Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to go to work tomorrow due to shitty email?

133 replies

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 18:53

I don't know if I'm overreacting here.

On Friday evening I worked past my hours to deal with what was a potentially challenging / contentious issue that had arisen that day. It caused me a lot of stress but no one else from my team was around to bounce anything off on Friday, so I dealt with it the best I could by myself. I then emailed the relevant colleagues on Friday evening who needed to know what had happened and how I'd dealt with it, so they'd be appraised of the situation.

I don't work Mondays but I logged in today just to see what I'm going into tomorrow. I'd had a reply from one of the senior members of the team (not my direct line manager but senior in the organisation) basically reprimanding me in what feels like a shitty way for one small aspect of how I dealt with the situation, ignoring the fact I worked past my hours to deal with the entire situation myself. She also hadn't commented on the issue itself really, she's just offered a criticism of one small aspect of how I dealt with it (which I also happen to disagree with her on). My main gripe is not that she disagrees with my approach as such, but that her reply was unnecessarily shitty and there was no thanks for dealing with the situation, and on top of that she "sent to all" instead of just me, so this now essentially feels like a public telling off via email as 5 other members of the team are copied in. I feel she could have more sensitively communicated her disagreement with the small aspect she has chosen to comment on, for example by just raising that part directly with me.

The upshot is I now feel anxious to go into work tomorrow because I am angry about the way she's handled it and don't particularly want to face her (she's not the most approachable person at the best of times), and also I just don't get paid enough to work past my hours on a Friday to give a shit about issues that might affect my team, to then receive basically no thanks and just criticism instead.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Flatulence · 29/01/2024 19:49

I really feel for you. It's shit being in that position on a Friday when everyone else has cleared off and you're left to to deal with an emerging issue. Well done for tackling it and not just walking away or panicking (as many would!).
I'd speak to your line manager about what's happened.
No one deserves a "shit-o-gram" when they've tried their best - even if things are far from perfect. If the person had such an issue with something they should pick it up with you or your manager directly - either by email or by phone.
I'd cool off overnight, and then have a chat tomorrow to your manager to explain how you feel. And how you feel is totally normal and justified.
These sorts of situations are always good learning opportunities: to learn (constructively, from your manager) how you could have handled things better, how to "pass the monkey up" even on a Friday afternoon (because you're not paid to deal with this sort of shit) but most importantly how not to raise issues with colleagues if you have an issue with their work. In the future, especially if you're in a more senior role, you'll remember this encounter and be a better boss/colleague as a result.

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:49

What annoys me more too is that it would've been obvious from the time stamp on my email on Friday evening that I was working past my hours when I updated everyone. That wasn't even acknowledged🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 29/01/2024 19:47

PinkflowersWhiteBerries · 29/01/2024 18:59

Actually I would go talk to my own manager and tell him/ her what you told us: that you worked late, alone , to deal with the situation; you did your best to put it to bed; you do not appreciate being called out in front of colleagues, but would appreciate her inout, and if needs be her support.

I agree 100%

KeepingKeepingOn · 29/01/2024 19:47

I HATE shitty emails with a burning passion and doubly so when other people are copied in. I have rarely respected anyone that’s done it and I strongly suspect those cc’d will feel the same way, so I wouldn’t worry about wider perceptions. If someone has an issue with how you’ve handled something, and other people need to know they’re picking it up, they can just say ‘thanks for sorting x; can we have a chat offline so we can think how we’d address this next time’. Job done.

key here is not to go back defensively or you’re ceding her power. Either acknowledge it professionally - ‘thanks for your note; it would be helpful to discuss your thoughts more offline’ - or ignore it. Don’t slip into apologies or justifications as she hasn’t earned them!

Toots22 · 29/01/2024 19:46

Hi - I feel your pain and could easily see this happening in my organisation - totally understand why you’re upset and angry and I would be too. I don’t know why people just can’t be kind and appreciative. The others have given great advice. Best piece of advice I’ve read recently and follow all the time with things like this is ‘Will this matter in 5 years?’ If the answer is ‘no’, I try and put it right out of my mind and not lose sleep over it. I know it’s not easy, but it helps a little. Big hug to you ❤️

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:46

And of course I could have done nothing and downed tools at the end of my working day. But I guarantee I'd have been far more heavily criticised for that than what I did, which was to make an attempt to resolve it before the weekend.

OP posts:
Lookingatthesunset · 29/01/2024 19:46

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:37

I will 100% be raising this with my line manager though, who is very supportive and approachable, so I'm sure she will help with addressing it.

Honestly, let your line manager handle it.

If you reply, you just give the auld bitch an opportunity to have another go at you and I wouldn't give her the pleasure.

I could dig out some deeply unpleasant email trails between me and our team manager. She has this habit of emailing something deeply passive aggressive, and if you reply, she makes a hue and cry about it and infers things you never said in the first place. Not just me either. I have learned to avoid. She's as thick as pigshit, promoted well beyond her level of capability. It's pointless.

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:44

@EveryoneEnviesMeEverywhere

Yes what I did was within my remit. Ideally, it requires a team response and some support, one person dealing with it is less than ideal. But nonetheless it's within my remit. I ended up staying later than my hours because it's a situation that could have done with a team effort, if that makes sense.

OP posts:
ANiceBigCupOfTea · 29/01/2024 19:42

Absolutely go in tomorrow, speak to your manager right away, show her the email and tell her how annoyed you are with the criticism, and the fact she sent it to everyone. Trust me all the other recipients won't be embarrassed for you, they'll just be thinking she's a massive dickhead for sending it.

Snowpatrolling · 29/01/2024 19:42

My response would be

”I’m sorry this wasn’t done to your satisfaction, next time a problem arises out of hours, I will know to forward the problem/complaint to direct to you to deal with, just to check your Number is xxxxxxxxxx so all queries can go straight to you?
many thanks

ChedderGorgeous · 29/01/2024 19:41

Here's what you do.
Open a word doc. Write a very passive aggressive reply.
Stare at it.
Delete it.
Don't reply.
Bring up that you felt demotivated with your manager in person tomorrow in a really professional and relaxed way.

EveryoneEnviesMeEverywhere · 29/01/2024 19:40

autienotnaughty · 29/01/2024 19:37

I'd be tempted to email back to all saying "Was this email intended for everyone to read or just me?"

NO - please dont' do as per my OP here - if you wish, good luck

Btw, some people are more sensitive than others - I'm sensitive but many are thick skinned as well as thick and IMO the cap fits on the person you OP are talking about

EveryoneEnviesMeEverywhere · 29/01/2024 19:39

Hi OP

Firstly, I feel for you
As importantly, please don't start flying emails off as once written/sent, cant be drawn and can get back up, no matter how right you are

Consult your line manager and hopefully they have more brain cells than that person who emailed you

What you need to cinsider

What you did, was it in your remit, if not, what is the recognised process/procedure? Are you an emergency service, I doubt it.

Assuming all of the above is good and what you did was in your remit/etc

Consider what outcome you want. You may want to rightly question why the jerk cc's the whole nation in it without talking to you/your manager/supv/etc

I'm sad to report that I worked ina vile/nasty environment for years but stayed there as it was local and flexible and gradually made like-minded friends and things came to a head. Thankfully, with the unions and equality behinds us, we got the senior moved. I suffered at times like you, made to feel as though I was walking on egg-shells - my work was being unnecessarily checked by those that had no reason etc - seniors were trying to push me around with others in our team - then i found out one day they were doing it to 2 other people - gradually we got to the right people to listen to us and built up a case againt the group of misfits

Be strong, you are entitled to your job as much as they are and like them you are part of a team. It is the managers job to listen, provide training/guidance and not allow the belittling of people and they email that was sent to several people need to be jusitifed.

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:37

PieAndLattes · 29/01/2024 19:25

Is there anything positive in the email? If so, focus on that and say, ‘Thank you, I’m so pleased to have been able to help, and yes, perhaps we all need a bit of extra training on procedures for xxx’.

Erm... the "Hi" before my name is the only positive I can pull out 😬

OP posts:
autienotnaughty · 29/01/2024 19:37

I'd be tempted to email back to all saying "Was this email intended for everyone to read or just me?"

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:37

I will 100% be raising this with my line manager though, who is very supportive and approachable, so I'm sure she will help with addressing it.

OP posts:
shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:35

manysausages · 29/01/2024 19:18

I don’t think I would even dignify it with a response. Unless she’s helping resolve the issue at hand, her comments are irrelevant.

If you absolutely have to reply, maybe you could just reply all asking if anyone else has any comments on the actual situation rather than some unhelpful feedback on your handling of the situation (that no one asked for)

“Ok, thanks for the feedback.

Does anyone have any suggestions/advice on how we move forward/close this topic?”

I did consider doing this but didn't want to come across as an arse 😂

OP posts:
Noshowlomo · 29/01/2024 19:35

Don’t reply to her email. My previous 2 bosses were like the one you describe.. one was my direct manager and then above was the OM. A pair of cows, threw their weight around no end. I would be so intimidated and anxious.
I left the job 2 years ago and my new job and boss are glorious but something I’ve learned in my time working is that the people who don’t put all the effort in, and generally don’t give a fuck what others think of them, and are confident are the ones who get away with it and don’t get these shitty emails. Bully bosses tend to go for the people pleasers, the ones who like you stay on, the ones like me who would go the extra mile. I wouldn’t do it for any one any more, and luckily now I don’t have to.
Speak to your line manager, tell her you’re not happily and completely demoralised after that email where you put that effort it, and you won’t be doing it again.

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:34

mynewusername2023 · 29/01/2024 19:24

Also, if you state you don't get paid enough to work extra, then please stop logging into your email on your day off.

Haha good point. My friend who I ranted to told me off for the same 😂

OP posts:
joelmillersbackpack · 29/01/2024 19:33

No good deed goes unpunished OP, I wouldn’t bother again if I were you. I’d be very clear about this and ask your manager for an out of hours escalation route as clearly it is inappropriate that you were left to deal with this alone outside of working hours. Fuckers.

shittyemail · 29/01/2024 19:32

MissersMercer · 29/01/2024 19:28

I kind of had the same, though the email was just to me. I emailed back saying it was 1 hour past the time I finish (we don't get overtime) and I was trying to get it done to leave the office as no one else able to do it and it needed doing. So will double check if I made the tiny, nonimportant error mentioned.

Edited

See in my case I didn't even make an error as such - different people and managers in the team have different opinions on which way to do this particular thing she commented on. Neither is right or wrong really - it's just a preference. And that's what she pulled me up on. And my colleague who I rang today to talk (rant) to agreed she would have done things my way had it been her on Friday dealing with the situation I dealt with. So that was reassuring.

OP posts:
moomoomoo27 · 29/01/2024 19:29

Nicole1111 · 29/01/2024 19:11

Oh I couldn’t help but send a catty reply. Something like
Thank you for your feedback. Just to clarify though, should a similar situation arise in the future where I am working out of hours, unpaid and alone, would you rather I contact you directly to check you’re happy with my response? If so do you have a work number that will be on at all hours or should I take your personal number?

I did the catty reply thing once when a manager sent an email to us saying that the cleaner was angry because we were putting things that were too heavy in the bins (the wastepaper bins by our desks, that were at most used for an end of a sandwich, a tissue, or a run out biro). I asked if we should weigh items before putting them in bins and if so what the acceptable weight range was.

I got in trouble but I'd do it again 😂

Lookingatthesunset · 29/01/2024 19:28

ToWorkOrNotToWork · 29/01/2024 19:11

I would not reply to her shitty email. I would forward it to your manager and say the nit-picking and public ticking off is very demotivating. Point out that your effort helped to avoid a worse outcome. Tell your manager that another time, you will walk out of the door bang on time regardless what crisis has arisen but you will in such an eventuality email/text your manager so they can pick up the issue out of hours if they wish to. Say you are not keen to expose yourself to criticism in front of the team when you try to go above and beyond. Let your manager know he’s welcome to pass your feedback on to the shitty senior colleague.

This is good advice.

Don't worry - senior manager has just shown up herself as a dick. Everyone probably knows that already too.

MissersMercer · 29/01/2024 19:28

I kind of had the same, though the email was just to me. I emailed back saying it was 1 hour past the time I finish (we don't get overtime) and I was trying to get it done to leave the office as no one else able to do it and it needed doing. So will double check if I made the tiny, nonimportant error mentioned.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 29/01/2024 19:26

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 29/01/2024 19:24

I'd struggle not to reply "Hi Janice, thanks for your kind and helpful feedback. I think you spelt thanks for staying late and picking up the pieces of our piss poor organisation, I am ever so grateful incorrectly. Yours - Never Working My Arse Off Like That Again.

😂 love this!