Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
jannier · 30/01/2024 11:16

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:40

@Willyoujustbequiet why are households with a joint income of ~£200k eligible while one with an income of £101k is technically eligible for nothing?

That doesn’t seem to be targeting those who ‘need it most’ either.

No the threshold needs to be reduced to £100k per household.

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:13

Natsku · 29/01/2024 14:02

Childcare/early childhood education should be affordable for every family, whatever their income level. In my country you pay on a sliding scale according to how much you earn so everyone can afford it, which is the best way (in my opinion) to do it. No one should be unable to work because they can't afford childcare, that puts women especially in a difficult position, forcing them to be financially reliant on their partner unless they have a high enough paying job.

People on £100k can afford childcare they choose to have more luxuries that doesn't mean you can't afford childcare just they prioritise differently then moan. There are lots of low income families that can't afford food....nurses for example. That needs addressing

SpinyNorma · 30/01/2024 11:12

jannier · 30/01/2024 10:44

I struggle with the concept that £100k isn't rich.

Rich and high earning are distinct and the disconnect between the two has become very stark.

You only need to earn around £180,000 to be in the top 1% of earners in the UK. But you would need more like £5 million in the bank to be in the top 1% richest. And you couldn't even get close to buying a top 1% by price home in the UK on a top 1% salary.

You can be comfortable on a good earnings but rich people don't get rich on salaries anymore.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 11:11

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 11:06

I was presuming that at half the remaining number of that 10 would be on UC especially as even nurses or other professionals claim it. Go on though. Carry on with the work shy narrative.

The government do actually publish those statistics - numbers in work, numbers who have to look for work, numbers who have no requirement to look for work. What exactly constitutes work shy is obviously a matter of opinions, but the raw data is publicized.

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:10

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:31

Interesting.

Why do you agree it should be capped at £100k, given you will need to earn more than £100k just to fund the nursery bill?

Should there not be some help for parents of multiples?

Yes there should be help for multiple births for lower income families...my son has twins they can't afford for mum to work full time as her pay is less he's the main earner on £54k she works evenings and weekends while he does childcare. They have a mortgage nice car and holidays why should people earning more then twice his earnings need help....better house more holidays?

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 11:06

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 10:54

@WithACatLikeTread

You seem to have a bit of a reading comprehension problem.

3.5M UC that do not work at all

1 in 10 = 35M working population

Logically, the total amount of UC not working relative to working is 3.5 / 3.5+x

With x < 3.5

I was presuming that at half the remaining number of that 10 would be on UC especially as even nurses or other professionals claim it. Go on though. Carry on with the work shy narrative.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 10:59

I have no issue with there being a cut off, but I do think it (and child benefit) should be based on household rather than individual income. Makes it extremely unfair.
Besides, a quick Google tells me only 4% earn over £100k, and of course only a fraction of those people would have toddlers. It seems staggeringly unlikely that it is worth the admin costs to means test childcare provisions.

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 10:59

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:55

Why are people making assumptions that extending the free 30 hours would be a net cost? You'd need to know not only how much it costs to administer the system but also how much is being lost by people adjusting their income, and what the longer term impacts of that are too. Sounds like a lot of guesswork being done.

Yep - childcare / early years education is an investment

Londonscallingme · 30/01/2024 10:56

I earn more than 100k so obviously I’d rather it was universal but as a general principle I’m not a fan of universal benefits so I don’t get wound up about it. I do think the mechanism to means test it is pretty poor. Both parents can earn 99k each but if one earns more than 100k you lose the entitlement. That’s a bit shit but I understand why it works like that since 100k already exists as a trigger for other stuff.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:55

Why are people making assumptions that extending the free 30 hours would be a net cost? You'd need to know not only how much it costs to administer the system but also how much is being lost by people adjusting their income, and what the longer term impacts of that are too. Sounds like a lot of guesswork being done.

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 10:54

@WithACatLikeTread

You seem to have a bit of a reading comprehension problem.

3.5M UC that do not work at all

1 in 10 = 35M working population

Logically, the total amount of UC not working relative to working is 3.5 / 3.5+x

With x < 3.5

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:53

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 10:48

Didn't you say most people on UC don't work? Seems like most do then.

🤦🏼‍♀️ read it again

jannier · 30/01/2024 10:53

As the government can not afford to pay a reasonable rate for the policy it's currently struggling to fund which areas should be cut to fund additional childcare? Health, education, care of the elderly, policing, defense, etc. Which of these do you feel is ilu necessary or over funded?

NeedToChangeName · 30/01/2024 10:51

fonfusedm · 29/01/2024 12:34

Should be universal, why not?

@fonfusedm Would be nice if the country could afford to offer universal childcare, but it won't happen unless / until we raise taxes to pay for it. There isn't a magic money tree

I think we need a wealth tax, at a low rate only payable on huge assets. So, would be easily affordable for those liable and would raise £££. But Rishi and his pals would probably just siphon their asset off into overseas tax dodges to get round it

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:50

You can actually be working and earning quite a lot whilst still being entitled to some UC. You just need very high rent and childcare costs. There are 40% taxpayers who are on UC, albeit not that many of them.

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 10:48

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:40

3.5 million people claim UC and do not work at all. That’s 1 in 10 people of working age. That’s very high.

Didn't you say most people on UC don't work? Seems like most do then.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:45

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:39

Right, well as long as it's seen in the same light as those on lower incomes who choose not to work because there's no incentive due to appallingly low wages?
Oh, you don't think that's the same at all? Thought not.

I think the principle is exactly the same, yes, and have given multiple examples of where it also applies to lower earners in this thread. Over the last couple of pages, in fact.

You know what they say about assumptions...

jannier · 30/01/2024 10:44

howaboutapartysong · 29/01/2024 12:04

Earning 100k means you get taxed on every single thing despite not being 'rich'

I struggle with the concept that £100k isn't rich.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:43

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:41

Ah right, we've entered unabashed benefit bashing territory, that was inevitable i suppose.

To coin your phrase, ‘that isn’t an argument’. I stated a fact, am I wrong?

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:42

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:40

Again, it is actually quite hard to get benefits.

Not really. The only requirements are that you live in the U.K., are of working age, but are not working, and have less than 16k in savings.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:41

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:40

3.5 million people claim UC and do not work at all. That’s 1 in 10 people of working age. That’s very high.

Ah right, we've entered unabashed benefit bashing territory, that was inevitable i suppose.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:40

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:33

MP salaries are very low given the hours they spend working and the general responsibility of the job. They’re on £86,000.

And it depends what benefits but in many cases it isn’t that hard. You don’t even need to be made redundant to claim. The threshold of who ‘really needs them’ used to be people who were unemployed through no fault of their own - redundancy or severe disability. Now it’s people who don’t want to work because it ‘doesn’t fit in with the kids’ or because they’re depressed. It’s massively lowered, there are shades of need but if you try to argue this you just get called every name under the sun.

Again, it is actually quite hard to get benefits.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 10:40

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 09:52

Everyone isn't on benefits.
Almost everyone benefits from things which taxation funds.
Some folk who receive certain benefits also pay tax on their income.

3.5 million people claim UC and do not work at all. That’s 1 in 10 people of working age. That’s very high.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:40

Tiredandgrumpykids · 30/01/2024 10:22

But there is a limit. How much tax should someone earning more than £100k pay? Because if you have 2 kids in nursery in London, anything you earn between £100k and £130-ish k is being taxed as OVER 100%. You have to pay money to ‘earn’ more. What op is saying is that she doesn’t think that is fair. She is correct of course!

Lots of things aren't fair though, that isn't an argument.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:39

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 10:18

The OPs situation is also one of incentives, though. If a person is going to lose access to a benefit or service by working more, such as 30 free nursery hours, that's a potential incentive to work less.

Right, well as long as it's seen in the same light as those on lower incomes who choose not to work because there's no incentive due to appallingly low wages?
Oh, you don't think that's the same at all? Thought not.