Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a gastric band is the best option

59 replies

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 09:36

DH has gained around 6 or 7 stone since we’ve been together. He’s around 26.5 st and a 5XL. No nasty comments please because he’s depressed enough about it. I’m on the chubby side myself for my height but I’m not obese (size 12 but I’m v short). We’re not really intimate anymore and he’s hurt his knees trying to do sports, etc, which he always loved.

Every time he tries dieting, he goes for extreme options like Keto or juice cleanses which are expensive and unsustainable. He’ll cut out food like bread or pasta but end up caving and eating a pack of biscuits by the end of the week/month thus the cycle continues.

I’ve been told I shouldn’t buy processed junk food but we have an autistic son who’s underweight and only eats stuff like pasta, chips, chicken nuggets, etc. So the temptation is always there.

I know two people who struggled to lose weight for years until they sought professional help and got a gastric band via the NHS. DH thinks it’s cheating.

AIBU to think it’s gone too far now and medical intervention is needed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hankunamatata · 01/02/2024 17:07

Would he join slimming world? My dad did and did so well. Suited his large appetite as could bulk everything with veg but needed the discipline of someone weighing him each week. He went to mens only group to start then with my mum

breakfastdinnerandtea · 01/02/2024 17:04

I don't know one person who was obese who has lost weight and kept it off through diet alone. Everyone I know that was that big has needed bariatric surgery to lose the weight and keep it off, and everyone I know who has had surgery has said it's been the best thing they've ever done. I wish I was brave enough myself to go to the GP and ask for it.

Definitely don't go for a band though. You wouldn't believe the amount of people who come into our emergency theatres to have them removed because they've slipped and caused an obstruction or got infected. Our surgeon who does bariatric surgery tends to do sleeves.

Workwhat · 01/02/2024 16:11

HipHop63 · 30/01/2024 13:23

Only 5% of very obese people having had bariatric surgery manage to keep the weight off for good. Its about a total lifestyle overhaul combined with psychiatric help for any trauma suffered in childhood or adult life. Its not a magic solution, it still takes a lot of hard work.

Where are you getting this statistic from?

greasypolemonkeyman · 30/01/2024 14:08

I'm currently going through the hooos for treatment in the nhs.

I'm a 45 yo woman. Survivor of childhood sexual abuse, bipolar, ptsd and several auto immune diseases. I gained weight from age 28-30 ish when I was put on mood stabilisers. They are scientifically proven to care weight gain as they interfere with your boss sugar and trick you into thinking you are hungry. I managed to lose 15 kg at 32 and then got diagnosed with auto immune stuff and spent a year on steroids. Gained 20kg. I've never truly recovered from it, waiting for a knee replacement and the nhs keep putting me off. I was told it would happen at 45 yo and then last year they said 55! So I got my Gp to refer me for help.

I spent 12 months of the bariatric waiting list for a nw hospital then had an apppoi to take my history. Signed up for an online nutrition course and a sleep study. Turns out I had awful sleep apnea and stopped breathing for a total of ten minutes every hour that I was asleep. Got a cpap, it's been revolutionary. I sleep deeper and so much better. As a result, I'm not craving carb based foods anywhere near as much as I was. So as a result of that , I'm losing 1- 2 lb a month without any real effort. I've done the nurturing course and it was just awful. Telling us to make smart substitutions over week. Instead of instant mash, use fresh mash potatoes 🤷🏼‍♀️. Try stay away from UPF but to consider quorn nuggets instead of chicken. Very contradictory and weird. The next step is to see a dietician and physical for 1-1 appointments.

After that I go back to the weight loss clinic and apparently they have funding now for weight loss injections, starting this spring. I can try those with dietician and physio input and then elect to have surgery or continue them if they are tolerated. Tbh I'm probably going to have the surgery. My eldest step sister has had a gastric sleeve i( revised from a gastric band) and said it's been great. She's gone from 28st at her largest to 9 st . Sure also went to turkey for a cosmetic body lift due to recurrent infections from all of her folds.

On the nhs they now only do a gastric sleeve which is for petite with no history of GERD or heartburn as it almost strays makes these worse. They staple your stomach into a sieve and remove the largest part of it and the party that produces the hunger hormone so turning off your hunger. This is irreversible. Side effects can be candy cane starting and restrictins that need dilation to be able to eat. Portion size for your stomach is an egg cup type of size.

The bypass divides your stomach and reroutes your internal plumbing and means that you absorb less nutrients. The downside of this is that people often say they have terrible toileting smells afterwards and smelly wind. These can be revised/reversed but often have better long term success than the sleeve. These still restrict the food.

There is also a mini bypass and a duodenal switch but these aren't widely available in the nhs but are privately.

Before having surgery you are required to sign a waiver that says you can't get future skin removal on the nhs.

I'm going to go for a bypass. I'm bipolar. While I'm stable I do great. I eat very healthily despite being obese but I go manic or depressive and it all goes to shit. Add in the frequent steps etc and I know I need help.

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 14:00

@amusedbush interesting you mention autism because DH and MIL always said he has undiagnosed Asperger’s (his words, not mine). I believe there’s a sensory aspect to it because he’ll literally eat a block of marzipan for that dopamine boost.

I was raised on a healthy diet. There were no snacks at home and we never ate large portions. I remember being physically unable to finish a meal at friends’ houses. I was excited about eating a mars bar but I couldn’t finish it and felt sick. I was always a size 8 until I was prescribed antidepressants. After a month on them I was ravenous and never felt properly full. I’ve been a size 12 for years but I’m only 5ft1 so I’m technically overweight, though not obese. I struggle to stop eating sometimes but nowhere near to the extent DH does. That’s why I think ozempic or gastric surgery might be the only option. But it’s hard for people who can regulate their appetite to understand.

OP posts:
StylishM · 30/01/2024 13:57

Hi OP, I'm a bariatric surgery success story.

I was 19st in lockdown, I had an NHS referral for weight management with a view to surgery, but the waiting list in my area was >3 years. I paid privately for a gastric sleeve, I'm not 11st, stable weight and healthy. I cannot stress how much it's changed my life for the better. However, I had to have a serious look at my eating habits and decide if I was ready to commit to not eating shit.

There's an incredible book written by an NHS consultant which I'd highly recommend. @HipHop63 said the success rate is 5%, to my knowledge, the failure rate of surgery is only 15-20% of people significantly regain in 10 years.

Gastric bands are no longer offered by the NHS, as they're a huge source of secondary issues, such as slipping, infection and over restriction.

A gastric sleeve removes 70-75% of the stomach, so literally reduces the portion size one can eat from a dinner plate to a ramekin.

A gastric bypass re-plumbs the lower digestive tract as well as removing a lot of the stomach, so malnutrition is more common in bypass patients.

Do some research but I'd recommend a sleeve to anyone!

To think a gastric band is the best option
Guttedme · 30/01/2024 13:43

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 12:12

Embarrassingly I didn’t really know the difference between a band and a sleeve. Ozempic never occurred to me either.

Sorry to be negative on the weight loss pens - please do not put all your faith in them.

I've just been told the second brand I have been on is going out of stock. I won't have achieved two years on any of the weight loss pens, left alone a lifetime due to incredible stock issues. They just do not manufacture enough pens to last everybody.

To say I'm gutted is an understatement. The pens just simply cannot be relied upon.

I'm temped by the 6 month dissolvable balloon (still not an easy procedure to have but I think it now just passes out no fuss when you get to the 4 or 6 months) I always thought that was quite BMI restricted but I'm sure I read something other day which blow my soaks off as it said if your BMI is nearer 60 you could stand a chance to get it on the nhs.

Non-surgical gastric balloon available on NHS for first time | NHS | The Guardian

Please involve your GP/surgery. As a diabetic taking Trulicity private at it's maximum dose, I will now have to explain myself to my surgery if my diabetic review bloods come back so good it reverses the diabetes with a now out of stock brand. 😰

Non-surgical gastric balloon available on NHS for first time

Treatment takes 15 minutes and involves swallowing a capsule with no need for surgery, endoscopy or anaesthesia

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/jan/23/non-surgical-gastric-balloon-available-on-nhs-for-first-time

amusedbush · 30/01/2024 13:40

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 13:17

Oh i’m autistic too. Constantly starving when not on meds. maybe there’s something in that

Maybe. Most autistic people struggle with proprioception and alexithymia so it might be that we are interpreting some other internal signal as hunger.

TimetohittheroadJack · 30/01/2024 13:33

I’d encourage him to try Wegovy first. Although it’s not cheap, the lower dose starters are around £200 per month. I’ve been on it for 8 weeks and lost a stone. You could put crisps, sweets, whatever in front of me and I’d eat a couple, compared to demolishing everything before.

HipHop63 · 30/01/2024 13:23

Only 5% of very obese people having had bariatric surgery manage to keep the weight off for good. Its about a total lifestyle overhaul combined with psychiatric help for any trauma suffered in childhood or adult life. Its not a magic solution, it still takes a lot of hard work.

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 13:17

amusedbush · 30/01/2024 13:07

I have been (on average) 15 stone my entire adult life. Every couple of years I'd put myself through misery to lose a bit of weight but I was ravenous constantly and I couldn't sustain it. During lockdown, my life felt like it was unravelling and my weight reached 18 stone 5. I was diagnosed with autism and ADHD, I started ADHD medication and for the first time ever, my brain had the dopamine it needed. I stopped binge eating overnight and I lost 50lbs with little effort but as soon as I got back to just under 15 stone, the weight loss stopped and I was back to misery if I wanted to get any smaller.

Like you say, dieting was awful because I was so hungry all the time. I'd be thinking about when I could next eat, literally while I was eating something else. I had no brain space for anything because all I could think about was food and how hungry I was.

Since starting Wegovy 12 weeks ago, I have lost another 32lbs with little effort because I just don't think about food. I wish I could stay on it forever!

Oh i’m autistic too. Constantly starving when not on meds. maybe there’s something in that

Thehamsterthatcametotea · 30/01/2024 13:15

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 12:12

Embarrassingly I didn’t really know the difference between a band and a sleeve. Ozempic never occurred to me either.

Thankfully it’s not you that needs to know the difference.

SquirrelsAssemble · 30/01/2024 13:10

Agree with @Foxblue
Your DH needs to address his relationship with food - nobody's happy being in pain & unable to do things they love at 26st.
There's a reason why the pack of biscuits is a stronger draw than a body he can comfortably live in.

FWIW, mine was ingrained association of food with love (mums a feeder) & horrendous snacking culture when I lived at home.

In the extreme situation that your DH is in, I'd personally spend my money on counselling before opting for potentially risky & unpleasant major surgery.

amusedbush · 30/01/2024 13:07

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 12:44

There is sooo much blame for obesity.

I have struggled with my weight my whole life, and for a lot of it have been a healthy weight but even at a healthy weight every day was a struggle. I was hungry ALL the time. I never felt full. I never ever refused seconds without wishing i could have more.

I have 2 kids, both skinny and both of them turn down sweets and cakes if they don’t fancy them, just eat until they are full. I would eat until there was nothing left in sight!

Starting Ozempic i felt like i’d been inducted into a secret society of all the people i’d ever seen saying ‘nah i’ll pass on the cake’ (without it being a wrench) or ‘ i’m not that hungry’ or ‘i’ll just have salad’.

And I realised why for some people it’s easier to just… be slim. Because they aren’t constantly ravenous.

I have been (on average) 15 stone my entire adult life. Every couple of years I'd put myself through misery to lose a bit of weight but I was ravenous constantly and I couldn't sustain it. During lockdown, my life felt like it was unravelling and my weight reached 18 stone 5. I was diagnosed with autism and ADHD, I started ADHD medication and for the first time ever, my brain had the dopamine it needed. I stopped binge eating overnight and I lost 50lbs with little effort but as soon as I got back to just under 15 stone, the weight loss stopped and I was back to misery if I wanted to get any smaller.

Like you say, dieting was awful because I was so hungry all the time. I'd be thinking about when I could next eat, literally while I was eating something else. I had no brain space for anything because all I could think about was food and how hungry I was.

Since starting Wegovy 12 weeks ago, I have lost another 32lbs with little effort because I just don't think about food. I wish I could stay on it forever!

Foxblue · 30/01/2024 12:58

Unless he does work to investigate the psychological root causes of why he eats, and makes unhealthy eating choices, all of these other things run the risk of being temporary.
Sugar addiction
Dehydration that feels like hunger
Hunger cues are out of whack - body is used to snacking, so sends hunger signals
Boredom
Lack of confidence in putting together healthy meals in a busy life
Emotional/stress triggers
And before anyone comes at me to go 'I tried all those things and they didn't work for me' - im not saying it definitely is any of the above! It's just a list of things that might help prompt some research into each of them, and some experimenting with the various methods out there to combat them. Worked for me (the top 3 were my big issues)

NonPlayerCharacter · 30/01/2024 12:57

"Cheating"...cheating who? Who would it be dishonest towards?

I know a couple of people who have had gastric bands and it was definitely right for them. As PPs say, it isn't a magic solution but for them it was the best one and the only thing to have demonstrable long term results. Neither of them are slim now but they are "normal" fat, if you see what I mean, without any of the issues that came from extreme obesity. The change is incredible and they've maintained for years and years.

There are reasons it isn't right for everyone but I don't think "it's cheating" is one of them. Weight loss isn't a moral act of worthiness, it's something you do for your health. It's a complicated issue and you find what works in as healthy a way as possible.

Fluffycloudsfloatinginthesky · 30/01/2024 12:55

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 10:00

@cindyhove a gastric bypass sounds like a safer option

A gastric bypass means you don't absorb as many nutrients. The person I know who had it done ended up malnourished. They also over ate for psychological reasons and they didn't address those (essentially it was a form of self harm) with that taken away they ended up with even worse issues, in fact they are only alive because their body cannot absorb all the panadol they keep swallowing.

It's not an easy / safer option.

Lifebeganat50 · 30/01/2024 12:53

horseyhorsey17 · 30/01/2024 12:50

She doesn't have restrictions as such but can only eat a really small amount - less than a child's portion. It's no wonder she lost the weight! But how can such a small amount of calories actually be healthy for a 5 foot 8 grown woman? She also has to leave an hour between drinking and eating. She's physically sick if she doesn't stick to this.

You need to eat little and often. I refer to it as toddler portions, but I’ve just eaten 3crackers and cheese with pickles for lunch…whilst losing you still need to be taking in 1200 ish calories a day, prioritising protein. I do 30 mins between eating and drinking, as advised by my surgeon. I deliberately eat a fairly boring diet as I’ve spent too many years obsessed by food, and now I work on eating to live, not living to eat

Lifebeganat50 · 30/01/2024 12:50

Gettingbysomehow · 30/01/2024 12:48

You can get chocolate, crisps and icecream down it with ease so I think I actually gained weight and became malnourished.

So you made poor choices. I deliberately don’t eat chocolate and crisps now. As is always said, it’s a tool, not a magic wand

horseyhorsey17 · 30/01/2024 12:50

Lifebeganat50 · 30/01/2024 12:46

That’s a shame about your friend, but I have to say that’s absolutely not been my experience with a sleeve. I’m 2 years out, over 14 stone down and have no restrictions on what I eat, just the portion size.
Yes I had hair loss, but it’s all back now and growing well

She doesn't have restrictions as such but can only eat a really small amount - less than a child's portion. It's no wonder she lost the weight! But how can such a small amount of calories actually be healthy for a 5 foot 8 grown woman? She also has to leave an hour between drinking and eating. She's physically sick if she doesn't stick to this.

Gettingbysomehow · 30/01/2024 12:48

You can get chocolate, crisps and icecream down it with ease so I think I actually gained weight and became malnourished.

Gettingbysomehow · 30/01/2024 12:47

At 26 stone a gastric band is completely useless. I had one fitted, adjusted super tight and lost no weight whatsoever. I had 5 stone to lose.
I've just had it removed as food would get stuck in it and make me vomit.
If you are that overweight you need a gastric bypass.
But personally I'm never doing quick fixes again. I'm on a calorie controlled diet of 1400 a day and I'm losing weight fast. I'm 62 so no spring chicken.

Lifebeganat50 · 30/01/2024 12:46

horseyhorsey17 · 30/01/2024 11:52

A friend of mine has had a gastric sleeve and she's gone from being over 20 stone to about 11 stone and looks fantastic BUT it does come at quite a heavy price, she can never eat normally again, and I do worry about the lack of nutrients that she now has from having to eat an extremely restricted diet. Her hair has fallen out (not all of it but it's v thin) and she has very weak nails etc, which isn't surprising. I wouldn't say it's the 'easy' option at all. I do think it's better - and a lot safer - to achieve results through diet and exercise though. I can't see that the long-term health implications of having severely restricted calories can be good - although, to be fair, neither are the long-term health implications of being severely obese.

Edited

That’s a shame about your friend, but I have to say that’s absolutely not been my experience with a sleeve. I’m 2 years out, over 14 stone down and have no restrictions on what I eat, just the portion size.
Yes I had hair loss, but it’s all back now and growing well

Plinkyplonky2 · 30/01/2024 12:44

amusedbush · 30/01/2024 12:25

I have been obese since I was a teenager and my entire adult life has been focused on my weight. I have tried everything and would lose a couple of stone every two years but I could never sustain it. For years people have said "just eat less and move more" but we have a better understanding now of how obesity causes metabolic dysregulation and upsets hormonal responses. Basically, if you're fat and you lose a lot of weight, your body will fight to get back to its previous weight until you maintain that lower weight for long enough to "reset". That can take years and not many people can fight their own body for long enough through willpower alone, so they gain it back.

I had a gastric sleeve consultation booked last year but I chickened out. Then my GP recommended I look into Wegovy injections (paying privately - getting it on the NHS is nearly impossible). I started taking it in November last year and it has been completely life changing.

There is sooo much blame for obesity.

I have struggled with my weight my whole life, and for a lot of it have been a healthy weight but even at a healthy weight every day was a struggle. I was hungry ALL the time. I never felt full. I never ever refused seconds without wishing i could have more.

I have 2 kids, both skinny and both of them turn down sweets and cakes if they don’t fancy them, just eat until they are full. I would eat until there was nothing left in sight!

Starting Ozempic i felt like i’d been inducted into a secret society of all the people i’d ever seen saying ‘nah i’ll pass on the cake’ (without it being a wrench) or ‘ i’m not that hungry’ or ‘i’ll just have salad’.

And I realised why for some people it’s easier to just… be slim. Because they aren’t constantly ravenous.

amusedbush · 30/01/2024 12:43

Tiredboymum22 · 30/01/2024 12:12

Embarrassingly I didn’t really know the difference between a band and a sleeve. Ozempic never occurred to me either.

There's no shame in not knowing something!

A gastric band is a device placed around the stomach to restrict how much food can be eaten. It can be adjusted by a surgeon and is reversible but there is a high risk of injury, e.g. the band can erode through the stomach and cause perforations, which are life threatening.

A gastric sleeve is when the majority of the stomach is surgically removed, leaving the original digestive system intact but the stomach drastically smaller.

A gastric bypass is when the stomach is sectioned off and the digestive system is rerouted so food goes from that section straight to the small bowel, "bypassing" the rest of the stomach.

In terms of weight loss injections, Saxenda is administered daily and Wegovy is weekly. Ozempic and Wegovy are the exact same medication but Ozempic is licenced only for diabetes treatment and Wegovy is licenced for weight loss. The medications work by lowering the blood sugar and slowing digestion, so you feel fuller for longer. In my experience, I feel normal hunger signals at meal times but I feel full after a small amount of food and I have no desire to snack.