Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend needs to get over her divorce now?

141 replies

Whattodo24xx · 30/01/2024 11:52

Ok, I know that sounds incredibly harsh but I'm at my wits end with my friend & it's beginning to affect how I feel about her...

For context, we've been friends since we were both 11, (38 now) and we've shared loads together. Including obviously supporting her when she split from her husband of 11 years 5 years ago. It was super tough for her at the time understandably and I was there for her every step of the way. She has a DD who's coming up for 10 now, whilst working full time and is a great mum. Ex still sees DD regularly but they don't have a good relationship which makes things harder.

The trouble is, my friend over the past 5 years has the attitude of 'woe is me' constantly 24/7 and it's so draining. Whilst I understand the struggles of being a single mum for the majority of the time, it's all she talks about like the entire world is out to get her. She doesn't have enough free time, she doesn't have enough money to do anything, she doesn't have this, she doesn't have that etc. Her ex is getting remarried this year and this has sparked a fresh set of hatred towards him that he's a dead beat, he should pay her more money (he pays her £465 pcm), he's a narcissist. Nothing is ever good enough and I just wish she would see how far she's come and what a wonderful life she does actually have. She has an amazing daughter, a house she owns outright with no mortgage and that her ex has no claim on, a decent career, she's a beautiful lady too, but she's blinded by the mindsight that is 'woe is me'.

I don't know how to approach this with her now, and I understand the transition period was always going to be hard, but 5 years of this attitude and it's beginning to take a toll on our relationship. We go out & do nice things together but the convo will quickly shift back to making a passing dissing comment about her ex, or how something went wrong in the house she had to pay for herself as she has no help etc etc. The thing is, she didn't even want to be with her ex at the end and it came to light a few weeks after he'd left she'd cheated on him anyway (which I've never criticised her for) but I do feel like she enjoyed the life she had before she divorced if that makes sense? I really have no idea how to broach this with her now...

YABU - It's hard for her
YANBU - She needs to start being happy for things she does have

OP posts:
Jumpers4goalposts · 31/01/2024 18:19

I think you should just be honest with her, honesty is always the best policy, but also keep in mind that I expect the remarriage has just pulled the plaster off so everything is a bit more sore now than it was.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/01/2024 18:12

Divorce is extremely traumatic and she can't help the way she feels but there does come a point where you need to stop making this everyone else's problem and if you can't do this on your own, get help for it.

If you're "stuck" with a situation to such an extent that you absolutely can't move on you get professional help. Not reasonable to turn her entire friendship group into a free therapy circle.

Serpentiner · 31/01/2024 16:35

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 20:01

So put up and shut up and then suffer and when you can't cope then you get blamed for not speaking up! Got it! Thanks!

The OP has clearly listened and provided support for the past 5 years. It is time now for the friend to change the narrative. That can mean several things, moving on herself, getting professional help to move on ….
The unhealthy option is to think that forever more your feelings and need to talk and be a victim can go on indefinitely. It’s not unusual for the friend to feel sad, why wouldn’t she. It is however, unhealthy and unfair to spend years draining those around her.

I find that people who are emotional vampires can find that hard to comprehend- why why why can’t I talk through my feelings with people, why why why won’t they listen to me anymore. It’s because they have worn everyone out. People only have a certain reserves

SapphireSeptember · 31/01/2024 15:16

I had an ex-bf who would moan constantly about how shit his life was and how much he hated his parents (whom he lived with rent free and who gave him money as he didn't have a job.) Any suggestions about how he could change things were shut down, but he liked telling me how he was going to off himself. (That was fun.) Thankfully he dumped me after five months of driving me mad. I'm surprised you've put up with this for five years OP!

Freakinfraser · 30/01/2024 22:08

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 18:42

The only reason ppl tell others to 'move on' is for their own comfort and really what they are saying is that I'm not comfortable and want you to shut up. Do you really think that telling someone to move on will suddenly make them flick a switch and they will stop feeling what they are feeling? All that happens is that they stop talking and suffer alone and struggle more and feel lonely and rejected and worthless. When someone dies in your life, remember there is a time limit on trauma and not to exert it please. This is why we have issues as ppl tell others to talk when they are struggling mentally but what they really mean is only talk for a short while but not too long. Where is the 'move on' switch located?

What is your point please, this reads like you feel the person allocated as listener has no rights, they should just take it, they don’t matter. The point being made is we all matter, and if someone abuses that, and talks to someone else negatively, to an extent it bothers them negatively they should speak up, but the negative person should absolutely recognise the listener is human, they don’t exist just to listen to the outpouring of negativity from someone else, that’s very self centred.

stardust777 · 30/01/2024 21:24

I think it's about getting the right support - professional help might be the best thing for OP's friend.

If someone's behaviour is causing you stress and anxiety, it could be the time to reassess boundaries. A few years ago my (now ex) friend told me that he had cancelled his appointment with his therapist as he had me to talk to (at the time, I had been diagnosed with depression and was really struggling).

VinegarTrio · 30/01/2024 20:09

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 20:01

So put up and shut up and then suffer and when you can't cope then you get blamed for not speaking up! Got it! Thanks!

Or maybe think about other people as well as yourself.

What you are describing is not someone at risk of ‘not speaking up’. It’s actually someone being totally self centred and taking advantage. To then try to weaponise mental health against people who don’t simply comply with their allocated role as listening support humans is pretty nasty.

If you actually think and behave like this, you will end up alienating friends. There has to be give and take, and the negative has to come with some positives. Otherwise, no one is going to stick around to just listen to exactly the same moans about something that happened years ago again and again.

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 20:01

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 19:12

@RheaRend and the rule is everyone has to find a middle ground. Being a negative drain for years is selfish.

So put up and shut up and then suffer and when you can't cope then you get blamed for not speaking up! Got it! Thanks!

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 20:00

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 19:09

@RheaRend you're being deliberately obtuse. I have had people in my social circle who absolutely cannot stop talking about themselves. Some people really do think they have it the hardest and there is no room for anyone else. I don't owe emotional support for the rest of my life to another adult without getting anything back. So yes, self centered people who can't stop talking about themselves end up getting dropped. And OP has a choice on who she chooses to spend her free time with, she's given this woman5 years of support, time for some distance.

Nope you clearly stated that because you suffer in silence you want others to. Sounds like you are one of those ppl who play the martyr and shame others who do thing differently. If you don't like helping friends then so be it, walk away.

Supersimkin2 · 30/01/2024 19:39

Professional victims are a bore.

PaulCostinRIP · 30/01/2024 19:31

Sit her down and tell her that life is what you make of it and her constantly moaning is only going to attract more negativity and that it's dragging you down.

Unless she lets go of the past, moves in and makes something of her life she's always going to be someone who wallows in the mud.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 19:12

@RheaRend and the rule is everyone has to find a middle ground. Being a negative drain for years is selfish.

MayThe4th · 30/01/2024 19:11

So as usual double standards abound here…

She’s the one who cheated and yet she’s the one trying to play the victim?

She made her decisions when she shagged someone else. If this was someone talking about their dh’s friend who had cheated and was now doing the woe is me thing people would say that it serves him right and he didn’t deserve sympathy.

Yes, affairs aren’t always black and white, but regardless of what happened and how something led to an affair, when you head down that road you do so in the knowledge that if you get found out then your life will fall apart, and the only person to blame for that is you.

If this was a man someone was posting about people would say that the woman should be happy, that she was well rid of him and that they were glad for her that she’d moved on.

I wouldn’t be pandering to this victim crap. I’m afraid I’d have to tell her to get over herself. She’s the one who is responsible for the situation she’s in, so she needs to get over herself.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 19:09

@RheaRend you're being deliberately obtuse. I have had people in my social circle who absolutely cannot stop talking about themselves. Some people really do think they have it the hardest and there is no room for anyone else. I don't owe emotional support for the rest of my life to another adult without getting anything back. So yes, self centered people who can't stop talking about themselves end up getting dropped. And OP has a choice on who she chooses to spend her free time with, she's given this woman5 years of support, time for some distance.

CruCru · 30/01/2024 19:03

The way the OP writes, I wonder whether the friend follows the 1/3 rule - the one where, if you meet 1:1, each person gets to talk for at least 1/3 of the time. It isn't a rigid rule but if it is never followed then the person who never gets to talk will get fed up.

If the OP has her own crisis, does she get to talk about it? Or does the conversation swiftly get turned back to the divorce? If so, that sounds quite miserable.

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 18:57

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 18:55

@RheaRend This isn't about helping a friend who needs to talk about the hard stuff she's going through. This is about someone who is continously negative and makes every conversation about herself. We all have shit in our lives. All of us. Whether it's divorce, death, illness etc, the older we get the more horrible stuff we have to deal with. But most people don't bring down every social event they attend. The ones who do are so self centered they can't see anything beyond their own suffering. Should the rest of us have to sit around forever silently suffering so we can be a sounding board for them.

Ah so what is the rule - talk about how you feel to prevent mental health crisis issues or be silent because we can't be arsed listening?

Why are you suffering silently because you daren't ask a friend for support?

Loopytiles · 30/01/2024 18:56

I’d reflect on whether I’d be prepared to risk losing the friendship. If I was, I’d say something like she talks negatively a lot and whilst sympathetic to her feelings and situation I’d rather she did it less. Or try ‘grey rock’ and changing the subject.

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 30/01/2024 18:55

@RheaRend This isn't about helping a friend who needs to talk about the hard stuff she's going through. This is about someone who is continously negative and makes every conversation about herself. We all have shit in our lives. All of us. Whether it's divorce, death, illness etc, the older we get the more horrible stuff we have to deal with. But most people don't bring down every social event they attend. The ones who do are so self centered they can't see anything beyond their own suffering. Should the rest of us have to sit around forever silently suffering so we can be a sounding board for them.

VinegarTrio · 30/01/2024 18:49

Maybe it’s not that they’re all useless and uncomfortable. Maybe it is just really boring and draining to listen to someone complain constantly for years, about the same thing.

At some point your friends will lose sympathy if you are always fixated only on your perpetual victimhood.

If you want to spend decades complaining about your divorce, then it’s best to pay a therapist. But even they may will try to get you to move forward and stop repeating the same grievances over and over again.

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 18:42

Serpentiner · 30/01/2024 18:30

I don’t think this is fair. We all have to at least try to ‘move on’ from difficulties we experienced. The reality is that no one likes a perpetual victim and their victim hood can often leave no room for anything else.

The only reason ppl tell others to 'move on' is for their own comfort and really what they are saying is that I'm not comfortable and want you to shut up. Do you really think that telling someone to move on will suddenly make them flick a switch and they will stop feeling what they are feeling? All that happens is that they stop talking and suffer alone and struggle more and feel lonely and rejected and worthless. When someone dies in your life, remember there is a time limit on trauma and not to exert it please. This is why we have issues as ppl tell others to talk when they are struggling mentally but what they really mean is only talk for a short while but not too long. Where is the 'move on' switch located?

Serpentiner · 30/01/2024 18:30

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 16:56

By all means tell her to put her poker face on and pretend she is ok because you feel uncomfortable but at least be honest with her.

I don’t think this is fair. We all have to at least try to ‘move on’ from difficulties we experienced. The reality is that no one likes a perpetual victim and their victim hood can often leave no room for anything else.

Freakinfraser · 30/01/2024 18:19

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 16:56

By all means tell her to put her poker face on and pretend she is ok because you feel uncomfortable but at least be honest with her.

That comes across as quite a belligerent response, it is fairly obvious that’s not what’s being said.

mathanxiety · 30/01/2024 17:02

stayathomer · 30/01/2024 13:11

I think the only people who can answer if you’re being unreasonable is someone who is divorced. Are you op? Because I remember a friend of mine telling me her friend should really be over her mum dying a few years on and then her own mum died and she said she’d been an idiot. The mortgage thing is nothing- she thought she had a certain family and certain life and now that’s gone. I don’t think married/ couples or single people can know if she should be over it by now

I agree with every word.

Divorce brings with it an enormous amount of grief. You had your life planned, you had a wedding with your family and friends present, you had a child based on the security of the relationship, and then you find it has all gone tits up. You've been unhappy, he's been unhappy, whatever. And you turn around and your life as you thought it would be bears no resemblance to the reality.

And it has all been public - people ask about your husband or partner and you say you're divorced, actually. You're telling them your life has fallen apart. You might have had friends when you were married but you find they've remained friends with your ex and cut you off, or his family never get in touch even though you were in good terms before the divorce. There's a lot of loss associated with divorce.

There is just you to deal with all the stupid things that go wrong with a house or a car or a child, all the admin and the physical housework, and you have your job to deal with too. On top of that is the guilt you may feel because you've brought a child into this world, and they didn't ask to one day have to deal with a stepmother or stepfather and half siblings or step siblings, or the feeling of visiting dad at 'dad's house' or visiting mum at 'mum's house' when classmates live 'at home', with mum and dad. There's only one of you and 24 hours in the day, so maybe your child doesn't get to do swimming or some other activity, because there's only so much you can get around to, or maybe dad won't take her to a Saturday ballet class om his weekends, just because he can fold his arms and refuse...

RheaRend · 30/01/2024 16:56

By all means tell her to put her poker face on and pretend she is ok because you feel uncomfortable but at least be honest with her.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 30/01/2024 16:53

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 30/01/2024 11:55

YANBU to not want to be her sounding board 5yrs down the line but YABU to tell her how she should be feeling about the end of her marriage.

This

Swipe left for the next trending thread