Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if differences between Scotland and rUK are generally known?

264 replies

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 09:51

I see lots of posts about UK and British issues, that seem to refer to England only.

Is it generally understood that Scotland was a separate country pre 1707 and already had its own legal and education system in place, which were retained on the creation of the United Kingdom?

Therefore house buying, school exams, wills, divorce, university degrees, criminal law, policing etc have real distinct differences.

Are people who use the term UK not aware of the differences when refering/advising on something that affects England only?

Genuinely interested and not meaning to cause an argument. I find the differences really interesting, things like inheritance law when people ask about wills, or issues when a buyer pulls out of buying a house. I don't want to comment on new/current controversial legislation!

OP posts:
Bargello · 30/01/2024 11:40

I think when you have grown up in one system, and lived in that country all your life and all you friends and families have done too, you don't come across differences in a practical sense.

I knew the English education system was different because of talk on telly about GCSEs but despite 10 years living south of the border, still can't get my head around school years and how old a child is when someone talks about "Year 7" because my kids have only ever been educated in the Scottish system.

I think most Scottish people are aware of the differences just because there are so many more people in England/Wales. Even if you've never lived in England or bought a property there you will have seen Homes under the Hammer banging on about leasehold (which isn't a thing here) or seen someone prosecuted on a TV drama for perverting the course of justice which has a different name here. English people aren't as aware because they don't need to be. Similar situation with the Americans, there are 300 million of them and only 60 million of us, so 99% of what they learn is about the US.

It only ever riles me on here when someone piles onto a thread where in the OP the poster has said they are in Scotland to make an irrelevant point about leasehold, or sixth form college, or grammar schools, or the NHS app, or pupil premium or any of the other things which there are in England/Wales and aren't in Scotland.

(Sorry Northern Ireland, you don't get a look in!!)

LegoDeathTrap · 30/01/2024 11:32

I feel that for many people UK=England=London.

Which conveniently makes the rest of us a sort of afterthought.

Jovacknockowitch · 30/01/2024 11:31

Dothefandangos · 30/01/2024 11:28

Same with Northern Ireland - which is why there are now devolved governments. wales is pretty much England - shut up, you know you are!
when Americans say ‘British’ for example they almost always mean English.

Most Americans don't know the difference - hence "The King Of England".

Jovacknockowitch · 30/01/2024 11:30

YANBU See also Norn Iron for some legal and other differences - I speak as an ignorant English person.

Dothefandangos · 30/01/2024 11:28

Same with Northern Ireland - which is why there are now devolved governments. wales is pretty much England - shut up, you know you are!
when Americans say ‘British’ for example they almost always mean English.

NancyPickford · 30/01/2024 11:26

In a discussion about the royal family with my in-laws, they kept referring to the Queen of England (the late queen) and now the new King of England. Eventually I said 'so, not the King of the UK, only England?' To be met with baffled looks and a 'you know what we mean' reply. To be clear, the chat was not just about England in isolation but the whole nation.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 30/01/2024 11:26

The areas where confusions seems to happen on mn are:

Inheritance
Social services/family law
Tax/benefits
Political choices/voting systems
Education, schools, uni & funding
Conveyancing law

People don't really know the history of the Union that most aspects of life were expected to remain distinct, law, banking/money, religion and education were all kept separate post 1707.

It was only into the 20th century with the expansion of the state that the nations became more aligned with day to day matters.

That was never the original intention of the Union.

Post 1999 devolution the gap is widening again.

Other differences that don't tend to come up here are:

Children's hearings
Scottish bank notes
Legal aid
Courts & lawyers having different names
Scottish breakfast v English breakfast
Outwith
Scots language
Criminal law inc definitions of rape, murder, assault
Mental health law
Contract law, negligence & bankruptcy
Kinship carers, post care leaving support
Toll roads
Prescriptions & eye tests
Age of criminal responsibility and legal maturity/school leaving age

RuffledKestrel · 30/01/2024 11:19

Yes, I am aware of many differences between them.
The most impactful day to day one?
24hr shops in Scotland are actually 24hrs, 7 days a week. They don't only open for 6 hrs on a Sunday !

Mrsjayy · 30/01/2024 11:13

and if you read mumsnet often you usually catch the gist.

Mrsjayy · 30/01/2024 11:11

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 10:53

Interesting responses thank you. I agree unless posting in Scotsnet, Scottish posters should state where they are or the assumption will be in England.

Water is another one I hadn't thought about, it's just part of our council tax so posts about water rates and meters confuse me!

tbf most posters will it's if they say something that an English poster doesn't understand that is often the issue, not scottish posters purposely being obstinate .

BakedBeansforabrain · 30/01/2024 11:11

Seeline · 30/01/2024 10:00

I work in planning in England and am aware that the planning systems differ and that property rules are different. Since having DCs I am aware that schooling/uni is different, but hadn't really thought about why that is.

I think part of the problem is that although I am English, I always feel a bit awkward about stating that. Being English and proud seems to make people think you are a far right racist - English people don't really feel able to celebrate their roots like the Scots and Welsh do. We are encouraged to think that we are all British.

I think this post is spot on. If you ask most English people where they are from most would say the UK. If you ask a Scottish or Welsh person they would also always say Scottish or Welsh

madeinmanc · 30/01/2024 11:08

I've met southerners with misconceptions about Manchester and anywhere that's not the South East of England so nothing would surprise me!

TheYearOfSmallThings · 30/01/2024 11:05

I suppose it's like us as Europeans talking about "the US" as if it is one entity, when in fact every state has its own laws, taxes, etc, and in some cases very little in common with other states. We fully know this, but we still say "In the US..."

PuttingDownRoots · 30/01/2024 11:04

@sparkysdream thank you. I thought S1 but a year group calculator said P7... which would feel really strange going from second year of Secondary to Primary school again!

Precipice · 30/01/2024 11:03

I agree unless posting in Scotsnet, Scottish posters should state where they are or the assumption will be in England.

English posters should also state they're in England rather than assuming it's obvious because UK=England and England is the centre of the bloody world.

Weepingwillows12 · 30/01/2024 11:02

I am English but was aware that there are differences in schooling, legal system, house buying etc but not really the specifics as it's never directly impacted me. It's more that if I were to, say, buy a house in Scotland I know the rules would be different and I would need to do more research. I would assume that knowledge is common in my friendship group but I have a fair few friends who have Scottish parents so it may not be representative.

sparkysdream · 30/01/2024 11:01

PuttingDownRoots · 30/01/2024 10:58

I was trying to explain the difference in school systems to my DD night as her friend had moved to Scotland... wasn't entirely sure whether her friend would be in P7 or S1 as apparently the homework is a lo t easier (August 2011 birthday if a friendly Scot is about!)

friend will be in S1, and in the middle of the age range for the year

PuttingDownRoots · 30/01/2024 10:58

I was trying to explain the difference in school systems to my DD night as her friend had moved to Scotland... wasn't entirely sure whether her friend would be in P7 or S1 as apparently the homework is a lo t easier (August 2011 birthday if a friendly Scot is about!)

Lemonyyellow · 30/01/2024 10:57

I also agree it’s on the op to state where they’re from if it’s an issue that would be different in a different part of the uk. As the majority of people in the uk live in England I can understand the assumption that posters are in England. I’m welsh so I’ll mention it if my post is to do with eg schooling or something that is different here

CrimsonElevenDelightPetrichor · 30/01/2024 10:55

I'm a Scot living in England. ☹️
Many people here seem to use UK when they mean England. It's very confusing.

weescotlass · 30/01/2024 10:55

Seeline · 30/01/2024 10:00

I work in planning in England and am aware that the planning systems differ and that property rules are different. Since having DCs I am aware that schooling/uni is different, but hadn't really thought about why that is.

I think part of the problem is that although I am English, I always feel a bit awkward about stating that. Being English and proud seems to make people think you are a far right racist - English people don't really feel able to celebrate their roots like the Scots and Welsh do. We are encouraged to think that we are all British.

Interesting. I would always describe myself as Scottish rather than British (irrelevant of independence discussions).

OP posts:
weescotlass · 30/01/2024 10:53

Interesting responses thank you. I agree unless posting in Scotsnet, Scottish posters should state where they are or the assumption will be in England.

Water is another one I hadn't thought about, it's just part of our council tax so posts about water rates and meters confuse me!

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 30/01/2024 10:16

Yes. But because I have worked in policy areas for over 15 years that have been a mixture of devolved and reserved matters.

The one that often catches even NI based people out is the fact the Equality Act 2010 does not apply in Northern Ireland.

Haydenn · 30/01/2024 10:16

I think the natural assumption is, that given the respective population differences, if you are asking something that has legal implications and you are in Scotland (or indeed rest of world given this is mainly a UK site) you should state that in the opening post.

For me it is the ultimate drip feed to come on, ask for advice- get it and then say “no I can’t do that I’m in Scotland”.

I am in Scotland by the way

Precipice · 30/01/2024 10:13

Thisisnottheend · 30/01/2024 10:06

i'm sure most people are aware but seeing as the population of England is approx. 56.5 mill, Scotland 5.5 mill, Wales 3.1 and NI 1.9 mill ----perhaps its rather more likely the poster will be in England ....so is it not the onus on them to say if they are living elsewhere!?

If you're asking for advice on a law related matter, the onus is on you to supply such basic information as your jurisdiction.