Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any teachers out there ?

68 replies

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 17:35

Can I refuse a scribe for my child?
He's got sen but a scribe isn't in any iep or support plan but they used one for a reading test today.
Surely they should have consulted with me before so I could decline to get a clearer understanding of where my child is compared to others his age!
I'm evidence gathering for an EHCP assessment application so I would like true abilities noted not falsified ones.

OP posts:
Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 20:06

@Aim92

Im sorry but that is simply not true.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 20:05

Aim92 · 29/01/2024 20:02

The thing is if he’s able the school will be doing everything they can to get him to pass the reading test next year. Laptops are probably allowed but would be a colossal waste of time in the end of Key Stage 2 Assessments. To echo posters above, the work on laptops is often of such poor quality it doesn’t reflect the child’s ability at all! Your best bet is probably allowing a scribe for tests (whilst continuing to collect your own evidence of course) and practising touch typing at home in preparation for using a laptop in secondary.

But he's not going to magically be up to speed with a laptop for secondary without using it in primary.
I've been advised by his ot it will take a minimum of two years to become able enough to keep up with his peers when using a typing aid.

OP posts:
Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 20:05

And who at the school are you talking too eg Senco, head, teacher...

Have you sent a strong email with medical evidence attached copying in governers.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 20:03

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 19:34

Op have you sought proper advice, told OT they are making him write, told rhe doctor etc?

It's absolutely barbaric.

A lap top is a medical aid, I assume lap top is easier for his fingers?

School have received lots of evidence and advice from medical professionals but won't budge unfortunately.

OP posts:
Aim92 · 29/01/2024 20:02

The thing is if he’s able the school will be doing everything they can to get him to pass the reading test next year. Laptops are probably allowed but would be a colossal waste of time in the end of Key Stage 2 Assessments. To echo posters above, the work on laptops is often of such poor quality it doesn’t reflect the child’s ability at all! Your best bet is probably allowing a scribe for tests (whilst continuing to collect your own evidence of course) and practising touch typing at home in preparation for using a laptop in secondary.

emmaempenadas · 29/01/2024 19:45

Ds has one. I would never refuse that, why would you?

boogaloola · 29/01/2024 19:44

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 29/01/2024 19:40

Not many of you have taught primary ICT have you?

A y5/y6 child that can write a page in an English lesson, generally can't manage more than a paragraph (badly punctuated because they can't find the correct punctuation mark) on a laptop in the same length of time.

It's a different skill though, isn't it? And if they have time to practice and learn then they'll get better.
The OPs child is never likely to be write more than a few words functionally. He needs to learn how to use tech that he will then continue to use throughout his life.

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 29/01/2024 19:40

Not many of you have taught primary ICT have you?

A y5/y6 child that can write a page in an English lesson, generally can't manage more than a paragraph (badly punctuated because they can't find the correct punctuation mark) on a laptop in the same length of time.

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 19:34

Op have you sought proper advice, told OT they are making him write, told rhe doctor etc?

It's absolutely barbaric.

A lap top is a medical aid, I assume lap top is easier for his fingers?

MrsHamlet · 29/01/2024 19:13

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 19:10

Clarpetal it's not that i have a problem with a scribe it's just that it's not an option (in schools opinion) at any other time but tests.
To me he should be tested in the same way he's expected to do in his lessons.

I have a number of students who have a scribe in assessments but we simply don't have the staff to scribe for 6 periods a day, every day.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 19:10

Clarpetal it's not that i have a problem with a scribe it's just that it's not an option (in schools opinion) at any other time but tests.
To me he should be tested in the same way he's expected to do in his lessons.

OP posts:
eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 19:07

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 19:00

@eatdrinkandbemerry

I'm gob smacked. I presume you have medical support for his fingers!.

We have regular occupational therapy but we have just been told there will never be improvement with the stability in his joints due to the sheer flexibility so we are really hoping to get some other method of writing well established.
He's a very bright child but this is really holding him back now.

OP posts:
clarepetal · 29/01/2024 19:06

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 18:57

Very messy and very slowly unfortunately.
He was being kept in at break and lunch to try complete more work but I had to stop that it's not his fault his fingers fail him.
This is why I'm having to put in for an EHCP assessment without school backing me.

I don't want to sound goady, but if you don't want him to lose his break and lunch to complete his work (which I do agree with) why are you then not happy for him to get a scribe?

MrsHamlet · 29/01/2024 19:06

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 18:57

Very messy and very slowly unfortunately.
He was being kept in at break and lunch to try complete more work but I had to stop that it's not his fault his fingers fail him.
This is why I'm having to put in for an EHCP assessment without school backing me.

Based on this I would say a scribe is the right thing. Typing fast and accurately is hard.

clarepetal · 29/01/2024 19:04

GreyhpundGirl · 29/01/2024 17:54

A scribe can only write down what the child says- absolutely verbatim, even if it's nonsense. I'm secondary and to have access arrangements in exams, there needs to be evidence of it being normal practice e. G in mocks. Technically you could refuse it but it wouldn't be in your child's interests.

This. I also work in secondary and scribe for kids often. It is there to help them as they need it, please don't refuse this!

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 19:00

@eatdrinkandbemerry

I'm gob smacked. I presume you have medical support for his fingers!.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 18:57

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 18:43

@eatdrinkandbemerry

OK, so how on earth does he write in normal lessons with joint issues etc?

Very messy and very slowly unfortunately.
He was being kept in at break and lunch to try complete more work but I had to stop that it's not his fault his fingers fail him.
This is why I'm having to put in for an EHCP assessment without school backing me.

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 29/01/2024 18:52

Dictation software can be more trouble than it's worth because it needs training to a voice. A scribe needs much less training.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 29/01/2024 18:49

I think it would be a good idea to get an assessment of his IT needs and capabilities. Depends on fine motor development and existing strength etc. There are so many AAC apps available, iPad or tablet better than laptop. He cgould use the mic or a scanner, tons of software. Very surprised that the school would turn this down. An SEN school are usually downpat with AAC technology as they use it all the time.

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 18:43

@eatdrinkandbemerry

OK, so how on earth does he write in normal lessons with joint issues etc?

Dismaljanuary · 29/01/2024 18:37

@Soontobe60@Soontobe60 and yet many secondary school schools not only let dc use them but some let all dc use them?

Writing tasks can be done on laptop

FrippEnos · 29/01/2024 18:30

spanieleyes · 29/01/2024 18:23

Indeed. Actually, laptops are worse for giving a false impression of ability unless you disable spell check and grammar functions. They are also impossible to use in all but straightforward writing lessons and very slow!

Not all pupils that used laptops are allowed to used the spelling and grammar functions. Unless it is part of their ECHP.

HollyGolightly4 · 29/01/2024 18:28

Soontobe60 · 29/01/2024 18:07

So has he been practicing at home? Using a scribe rather than typing out answers would be much more preferable in a test.

This is absolutely not true! Scribes are much rarer than laptop usage. Also, unless the child dictates every punctuation mark and letter by letter, spag must be disallowed. OP is quite right to expect school to be providing a laptop. They're effective when people can be bothered to use them correctly. It's also likely not to to be for every subject, more the essay ones

FrippEnos · 29/01/2024 18:28

@eatdrinkandbemerry

You have already stopped the issue with a laptop and most schools wouldn't now where to being with typing and would have to outsource it.
Having said that I believe that touch typing should be taught in schools.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 29/01/2024 18:28

Notgoodatpoetrybutgreatatlit · 29/01/2024 18:18

I second the post about ots and laptops. Most secondary students I work with struggle with laptops. Many can't resist the Internet which is tricky to disable because that is how you print.
Also creates an actual barrier between the child and the teacher. The exact opposite of what we want.
And OTs don't work everyday in classrooms so don't get how this translates.

I'd love for him not to have to use a laptop but his fingers are almost like jelly with unstable joints and missing all his last finger joints so its physically painful for him to write more than a couple of sentences.
My point being is nothing is written in his support plan he's just expected to keep trying with his pencil so even he was shocked that someone wrote for him today. He's year 5 and this has never happened before so I presume it's in preparation for his sats.
I'd rather they agree to meet halfway in all his normal lessons( the dictation software is something i will read up on ) because sats are not important to me his physical comfort is my priority.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread