Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:33

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:14

It is actually really hard to get awarded benefits in the UK today, those who really need them and who are struggling beyond what we can imagine (with illness or disability) have to spend hours proving that they really do need support. Do many of those sitting in the House of Lords, and even some in the House of Commons, deserve all that they are taking? I doubt it.

MP salaries are very low given the hours they spend working and the general responsibility of the job. They’re on £86,000.

And it depends what benefits but in many cases it isn’t that hard. You don’t even need to be made redundant to claim. The threshold of who ‘really needs them’ used to be people who were unemployed through no fault of their own - redundancy or severe disability. Now it’s people who don’t want to work because it ‘doesn’t fit in with the kids’ or because they’re depressed. It’s massively lowered, there are shades of need but if you try to argue this you just get called every name under the sun.

SpinyNorma · 30/01/2024 10:27

The economic benefit of having more people working and more children being born would far outstrip the short term cost of letting people pay for childcare out of their gross salary. But then we do have a very short termist government.

We also have a government that let's you write off the cost of a personal chauffeur against your tax bill as a work expense but not the cost of childcare in work hours. So there you go.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:24

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 10:23

To be fair those on UC would lose out a lot too in that situation due to the savings limit.

Yep, which is another perverse incentive. People don't seem to realise just how many of those we've managed to sprinkle throughout our tax and benefits systems.

Justfinking · 30/01/2024 10:24

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:52

Everyone isn't on benefits.
Almost everyone benefits from things which taxation funds.
Some folk who receive certain benefits also pay tax on their income.

If you're paying tax on your benefit, it's not your income. And there's plenty out there who take more than they give. Also what I'm saying is if everyone takes, soon there won't be anyone to give.

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 10:23

Charlie2121 · 30/01/2024 09:58

You need to incentivise those who can help to continue doing so.

As I explained in a previous post I once received a £20k bonus and kept not a single penny of it due to the tax and childcare rules. Are people faced with that situation just supposed to suck it up and say nothing for the greater good?

How many people whether they be higher or lower earners would be happy to have an effective marginal tax rate of 100% or more?

To be fair those on UC would lose out a lot too in that situation due to the savings limit.

Tiredandgrumpykids · 30/01/2024 10:22

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:08

What 'policy' - what I describe is a caring society, not a policy.
Wouldn't anyone who was comfortable want some of their comfort to also be passed on to someone in need?

But there is a limit. How much tax should someone earning more than £100k pay? Because if you have 2 kids in nursery in London, anything you earn between £100k and £130-ish k is being taxed as OVER 100%. You have to pay money to ‘earn’ more. What op is saying is that she doesn’t think that is fair. She is correct of course!

sbhydrogen · 30/01/2024 10:21

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

OP - are you in the 60% tax trap income threshold?

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:18

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:16

I wasn't referring to incentives to work, I was referring to incentives such as as those which the OP thinks she deserves!

The OPs situation is also one of incentives, though. If a person is going to lose access to a benefit or service by working more, such as 30 free nursery hours, that's a potential incentive to work less.

afkonholidaynearleek · 30/01/2024 10:18

Just contribute more to your pension to get your taxable income to below £100k. If you earn more than £140k in a financial year it'll be more tricky because of the maximum pension contribution limit.

NRFT but it's also £100k limit per parent, so you could have a household income of £198k (that's £99k total taxable per parent) and get your 30 free hours per child and tax-free childcare.

fonfusedm · 30/01/2024 10:17

I just wonder if people realise how good they have it on these salaries like the OP's. Many can only dream of having that kind of annual salary.

there’s no nuance to this though. I don’t earn 100k but anyone wanting to buy my first flat would need to earn more than that to afford it & my childcare was cheaper. I don’t begrudge my neighbours who are much higher earners than me (GP & teacher) getting CB or free hours as they likely have a much bigger mortgage than me.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:16

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:14

Yes, people often need incentives to work, other than pure altruism. It's therefore a good idea to design tax systems with this in mind, regardless of whether one wishes it wasn't necessary.

I wasn't referring to incentives to work, I was referring to incentives such as as those which the OP thinks she deserves!

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:14

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:09

Only if the person was deserving and genuinely trying to help themselves. I will now run for cover!

It is actually really hard to get awarded benefits in the UK today, those who really need them and who are struggling beyond what we can imagine (with illness or disability) have to spend hours proving that they really do need support. Do many of those sitting in the House of Lords, and even some in the House of Commons, deserve all that they are taking? I doubt it.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:14

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:11

Yep, and it would seem they need incentives to actually care about those less fortunate. Sigh.

Yes, people often need incentives to work, other than pure altruism. It's therefore a good idea to design tax systems with this in mind, regardless of whether one wishes it wasn't necessary.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:11

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 10:09

It wasn't a dig at you @Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter it was the poster you responded to. I just wonder if people realise how good they have it on these salaries like the OP's. Many can only dream of having that kind of annual salary.

Yep, and it would seem they need incentives to actually care about those less fortunate. Sigh.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:09

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:08

What 'policy' - what I describe is a caring society, not a policy.
Wouldn't anyone who was comfortable want some of their comfort to also be passed on to someone in need?

Only if the person was deserving and genuinely trying to help themselves. I will now run for cover!

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 10:09

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 10:00

No let's bring back the workhouses and make sure people who are poor suffer for being absolutely inadequate.

It wasn't a dig at you @Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter it was the poster you responded to. I just wonder if people realise how good they have it on these salaries like the OP's. Many can only dream of having that kind of annual salary.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:09

Charlie2121 · 30/01/2024 09:58

You need to incentivise those who can help to continue doing so.

As I explained in a previous post I once received a £20k bonus and kept not a single penny of it due to the tax and childcare rules. Are people faced with that situation just supposed to suck it up and say nothing for the greater good?

How many people whether they be higher or lower earners would be happy to have an effective marginal tax rate of 100% or more?

We actually need to incentivise people to care about those in society who are less fortunate than them?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:08

Tiredandgrumpykids · 30/01/2024 09:59

And due to this policy the government will have LESS money to spend on those who need it! If you have t understood this yet look at scrunchmum’s excellent explanation above.

What 'policy' - what I describe is a caring society, not a policy.
Wouldn't anyone who was comfortable want some of their comfort to also be passed on to someone in need?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:06

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 10:00

No let's bring back the workhouses and make sure people who are poor suffer for being absolutely inadequate.

I am not sure the point of your reply, tbh.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:01

Charlie2121 · 30/01/2024 09:58

You need to incentivise those who can help to continue doing so.

As I explained in a previous post I once received a £20k bonus and kept not a single penny of it due to the tax and childcare rules. Are people faced with that situation just supposed to suck it up and say nothing for the greater good?

How many people whether they be higher or lower earners would be happy to have an effective marginal tax rate of 100% or more?

Yep.

People respond to financial incentives rather than other peoples moral takes. This is as true for someone on six figures as it is for someone reliant on top up benefits. Disincentives to work when a person otherwise would are bad for all of us, whether the person concerned happens to he somebody one sympathises with or not.

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 10:00

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:54

Are you familiar with the concept of a society where those with the most help those most in need?

No let's bring back the workhouses and make sure people who are poor suffer for being absolutely inadequate.

Tiredandgrumpykids · 30/01/2024 09:59

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:54

Are you familiar with the concept of a society where those with the most help those most in need?

And due to this policy the government will have LESS money to spend on those who need it! If you have t understood this yet look at scrunchmum’s excellent explanation above.

Charlie2121 · 30/01/2024 09:58

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:54

Are you familiar with the concept of a society where those with the most help those most in need?

You need to incentivise those who can help to continue doing so.

As I explained in a previous post I once received a £20k bonus and kept not a single penny of it due to the tax and childcare rules. Are people faced with that situation just supposed to suck it up and say nothing for the greater good?

How many people whether they be higher or lower earners would be happy to have an effective marginal tax rate of 100% or more?

Vettrianofan · 30/01/2024 09:58

"The system is massively reliant on a relatively small number of people funding everyone else."

Good. As it should be. There has to be a downside of aiming high🤷🏻 if you're smart enough and have the resources to succeed in life, it has to be balanced out somehow for the rest in society.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:54

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2024 08:53

Because it's not fair the high earners are paying the most tax, paying out but don't see any benefits for themselves.

Are you familiar with the concept of a society where those with the most help those most in need?