironically, would make more of an effort to see them, if we didn't live round the corner, which I hate! Please help me to help her... before she ruins our relationship for good...

OP posts:
Remotel · 30/01/2024 17:58

shewasrooting · 30/01/2024 16:58

for the fourth time

what does your DH think about his mum and is he as bothered about it all as you are?

surely you have much much bigger things to be channeling your energy in to at this time

Embarrassingly aggressive given it’s there in her OP.

He is entirely happy to move back to my "home" and sees it as I've paid my dues living here so long already. We will be 1.5-2 hours drive away from where we are now and it will not impact jobs etc.

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 17:57

To answer some questions...

  • Incredibly close to my DP's, my DM is the closest person to me in the world and I am far closer to her than my DH is to MIL
  • MIL has chosen to not do anything with her retirement other than wait for grandchildren to appear so there has been pressure from Day Dot to give her "the only life she has ever seen for herself". This in in spite of FIL being adventurous and wanting to go on holidays etc, but she says no. We both feel incredibly sorry for him dealing with the fall out but he has been nothing but absolutely supportive of our plans
  • I actively do not use her for any childcare unless absolutely necessary. If I had my way, she wouldn't even have DD the one day a week but I have graciously accepted my DH's financial argument on this, and again, I couldn't be bothered to deal with the fall out from her if we didn't use her at least one day a week
  • Finally, some more context, my BIL lives with IL's and both DH and I are in total agreement that we do not want DD around him if we can help it. No job, gambler, drinker etc.
OP posts:
Isitautumnyet23 · 30/01/2024 17:56

She sounds absolutely nuts! Ofcourse she will be feeling abit sad, but we don’t control our children’s lives when they are adults. You are free to live wherever you want to live (perhaps remind her how many families leave for other countries every year…Australia for example). I will always encourage my kids to go wherever they want to go in life. If they have a dream to live the other side of the world, go for it (i’d be crying privately but would never force or guilt my kids to live near me).

Does she have her own life, hobbies, friends etc?

IfYouDontAsk · 30/01/2024 17:56

I can totally understand why you feel like you’re being guilt tripped…however, I can also understand why MIL is devastated that you’re moving. She’s presumably very close to your DD, looking after her once a week, and your DD will be a huge part of her life. To have that suddenly taken away (the weekly contact I mean) and without any say in the matter will obviously be hard.

Constant comments aren’t going to feel helpful as they of course aren’t going to change the fact that you’re moving. But I don’t think parents and in laws should have to cover up the fact that they’re sad their adult children are moving away.

I don’t know what the answer is, can you focus on plans for her visiting you at the new home/you going back to visit.

Zanatdy · 30/01/2024 17:55

She’s being unreasonable and you need to go, my mum was devastated when at 24 I announced I was moving to london from north wales with my then 7yr old child, the child who had lived with her for the first 18 months of his life. I’d like to say she got over it, but 23yrs later she’s learned to live with it! I probably will return in 2yrs when my youngest goes to Uni but I do love it here, but lure of cheap houses is strong. You just have to put yourself first, she’s being unreasonable. My mum enjoys me staying over and coming to stay with me too

Remotel · 30/01/2024 17:55

fleurneige · 30/01/2024 17:51

I can understand she is 'bereft' - my MIL was when we moved a good 4 hrs away when our kids were baby + toddler. But she pulled herself together, put a smile on, said she would miss us terribly and hope we would visit often and that she would be welcome to stay regularly. And she kept the brave face and support on. When she visited our new, much better and much lovelier home, which we could afford by moving north- she was so happy for us. She cried when she left, as she said she missed us all so much - but she made sure we knew that she was behind us and with us all the way. And THAT is how you earn respect and so much loved. She loved 'her' room in the house and had her own little patch of garden. None of the histrionics and emotional blackmail.

She sounds absolutely lovely and how I hope I’d manage to be in this situation.

BobbyBiscuits · 30/01/2024 17:55

The idea you wait till she dies? Your life should be uncomfortable for what, another 30 years? Now that is utter crap.
She will get over it. Your kid can come for sleepovers with her whenever she likes to an extent surely? Maybe it won't be every week but she could stay for a few days a month? I would be annoyed if I were you, but just ride it out. Your decisions are valid and do not allow her to sideline you.

Remotel · 30/01/2024 17:54

AngelinaFibres · 30/01/2024 17:17

This. I'm a MIL and look after my grandson once a week. I have a lovely life and I would fill the hole him moving away would leave , but I am not made of stone. On mumsnet all MILs are to be treated like shit. A bit of empathy wouldn't go amiss.

I don’t think the feelings are unreasonable, but the manner of expressing them is very much so.

NigellaAwesome · 30/01/2024 17:54

'Edwardandtubbs · Today 17:18

Exactly the same thing happened to me - right down to the same county! I lived in Kent for over ten years just down the road from the PILs. During that time my dad died and my mum was diagnosed with a terminal disease.

When we decided to move back closer to my mum, MIL went mad. Stopped talking to us in the end. We moved anyway. We visited recently and she told us she’d never get over it and she needed counselling to deal with the loss.

We are 2 hours drive away. The same distance I was from my parents for 10 years. She’s refusing to come and see us and is now not talking to us again. This suits me down to the ground.'

I hope the counsellor helped your MIL to recognise the narcissism in her reaction to your move, but I suspect not, given that she seems to have imparted this information to you without any sense of irony, and instead with the intention to make you feel guilty. The very fact that she felt she needed counselling for what is a fairly run of the mill situation, albeit a bit sad at the same time, suggests that she perhaps has abandonment issues which could be indicative of BPD.

Oldtigernidster · 30/01/2024 17:54

What a nasty, selfish old bat!

fleurneige · 30/01/2024 17:51

BorgQueen · 30/01/2024 16:04

She doesn’t sound ‘nuts’,
she sounds absolutely bereft, she must have a close bond with her Grandaughter if she has her one day a week.
I would be devastated if my DD decided to move a couple of hours away with my Grandson, I have him before and after school 4 days a week, after having him every week day from 9 months to 2 years.

She’ll get over it but give her a bit of bloody time and sympathy ffs.

I can understand she is 'bereft' - my MIL was when we moved a good 4 hrs away when our kids were baby + toddler. But she pulled herself together, put a smile on, said she would miss us terribly and hope we would visit often and that she would be welcome to stay regularly. And she kept the brave face and support on. When she visited our new, much better and much lovelier home, which we could afford by moving north- she was so happy for us. She cried when she left, as she said she missed us all so much - but she made sure we knew that she was behind us and with us all the way. And THAT is how you earn respect and so much loved. She loved 'her' room in the house and had her own little patch of garden. None of the histrionics and emotional blackmail.

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/01/2024 17:51

IkeaMeatballGravy · 30/01/2024 17:47

Where are you moving to? I may be biased as I am from Kent but I can't think of anywhere better to raise children. Good schools, London one side, the coast on the other and the best future opportunities for your DC. There is a reason houses are cheaper elsewhere! I do like where I live now but if I could afford it I would be there in a heartbeat!

Your post is all about you, nothing about how this move would benefit your DC. You don't like MIL but how will your DC react to being further away? Do they have much of a bond with your DPs?

Those of us from the North might beg to differ. The OP has already indicated that one benefit is the chance to have a much better house.

OhmygodDont · 30/01/2024 17:50

She may miss you guys but it’s exactly the same for your side of the family. She’s had 11 years of you and dh living on her doorstep.

The wait till I die comment is hilarious you’re nearly 70 and unless she’s elderly old could go another decade or even two.

Move feel no guilt phones call in both directions and cars travel both ways too.

Bululu · 30/01/2024 17:50

What a bloody ridiculous woman! I would try to ignore her and just move as you planned and set boundaries. How entitled. It is not even too far and she can visit on the train. This could only get worse with your second child.

I have a friend whose son from university comes to see her every weekend. 3 hrs journey and I fear the woman who marry him is going to suffered because I have a feeling the mum puts pressure on him to do the journey. Begging for love is never a good idea or ends well. We do not own our children so she is very selfish.

weaseleyes · 30/01/2024 17:49

I can absolutely understand her feeling so bereft, and I don't think anyone can tell her she oughtn't to feel like that - even if this is a common and predictable scenario. However, she clearly shouldn't be so manipulative and unpleasant about it. It doesn't sound like there's going to be any way that she will stop - just telling her it's uncalled for is unlikely to cut through her distress and what sounds like well-established patterns of behaviour.

I think all you can do is move and move quickly, not because she's a monster to get away from, but because all this anticipation is worsening it for everyone. Thinking about an unhappy event to come is agony. It's better to get it over with and then she can start adjusting to the new reality, which inevitably won't be as bad as she fears. I'd just ignore what you can for now, don't bring the subject up unless forced, shut it down quickly and just go as fast as you can.

Nonimai · 30/01/2024 17:48

I think you have to make your own decision, but I might feel rather sorry for your MIL under certain circumstances. Is she a widow? Has she been providing childcare. My mum was there at my kids birth, did an awful lot of childcare, helping out/running around and as a widow would have been utterly bereft if I had taken the kids away.

IkeaMeatballGravy · 30/01/2024 17:47

Where are you moving to? I may be biased as I am from Kent but I can't think of anywhere better to raise children. Good schools, London one side, the coast on the other and the best future opportunities for your DC. There is a reason houses are cheaper elsewhere! I do like where I live now but if I could afford it I would be there in a heartbeat!

Your post is all about you, nothing about how this move would benefit your DC. You don't like MIL but how will your DC react to being further away? Do they have much of a bond with your DPs?

mnahmnah · 30/01/2024 17:47

Have you pointed out that she can visit you when she wants? A two hour drive is hardly a rarity to manage!

5128gap · 30/01/2024 17:44

She'll miss her son and grand daughter. Living round the corner with casual day to day contact and a full day caring for DD each week isn't remotely the same as a planned visit from time to time when your commitments allow, which realistically won't be that often with busy lives and your own family on the doorstep. So however much you sell it as you'll see more of her, she isn't daft. She knows it's going to be a big change.
However it's entirely reasonable for you to live wherever you choose, and its her job to hide her feelings and let her son live his life without guilt or worry about her. Hopefully when she's got used to the idea and realises she's powerless to prevent it she'll stop this behaviour. Meanwhile, there's not a great deal you can do but ignore it. Nothing you can say will make it better.

Dacadactyl · 30/01/2024 17:44

Depends. If you've used her a lot for childcare in the past (I know you say just one day a week currently) then I'd think it was a bit rich to leave her now.

I know someone whose mum looked after all 3 of their kids, fulltime (!) til they went to school and then they all upped and left to go to Australia. If my kids did that to me, they'd be written out of my will, no doubt.

Stanfordish · 30/01/2024 17:41

OP I'd be tempted to very sincerely thank her for making the move so much easier for you all every time she behaves negatively about it.

lazyarse123 · 30/01/2024 17:40

pizzaHeart · 30/01/2024 17:32

I think you should be a bit more understanding. Yes, she reacted badly but it’s a very difficult situation to handle.
Also your move doesn’t look like you are moving for work or for bigger house or more opportunities for children. It looks like the only reason is to move from her to your parents. I get that you always wanted to come back home etc etc. but I can’t see clear argument in your post for moving, it’s just that you don’t like it here and you want to go back home. Which is fair enough but for your MIL you are making emotional decision so in a way she is entitled to give you an emotional response.
I get that your MIL is an emotional type but even though she would have responded better if she were presented with more solid arguments.

They don't need to give anybody any reasons for what they want to do. It's not really up for discussion.

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/01/2024 17:36

Honeychickpea · 30/01/2024 17:33

Yes, the childcare won't be needed anymore.

Except the OP is expecting another - not the cynical move you're suggesting.

AnonRR · 30/01/2024 17:35

pizzaHeart · 30/01/2024 17:32

I think you should be a bit more understanding. Yes, she reacted badly but it’s a very difficult situation to handle.
Also your move doesn’t look like you are moving for work or for bigger house or more opportunities for children. It looks like the only reason is to move from her to your parents. I get that you always wanted to come back home etc etc. but I can’t see clear argument in your post for moving, it’s just that you don’t like it here and you want to go back home. Which is fair enough but for your MIL you are making emotional decision so in a way she is entitled to give you an emotional response.
I get that your MIL is an emotional type but even though she would have responded better if she were presented with more solid arguments.

We can absolutely afford a bigger house if we moved... the main reason my DH is very happy to oblige!

OP posts:
wronginalltherightways · 30/01/2024 17:35

So it's been perfectly acceptable for OP to be X distance from her own mum an dad for all these years, but not acceptable for them to now be closer to OP's mum, out of fairness, and the same X distance from MIL.

Ignore her. Tell her she's being selfish, entitled and ridiculous.