Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people I know live anove their means?

231 replies

PrincessBananaH · 30/01/2024 12:43

I just came across a statement that really got me thinking which is that, essentially, you should always live below your means in order to be financially secure. It’s a pretty simple statement but I don’t think many of us follow this in life. Most people I know are trying to keep up with the Jones, stretching their mortgages to almost unafforable amounts to buy bigger houses instead of being happy in a modest home, going on lots of holidays and dinners out etc.
I am trying hard to save currently and with lots of family expenses and childcare I often think we’d be better off living below our means in the future years to keep building more financial stability, however I find it hard when everyone around us is trying to “have it all”.
AIBU to think most people don’t want to live below their means?

OP posts:
pollymere · 01/02/2024 19:10

We had our mortgage with Nationwide because they didn't base it on salary but on your income versus outgoings. We had two lots of people come back to us to confirm that we didn't have credit card debt, store card debt or car payments. Obviously we'd worked hard to be in a good place to get a mortgage and so our only real outgoings were rent (including bills) and food.

I think many just rack up debts and live with a permanent overdraft. It's so easy to get credit for purchases and the zero interest for twelve months or whatever ones - people don't realise they're accruing interest in those twelve months so one late payment and you're stuck with paying a stupid price for something. So many treading water it scares me. And the stupid thing is, this page has taught me that it doesn't matter if someone is earning £30K or £100K, people don't know how to only spend what they have.

That isn't to say there aren't also the people who are seriously struggling due to inflation and terrible wages - ironically they're often the ones with the most money sense.

Ilovecleaning · 01/02/2024 18:50

Wages are too low.

Sheilabow · 01/02/2024 18:49

My sister is one of them.

Last year went to New York, Barbados and Paris. Must have cost £15k at least. Also got a brand new car. Mortgage debt about £150k and personal debt about £100k. She doesn’t worry about it.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 01/02/2024 18:47

UnfriendMe · 01/02/2024 18:10

It really depends on circumstances though, right? How exactly do you define living above your means? Putting a holiday on a credit card? We both make good money and have no kids, therefore we do buy designer things or have no problem putting 20k for a holiday on a credit card. Does that mean living above your means if it gets paid off?

£20k for a holiday? On credit cards? How long would that take to pay off? And what if you suddenly lost one income before it was paid off?

Kaleidoscope2 · 01/02/2024 18:40

Everyone I know closely live within or below their means. However, from the outside looking in it might not seem that way as they might have had family support to buy a big house or inheritances from childhood etc. I think millennials are probably the most divided in terms of wealth between the double income, no children households whether renting or home owners, they'll be richer than those millennials with young children in childcare. Then they'll be differences in interest rate effects on mortgages for example those in long term fixed rate low mortgages and those that have been stung by the hikes in interest also more sharply felt if the mortgage was high to begin with. I feel we are incredibly sensible and dare I say boring but any huge advances in saving are slow in coming

HarrietStyles · 01/02/2024 18:30

I think it’s easier to think that your colleagues are living above their means because they are going on several holidays per year and getting a new Mercedes SUV. It makes us feel better about ourselves to think that they must be getting in to loads of debt, but we don’t have those things because we are being more sensible. Pat self on back. Quite simply they are likely just richer than you - maybe they have a high earning partner, received money from family, their mortgage payments might be much lower than yours, leaving them more spending money. Living above your means can only last for a few years……… if they are consistently spending more money than you, they probably have more money than you.

Mrspoo2023 · 01/02/2024 18:16

Do you think that was also because most families were single income? However, from my experience,most people could afford a reasonable home without too much difficulty. Even on a single income. My parents lived exactly as you described, however at the same time they did all those things and could pay for the house and cover their bills. That is not the case anymore. 😞

UnfriendMe · 01/02/2024 18:10

It really depends on circumstances though, right? How exactly do you define living above your means? Putting a holiday on a credit card? We both make good money and have no kids, therefore we do buy designer things or have no problem putting 20k for a holiday on a credit card. Does that mean living above your means if it gets paid off?

Carpedimum · 01/02/2024 18:06

Dickens: Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six , result happiness.
Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.

cremebrulait · 01/02/2024 17:49

Simple. Do what you want. Pick and choose how you join in. What others do is none of your business.

fungibletoken · 01/02/2024 10:23

I think a lot of people stretch themselves to their limit, such that pretty much all their income is spoken for - i.e. the most expensive house, PCP car deal, etc. they can get on their salary. This is quite obvious when I go back to where I grew up - it's not the most affluent part of the country, but people work hard and are very aspirational. Houses are all newly renovated inside and out, men and women are perfectly groomed when they leave the house.

No judgement here - in some ways I think I'm a bit too cautious with money, but it's hard to shake off.

Bowbobobo · 01/02/2024 10:11

I’m finally living within my means but for years I didn’t. I was funding school/uni fees for three DC (my choice) and paying about £2k a month for the mortgage. This would have been ok as I’m a high earner if now XH had fulfilled his side of the deal but he didn’t, he constantly lost his job but still bought vfucking stupid cars and motorcycles 😡. I used CC a lot, juggling funds left right and centre and spending nothing on myself. Holidays were camping in UK - no regrets about that, we all loved it! DC are now early 30s and I’m finally straight. XH is not but that’s his problem!

it was a risky strategy for sure and not one I would have taken if a) I’d known quite what an idiot XH was and b) I hadn’t had a safety net (my DPs). I never had any money off them but I always knew they would have helped if necessary.

Not spending on cars/clothes/holidays has become so ingrained that I can’t change the habit now, but that’s fine. I finished what I started.

HarrietTheFireStarter · 01/02/2024 09:40

If you follow Dave Ramsey you'll get a pretty clear picture of what's going on and why.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 01/02/2024 09:38

Freakinfraser · 01/02/2024 06:45

I really don’t think you can compare a ten year old Audi with a Bentley to be honest , and where as sure, some live frugally to afford other things like you, the fact remains many people are wealthy and can afford to buy expensive things, without having to sit with a lunch box.

The uber wealthy are a different breed though. Lots of people have money because they made cuts elsewhere. I earn the same as my BIL. He has more stuff. I have more cash money. On paper, he LOOKS more wealthy. He's not. I could go out and buy something nice outright, but because he's spent all his disposable on credit card/loan payments he can't. You don't always know what "wealthy" is, because people live above their means to look it.

And tbh, a 10 year old Audi (not a bog standard one) at age 25 is still a nice car. And I'd take a LOT of different cars over a Bentley even if money was no object. The definition of "nice" or "flash"or "fancy" is subjective. Personal preference plays a big part. And I'd never actually thought about "sitting with a lunchbox" as cost cutting. I just don't want to spend £50+ a week on food I don't really enjoy.

2under4 · 01/02/2024 08:18

We are living "above our means", in terms of getting into debt with the energy supplier, and maxing out overdrafts each month. But we have two young children, so can't really not put washer on for example, when everything's covered in poo, or have it cold in their bedrooms.

We don't go on holidays, modest house, always buy 2nd hand etc, and OH works 6 days a week whilst I do 2. HOWEVER, we do spend on getting stuff for the children like correct car seats or shoes that fit properly. Also softplay or an icecream at the park or petrol getting to free / cheap stay and plays. Also decent food for them. In theory they could survive on less, but would rather spend on them gor whst I consider basics, than give everything to bloody Shell. I think it's easier to live beyond your means when cost of living is so high, even without frivolous stuff.

Heatherbell1978 · 01/02/2024 06:59

We live below our means I think. Well this is where it's confusing as we plough loads into pensions (£3.5k a month between us) and a chunk into savings. So by the time all that has moved into various accounts, we're left with very little. I guess we could not do that and live the high life. Maybe many people do in our position. We certainly drive a far less flashy car than many we know! I don't get sucked into keeping up. I look at designer handbags and immediately think 'what a waste' but each to their own!

Freakinfraser · 01/02/2024 06:45

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 31/01/2024 20:31

It does kind of make sense though. They can afford the Bentley because they haven't wasted their cash on loads of "tat" (can't think of a better word).

I remember once sitting chatting with a fellow car person on our lunch break. Another colleague came in and was complaining about their car (fairly new Ford Focus on finance) and saying how they'd like a "nice car" like mine (10 year old Audi at that time but I owned it outright). Then in the next breath they took the mick out of my little sandwich box with my sandwiches from home made of left overs, while they unpacked around £12 of Costa Coffee lunch, which they went for most days. The guy I was chatting to previously said "this is why she has the nice car and you can't afford what you're happy with".

I've never forgotten that. Hadn't really thought about it before but it's true. A lot of my "stuff" would be considered nice, my uncle calls it fancy. But I only buy what I actually WANT and I'll save for it first. I don't spend money on things that aren't important to me, like lunch from the coffee shop when I can make a sandwich, or a designer handbag when my £30 one does the same job.

I really don’t think you can compare a ten year old Audi with a Bentley to be honest , and where as sure, some live frugally to afford other things like you, the fact remains many people are wealthy and can afford to buy expensive things, without having to sit with a lunch box.

familyissues12345 · 01/02/2024 05:41

I have a couple of friends who openly tell me how much they live above their means - living a life of luxury, but only by taking out another credit card, or borrowing more against the mortgage. I find it a bit bizarre, as a lot of the purchases are really out there, but each to their own. I'd be so stressed with the CC repayments!

dottykoala · 01/02/2024 05:26

anonymousamy · 01/02/2024 03:33

I read on here once not to do something (holidays etc) if you can’t afford to do it 3 times over. I think it’s a good rule.

Lol - that’s the silliest advice I’ve read in a while on here. I can afford one holiday this year that I’ve been saving up for. Should I keep saving and wait till 2026 to go? Fat chance. Sorry, but life is short and you do have to live a little. There’s nothing wrong with that.

I agree that that’s ridiculous advice. Living within your means is sensible but scrimping and saving every penny and not living a little if you have spare money is not a great way to live either. I have elderly relatives in their 90s who saved all their lives rather than spend and go on holidays, and they say that their one regret is not travelling lots while they had their health. You save all your life and then it can get eaten up by care home fees etc very quickly if your health declines - I’ve seen this happen.

anonymousamy · 01/02/2024 03:33

I read on here once not to do something (holidays etc) if you can’t afford to do it 3 times over. I think it’s a good rule.

Lol - that’s the silliest advice I’ve read in a while on here. I can afford one holiday this year that I’ve been saving up for. Should I keep saving and wait till 2026 to go? Fat chance. Sorry, but life is short and you do have to live a little. There’s nothing wrong with that.

Blinky21 · 01/02/2024 03:25

We live within our means, only debt is our mortgage and we don't buy anything big on credit. I'm staggered by the number of people who stretch themselves to pay for luxury cars on hire purchase each month. My brother works in personal insolvency and his case load would suggest thousands of people do live well beyond their means

Mulhollandmagoo · 01/02/2024 00:56

Me and my husband know a few of these OP, and it is so hard not to get sucked in or feel rubbish!! We drive old cars, nothing wrong with them, just not swanky ones like some of our friends - but they're economical and well looked after and get us where they need to be. We have no debt, and a manageable mortgage, even when we have to renew our fixed rate at a higher % we have a lovely life and sometimes I need to remind myself of that.

A good friend of my husband badgers us constantly about moving to a bigger house, we have a three bed semi, and one child, so we don't need to move! Sometimes I think it's to just this choices. A few of them say it will benefit them in the future having a huge mortgage now.

FilthyforFirth · 31/01/2024 22:56

I'm terrible with money and certainly dont live within my means. I am lucky that we have a relatively high household income (6 figures between us not the usual mn £250k salary) so it means the debt is servicable.

I suppose that knowing, or rather assuming one cant account entirely for the future, that both our next promotions will see us earn an extra £20kish each.

We also have family to fall back on if things get bad. I dont love the credit card debt but it is interest free and now nursery fees have lowered it will start to reduce.

But I'd rather not be miserable in the meantime. I will probably get flamed for this, but we are also due to inherit a fair amount between us, so I suppose I also have that in the back of my mind.

Ap24 · 31/01/2024 22:37

I know people on each end of the scale, varying salaries. For most I don't have a clue about their finances, especially the older generation. I think it's now less taboo to talk about debt.

The biggest difference between the income bands is the availablity of cheap credit. If anything in our home broke or we needed to upgrade we could afford to replace it immediately with cash. But we've made use of 0% finance over the years and left the savings to gain the interest. Growing up on a council estate everyone seemed to use provident. The APR was ridiculous but it was the only way many could afford to replace a washing machine. And don't get me started on those stupid TVs that you had to insert coins into to watch.

gmgnts · 31/01/2024 22:26

In Charles Dickens' David Copperfield, Mr Micawber's famous, and often quoted, recipe for happiness: "Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen [pounds] nineteen [shillings] and six [pence], result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery."