Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
fonfusedm · 30/01/2024 12:51

We need a wealth tax as paye tax is disproportionate & housing is a huge issue

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 12:12

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 11:59

Just one problem with that hypothesis @Tiredandgrumpykids. A house is an illiquid asset, you can’t spend it or pay tax out of it. Of course an £800k house is taxed when you die. Most of those high earners are also living in expensive houses so in your world they’d be taxed on those assets.

A household income of £100K isn't buying a house worth £800k though are they? Not without a couple of decades of equity behind them.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 12:06

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 12:04

@Tiredandgrumpykids

You are correct. Property should be taxed at much highe rates.

Oh, and ignore blossomtoes. She is ageist against young people through and through and provides no real value to these discussions.

So you think property should be taxed at higher rates but only if it belongs to people over working age? And you call me ageist! 😂

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 12:04

@Tiredandgrumpykids

You are correct. Property should be taxed at much highe rates.

Oh, and ignore blossomtoes. She is ageist against young people through and through and provides no real value to these discussions.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 12:03

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:36

The answers are obvious then. Give up your high earning job and do one that benefits society, claim the benefits lose the holidays, house and luxury and feel better as you're being treated fairly.

Why are you assuming that a £100k job doesn't benefit society? Or that a lower paying one would? You've got an almighty chip on your shoulder.

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 12:00

@Araminta1003

Its posts like the one you quoted which makes me conclude the UK is in terminal decline when you have over 50% of people dependent on the state.

The lack of education and the profound inability to understand how the country works in a global world leads to mentalities like that one.

Its easy to "vote yourself other peoples money" until you run out of money.

And thats the UK today. It has run out of money.

They seem unable to understand that the UK has lived way beyond its means for the last 20 years and that bill has now come due. The UK is not a "wealthy" country anymore. It has a very small slice of very rich people (who pay some taxes), a small slice of professionals (who pay the bulk of the taxes), and a huge amount of poorer people in the middle (who pay little tax and receive more in benefits).

So what will happen is that they will get a lot poorer in real terms because they have limited options. The wealthier people with options will leave, retire, or work less, further making the lower earners poorer in real terms.

Thats what I see over the next five years or so.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 11:59

Just one problem with that hypothesis @Tiredandgrumpykids. A house is an illiquid asset, you can’t spend it or pay tax out of it. Of course an £800k house is taxed when you die. Most of those high earners are also living in expensive houses so in your world they’d be taxed on those assets.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 11:53

Araminta1003 · 30/01/2024 11:41

People are so blind. The Tories have taxed the middle earners and bedrock of society through the roof because they want the Uber elite and serfs at the bottom. That is their model.

By no stretch of the imagination are those on £100k+ middle earners. The average salary is £35k and those on six figure salaries are in the top 4%. They may not be members of the uber elite but they’re not so far off.

Tiredandgrumpykids · 30/01/2024 11:51

jannier · 30/01/2024 10:44

I struggle with the concept that £100k isn't rich.

‘Rich’ doesn’t depend on your earnings these days, but your assets. A pensioner on £25k a year in a house they have paid the mortgage off on which has inflated massively and is now worth £800k is far, far richer than a couple renting with 2 kids in nursery in a similar area, one on £101k, one on £40k. Post tax earnings of the couple = £6.5k, nursery takes £3k of that, rent takes £2k, Council tax, bills, food, swimming lessons. Not a lot left.

Yes the earners are possibly wealthier than 2 x people earning £40k, but it’s the people with no housing costs that are actually ‘rich’. We need to start taxing wealth more and income less.

bluetongue · 30/01/2024 11:50

Wakeywake · 29/01/2024 13:03

I agree with you. In fact I think childcare should be fully tax deductible as it's essential for enabling people to work, regardless of how much you earn. For full disclosure, I've not got any skin in the game, mine are teenagers.

Public transport is essential for me to get to work and it’s not tax deductible.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 11:45

Even more obvious than doing anything as drastic as career changing or emigrating, is just working a bit less.

Araminta1003 · 30/01/2024 11:41

People are so blind. The Tories have taxed the middle earners and bedrock of society through the roof because they want the Uber elite and serfs at the bottom. That is their model.

Araminta1003 · 30/01/2024 11:39

“The answers are obvious then. Give up your high earning job and do one that benefits society, claim the benefits lose the holidays, house and luxury and feel better as you're being treated fairly.”

NAH I think better to go and live in another country if you are skilled where they have a functioning health and education system and you as a family are valued, rather than blamed/envied. Because Governments in other countries know your value and those of your children.

It is these thresholds that have lowered productivity nothing else.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 11:37

whatkatydid2014 · 30/01/2024 11:24

This.

We are on a different cliff edge (both earned under £50k pre kids, both on over £50k now). Our approach has been to up pension contributions & take parental leave unpaid in school holidays.

By doing that we have kept child benefit. Basically we currently have a household income of just under £80k after tax with child benefit. One of us could put less into pension and have taxable income of £60k. If we did then we’d get around an extra £3.7k/year, half of which would likely be spent on holiday clubs for the kids. We’d lose £5k going into our pension & the time off in the summer. We figure we are better off for a few years at least just shoving money into our pensions. We also have considered that we might eventually have one or both of us drop down to 4 days a week and stop making the extra pension contributions. I’m sure people on all the other thresholds do similar things.

I think when you see you’ll get less than half of a bonus or payrise to take home it does make you think about whether it’s worth it or if it’s better to do something else.

In the case of the 20k bonus mentioned up thread I’d probably be looking at whether I could donate the money and adjust my taxable income on that basis (guessing it wouldn’t work putting it in a pension with the thresholds but maybe it would depending on usual contributions)

We do the same wrt child benefit, albeit it's only one of us earning over 50k. Unpaid parental leave in the holidays, thus resulting in less money going into the Exchequer. The next step will be dropping either a half or full day. It's just not worth the extra effort at this point.

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:36

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2024 08:53

Because it's not fair the high earners are paying the most tax, paying out but don't see any benefits for themselves.

The answers are obvious then. Give up your high earning job and do one that benefits society, claim the benefits lose the holidays, house and luxury and feel better as you're being treated fairly.

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:32

mydogwantsabone · 30/01/2024 07:14

It penalises wives of high earners getting back to work. My husband earns well over £100k. His CEO isn't remotely interested in part time working. We as a family need to prioritise his career because he out earns me by several multiples, therefore I need to do the pick ups, drop offs, and the judgement of whether it's financially worth it for me to work is made against the cost of childcare against my salary.

Why is it you making the decision against your salary against you both making the decision against your joint incomes? Are the children not his? Does he not think he should be using his salary because his little woman wants a hobby? As a family you have lots of money make the decision as a family. Most people don't have the luxury of making this decision even with supported childcare they struggle to pay their share and live hanging on with their nails until full time school.

WillowBarkTree · 30/01/2024 11:30

@110APiccadilly agreed. The 100k threshold is more based on an outdated view that someone earning this amount or over, will almost certainly be man, the wife would normally be a SAHP and therefore does not need as much “free” childcare.

Naptrappedmummy · 30/01/2024 11:30

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:13

People on £100k can afford childcare they choose to have more luxuries that doesn't mean you can't afford childcare just they prioritise differently then moan. There are lots of low income families that can't afford food....nurses for example. That needs addressing

Do you know how much housing costs in places like London, Bristol, Oxford? And childcare? As in, do you actually?

Charlie2121 · 30/01/2024 11:30

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 30/01/2024 10:39

Right, well as long as it's seen in the same light as those on lower incomes who choose not to work because there's no incentive due to appallingly low wages?
Oh, you don't think that's the same at all? Thought not.

Those people are not net contributors so they are choosing to make others subsidise them if they turn down work.

Higher earners already pay their own way and subsidise others. All they are doing is choosing to reduce the money they give to others.

110APiccadilly · 30/01/2024 11:28

pessaryforthepressurey · 29/01/2024 12:26

It's ideological. So that the one that is not highly paid stays home. And that is usually the woman.

It's not accidental. They haven't made these rules and thought "whoopsie!"

It's to reinforce "traditional conservative family values" and to get votes from the "traditional family values" cohort.

It's sexist. Not very well disguised.

If this were true, couples with a single income wouldn't be hammered in the tax system (which they are).

whatkatydid2014 · 30/01/2024 11:24

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 07:02

Yes, they should be universal. We need to keep higher earners feeling they have a stake, and our terrible public services won't suffice. Plus we also need to prioritise a tax system that minimises cliff edges, bottlenecks and perverse incentives not to work more, especially with our current worker shortage. That applies at all points on the income spectrum.

This.

We are on a different cliff edge (both earned under £50k pre kids, both on over £50k now). Our approach has been to up pension contributions & take parental leave unpaid in school holidays.

By doing that we have kept child benefit. Basically we currently have a household income of just under £80k after tax with child benefit. One of us could put less into pension and have taxable income of £60k. If we did then we’d get around an extra £3.7k/year, half of which would likely be spent on holiday clubs for the kids. We’d lose £5k going into our pension & the time off in the summer. We figure we are better off for a few years at least just shoving money into our pensions. We also have considered that we might eventually have one or both of us drop down to 4 days a week and stop making the extra pension contributions. I’m sure people on all the other thresholds do similar things.

I think when you see you’ll get less than half of a bonus or payrise to take home it does make you think about whether it’s worth it or if it’s better to do something else.

In the case of the 20k bonus mentioned up thread I’d probably be looking at whether I could donate the money and adjust my taxable income on that basis (guessing it wouldn’t work putting it in a pension with the thresholds but maybe it would depending on usual contributions)

TheSeasonalNameChange · 30/01/2024 11:24

There was a really heartbreaking story on here a while back where someone was a single mum on just under 100k and worried about her and her kids becoming homeless if she tipped over or got the calculation slightly wrong because she'd lose so much she wouldn't be able to pay the mortgage and benefits wouldn't cover it either. This really is hitting vulnerable people.

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:21

Wahawa · 29/01/2024 15:48

Also OP we are exploring the option of moving to other countries in middle east where there are no taxes and much better quality of life for your money. if your industry allows then you should explore that option too. Some of our friends have moved and they totally love it. No point just paying higher taxes here to be treated unfairly just because you are hardworking and well qualified to be able to earn that sort of money here. This country rewards mediocrity and laziness!

Look at where you stand if you become ill and can no longer work my friend had a stroke and he couldn't continue work they all came home.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 11:19

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:17

But high earners pay less VAT and have more savings and pensions.

How do they pay less VAT?

jannier · 30/01/2024 11:17

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:58

@Viviennemary

The lower earner is paying in £x in tax and extracting £y in benefits.

With y >>>> x

They are not subsidising anything. You dont understand that higher earners do not get a subsidy. They pay the full price from post tax income AND they pay large amounts of tax.

There is so much entitlement in the UK it is astonishing.

But high earners pay less VAT and have more savings and pensions.