Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 23:12

I can't remember who it was but if you are struggling to pay for three kids childcare it sounds like you couldn't afford to have three or do we only say that to low earners?

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 23:11

JemimaTiggywinkles · 30/01/2024 22:58

A single parent with two children in childcare has to earn £150,000 to have the same net income after tax and childcare as a couple both earning the average full time salary of £38k. That's indefensible and completely illogical.

This is extraordinary and certainly needs to change.

However, in the vast majority of circumstances the children of a single parent with have a second parent who ought to be supporting the children too. IMO child support needs to cover 50% of childcare as well as a general living costs. Unpaid child support should be given to the RP by the state and the government should pursue the money with the same vigour they chase unpaid tax. It is unacceptable that many NRPs don’t come close to paying their fair share.

Ii completely agree. Non-payment should result in significant penalties: fines (enforced with confiscation of property/ assets if unpaid), suspension of passports etc. and for continued non-payment there should be prison sentences as for tax evasion.

The amount an absent parent (i.e. not sharing residency) is required to pay should also be raised to something resembling 50% of the cost of raising a child. The "they can't afford it" argument is laughable: then how do they think the resident parent can afford to fund their own 50% share AND most or all of the non-resident parent's share when they are the one whose work is limited by caring responsibilities also? The pittance that is supposedly required at the moment is an insult to children. There should also be a deminimus amount to be paid regardless of income. If your income is insufficient then go and get a job and pay up, or go to prison. This would prevent all of the attempts to underdeclare earnings etc.

That said, many single parents do not have any prospect of receiving a meaningful amount of maintenance. The other parent may have vanished or be dead. The system cannot rely on maintenance being paid and it certainly isn't a substitute for reforming he tax system and putting single parents on a level playing field so that they are taxed the same amount on the same household income as a couple, and receive the same childcare funding etc as a couple with the same household income. It's completely unacceptable that this isn't the case like in pretty much every other country. Why would we compound the inbuilt disadvantage in one person trying to do two roles, by also taxing them MORE? More countries provide additional tax allowances to single parents. It's hardly much to ask to simply stop taxing them more than couples!

Anybody who actually cared about women and children would campaign for this to change. Neither major political party seems to care about it despite them being aware of all the evidence, which is disgusting frankly.

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 23:11

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 23:04

@WithACatLikeTread

The UC poster is DEPENDENT on the state to survive when is a healthy working age human being.

Do you not understand this?

Thats not ok. That attitude is precisely why the UK is so unproductive.

Interesting. I claim UC but not dependent on the UC to survive. Might be many the same. I don't see an issue with pointing out hypocrisy of discovering a loophole to claim something you aren't entitled to whilst pushing others to do more work and lose their benefits.

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 23:08

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 23:00

All the tax is the difference. And the work.

She was employed. I can understand doing what you do but don't make out that it makes you a better individual than the one on a poor income.

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 23:04

@WithACatLikeTread

The UC poster is DEPENDENT on the state to survive when is a healthy working age human being.

Do you not understand this?

Thats not ok. That attitude is precisely why the UK is so unproductive.

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 23:00

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 22:53

Yet you berated a poster for not wanting to work extra and lose her UC? What is the difference there then between you? Nothing.

All the tax is the difference. And the work.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 30/01/2024 22:58

A single parent with two children in childcare has to earn £150,000 to have the same net income after tax and childcare as a couple both earning the average full time salary of £38k. That's indefensible and completely illogical.

This is extraordinary and certainly needs to change.

However, in the vast majority of circumstances the children of a single parent with have a second parent who ought to be supporting the children too. IMO child support needs to cover 50% of childcare as well as a general living costs. Unpaid child support should be given to the RP by the state and the government should pursue the money with the same vigour they chase unpaid tax. It is unacceptable that many NRPs don’t come close to paying their fair share.

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 22:53

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:08

I wasn't I complaining. I was just explaining to you how much it costs and how I don't care whether or not you think we deserve subsidised childcare. We will claim it as long as we can, we will stick as much in pensions as we need to and will not feel an ounce of guilt.

Yet you berated a poster for not wanting to work extra and lose her UC? What is the difference there then between you? Nothing.

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 22:46

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 22:40

The marginal tax rate can be over 20,000% if you accidentally earn £1 over the £100,000 threshold. That is clearly insane.

The withdrawal of the personal allowance is equally a "shoot yourself in the foot" for the UK economy with many of our most productive workers cutting their hours and - like the withdrawal of child benefit - has been shown to reduce overall tax revenues. Increased productivity is the only sustainable way to raise living standards and these policies are having the opposite effect: economic research has demonstrated this is the case.

A single parent with two children in childcare has to earn £150,000 to have the same net income after tax and childcare as a couple both earning the average full time salary of £38k. That's indefensible and completely illogical.

Childcare is also a public good, like education, so absolutely should be universal. It enables participation in the economy, financial independence of women, reduces child poverty, reduces the gender pay gap, reduces welfare dependency right through to women with insufficient retirement funds and impoverished old age.

In addition public services/ benefits that are universal maintain public support. Higher earners pay for their share many times over and subsidise everyone else as they do with the state pension, education, health etc but the fact they also get the benefit of it means they don't tend to object to that. If you make them pay for it for everyone else but tell them they can't use it themselves, that is the quickest way to undermine the service/ benefit completely. It will end up either being scrapped or the threshold frozen (as we've already seen...) so that fewer people are eligible by the year until very few receive it at all. People who suggest means-testing the state pension should take heed!!

So in short, OP: you're absolutely right. It's a terrible policy in every respect: illogical, unfair and damaging to the wider economy. Those who support it are either economically illiterate or the "cutting off your nose to spite your face" type because they hate people who earn higher salaries.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 exactly this

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 22:41

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 22:35

@ThePeaAndThePrincess

Agreed. The UK should either move to household income for tax purposes, or temove the tax cliffs at £50k and £100k. The US operates with the household income model and it works reasonably well.

Pretty much every other developed country does, for very good reason!

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 22:40

The marginal tax rate can be over 20,000% if you accidentally earn £1 over the £100,000 threshold. That is clearly insane.

The withdrawal of the personal allowance is equally a "shoot yourself in the foot" for the UK economy with many of our most productive workers cutting their hours and - like the withdrawal of child benefit - has been shown to reduce overall tax revenues. Increased productivity is the only sustainable way to raise living standards and these policies are having the opposite effect: economic research has demonstrated this is the case.

A single parent with two children in childcare has to earn £150,000 to have the same net income after tax and childcare as a couple both earning the average full time salary of £38k. That's indefensible and completely illogical.

Childcare is also a public good, like education, so absolutely should be universal. It enables participation in the economy, financial independence of women, reduces child poverty, reduces the gender pay gap, reduces welfare dependency right through to women with insufficient retirement funds and impoverished old age.

In addition public services/ benefits that are universal maintain public support. Higher earners pay for their share many times over and subsidise everyone else as they do with the state pension, education, health etc but the fact they also get the benefit of it means they don't tend to object to that. If you make them pay for it for everyone else but tell them they can't use it themselves, that is the quickest way to undermine the service/ benefit completely. It will end up either being scrapped or the threshold frozen (as we've already seen...) so that fewer people are eligible by the year until very few receive it at all. People who suggest means-testing the state pension should take heed!!

So in short, OP: you're absolutely right. It's a terrible policy in every respect: illogical, unfair and damaging to the wider economy. Those who support it are either economically illiterate or the "cutting off your nose to spite your face" type because they hate people who earn higher salaries.

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 22:35

@ThePeaAndThePrincess

Agreed. The UK should either move to household income for tax purposes, or temove the tax cliffs at £50k and £100k. The US operates with the household income model and it works reasonably well.

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 22:31

@BIossomtoes

Given her houshold is > £95k/year

She is a NET taxpayer. They pay in a lot more than they take out.

That means you don't get to tell her that she is making public services worse.

Those that are "making them worse" are the households on less than £55k (take out more than they pay in) and 95% of pensioners (under £80k).

That would be people like....yourself.

So, care to stop utilising services as you are "making public services worse"?

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 22:29

pessaryforthepressurey · 29/01/2024 12:19

It's income after pension etc, though. I think the idea is that if you're on whatever results in £100k+ taxable income is, you can afford a tax advisor to help you with this. 😉

Or it encourages the parents to cut their hours a bit, or take unpaid parental leave to bring down to 99k, and the children benefit from time with their hard working parents, without losing out on essential income? Children need parent time as well as childcare. Obviously, you may be earning £100k+ taxable and be working very part time with great quality time with the kids, but that must be the exception rather than the rule.

Much more scandalous is that if you get your taxable family income down to 99k, but neither of you earn over 50k, you get to keep child benefit, whereas a single parent household can have half that, and lose it. That's where the battle is.

At 100k+, sort it out with your accountant.

It's also pretty scandalous that a single parent earning £100k loses all nursery/ childcare funding whereas a couple earning £50k each get nursery/ childcare funding and child benefit and are taxed FAR less so have a much higher household income despite having two people to share childcare so needing less paid childcare than the single parent.

autienotnaughty · 30/01/2024 22:03

@User5512 and they are fortunate to grow up in an environment/financial situation that enables them to do that as well as of course having the capability

Passingthethyme · 30/01/2024 21:50

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 21:21

We need people to have children to support our public services in a few years!
We have an aging population and a declining birthrate, it's going to be a big problem when there is noone to look after our older folks.

Anyone smart will leave the country so they won't be around anyway

User5512 · 30/01/2024 21:49

ManchesterLu · 29/01/2024 12:38

You are a high earner. If you are struggling to get by on that, that's because of your own lifestyle decisions i.e. large mortgage, car finance, etc. Why should you have a lifestyle like that, and get the same free childcare as someone who has to make a decision about whether they can afford to feed themselves AND their child this week?

Because high incomes don’t fall from the sky? People make conscious choices to prioritise education and then careers/building businesses (over having children early on) to get to those high incomes.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:41

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:39

Why does it matter if we do?
And because that little bit of childcare is really really expensive.

Edited

I think we’ve gone the complete circle now don’t you?

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:39

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:37

If it’s only a little bit why bother to find ways round it?

Why does it matter if we do?
And because that little bit of childcare is really really expensive.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:37

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:34

Yeah, because obviously higher earners getting a little bit of childcare for a couple of years are the reason public services are stretched. That maths adds up perfectly.

If it’s only a little bit why bother to find ways round it?

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:34

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:14

Don’t complain about the state of public services then.

Yeah, because obviously higher earners getting a little bit of childcare for a couple of years are the reason public services are stretched. That maths adds up perfectly.

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2024 21:33

Kpo58 · 30/01/2024 21:30

If the figures don't add up, then they don't add up. Is it realistic to tell people that they need to go into debt and potentially loose their home because of the cost of working because they might do a little better in the future?

Why would they be going into debt and potentially losing their home if their partner is earning £100k+?

Kpo58 · 30/01/2024 21:30

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2024 20:12

I think we need to stop telling women who are usually the lower earners that it isn't 'worth it' to continue their careers because that is exactly why it is worth it long term to stay in work.

If the figures don't add up, then they don't add up. Is it realistic to tell people that they need to go into debt and potentially loose their home because of the cost of working because they might do a little better in the future?

scrunchmum · 30/01/2024 21:21

We need people to have children to support our public services in a few years!
We have an aging population and a declining birthrate, it's going to be a big problem when there is noone to look after our older folks.

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:14

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:08

I wasn't I complaining. I was just explaining to you how much it costs and how I don't care whether or not you think we deserve subsidised childcare. We will claim it as long as we can, we will stick as much in pensions as we need to and will not feel an ounce of guilt.

Don’t complain about the state of public services then.

Swipe left for the next trending thread