Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend needs to get over her divorce now?

141 replies

Whattodo24xx · 30/01/2024 11:52

Ok, I know that sounds incredibly harsh but I'm at my wits end with my friend & it's beginning to affect how I feel about her...

For context, we've been friends since we were both 11, (38 now) and we've shared loads together. Including obviously supporting her when she split from her husband of 11 years 5 years ago. It was super tough for her at the time understandably and I was there for her every step of the way. She has a DD who's coming up for 10 now, whilst working full time and is a great mum. Ex still sees DD regularly but they don't have a good relationship which makes things harder.

The trouble is, my friend over the past 5 years has the attitude of 'woe is me' constantly 24/7 and it's so draining. Whilst I understand the struggles of being a single mum for the majority of the time, it's all she talks about like the entire world is out to get her. She doesn't have enough free time, she doesn't have enough money to do anything, she doesn't have this, she doesn't have that etc. Her ex is getting remarried this year and this has sparked a fresh set of hatred towards him that he's a dead beat, he should pay her more money (he pays her £465 pcm), he's a narcissist. Nothing is ever good enough and I just wish she would see how far she's come and what a wonderful life she does actually have. She has an amazing daughter, a house she owns outright with no mortgage and that her ex has no claim on, a decent career, she's a beautiful lady too, but she's blinded by the mindsight that is 'woe is me'.

I don't know how to approach this with her now, and I understand the transition period was always going to be hard, but 5 years of this attitude and it's beginning to take a toll on our relationship. We go out & do nice things together but the convo will quickly shift back to making a passing dissing comment about her ex, or how something went wrong in the house she had to pay for herself as she has no help etc etc. The thing is, she didn't even want to be with her ex at the end and it came to light a few weeks after he'd left she'd cheated on him anyway (which I've never criticised her for) but I do feel like she enjoyed the life she had before she divorced if that makes sense? I really have no idea how to broach this with her now...

YABU - It's hard for her
YANBU - She needs to start being happy for things she does have

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 30/01/2024 16:49

Don't underestimate the stressful and often depressing effect of trying to co-parent with an ex when you don't get along.

Your life doesn't turn into sunshine and daisies when you divorce if you're stuck having to communicate with someone who is uncooperative or sullen or begrudging or contrary, or downright abusive.

There are many opportunities for an ex who feels like it to punish a former spouse for cheating or divorcing or just for the heck of it.

I'd sit her down and let her vent about any trouble she's having with her ex. Don't assume he's been able to draw a line under the conflict or the behaviour that caused the breakdown of the relationship.

YouOKHun · 30/01/2024 16:47

I did suggest, along with many others that therapy would be good for her and she went initially in the first 6 months post break-up, but I believed at the time she was only going to try and win her ex back as it was all based around why she had cheated and she was trying to prove to him she'd changed. I know that if I suggest it now it would go down like a lead balloon. I genuinely don't think she is depressed....I think she just likes to steer the convo back to her divorce. I don't know whether this is to get attention or her not actually being over it all. That I can't quite tell

I wouldn’t completely dismiss the idea of depression or at least some of the markers of depression, it often manifests in anger and she sounds as if she is SEETHING. She is also constantly ruminating and picking over what has happened and the injustice of it. Distorting the awfulness and deleting the positives. Practicing being the victim of circumstances. Constantly going over the past and it sounds as if she is not allowing contentment or happiness to override her anger because “why should he be let off the hook by me moving on as easily as he has!”.

I think when something really hard happens and we’re very unhappy for an intense period there’s often a shift in our perception of the world and a negative view of everything and everyone becomes habitual. I felt myself slide towards it when my DF died during Covid and then bad things kept happening (or at least it felt like it). I felt fucking livid about everything and everybody and the injustice. In the end I didn’t want to be positive or act as if I was. It took a monumental effort to get out of the thinking habits I was in.

It’s a shame she would be resistant to seeing a therapist again because it would do her good to have some fairly structured therapy to get her to focus on the future and what she actually wants out of life and to examine what she gets out of rigidly demanding things shouldn’t have happened the way they did. She’d probably benefit from something like Rational Emotive Behavioural Therapy (which forces you to confront your own irrational thinking and behaviour; it’s not counselling as such, it’s more structured).

ultimately it’s not your job to be a sounding board and I would tell her that you’re worried she will never be happy and she needs to find a professional sounding board. It probably won’t go down well but maybe she will reflect on it and realise that she does have a choice about how she feels and her happiness is her responsibility at this point not your’s.

SheRasBra · 30/01/2024 16:40

If you genuinely want to give the friendship one more try before a tactical withdrawal you might try suggesting to her that she's giving him power over her by continuing to rage about him. The best revenge is to live a happy life etc. For her it might just be about control: she was unhappy but he was the one to leave the marriage, taking away her agency. That can really sting.

If she starts to bring him up in conversation just say, "don't waste your time on him" or "don't give him any more headspace" and try and move the conversation to something positive she has going on.

Try not to make it about you and how it's making you feel, justified though that would be. If that fails I really would consider being less available.

Onthebusallday · 30/01/2024 16:24

My mum is still like this, 35 years after my dad left her for OW, and she's going to take the bitterness to her grave.

She wasn't left in a terrible situation - really could have been a lot worse. It was quite clear my DF had been unhappy for some time and became a different person completely after leaving and is still with OW.

I genuinely think about 5 years after DF left she knew full well looking back when everything happened the way it did, and could have said ' well, fair enough, time to put it behind me now' but was scared to let go of the anger.

Thing is as her grown children it made life very difficult for us, watching what we talked about and I'm sure there were no more big family occasions due to the hassle it would have caused.

I think hanging on to bitterness even in the face of obviously being in a much better situation is definitely a real phenomena

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 16:13

It's not about the divorce, some people really are very negative and think they always have it harder than others and feel like they can talk about it all the time.

I've distanced myself from 2 friends like that recently because after every single time I hung out with either of them, I felt drained, depressed and snappy. We all have stuff going on. When I go out with friends, I also just want to have a laugh and a nice time, not be someone's therapist.

Augustus40 · 30/01/2024 16:09

Does she need medication at all? Anti depressants may help.

Mariluisa · 30/01/2024 16:00

When my kids were young I remember this really being a barrier to friendships at one school in particular. There was an impenetrable projection that those of us with partners/husbands by definition had money and zero problems! They, as single mothers had this trump card and we were entitled and had no right to moan about anything.

Another mother did make me laugh one day by summing it all up: they have a great social life, get time to themselves we could only dream of, and most are retraining for better careers! She was referring to the mothers who had really good support from parents and/or a good co parenting situation with their ex.

I know that’s not quite the same as your situation but your OP reminded me a bit of that artificial barrier I encountered at that time - and the resentments that arose on either side

stardust777 · 30/01/2024 15:33

It's tricky - sometimes habits are so ingrained that you no longer notice them. If it's a friendship worth saving, I'd want to address the issue and give the person a chance to change.

To avoid any resentment building up, I'd mention it e.g.

"I've noticed that you've become more negative lately, and sometimes I don't recognise the friend I used to know. If you're feeling down or overwhelmed, do you think it would be worth speaking to a counsellor about it?"

cauliflowerqueen · 30/01/2024 15:23

It sounds like she's decided (subconsciously) to make 'woe-is-me divorced woman' her new central identity. She's 'enjoying' playing this role, for lack of a better word. After five years, she's unlikely to change, unless something drastic happens and gives her a better identity to latch onto. If she finds a new partner, maybe that would do it.

I know you don't want to lose her as a friend, but I don't see many options (other than putting up with it) that wouldn't risk alienating her. I'd try to steer the conversation away or ignoring as many of her comments as possible, but there's only so much of that you can do without seeming rude.

Edit: I missed the last update that she's actually moved on and found another man (although maybe not a perfect match) and is still like this. So much for that, then!

Lookingatthesunset · 30/01/2024 15:12

I used to have a 'friend' like that. Her split defined her life forever after. The friendship ended for other reasons but at least it saved listening to the moaning on.

It was traumatic I know because her boss at work told her her ex was having an affair - he was on the same flight as ex and the other woman! Sympathy isn't infinite though.

reesewithoutaspoon · 30/01/2024 14:45

I think some people just get stuck in a rut of moaning. They don't know any other way to have a conversation. Or they are just so self-absorbed they don't recognise that other people aren't just there to be their moaning outlet.

My mum is a moaner. every conversation is negative. If she hasn't got anything personal going on to be negative about, she will switch to ranting about something from GB News instead. It's like she doesn't know any other way to be around people.

If you tell her about something good that has happened, eg you won an award, she immediately jumps to "Well you're lucky. I never had the chance to do anything like that because [insert some woe is me story]

Most of the family are LC with her because she is draining

Outwiththenorm · 30/01/2024 14:38

My DMIL has been like this for 25 years now - never got over her husband leaving her and remarrying. He behaved obnoxiously but she has made it her whole life. It wasn’t my place to tell her but I wish she’d had a friend like you.

SonicAllanKey · 30/01/2024 14:36

I left a long term friendship behind because of this sort of attitude. It wasn’t divorce, it was other personal stuff, but everything we did was undercut by her constant narration of all her woes. This was combined with a total lack of desire to do anything positive to improve the situation, all of which was in her grasp.

i realised I was just being used as a dumping ground for all her negativity so I stopped being as available. It’s a shame but she’s still the same now apparently!

Flottie · 30/01/2024 14:36

After 5 years I think unfortunately she does just need to get over it now :( are there ways you can encourage her to? Or even suggest therapy if you think she’d take it well?

DeeCeeCherry · 30/01/2024 14:35

No she doesn't need to get over it, she's obviously still hurt. However she does need to stop using you as a sounding board. Why can't you woman up and just tell her its just too much for you to constantly absorb? Then gently suggest therapy/counselling? You may lose the friendship but at least you won't be soaking up negativity. Honestly what's the point of all this dithering? Just speak up for yourself or at least send it in a text if you can't face saying it.

Greenpolkadot · 30/01/2024 14:34

Divorce is shit for anyone. Your friend seems to have taken it so deep and can't seem climb out.

Does your friend hope to start a new relationship with someone.?
Shes got no chance if she starts to use them as a sponge to soak up her misery.
Blokes will disappear pretty quick if all she does is whine

chaosmaker · 30/01/2024 14:33

Can you just tell her not to talk about it to you any more as she doesn't listen to your advice and can't see how much better her life is now. I would have to shut down any further conversation on that topic.

idontlikealdi · 30/01/2024 14:31

Freakinfraser · 30/01/2024 12:40

My friends mum was like this, it lasted over 30 years till the day she died . It was very sad for her, she never got over her marriage ending, never saw the joy in her own life, she got herself in a cycle of hatred, resentment, bitterness. It permeated everything she did. Every day she thought about it.

He moved on and married again, enjoyed his life, as he should, the children all felt very sorry for her. It damaged her relationship with everyone round her.

I don’t think you can say anything, she will shoot the messenger, you just need to decide if you can continue to be her friend or if ultimately you need to distance yourself.

My MIL is exactly the same, they have been divorced 20 years and separated for longer. It's exhausting. She bad mouths him at every opportunity, and does it on the sly to the grandkids too, and they are at the age where they don't like it as they have a great relationship with FIL and his wife but they feel they have to be very careful about what they say around her.

Quitelikeit · 30/01/2024 14:30

These types do exist. I personally know a few. I think it’s a sad way to live your life tbh.

I have distanced myself for the very reason.

Capsicumus · 30/01/2024 14:29

*Almostwelsh · Today 12:32

It's unreasonable to expect her to be over it. It's not something you can force. I split with my husband 10 years ago and it's left deep emotional injuries that I will probably never get over. I think about it every day and it's a deep grief.

However I do try and not go on about it to others and its reasonable to expect her not to talk about it constantly.*

This. You should try as a friend to make her snap out of it, and talk to her. But you cannot expect her to feel differently...My mum divorced 30 years ago, and is still not over it. It is sad, and really, really, boring to listen to her go on and on, say the same things about stuff that happened when i was a baby, but no matter how much I try to avoid it, the conversation goes back to this one scapegoat in her life that caused her all the misery she experienced afterwards. This one root cause of everything bad in her life. Some people are like this, passive. Things happen to them, they feel they have no control over their lives and they can’t make it better so they dont try anymore but constantly moan and live in the past. Others fight and change and adopt. It is just how people are. So you can try to encourage, but you can’t expect them to change. Then it is up to you to decide how much you can bear them and adjust the time with them accordingly...

MeridianB · 30/01/2024 14:25

YANBU OP

Five years?! It sounds like really hard work for you, but I’d be really worried about her DD living her life with a parent who has a constantly gloomy/bitter outlook.

Does she listen when you try to help her? She sounds like she needs professional help - therapy and/or a visit to the GP.

Serpentiner · 30/01/2024 14:23

This is how my mother behaved and she never really stopped. So much so that over 30 years after her separation she said to a recently widowed friend that her divorce was the same as friends bereavement. Friend has cut her out, saying she can’t deal with someone who can never allow space for someone else to be a victim. Your friend may never change but I would speak to her about it before you cut her out

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 30/01/2024 14:19

I think part of the problem here is people in couples generally offload an awful lot of their moaning to their spouse. Being single, she's sort of cast you almost in the spouse role in the sense that, as her oldest friend, she feels you're the safe person to always moan at. I bet she's not like it so much with newer friends.

You need to find a way to signal to her that it's not ok and you've had enough of it.

PerkingFaintly · 30/01/2024 14:18

OnaKitchenRoll · 30/01/2024 13:57

Has she always been a moaner? I have a friend, who is otherwise lovely, but she'll tell you all about the paper cut she got taking her million pound lottery win cheque to the bank...

Grin
PerkingFaintly · 30/01/2024 14:17

blatant fabrications at times, and her version of the truth has definitely changed over the years.

Ah this sounds familiar.

Yup, it's all about generating sympathy and attention.

It's working well for her, so she has no desire to leave her comfort-zone as The Victim and develop a new identity as an adult responsible for her own life and future.