Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:08

jannier · 30/01/2024 20:50

But you decided to have 3 kids and pay the £35k plenty have 3 kids on a half or less than this so even with getting paid childcare are on less than you £60k is an enormous amount of money after childcare.

I wasn't I complaining. I was just explaining to you how much it costs and how I don't care whether or not you think we deserve subsidised childcare. We will claim it as long as we can, we will stick as much in pensions as we need to and will not feel an ounce of guilt.

jannier · 30/01/2024 20:50

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 18:57

We've got 3 kids, nursery x2 and wraparound x1 would cost us about £35k per year. Given we also pay a truly vast amount of tax, I genuinely don't feel bad about getting some of it back in childcare temporarily. Fortunately DH is "only" on £95k for now, so we do get some help still.

But you decided to have 3 kids and pay the £35k plenty have 3 kids on a half or less than this so even with getting paid childcare are on less than you £60k is an enormous amount of money after childcare.

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2024 20:21

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 20:17

@SouthLondonMum22

I'm not telling them that, I know of people who have come to that conclusion themselves and would prefer to work as the numbers don't add up.

It seems to be a common conclusion, it is very short sighted. Especially if the husband is earning £100k+ and childcare isn't considered an expense from the mothers lower salary.

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 20:17

@SouthLondonMum22

I'm not telling them that, I know of people who have come to that conclusion themselves and would prefer to work as the numbers don't add up.

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2024 20:12

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 30/01/2024 19:28

Your last paragraphs are key. People on this thread saying “if you earn over £100k then you earn enough to pay childcare” are perhaps forgetting the common situation where it’s the partner earning over £100k and the primary caregiver earning nothing because it’s not worthwhile to do so. They take career breaks and sometimes struggle to get back into work. What happens when a couple in this situation split up compared to a couple earning £60+k each who have been able to have massively reduced childcare in comparison? The opportunities are not fair for primary caregivers in this situation and it is bad for the economy. It’s very myopic to think “£100k! You can’t complain”.

I think we need to stop telling women who are usually the lower earners that it isn't 'worth it' to continue their careers because that is exactly why it is worth it long term to stay in work.

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 20:07

@CouldIBeAnymoreOuting

This is so true, especially for unmarried women this could be a huge problem eg not contributing to their own pension.

Again bad for society - we have a pensions crisis on the horizon!

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 30/01/2024 19:28

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 14:43

It's really not all about who we support and don't though. It's much bigger than that and basic economics at thatS

If someone earns just over £100k they are putting money into pensions etc to circumvent it, or cutting hours = less tax take.

If one of a couple earns over £100k and the other earns £30k (probably the woman) then the woman ends up giving up work. Again less tax take.

We have a workforce crisis in this country especially since covid where lots of people retired early. Tphe government are trying to get newly retired people back into work for example. This is a whole group of people who aren't working as it's not worthwhile for them to do so. It's nonsensical.

Your last paragraphs are key. People on this thread saying “if you earn over £100k then you earn enough to pay childcare” are perhaps forgetting the common situation where it’s the partner earning over £100k and the primary caregiver earning nothing because it’s not worthwhile to do so. They take career breaks and sometimes struggle to get back into work. What happens when a couple in this situation split up compared to a couple earning £60+k each who have been able to have massively reduced childcare in comparison? The opportunities are not fair for primary caregivers in this situation and it is bad for the economy. It’s very myopic to think “£100k! You can’t complain”.

DrCoconut · 30/01/2024 19:21

The allowance my employer pays me for essential work travel is "an expense that allows me to work" too. Universal credit still take money off me for getting it though even though it is not really income as I am claiming back money already spent that is not discretionary spending (my employer might have something to say if I don't turn up for work). My better off colleagues get to benefit fully from their allowance. I'm also seeing lone parent students losing UC money due to being awarded a bursary for equipment for their course. The money is for equipment, it's not "income" either. It's shit being able to do nothing but pass them tissues and send them for a foodbank referral. I think things like this where people trying to better their situation are harshly penalised need addressing before universal childcare for the better off. In an ideal word you may be right but for now it's less of a priority, at least from where I'm standing. I'm not planning to remain on UC for life so I have minimum skin in the game here, I just think the government treats the less well off appallingly.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 18:57

jannier · 30/01/2024 18:47

No but £100k is a big salary if you don't want to pay all of your childcare bill because of some strange sense of fairness give it up do an equally well valued poorer paid job that took as much time to qualify for and claim the benefit then you will feel better.

We've got 3 kids, nursery x2 and wraparound x1 would cost us about £35k per year. Given we also pay a truly vast amount of tax, I genuinely don't feel bad about getting some of it back in childcare temporarily. Fortunately DH is "only" on £95k for now, so we do get some help still.

Kpo58 · 30/01/2024 18:47

It shows how broken our housing market has gotten if a couple on 100k can't buy a 4 bed house in much of the country.

jannier · 30/01/2024 18:47

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 12:03

Why are you assuming that a £100k job doesn't benefit society? Or that a lower paying one would? You've got an almighty chip on your shoulder.

No but £100k is a big salary if you don't want to pay all of your childcare bill because of some strange sense of fairness give it up do an equally well valued poorer paid job that took as much time to qualify for and claim the benefit then you will feel better.

jannier · 30/01/2024 18:43

Nursery772 · 30/01/2024 16:04

@jannier if it was a household cap of £100k, a couple earning £50k each might be spending 2/3 of their joint income on childcare costs and not be eligible for help.

£100k is a lot of money you can have a comfortable life on that with holidays ....maybe not a 4 bed house or several holidays but a reasonable 3 bed I'm most areas and a holiday I would rather put more into the NHS then help people have more holidays, cars etc.

jannier · 30/01/2024 18:34

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 30/01/2024 14:06

Ok but if 100% of your pay goes on childcare then it doesn’t matter how but your mortgage is you can’t afford it and you too will be making decisions about how to feed your children.

No you brought an expensive house downsize. Many can't afford a mortgage and pay exorbitant rent, do 40 hour weeks and can't eat or heat

110APiccadilly · 30/01/2024 18:14

lieselotte · 30/01/2024 14:30

In my view childcare should be tax deductible - regardless of income level. Childcare means you can work and be economically active and is a cost of working. If you earn well you pay lots of tax, not just income tax but other taxes.

If it all goes on childcare costs, you don't contribute to the economy in the same way.

I tend to agree with this - but then, if we're going to allow expenses related to working to be tax deductible, why not commuting?

Nursery772 · 30/01/2024 16:04

@jannier if it was a household cap of £100k, a couple earning £50k each might be spending 2/3 of their joint income on childcare costs and not be eligible for help.

OP posts:
lieselotte · 30/01/2024 14:30

In my view childcare should be tax deductible - regardless of income level. Childcare means you can work and be economically active and is a cost of working. If you earn well you pay lots of tax, not just income tax but other taxes.

If it all goes on childcare costs, you don't contribute to the economy in the same way.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 30/01/2024 14:22

IsGoodIsDon · 30/01/2024 14:16

My OH is a higher earner so we don’t qualify for any childcare help. I am a nurse but chose to quit my job as it wasn’t worth the childcare costs and headaches with my shifts. Maybe if we had a bit more help to pay childcare costs I would have continued with nursing that I loved but my income just wasn’t worth it.
I still do a bit of nursing to keep my registration but now I’ve left it I’ll never go back to a permanent role again. And they wonder why they don’t have any nurses!

Essentially yes.

People allow themselves to be distracted by whether they find you personally sympathetic or not, meanwhile we've designed a system that discourages you from using skills that they very much need. It's batshit.

IsGoodIsDon · 30/01/2024 14:16

My OH is a higher earner so we don’t qualify for any childcare help. I am a nurse but chose to quit my job as it wasn’t worth the childcare costs and headaches with my shifts. Maybe if we had a bit more help to pay childcare costs I would have continued with nursing that I loved but my income just wasn’t worth it.
I still do a bit of nursing to keep my registration but now I’ve left it I’ll never go back to a permanent role again. And they wonder why they don’t have any nurses!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 30/01/2024 14:06

ManchesterLu · 29/01/2024 12:38

You are a high earner. If you are struggling to get by on that, that's because of your own lifestyle decisions i.e. large mortgage, car finance, etc. Why should you have a lifestyle like that, and get the same free childcare as someone who has to make a decision about whether they can afford to feed themselves AND their child this week?

Ok but if 100% of your pay goes on childcare then it doesn’t matter how but your mortgage is you can’t afford it and you too will be making decisions about how to feed your children.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 14:04

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 13:57

Why would it need to more or less double? The average house price was £188k in 2014, it’s now £310K. It’s not double but it’s more than 50% growth. In any event the hypothetical £100k under discussion here isn’t household income, it’s individual income.

Is 2014 is not a few years ago

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 13:57

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 13:45

It's not "fairy money". Its an asset that can be liquidated. And "a few years ago", where is this house that must have more or less doubled in value in a "few years"?

Why would it need to more or less double? The average house price was £188k in 2014, it’s now £310K. It’s not double but it’s more than 50% growth. In any event the hypothetical £100k under discussion here isn’t household income, it’s individual income.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 13:45

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 13:28

Of course it can be. Assuming the house worth £800k today was purchased a few years ago. Just like the pensioners’ £800k house wasn’t that price when they bought it. That’s the problem with taxing assets, it’s essentially fairy money.

It's not "fairy money". Its an asset that can be liquidated. And "a few years ago", where is this house that must have more or less doubled in value in a "few years"?

BassoContinuo · 30/01/2024 13:30

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 13:28

Of course it can be. Assuming the house worth £800k today was purchased a few years ago. Just like the pensioners’ £800k house wasn’t that price when they bought it. That’s the problem with taxing assets, it’s essentially fairy money.

But if you have an asset you can presumably borrow against it? Or there could be a charge put on it repayable on death. Or someone in an £800k house could downsize if they can’t afford the tax.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 13:28

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 12:12

A household income of £100K isn't buying a house worth £800k though are they? Not without a couple of decades of equity behind them.

Of course it can be. Assuming the house worth £800k today was purchased a few years ago. Just like the pensioners’ £800k house wasn’t that price when they bought it. That’s the problem with taxing assets, it’s essentially fairy money.