Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a gastric band is the best option

59 replies

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 09:36

DH has gained around 6 or 7 stone since we’ve been together. He’s around 26.5 st and a 5XL. No nasty comments please because he’s depressed enough about it. I’m on the chubby side myself for my height but I’m not obese (size 12 but I’m v short). We’re not really intimate anymore and he’s hurt his knees trying to do sports, etc, which he always loved.

Every time he tries dieting, he goes for extreme options like Keto or juice cleanses which are expensive and unsustainable. He’ll cut out food like bread or pasta but end up caving and eating a pack of biscuits by the end of the week/month thus the cycle continues.

I’ve been told I shouldn’t buy processed junk food but we have an autistic son who’s underweight and only eats stuff like pasta, chips, chicken nuggets, etc. So the temptation is always there.

I know two people who struggled to lose weight for years until they sought professional help and got a gastric band via the NHS. DH thinks it’s cheating.

AIBU to think it’s gone too far now and medical intervention is needed.

OP posts:
amusedbush · 30/01/2024 12:25

I have been obese since I was a teenager and my entire adult life has been focused on my weight. I have tried everything and would lose a couple of stone every two years but I could never sustain it. For years people have said "just eat less and move more" but we have a better understanding now of how obesity causes metabolic dysregulation and upsets hormonal responses. Basically, if you're fat and you lose a lot of weight, your body will fight to get back to its previous weight until you maintain that lower weight for long enough to "reset". That can take years and not many people can fight their own body for long enough through willpower alone, so they gain it back.

I had a gastric sleeve consultation booked last year but I chickened out. Then my GP recommended I look into Wegovy injections (paying privately - getting it on the NHS is nearly impossible). I started taking it in November last year and it has been completely life changing.

FrederickTrottersville · 30/01/2024 12:16

I don't know if its always the case that fat people put it back on with WLS. I was fat and fed up, I went to Turkey for a sleeve, had 5 days off work and went tlfrom 96 to 57 kg, 5 years ago. Never put it back on, didn't feel a need to liquidise bug macs, learned to use it as a tool to not eat so much. I didn't want ir need 5 years of NHS therapy or waiting and am all the better for just getting on with it independently. There are some amazing groups out there, especially the friendly gastric surgery group on Facebook, you get to follow people through their processes, some abroad some in the UK, some people 25 stone, some people less. Totally kind and inclusive

Freddiefan · 30/01/2024 12:13

There was something on tv the other day. I didn't take much notice but I think it is a new thing where you swallow a balloon type thing which is then inflated (or filled with water) and eventually it breaks down and is passed. I should have taken more notice.

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 12:12

Embarrassingly I didn’t really know the difference between a band and a sleeve. Ozempic never occurred to me either.

OP posts:
littlemousebigcheese · 30/01/2024 12:06

Family member had one - not an easy quick fix at all. Had to lose significant amount of weight before op could go ahead anyway, lost lots of their hair and was very unwell afterwards and a year on the weight is coming back on

Thedrownedprophet · 30/01/2024 12:04

My friend had gastric surgery and within a year her liver completely failed. She was so lucky to get a liver transplant, but she's still not completely rehabilitated two years later.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 30/01/2024 12:03

@Tiredboymum22 tell him to read the obesity code (its scientific so i found it easier to listen to an audio book). Seriously it will change his life. An easier listen that explains tha science behind intermittant fasting is Fast feast repeat by Gin stephens.

FluffyChemical · 30/01/2024 12:00

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 10:06

Has he tried ozempic? I found it life changing. Got rid of hunger pangs so suddenly sticking to a diet was easy as i didn’t have hunger pangs x

I'll second this suggestion. I have lost about 15kg of the 30kg I needed to lose on Ozempic. It got rid of my hunger pangs and enabled me to stick to a much healthier diet without constantly thinking about food all the time. It's expensive but I think if your BMI is high enough might be able to get it via NHS?

horseyhorsey17 · 30/01/2024 11:52

A friend of mine has had a gastric sleeve and she's gone from being over 20 stone to about 11 stone and looks fantastic BUT it does come at quite a heavy price, she can never eat normally again, and I do worry about the lack of nutrients that she now has from having to eat an extremely restricted diet. Her hair has fallen out (not all of it but it's v thin) and she has very weak nails etc, which isn't surprising. I wouldn't say it's the 'easy' option at all. I do think it's better - and a lot safer - to achieve results through diet and exercise though. I can't see that the long-term health implications of having severely restricted calories can be good - although, to be fair, neither are the long-term health implications of being severely obese.

headcheffer · 30/01/2024 11:45

Take him to the GP and see what they advise. There are several tiers of weight loss support on the NHS, and they're all evidence based and supported by clinicians.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 30/01/2024 11:31

Gastric bands can fail, cause serious health problems and when you look at them they’re basically forced long-term extreme diets, far more so than keto for example. No easy options unfortunately and a gastric band definitely isn’t an easy option. I believe you also have to prove you can lose some weight before you’re even eligible for one.

KarenNotAKaren · 30/01/2024 11:29

A family member of mine who tried everything, and was hindered my a crisis of confidence, had a gastric sleeve op. Best thing she ever did - it does mean you are restricted pretty much forever in some things you can’t eat but totally worth it for the results

Daleksatemyshed · 30/01/2024 11:29

@Plinkyplonky2 but if you eat the right diet you don't have to be starving all the time. A lot of people just snack all the time and it's all the fatty, sugary high calorie foods

MessyTess · 30/01/2024 11:06

Gastric bands aren’t recommended anymore. He’d be better off getting a gastric sleeve or gastric bypass. Once you become morbidly obese for a long period of time it’s almost impossible to keep the weight off even if you do manage to lose it, very few people can maintain a weightloss of that magnitude. The body will always force you back up to that original heavy weight, it will even slow down your metabolism to get you back there. If you’re only overweight for a shorter period of time but you’re naturally slimmer it’s easier to go back to your normal weight and stay there without much effort. Take Slimming World for example, you’ll see women who’ve gained weight for example through pregnancy, praised for getting back to their normal weight and maintaining it easily. Now look at those who have been obese for 10 years and they lose the weight, less than a year or a two at max and they are back to where they were or bigger….same faces at club year after year. Dieting will not work when you are morbidly obese, but it keeps those pushing the plans/meals making easy money!

NanFlanders · 30/01/2024 10:45

Would he consider Weightwatchers or Slimming World, perhaps combined with Ozempic/Wegovy to control his appetite while he gets used to it.? I feel your pain with the autism issue. Our DD has anorexia and needs to eat 6 times a day, which means the house is full of snacks (we used to have what the kids call an 'ingredients house' where I cooked from scratch) - not great for me nor diabetic DH!

HowToSaveAWife · 30/01/2024 10:39

I had a gastric bypass years ago and was similar size to your husband. Your DH wouldn't be a candidate for a band as that's for people with less to lose.

There's a huge process to getting medical intervention, psych evals, a total lifestyle change and learning how to eat again AND it only works if you make it work. It was life changing for me though. Lost 10st, and kept it off.

Lifebeganat50 · 30/01/2024 10:38

Gastric surgery is far from the EASY option, or cheating. It’s a fully committed life change…ask me how I know …best thing I ever did, but it’s a HUGE lifelong commitment

Precipice · 30/01/2024 10:37

My friend's mother had gastric band surgery and nearly died. I wouldn't rush to that option.

Illpickthatup · 30/01/2024 10:35

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 10:05

Tricky - i tend to find this advice works great for not getting overweight in the first place, but the reality is to lose weight you need to cut calories below what you are burning. If you have a sedentary lifestyle (office job for example), this is a pretty low calorie intake. You feel hungry and hunger day after day week after week is a horrible form of torture.

Someone 26 stone probably burning about 3.5 - 4k calories a day just living. So even being in a 500 calorie deficit will cause them to lose weight. Some of these fad diets are 800-1200 calories with is just a ridiculous deficit for someone 26 stone and exactly why they can't stick to it for long.

Workwhat · 30/01/2024 10:06

Yes but not band.you need to do some research as they have significant complication rates.

Ive had bariatric surgery, all the evidence shows people don't lose weight and keep it off through dieting. I think there is a lot we don't understand about weight and bodies. People will say calories in calories out, move more etc... But I'd it wss so simple people would.

So I think you are right to think about surgery but absolutely not the band. Also many placed don't offer this anymore.

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 10:06

Has he tried ozempic? I found it life changing. Got rid of hunger pangs so suddenly sticking to a diet was easy as i didn’t have hunger pangs x

MatildaTheCat · 30/01/2024 10:06

What does your doctor think? Seriously you need medical advice and a plan which will all take time but jumping straight to surgery- are you proposing private surgery to avoid all the interim measures that would be necessary on the NHS?

He needs a full assessment and bloods before any plan can be considered.

Good luck with this though. I believe that in cases such as this surgery is often the most successful route to sustained weight loss but ONLY when the correct processes are followed. Also the injections available now may be a suitable option.

Long short, see your GP together.

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 10:05

Daleksatemyshed · 30/01/2024 09:51

He doesn't have to do drastic diets , much too hard to stick to long term, he'd be better off with a sensible diet that takes the weight off gradually

Tricky - i tend to find this advice works great for not getting overweight in the first place, but the reality is to lose weight you need to cut calories below what you are burning. If you have a sedentary lifestyle (office job for example), this is a pretty low calorie intake. You feel hungry and hunger day after day week after week is a horrible form of torture.

PaulCostinRIP · 30/01/2024 10:03

Would he consider this?

He needs to understand that he is not only shortening his life considerably but is also restricting things he can do with his family and could end up alone.

cindyhove · 30/01/2024 10:03

It is!