Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people crash on a straight stretch of motorway?

132 replies

ColonelBrandonsPiano · 30/01/2024 01:43

After another motorway crash, involving road closures and delays etc, I’m once again wondering how so many people seem to crash on a straight stretch of motorway.

junctions - yes, built up traffic in a city - yes, roundabouts- again yes.

but why motorways? Is it due to lack of familiarity? Tiredness from a long drive? Lack of motorway experience. Absolutely baffles me.

OP posts:
Sparklesocks · 30/01/2024 16:31

I crashed on the m25 when a car suddenly swerved into my lane in the gap behind me, very nearly hitting me, which caused me to surge forward to avoid him and meant I hit the car in front (everyone was fine).

Stupid, my fault, but it was a split second that I misjudged because of someone else’s split second misjudgement. Everyone was slowing and getting in lane because it was one of those stretches where it divides into two directions and gets really busy.

I think the number of cars plus how fast everyone is driving means that silly mistakes can cause more accidents than you realise.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 30/01/2024 16:17

Include the mirrors even if you are not planning a manoeuvre, as then you know what's likely around you if you need to take emergency action.
Isn't this one of the most basic things you first learn when you're learning to drive? That you should be regularly checking your mirrors, it's not just something you do when about to manoeuvre. You should always be, aware of what's going on behind and to the sides of you as well as in front. Your post made it sound as if it's some new advice, and not something every driver should already be doing.

IBegYourBiggestPardon · 30/01/2024 15:28

Shoppingfiend · 30/01/2024 06:44

Fiddling with their phones.
Surely this is it.
Or fiddling with the buttons on the dashboard navigation/ media selection/ radio.
I read somewhere that manufacturers are doing away with the push buttons because of this
https://slate.com/business/2023/04/cars-buttons-touch-screens-vw-porsche-nissan-hyundai.html
My VW buttons had to be pressed again and again which meant taking my eye off the road.

My fogs lights are this. Set off to the side which means having to take my eyes off the road to turn them on or off.

BlowDryRat · 30/01/2024 15:24

Edited to fix weird formatting.

There's the odd incident like ladders/rakes/scaffolding that's fallen off a van, tyre blow-outs and car malfunctions. Not a lot people can do about that other than make sure your car is serviced and loads are properly secured.

There are the accidents that happen because of routinely poor driving:

Middle-lane driving
Speeding
Driving too fast for the road/weather conditions
Inadequate distance from the vehicle in front
Using a phone/touch screen/radio

This needs better enforcement and more regular driver testing. I know there's no capacity in the current system, but I reckon we'd be a lot safer if every driver had to sit a re-test every 10 years to keep their licence.

Then there's the accidents that happen because driving is boring and our brains switch off or we get distracted by other people/pets in the car. My friend crashed into the back of someone because her toddler escaped from his car seat and she turned when he tapped her on the shoulder (no injuries, thankfully). That's when I think the driver aid features in modern cars can really help. If I have adaptive cruise control and lane assist turned on, then I'm not going to get too close to the car in front or wobble over the lines. My car screams at me and flashes warning lights if I indicate to change into a lane with something in it, even in my blind spot. People also need to take more breaks and not try to do stupidly long unbroken journeys above their ability to concentrate.

oldwhyno · 30/01/2024 14:41

speeding, not driving to the conditions

namechange301 · 30/01/2024 14:14

I see so many near misses on my many motorway drives. Mainly lack of concentration when switching lanes, boy racers, tiredness, defective car, and at that speed, the slightest nudge or knock can be lethal.

DdraigGoch · 30/01/2024 13:48

jasflowers · 30/01/2024 08:11

Do they?

When did the UK last design a motorway? nothing to do with the topography of the land, avoiding steep hills or cuttings, which means even if we wanted too, its not feasible to build dead straight roads.

Driver error is as always, the number one cause of accidents, the higher speeds on m/ways means accidents, when they happen, are far more severe.

Edited

A few built in the nineties which had incorporated experience from the preceding 30 years, not to mention possible future schemes such as the West Birmingham Orbital and the Lower Thames Crossing.

Using engineering to govern human behaviour is more effective at saving lives than just praying that the population will drive safely. So just as we now raise up pedestrian crossings to force drivers to slow down when approaching them, we avoid building dead-straight roads any more.

mitogoshi · 30/01/2024 13:21

Oh and the number of people on phones is ridiculous, even watching a movie! I ride pillionon a motorcycle and you can see right in, if only I had a go pro on my helmet, I could be a plain clothes traffic cop!

mitogoshi · 30/01/2024 13:19

Lane changing due to vehicles travelling at 55mph in the middle lane ( no significant traffic in left lane) refusing to pull into left lane .... Tesla drivers in particular!

ManchesterLu · 30/01/2024 13:19

Straight is the worst, your mind wanders, you don't realise someone's braked in front of you, and before you know it there's a pile-up.

WetBandits · 30/01/2024 13:12

Mostly inattention and failure to leave adequate distance.

The scariest I’ve had by far was a crazy man at night on a very quiet stretch of motorway. He cut me up on the single-lane slip road just as we were about to join the motorway, then turned his lights off and swerved across all three lanes repeatedly whilst I was behind him to try and make me crash into him. I hung back as much as I could and he just stopped his car until I was close again, so I pulled onto the hard shoulder as it wasn’t safe to try and get past him with what he was doing, then he pulled up in front of me. Locked myself in and called the police while he was banging on my windows and trying all the doors. Still nobody else around at this point, a good thing in a way as others wouldn’t have known what he was doing until there was a pileup, but also terrifying because I was alone on the hard shoulder with a madman trying to break into my car.

I’ve since invested in a dashcam as I couldn’t actually believe what he was doing and that I’d survived it!

HotToes · 30/01/2024 12:39

Is it so many though? You have to take into account how many cars are on the road.

ntmdino · 30/01/2024 12:06

I've had a few crashes on straight dual carriageways - in fact, the same stretch every single time. None of them were my fault, but they always followed the same pattern - slow/stopped traffic in front, and somebody hitting me from behind.

Most recent one was just before COVID - traffic had stopped about 500m in front of me, so I slowed and came to a stop. Nearest car was about the same distance behind me when I stopped, so I figured I was OK.

Then it didn't slow down. I push the brake pedal hard and yank the steering wheel away from the other lane in the hopes of there not being too much damage.

She saw me (and all the other stopped cars) at the last second, and hit me at around 50mph, driving me into the van in front...in total, four cars written off and a lot of damage to the tools in the van.

The cause of it? Well, when she got out of the car her hair and shoulders were wet with coffee, as was her right arm. There are no cup holders on the right hand side of the driver in the BMW she was driving. She admitted she was drinking coffee and didn't see the cars at the time, but started denying it as soon as we got all the cars off the road. Fortunately, we all made sure to get her coffee-drenched self in at least some of the photos we took of the damage for the insurers.

In total, I'm told the insurance claims came to around £120k not including injury claims, all because one woman couldn't wait for her morning coffee.

The problem is that, on that particular stretch of straight road, people just stop concentrating - because it's a straight road. Happens all the time - there are usually three or four crashes a week on that stretch, even now that there's a 50mph limit due to works (which don't seem to actually be happening). It's madness.

LakieLady · 30/01/2024 11:50

Reliance on satnavs
I've noticed that many leave telling you to move for exit lanes far too late. I was using Google maps at the weekend and noticed it told me that in a 1/4 mile keep left.... just as the road markings changed to show the lane had already become the filter/exit lane. If you left it until the satnav said move, traffic was already solid and there was no real room to move over.

I don't understand why anybody bothers with a satnav on a motorway. How hard is it to remember (eg) M23/M25 clockwise/M4 until you get to the A34 or whatever?

I think I've used mine twice in the last year, and last time I used it, it was a complete fucking disaster. The road I needed to go down was closed for road works, the diversion was badly signposted and the satnav kept telling me to go down the closed road. I pulled into a Tesco car park and worked out an alternative route using Google maps as an actual map.

I actually asked a few people for directions, but the people of Havant must be unusually law abiding, because none of them had a clue where the court building was.

Alicewinn · 30/01/2024 11:47

MojoMoon · 30/01/2024 08:42

At 70mph, stopping distance is about 100m when you include reaction time and physical braking time. Cars are getting bigger and heavier.

People drive much closer than 100m to the vehicle in front. So any issues, and it is hard to avoid.

Cars are also much wider now - an SUV really fill the lane so no space for error.

Added to that, the plague of people using their phones while driving. Either in their hand or in a cradle - it doesn't matter, it's still distraction.

Many road deaths are avoidable if traffic laws were followed but we allow terrible, unsafe drivers to continue to drive when they have repeatedly proved how unsafe they are. Plus the punishment for driving without a license is far too weak.

Absolutely, and you leave 100m gap and then someone instantly moves into it.

DanceMumTaxi · 30/01/2024 11:01

I think too close to the car in front and being impatient is a big one. I drive on a busy stretch of the M6 to get to/from work. I try to leave a reasonable gap but someone always shoves themselves in it. So many people darting in and out at high speed. It’s not helped by the amount of HGVs that slow up the inside lane then try and pull out round each other, therefore slowing up the middle lane too. It takes them an absolute age to overtake so causes chaos at busy times.

WarrenSpeck · 30/01/2024 10:55

It's truly concerning how prevalent dangerous driving behaviors are on motorways.

EBearhug · 30/01/2024 10:52

Statistically, motorways are safer, but when things do go wrong, because of the speeds, the consequences are often worse.

When I first got a car in the '90s, which was a few years after I passed my test, I took a motorway lesson. The instructor took me out on the motorway, focussing on joining at the slip road, but took me home via the parallel A-road, because that's where more accidents happen.

timetofetgit · 30/01/2024 10:32

People not using their mirrors.
Driving too fast /too slow
Not keeping to safe distances
Complete lack of awareness of other road uses
Not driving correctly according to the road conditions ie too fast in fog, not enough breaking distance in the rain, dazzled by a low sun etc
Being distracted
Not keeping eyes on the road, I have a friend who eye balls you (when talking) when she's driving....it's fooking terrifying and I won't get in the car with her again!
Pissing around at the wheel...once saw a women probably early 20s bopping to music waving her hands up in the air whilst over taking...wtaf
Refusing to move out of the middle lane, and being undertaken....one incredibly thoughtless one incredibly dangerous.
Banned drivers
Inexperienced drivers
Drivers without a licence with no knowledge of the Highway Code
A lot of very angry people running late then driving like loons at speed.
Too many vehicles on an overloaded infrastructure, means there simply isn't room for a mistake / lack of judgement etc without consequences.
So many reasons really.

Workwhat · 30/01/2024 10:13

I have a motorway close to my house and around the edge of the city I live in. So I use it a lot. Something I increasingly notice is how bad people are at joining to motorway. It seems to be two approaches, either bombing along assuming the people on carriageway will more for you, often combined with not looking. Or slowly down to 40 or 30 mph and being really hesitant causing issues on the slip road and the carriageway they're joining.

I've had loads of experience f having to react to both if these approaches and look out for them. But I can easily imagine this causes accidents. Plus on the sections with no slip roads. I think if people join and leave like this how do they change lanes or overtake? Probably in a similar fashion. So I can totally see how they cause accidents.

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 30/01/2024 10:07

There's a stretch near us that has lots of accidents, usually around similar times in the morning at this time of year. It's a combination of factors:

  • down hill stretch with an uphill stretch straight after (people speeding up doing down the hill, then failing to accelerate and keep to the same speed going up the other side leads to a concertina effect at the bottom of the hill)
  • higher traffic due to the time of day
  • and at this time of year, heading east bound in the rush hour means glaring sunshine straight in your windscreen

Once we get past February the accidents normally reduce again, once the sun glare is out of rush hour.

littlebopeepp234 · 30/01/2024 10:03

Jovacknockowitch · 30/01/2024 09:57

Crash statistics aren’t a theory.

I never said they were 🙄

Jovacknockowitch · 30/01/2024 09:57

littlebopeepp234 · 30/01/2024 09:51

In theory yes if everyone used them correctly. They are very long straight stretches of road, no twists, turns or bumps so ideally they would be the safest type of road. However some of the idiots who use them aren’t safe at all.

Crash statistics aren’t a theory.

littlebopeepp234 · 30/01/2024 09:51

Deathbyfluffy · 30/01/2024 09:08

Statistics strongly disagree - per mile, motorways are the safest type of road.

In theory yes if everyone used them correctly. They are very long straight stretches of road, no twists, turns or bumps so ideally they would be the safest type of road. However some of the idiots who use them aren’t safe at all.

hudpat · 30/01/2024 09:38

People falling asleep at the wheel due to the monotony.
People changing lanes abruptly without indicated.
People cutting in without enough room to spare causing the person behind to brake suddenly.
People driving too close - that drives me mad.
Impatient and aggressive drivers.