Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if differences between Scotland and rUK are generally known?

264 replies

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 09:51

I see lots of posts about UK and British issues, that seem to refer to England only.

Is it generally understood that Scotland was a separate country pre 1707 and already had its own legal and education system in place, which were retained on the creation of the United Kingdom?

Therefore house buying, school exams, wills, divorce, university degrees, criminal law, policing etc have real distinct differences.

Are people who use the term UK not aware of the differences when refering/advising on something that affects England only?

Genuinely interested and not meaning to cause an argument. I find the differences really interesting, things like inheritance law when people ask about wills, or issues when a buyer pulls out of buying a house. I don't want to comment on new/current controversial legislation!

OP posts:
Librarybooksandacoconut · 04/02/2024 11:35

Perth has Perth High, Perth Grammar and Perth Academy. I’m sure there were differences between them in the past, but they are now just all standard comprehensives.

Bargello · 04/02/2024 11:21

In my area (East Dunbartonshire) there are 10 secondary schools. 7 are "academy", 3 are "high school".

But it just all means the same thing. Schools, school intake, exams and catchment areas are definitely what crops up here the most on threads as the two systems are very different yet people moving from England to Scotland or vice vera are constantly trying to compare the two.

Heather37231 · 04/02/2024 10:57

I’ve just done a little survey on Wikipedia. It seems that “Academy” is the most common naming style for state schools in Aberdeenshire and Dundee. Highland has a mixture of the two, then as you go into the Central Belt (where I am from) it’s almost exclusively “High School”.

And here’s an example of a former “High School” being renamed “Academy” after merger with another state school, but there is clearly no structural significance in the name.

I also noticed that fewer private schools than I expected are called “Academy”, it just so happened that the two near me were- possibly because the term was less used in the state sector in my area. Many of the private schools are just called “X School”.

To wonder if differences between Scotland and rUK are generally known?
Kwam31 · 04/02/2024 10:53

My DD attended a state school which happened to be named town academy, no different to town high school along the road. We don't have different types of aye high school.

Heather37231 · 04/02/2024 10:45

TheSilv · 04/02/2024 09:36

I’m in Scotland & Scottish. I & everyone I know refer to the school after primary as Secondary school (so first school then second school) there are different types of Secondary schools, High school, Academy as well as in my town Colleges (from age 11/12 to 16-18) - different from a college you’d attend following on from Secondary school. My husband & I attended Academy while our daughter attended a High School.

Are you saying that your “Academy” was run in a different way to your daughter”s “High School”?
I thought it was literally just a choice of name, with no significance to high vs Academy.

Though as I said upthread, I think that quite a lot of private schools choose to be called “Academy” as it sounds a bit posher (Dollar and Morrison’s are examples). But state schools are free to use “Academy” too.

Heather37231 · 04/02/2024 10:40

Sunsetboardwalk · 03/02/2024 22:23

Heather my question referred to the comments about schools.

Sorry @Sunsetboardwalk , I tagged you in “the answer to that” when I should have tagged @Daphnis156 .

Sunsetboardwalk · 04/02/2024 10:23

Other than private schools they are just names - they are all non-selective comprehensive schools. Selection still done via parents choosing where to live! But not by the school. (I suppose you could say faith schools select by faith to an extent).

Bargello · 04/02/2024 10:04

All the secondary schools round my way are called X Academy but they are not academies in the way they are in England in that they have not opted out of local authority control - that sort of school just doesn't exist in Scotland. There is also a school near where I grew up called Musselburgh Grammar - and that's not a grammar school in the English sense either.

TheSilv · 04/02/2024 09:36

I’m in Scotland & Scottish. I & everyone I know refer to the school after primary as Secondary school (so first school then second school) there are different types of Secondary schools, High school, Academy as well as in my town Colleges (from age 11/12 to 16-18) - different from a college you’d attend following on from Secondary school. My husband & I attended Academy while our daughter attended a High School.

Sunsetboardwalk · 03/02/2024 22:23

Heather my question referred to the comments about schools.

Heather37231 · 03/02/2024 21:48

I guess she means that since Scotland England both had a lot of EU law, that would make their laws more similar.

The answer to that @Sunsetboardwalk is that so did France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Hungary, Denmark etc etc and their systems are very varied indeed. EU law is/was often about principles but each Member State could implement those in its own way. It also rarely dictates things like court procedure, which is where Scots and English law differ the most.

Batteredoldchesterfield · 03/02/2024 18:45

Daphnis156 what do you mean re the EU? I don't understand your question.

Sunsetboardwalk · 03/02/2024 18:20

Daphnis156 · 03/02/2024 12:42

I had no idea the Scottish education system was set in the 1700s.
I knew many laws were different, and house buying, and the court system.

But Scotland was so keen on the EU that many of its laws must have been subject to the EU, when the UK was a member?

But then in any country ruled by Nicola Sturgeon and her cronies, the law hardly mattered...

What do you mean by "set in the 1700s"?

Daphnis156 · 03/02/2024 12:42

I had no idea the Scottish education system was set in the 1700s.
I knew many laws were different, and house buying, and the court system.

But Scotland was so keen on the EU that many of its laws must have been subject to the EU, when the UK was a member?

But then in any country ruled by Nicola Sturgeon and her cronies, the law hardly mattered...

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 12:34

@x2boys , I'm not from Manchester and the evening meal is 'supper'.
(Apparently, on MN supper is a drink and biscuit before going to bed. )

I eat dinner at lunchtime.

Tea is either 'afternoon tea' or a meal eaten in the early evening. It depends on who said it and in what context.

x2boys · 03/02/2024 10:40

Februaryfeels · 03/02/2024 10:21

I'm on another thread where there is total disbelief (and accusations of being snide) because it is apparently universal that pots = dishes

I celebrate local dialect all over the UK and have no issue with people collecting pots (bringing dirty dishes downstairs)

What gets me is the assertion that this is a universal term and if we don't understand it then we are being unpleasant.

So in terms of differences, we all speak English but there seems to be no recognition that we don't all speak and understand the same dialects

Anyway I'm going to get dressed and away to get the messages!

I.was on a thread once and there waa heated arguments about what people call their evening meal
One poster suggested we should all ust agree to csll.it Dinner!
I live in grater Manchester and in my house I we have our tea in the evening

Februaryfeels · 03/02/2024 10:21

I'm on another thread where there is total disbelief (and accusations of being snide) because it is apparently universal that pots = dishes

I celebrate local dialect all over the UK and have no issue with people collecting pots (bringing dirty dishes downstairs)

What gets me is the assertion that this is a universal term and if we don't understand it then we are being unpleasant.

So in terms of differences, we all speak English but there seems to be no recognition that we don't all speak and understand the same dialects

Anyway I'm going to get dressed and away to get the messages!

weescotlass · 03/02/2024 10:05

Also no fines for taking holidays in term time in Scotland. And yes, the assumption that the whole of the UK has the same holiday dates, and confused by lack of May half term etc.

OP posts:
Heather37231 · 02/02/2024 23:23

Mrsjayy · 02/02/2024 21:28

where my dh grew all the schools are academies I just went to a .High school. I don't understand the difference.

In my area the state schools were X High, Y High and Z High and the private schools were A Academy and B Academy.
My parents were always very pedantic about the name of their (state) school- it was The High School of X town, not X town High.

Sunsetboardwalk · 02/02/2024 23:06

Academies in England don't mean the same thing as "X academy" which is just a name in Scotland.
Modern Studies isn't just an option, my S1 child does it though hasn't said what they do!

Sunsetboardwalk · 02/02/2024 23:05

It is usually obvious when a poster is Scottish by their writing style
What now?

Tarkan · 02/02/2024 22:11

There are only two secondary schools in my town. One is TownName High School and the other is TownName Academy. Most people just refer to them as the academy or the high school because of that. I think we'd probably say secondary to refer to them both together otherwise it just sounds like one of them.

ssd · 02/02/2024 22:05

Batteredoldchesterfield · 02/02/2024 19:41

Yes, I grew up in England and went to 'secondary school'. Live in Scotland now and 'high school' is the term here.

It was called secondary when i was younger and it still often is

Mrsjayy · 02/02/2024 21:28

icebearforpresident · 02/02/2024 21:25

All the secondary schools/high schools in my area are academies - Town A academy, Town B Academy, Robert the Bruce Academy etc. Seeing all the talk of academies in the English education system and how it seems to be a plus point always seems weird to me.

where my dh grew all the schools are academies I just went to a .High school. I don't understand the difference.

icebearforpresident · 02/02/2024 21:25

All the secondary schools/high schools in my area are academies - Town A academy, Town B Academy, Robert the Bruce Academy etc. Seeing all the talk of academies in the English education system and how it seems to be a plus point always seems weird to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread