Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if differences between Scotland and rUK are generally known?

264 replies

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 09:51

I see lots of posts about UK and British issues, that seem to refer to England only.

Is it generally understood that Scotland was a separate country pre 1707 and already had its own legal and education system in place, which were retained on the creation of the United Kingdom?

Therefore house buying, school exams, wills, divorce, university degrees, criminal law, policing etc have real distinct differences.

Are people who use the term UK not aware of the differences when refering/advising on something that affects England only?

Genuinely interested and not meaning to cause an argument. I find the differences really interesting, things like inheritance law when people ask about wills, or issues when a buyer pulls out of buying a house. I don't want to comment on new/current controversial legislation!

OP posts:
Heather37231 · 30/01/2024 21:36

OK , I stand corrected. I was taught local history back to Wallace and Bruce but did not know Gaelic had been spoken in my area before them.

Beithe · 30/01/2024 20:00

Heather37231 · 30/01/2024 19:28

My old primary school, slap bang in the middle of the fairly urban Central belt, in an area where Gaelic was never ever spoken by the native population at any point in history, now offers the opportunity for local children to be educated entirely in Gaelic for the whole 7 years. So each year group offers two English medium and one Gaelic medium class. No prior knowledge of Gaelic required for entry. It’s fascinating.

Gaelic was spoken throughout the Central Belt in the period from 900 to 1150 AD. This is demonstrated by the place names.
I.e. Gartnavel - Farm of the apple orchard
Stirling - a deep river pool

Basically place-names with elements like Cambus (a bend in a river), Dal (a meadow) and many more tell us that Gaelic speakers lived there enough to name the landscape and for those names to be remembered.

owlsinthedaylight · 30/01/2024 19:39

I think that generally (based of discussion with work colleagues):

people in England feel like there are massively more people in England that Scotland. That if they had to guess they would say there were 50 times as many people in England as Scotland. I think people are surprised to find out that it is only a factor of 10.

people generally think that Scotland was conquered by England … and that was probably about 800 years ago. Maybe more. Something to do with Mel Gibson and the avatar movie blue face paint.

as a result of these two points, they feel that the people of Scotland are just being stubborn and silly, hanging on to different ways of doing things just to prove a point.

Mnk711 · 30/01/2024 19:32

I know the difference, having lived in Scotland previously and now in Wales though am very much English. I think part of the problem is the West Lothian question - devolution for Wales, NI, and Scotland, but not England. It means that English people see the Westminster government as theirs whilst also knowing it legislates quite a bit for the rest of the UK. it makes English people feel like we all have one government and are all the same. Your attention is drawn more to the differences if you have to vote for your devolved government as well I think. My family keep saying isn't it great that I will now get free nursery hours for my baby -ignoring, despite being told, that the Welsh government isn't introducing that here. Very minor but still annoying. The worst though was the differing covid lock down rules between Wales and England when we live smack on the border, so annoying.

maddening · 30/01/2024 19:30

Surely the assumption of place is only relevant if seeking legal advice or other similarly impacted (health service/education system etc) though ?

Heather37231 · 30/01/2024 19:28

My old primary school, slap bang in the middle of the fairly urban Central belt, in an area where Gaelic was never ever spoken by the native population at any point in history, now offers the opportunity for local children to be educated entirely in Gaelic for the whole 7 years. So each year group offers two English medium and one Gaelic medium class. No prior knowledge of Gaelic required for entry. It’s fascinating.

maddening · 30/01/2024 19:27

I also grew up on the border with Wales and happily aware if the Welsh language, again day to day living no different really. Wales and Scotland are 2 of my favourite places - I would live in Edinburgh or Glagow in a heartbeat.

maddening · 30/01/2024 19:24

I have lived in both and am aware of the different legal system, general day to day living is no different ime.

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 19:21

Thanks for the replies guys! I think this is fascinating.

Beithe · 30/01/2024 19:15

There are 61 Gaelic medium primary schools and 33 secondaries with Gaelic medium provision in Scotland.

Mrsjayy · 30/01/2024 18:50

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 17:08

I only found out through MN last week that there are schools in Wales where Welsh is the language used! I'm 37 and never knew that!

Does Scotland have Gaelic schools?

I have a Welsh friend so I knew about Welsh as a first language

yes there is Gaelic medium classes on the mainland and I think its spoken more in schools as a first language on the islands.

edited to say Gaelic not garlic 😁

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 18:43

There are 60 GME units. mainly in the Highlands & Islands.

OP posts:
GintyMcGinty · 30/01/2024 17:38

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 17:08

I only found out through MN last week that there are schools in Wales where Welsh is the language used! I'm 37 and never knew that!

Does Scotland have Gaelic schools?

Only very small numbers. None in my town.

hogmanayhoolie · 30/01/2024 17:09

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 17:08

I only found out through MN last week that there are schools in Wales where Welsh is the language used! I'm 37 and never knew that!

Does Scotland have Gaelic schools?

Not many but there are Also GME (Gaelic medium education) provisions in mainstream primary and secondary

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 17:08

I only found out through MN last week that there are schools in Wales where Welsh is the language used! I'm 37 and never knew that!

Does Scotland have Gaelic schools?

TheBayLady · 30/01/2024 17:00

MermaidProject · 30/01/2024 09:59

Given that when I moved to England some seventy years after Ireland had become an independent country, an entire succession of employees of Jobcentres, including a supervisor, just kept telling me to use the NI number I already had 'because it's all the same system', despite me repeatedly telling them I was not from Northern Ireland, but from Ireland, I doubt it.

I mean, if you don't even know that a neighbouring country isn't in the UK at all, and hasn't been since 1922, I'd be surprised if you had any grasp on Scotland's history, separate education, legal system etc.

Edited

Many years ago after moving back to Scotland from Northern Ireland I called the CB agency to change my address, they told me i wasn't entitled to any child benefit as i had been overseas, no amount of arguing made the fool on the other end of the phone understand that N.I was part of the U.K I lost 3 months worth of CB.

picklesandcucumbers · 30/01/2024 16:55

@Seeline

When I'm asked what I am, I say I'm English - never British.

And if people ask why I make such a distinction I say because that's the country / culture I'm familiar with and that I'm not familiar with Scotland etc, and that they have their own distinct cultures.

But I get what you mean, there's some definite cultural relation between people who are "PROUD TO BE ENGLISH" and well, racism. It's an unsavory truth

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 30/01/2024 16:49

No. To be fair, plenty of people don't have very detailed knowledge about how those things work in the part of the British Isles where they live themselves, never mind in any other bit.

Sunsetboardwalk · 30/01/2024 16:49

EverleighMay · 30/01/2024 12:37

I generally always say I'm UK/British rather than Scotland/Scottish.

I absolutely hate the 'English bashing' aka blatant racism and 'independence at any cost' that our nation is infamous for so that's my mini protest towards.

You just called a whole nation racist? Ffs

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 16:42

ssd · 30/01/2024 10:01

I think a lot of posters on mn say "England" when they actually mean the UK. To them England is the UK.

Definitely this.

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 16:34

Kwam31 · 30/01/2024 15:07

I find the faux ignorance regarding school holidays, regional accents/pronunciations frustrating. Surely if your a MN high earning RG graduate you'd know these things 🤣

Aye, by that you mean Robert Gordon University. RG. RG.🤪

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 16:32

Precipice · 30/01/2024 11:03

I agree unless posting in Scotsnet, Scottish posters should state where they are or the assumption will be in England.

English posters should also state they're in England rather than assuming it's obvious because UK=England and England is the centre of the bloody world.

This this this!!!!

TinkerTiger · 30/01/2024 15:56

Kwam31 · 30/01/2024 14:33

@Mrsjayy
Fully agree, I read a post once where an OP was spoken to nastily because she was in Australia, how dare she not realise she had to live in SE England!!

Obviously I don't have the context, but when it comes to asking for advice, TBH, (and nastiness aside) I don't get Australians posting on this site. I don't go on Australian forums asking for advice?

GlasgowGal82 · 30/01/2024 15:33

Most people have a very low level of understanding in my experience. I've worked with UK civil servants who aren't aware of the differences, and therefore do not understand the limitations of their remit and powers. For example attempting to distribute funding that needs to get to schools across the UK by handing it to DofE who have no mechanism to get cash to Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. Or drafting (and passing!) legislation that says 'and amends the equivalent legislation in Scotland' when there is no equivalent legislation because we've had separate systems for hundreds of years (and that happens all the time - look at any immigration legislation that touches on devolved areas like children, social work, health for example). If the people running our country don't understand the differences, then the chances of your average person understanding are slim-to-none. As you point out many of these differences are hundreds of years old - I can only imagine how much worse it was before devolution!

Abitofalark · 30/01/2024 15:32

It's an English-owned and -based forum and with England having a much larger population within the UK, the probability and working assumption is that more users will be English, so it is reasonable for people to state that they are posting from Scotland or other part of the UK which may have different laws or systems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread