Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people crash on a straight stretch of motorway?

132 replies

ColonelBrandonsPiano · 30/01/2024 01:43

After another motorway crash, involving road closures and delays etc, I’m once again wondering how so many people seem to crash on a straight stretch of motorway.

junctions - yes, built up traffic in a city - yes, roundabouts- again yes.

but why motorways? Is it due to lack of familiarity? Tiredness from a long drive? Lack of motorway experience. Absolutely baffles me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MagentaRocks · 31/01/2024 15:11

ColonelBrandonsPiano · 30/01/2024 01:58

I wonder if a minimum speed limit would help by reducing overtaking. Realistically you shouldn’t need to overtake unless there’s a slower moving vehicle I.e lorry, caravan etc. But often you have drivers travelling much lower than the speed limit, and then also slower moving vehicles in the middle lane who seem afraid to change lanes.
So much safer if we could set the adaptive cruise control, and then only occasionally change lanes.

that wouldn’t work. It is a speed limit not a target. People should, and do drive at a speed that is suitable for the conditions. If there is horrendous rain I go a lot slower than if it is a clear dry day.

it is people not concentrating, overtaking without looking etc that causes it as well as being on their phones, texting etc

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 31/01/2024 15:07

RichardMarxisinnocent · 31/01/2024 06:43

I like the suggestion of a mini quiz. When I was, learning to drive many years ago, a relative who had done an advanced driving course, and drove for a living used to take me out to practice. Every so often he would ask me what car was behind me, to check I was using my mirrors regularly and taking notice of what I saw in them.

My DF was a driving instructor. While supervising me driving one day, he stuck his hand over the rear view mirror and said "what colour's the car behind?". Of course I could have looked in my wing mirror, but don't forget I was inexperienced at this point.

It was an excellent way to prove the point that I wasn't looking in my mirrors enough.

To pick up on another PP point, I'm staggered that people aren't taught to look over their shoulder, if that's true. I have a massive blind spot on my (very small!) car. I generally know what's around me (due to my father's above pesky trick), but will still always check before I move. Occasionally I am caught out by a vehicle in my blind spot, so it's absolutely necessary!

Netflixmad · 31/01/2024 15:03

Mostly lack of concentration, not reading the traffic situation, excess speed, messing about in a phone, watching tv on an iPad, painting their nails. I’ve seen all these things on a motorway and they all cause collisions.

shrodingersvaccine · 31/01/2024 15:00

MurielThrockmorton · 30/01/2024 06:41

I've had a left-hand drive lorry pull out on me as I was overtaking, I guess I was in his blindspot, the car that was about to overtake me slowed down so I could pull out, so the lorry touched the side of my car with a lot of noise, but I was okay. I don't think he even knew he hit me, so I'm now much more aware of not being in their blindspot. I've also had a van push me onto the hard shoulder. And more recently early on a Sunday morning when it was quite quiet I had to swerve around a car that had stopped just past a junction, and I watched in my rearview mirror him reverse down the motorway so he could get off at the junction he just passed!

There was also a thread on here a while ago, about people, not actually physically looking over their shoulder as they pulled out on the basis that they knew where cars were from their mirrors. Cars moving into the middle lane in a three lane motorway from both the inside and outside lanes seems also to have potential for accidents if drivers aren't aware of what's going on in every lane not just the one next to them.

Same, I was written off by a lorry that didn't check its blind spot and pulled into my lane - road was busy and I had nowhere to go so he just crushed the side of my car, idiot. So many people don't check their blind spot, someone else nearly got me as I came off a slip road the other week.

I'm British but learned to drive in Europe and one thing I see here is really slow drivers on the motorway must cause accidents - everyone's trying to get round them or you come off a slip road behind them and nearly end up into the back of them. If you're too scared to drive over 50mph you shouldn't be on the motorway, even if you are sticking to the 'slow' lane. You'd get a ticket for 'impeding the flow of traffic' in most of Europe for driving like that.

CormorantStrikesBack · 31/01/2024 13:32

When I learnt to drive I was taught to do a shoulder check before changing lanes due to the blind spot. They don’t teach that now and tell people just to use their mirrors, not sure if that’s an issue

maddiemookins16mum · 31/01/2024 13:27

We were hit from behind on the M4 right by Heathrow, I’ll never forget the noise - and my glasses flew off. We were probably only going at 50mph too - as it was a Friday night and very busy. The bloke just rammed in to us. God knows how he managed it. Car was a write off. Poor DD who was about 10 at the time was terrified.

lavenderlou · 31/01/2024 06:46

Not leaving an appropriate distance between vehicles. Lorries are especially bad for this IME.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 31/01/2024 06:43

2024GarlicCloves · 30/01/2024 21:13

I like that move your head or you're dead!

I had an 'advanced' motorway lesson; the most useful thing - along with keeping safe distance, overtaking like a grown-up and taking account of conditions - was to run an ongoing quiz to myself about what the vehicles way up ahead are doing, speeders and lane-changers behind me, any minor landmarks and interesting details about other traffic or drivers.

The instructor could actually remember all this - he was able to replay the whole journey in his mind - but, for me, it's about observation & anticipation. Keeps your brain engaged with the task.

I like the suggestion of a mini quiz. When I was, learning to drive many years ago, a relative who had done an advanced driving course, and drove for a living used to take me out to practice. Every so often he would ask me what car was behind me, to check I was using my mirrors regularly and taking notice of what I saw in them.

mumda · 30/01/2024 22:13

My experience (as a passenger on the motorway who can pay more attention to other cars) is that the bad drivers are usually fiddling with a phone either on their lap or in their hand.

LlynTegid · 30/01/2024 21:47

Lots of reasons as noted. Perhaps if we had medical standards that were actually enforced and not relying on self declaration, maybe some of those could be prevented.

pickledandpuzzled · 30/01/2024 21:46

People think they are great drivers- making the most of every opportunity and seeing how quickly they can arrive.

Unfortunately that makes them unpredictable, and leaves no room for other people to make mistakes- which is inevitable.

I think accidents are caused by people who think they are good drivers. The three people I know who present that way have been the most alarming journeys ever. One (pre mobile laws) got me to change gear so she could take a roundabout without putting down her phone. Another was weaving across the lanes as he looked for his other glasses. And my brother ‘knows the road really well’.

Noglitterallowed · 30/01/2024 21:46

We go to the hospital in a big city ao have to use the motorway and the amount of VERY near misses we’ve had due to lorry drivers is insane! They seem to think they own the road.
im not saying every one as im sure many are great but by far most of them that we have encountered think as they are bigger they can do what the hell they want and then obviously the impact is a lot greater.
we had one very near miss then right behind us we saw the same lorry absolutely wipe as several cars and it was horrific

GnomeDePlume · 30/01/2024 21:35

@2024GarlicCloves In the same program they talked about how your brain essentially discounts the area either side of something static such as the pillars on either side of the windscreen.

Moving your head stops the pillars from being static in your vision.

I like the quiz idea. It keeps you actually looking rather than just having your eyes pointed at something.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 30/01/2024 21:32

Also you aren't taught to drive on a motorway.

Frankly I find it absolutely infuriating that it should be the fastest route to use a motorway but you get stuck on them so often you have to factor an extra chunk of time to leave if you are going to use one.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 30/01/2024 21:31

Variations in people's speed. You have the nuggets in the inside doing 55mph and the show offs in the outside doing 90mph. It's hazardous to move between them.

Also lack Of braking distance. Cars drive so close to each other on motorways.

Lorries trying to overtake each other. It's so often lorries involved in motorway crashes.

2024GarlicCloves · 30/01/2024 21:13

GnomeDePlume · 30/01/2024 07:02

I think this is very significant.

On the radio I heard an RAF pilot talking about this. They have a saying move your head or you're dead.

Your brain interprets what the eyes see. If, as on a straight bit of motorway, nothing is changing your brain kind of switches off.

If you routinely move your head so that what your brain is having to interpret changes then your brain stays alert.

I like that move your head or you're dead!

I had an 'advanced' motorway lesson; the most useful thing - along with keeping safe distance, overtaking like a grown-up and taking account of conditions - was to run an ongoing quiz to myself about what the vehicles way up ahead are doing, speeders and lane-changers behind me, any minor landmarks and interesting details about other traffic or drivers.

The instructor could actually remember all this - he was able to replay the whole journey in his mind - but, for me, it's about observation & anticipation. Keeps your brain engaged with the task.

DdraigGoch · 30/01/2024 20:54

Such a pointless death again where the driver will no doubt serve 2 or 3 years then be back at the wheel to do it all again.

If you ever want to get away with murder, make it look like a road traffic "accident". Sentences are so poor, considering that the offence would be manslaughter if it didn't involve a car.

Trainstrike · 30/01/2024 20:36

Today's fatal M4 crash (I assume thats what you were talking about OP?) was near where an A road merges onto the M4. People like to drive 80+ on to that bit at rush hour; I imagine when that happened at 10pm-ish, the driver who was arrested for dangerous driving was probably speeding on to the M4/ on his phone etc.

Such a pointless death again where the driver will no doubt serve 2 or 3 years then be back at the wheel to do it all again.

Oakbeam · 30/01/2024 19:13

I'd say lane changes without looking are probably the main reason

Lane changes without signalling doesn’t help either.

macshoto · 30/01/2024 17:51

RichardMarxisinnocent · 30/01/2024 16:17

Include the mirrors even if you are not planning a manoeuvre, as then you know what's likely around you if you need to take emergency action.
Isn't this one of the most basic things you first learn when you're learning to drive? That you should be regularly checking your mirrors, it's not just something you do when about to manoeuvre. You should always be, aware of what's going on behind and to the sides of you as well as in front. Your post made it sound as if it's some new advice, and not something every driver should already be doing.

You're not wrong. The point I was making was more about the constant rotation of where you are looking.

I come across a lot of drivers who seem to rarely use their mirrors in day-do-day driving, unless possibly, they are planning a manoeuvre.

Justleaveitblankthen · 30/01/2024 17:48

mitogoshi · 30/01/2024 13:21

Oh and the number of people on phones is ridiculous, even watching a movie! I ride pillionon a motorcycle and you can see right in, if only I had a go pro on my helmet, I could be a plain clothes traffic cop!

You can get excellent quality almost 360° vision range cameras for your helmet.
The Police are always happy to receive footage if it assists in any way.

Oakbeam · 30/01/2024 17:41

jasflowers · 30/01/2024 08:11

Do they?

When did the UK last design a motorway? nothing to do with the topography of the land, avoiding steep hills or cuttings, which means even if we wanted too, its not feasible to build dead straight roads.

Driver error is as always, the number one cause of accidents, the higher speeds on m/ways means accidents, when they happen, are far more severe.

Edited

They always have, although the M1 is not a good example. When the first UK motorways were being designed in the 1950s, data from German autobahns constructed in the 1930s and 1940s was used.

Essentially, best practice is to create a succession of gentle curves. This is an excerpt from a UK highway design document from the 1990s…

To wonder why so many people crash on a straight stretch of motorway?
lieselotte · 30/01/2024 17:23

People also need to take more breaks and not try to do stupidly long unbroken journeys above their ability to concentrate

Yes this as well.

lieselotte · 30/01/2024 17:22

I'd say lane changes without looking are probably the main reason, as well as people going too fast. And looking at their phones/those ridiculous display units on the dashboards (why are they even allowed)?

We don't need a minimum speed limit, we need the 70 limit being properly enforced.

Swipe left for the next trending thread