Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 11:58

jannier · 31/01/2024 11:53

If that's what makes you feel better ....somebody tweaking the system to give their kids heating and food to me beats someone getting a second or third holiday or feathering the retirement nest.

How about everyone decides that it is not worth putting in the time and investment to study and train for the jobs that make you a high earner in your eyes. Then see how much better the country is without any of those jobs being filled, feeding your children and heating your houses will become a lot harder.

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 11:58

jannier · 31/01/2024 11:53

If that's what makes you feel better ....somebody tweaking the system to give their kids heating and food to me beats someone getting a second or third holiday or feathering the retirement nest.

That’s such a ridiculous and ill informed response that it’s pointless conversing with you any further.

jannier · 31/01/2024 11:53

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 11:19

If someone who is a net contributor decides to take steps to contribute less but still remains a net contributor that cannot be in anyway considered the same as some who is a net recipient refusing to do something that would make them less of a burden on other taxpayers.

If that's what makes you feel better ....somebody tweaking the system to give their kids heating and food to me beats someone getting a second or third holiday or feathering the retirement nest.

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 11:20

Elisj · 31/01/2024 10:37

YANBU. Britain is a fabulous place to be either very rich or very poor but if you’re
median income you’re expected to pay for everyone else while receiving fuck all from the system yourself.

Anyone earning the median UK income is not a net contributor. They are subsidised by higher earners.

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 11:19

jannier · 31/01/2024 10:19

So basically happy to exploit the system just like benefit frauds at the other end claiming and working.

If someone who is a net contributor decides to take steps to contribute less but still remains a net contributor that cannot be in anyway considered the same as some who is a net recipient refusing to do something that would make them less of a burden on other taxpayers.

Elisj · 31/01/2024 10:37

YANBU. Britain is a fabulous place to be either very rich or very poor but if you’re
median income you’re expected to pay for everyone else while receiving fuck all from the system yourself.

Spiderzed · 31/01/2024 10:34

Haven't read the whole thread but I can imagine lots of the responses.

I agree though OP, people have calculated it and there's a sharp cliff edge after 100k where you're actually worse off until you reach I think it's 120k-ish.

Wahawa · 31/01/2024 10:32

@jannier I see you loathe High earners. Why is that?
Looking at how much free time you have, may be you can go back and work so you can pay taxes to subsidise the high earners childcare.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 31/01/2024 10:31

Yes, it is a bit daft to start bringing criminal behaviour into it. That's something else again.

Oliotya · 31/01/2024 10:24

jannier · 31/01/2024 10:19

So basically happy to exploit the system just like benefit frauds at the other end claiming and working.

Only one of those is fraudulent.

jannier · 31/01/2024 10:19

Oliotya · 30/01/2024 21:08

I wasn't I complaining. I was just explaining to you how much it costs and how I don't care whether or not you think we deserve subsidised childcare. We will claim it as long as we can, we will stick as much in pensions as we need to and will not feel an ounce of guilt.

So basically happy to exploit the system just like benefit frauds at the other end claiming and working.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 31/01/2024 10:05

whatkatydid2014 · 31/01/2024 08:49

For what it’s worth I actually think the person on UC who doesn’t want to increase hours as it will make them worse off is exactly the same as my husband and I shoving extra money in our pension & taking unpaid leave to avoid losing child benefit or @Oliotya‘s husband putting extra money in pension to avoid losing tax free childcare. All these behaviours are a direct result of the way the tax/benefits system is structured and I would never blame an individual for doing what makes sense for their family. We almost all do it (whatever our level of income). Even though we benefit from the current set up I also strongly agree the way benefits/taxes are structured at a household level for some things and an individual one for others drives a lot of unfairness for single people and in particular single parent families (mainly women - might that be a reason why we haven’t fixed it?)

Completely agree. The principle is identical, and I think people focusing on their moral takes on either is completely pointless. Nothing ever gets done about the system flaws because it's far too easy to present it as greedy rich or undeserving poor. People respond to incentives, is what it comes down to.

CouldIBeAnymoreOuting · 31/01/2024 09:51

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/01/2024 20:12

I think we need to stop telling women who are usually the lower earners that it isn't 'worth it' to continue their careers because that is exactly why it is worth it long term to stay in work.

You are right. I should have written 'viable' instead of 'worthwhile'. In many cases, it is just not viable for the primary care giver to work, even with a partner's salary over £100k. If they were eligible for the 30 free hours, this would make a significant different to their financial independence.

Oliotya · 31/01/2024 09:28

WithACatLikeTread · 31/01/2024 09:26

@Oliotya Who is that directed at?

Oh sorry, quoted wrong. I was on about blossom being obtuse.

WithACatLikeTread · 31/01/2024 09:26

@Oliotya Who is that directed at?

Oliotya · 31/01/2024 09:05

whatkatydid2014 · 31/01/2024 08:49

For what it’s worth I actually think the person on UC who doesn’t want to increase hours as it will make them worse off is exactly the same as my husband and I shoving extra money in our pension & taking unpaid leave to avoid losing child benefit or @Oliotya‘s husband putting extra money in pension to avoid losing tax free childcare. All these behaviours are a direct result of the way the tax/benefits system is structured and I would never blame an individual for doing what makes sense for their family. We almost all do it (whatever our level of income). Even though we benefit from the current set up I also strongly agree the way benefits/taxes are structured at a household level for some things and an individual one for others drives a lot of unfairness for single people and in particular single parent families (mainly women - might that be a reason why we haven’t fixed it?)

Pay no heed to her. She took issue with me years ago. I could tell her water is wet and she'd argue about it.

whatkatydid2014 · 31/01/2024 08:49

For what it’s worth I actually think the person on UC who doesn’t want to increase hours as it will make them worse off is exactly the same as my husband and I shoving extra money in our pension & taking unpaid leave to avoid losing child benefit or @Oliotya‘s husband putting extra money in pension to avoid losing tax free childcare. All these behaviours are a direct result of the way the tax/benefits system is structured and I would never blame an individual for doing what makes sense for their family. We almost all do it (whatever our level of income). Even though we benefit from the current set up I also strongly agree the way benefits/taxes are structured at a household level for some things and an individual one for others drives a lot of unfairness for single people and in particular single parent families (mainly women - might that be a reason why we haven’t fixed it?)

whatkatydid2014 · 31/01/2024 08:38

BIossomtoes · 30/01/2024 21:41

I think we’ve gone the complete circle now don’t you?

You are being deliberately obtuse. It’s a small number of families that are losing their personal allowance plus childcare help (free hours & tax free childcare) when they go over a certain earnings limit. Some of it immediately & some over a slice of income. Tax & NI on that income is 42%, the loss of personal allowance on that slice increases marginal rate to over 50%. If you have 3 children in child care you lose up to an additional £6,000 a year for tax free childcare and ~1,700 subsidised “free” hours. On an individual basis it can amount to losing net income on a payrise or bonus which is significant. On a countywide basis it isn’t going to be what makes the difference between funding a service or not. I don’t earn that much and I probably never will but I struggle to believe anyone truly thinks that the current system is sensible. There are equally stupid rules around universal credit thresholds and other points where increasing income doesn’t make sense for individuals. Removing them would be fairer and modelling suggests it would also generate more tax revenue overall (which in turn funds better public services).

WithACatLikeTread · 31/01/2024 08:18

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 23:27

It may have escaped your notice but there's been significant inflation in the last few years. Salaries have not kept pace with inflation. Many people who could afford their children and planned prudently with a sensible contingency spare have had that eroded and are now struggling to fund essential costs like childcare that enable them to earn their salaries. Benefits, however, have been uprated with inflation and the minimum wage has been raised by far more than inflation over the last decade or so. The personal allowance has nearly doubled in real-terms in the last 15 years. Lower earners have therefore been cushioned against the impact of the last 15 years while higher earners have been carrying everybody and paying Scandinavian levels of tax for Albanian levels of public services. Which apparently they shouldn't even be allowed to use, anyway.

When the minimum wage and benefits get increased though so does everything else and obviously you will be less affected than low earners. You also know that childcare years are short and you will have a significant amount of your £100k plus salary free again in a few years unless you are planning on private school. Those on minimum wage will continue to struggle.

Thementalloadisreal · 31/01/2024 08:07

pessaryforthepressurey · 29/01/2024 12:23

For the Tories, there are ideological pros to getting women to cut their hours to look after the children. I'm not saying they're correct, but it's not unintended.

Plus, are we sure that, if it were gender equal, there's aren't benefits to high earners cutting hours to raise children? I think if a family has enough money, then ideally both parents should have at least a day a week dedicated to parenting, in addition to the weekend. It would benefit society hugely. Much more than needing more childcare places and funding them too little, which is what's happening.

But the Tories want women to go back to work?
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/ministers-rinsed-over-plan-to-woo-mums-back-to-work-with-letter-writing-campaign_uk_63d24cbee4b0c8e3fc7c52b0

Ministers Rinsed Over Plan To Woo Mums Back To Work With 'Letter Writing Campaign'

"Oh wow I’m sure a letter to mums will suddenly make childcare affordable," one critic said.

https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/ministers-rinsed-over-plan-to-woo-mums-back-to-work-with-letter-writing-campaign_uk_63d24cbee4b0c8e3fc7c52b0

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 08:03

So, care to stop utilising services as you are "making public services worse"?

I don’t utilise many public services. I pay for my own healthcare and obviously I don’t have children in education (nobody with kids in state education is putting in more than they’re taking out, use of healthcare is also concentrated in extreme old age and childhood). I don’t use social care. So my use of public services is basically using the potholed roads and having my bins emptied.

I’d also be interested to see the working for the income figures quoted although I suspect they have, as usual, been plucked from thin air.

ladykale · 31/01/2024 00:15

BouncingJAS · 30/01/2024 12:00

@Araminta1003

Its posts like the one you quoted which makes me conclude the UK is in terminal decline when you have over 50% of people dependent on the state.

The lack of education and the profound inability to understand how the country works in a global world leads to mentalities like that one.

Its easy to "vote yourself other peoples money" until you run out of money.

And thats the UK today. It has run out of money.

They seem unable to understand that the UK has lived way beyond its means for the last 20 years and that bill has now come due. The UK is not a "wealthy" country anymore. It has a very small slice of very rich people (who pay some taxes), a small slice of professionals (who pay the bulk of the taxes), and a huge amount of poorer people in the middle (who pay little tax and receive more in benefits).

So what will happen is that they will get a lot poorer in real terms because they have limited options. The wealthier people with options will leave, retire, or work less, further making the lower earners poorer in real terms.

Thats what I see over the next five years or so.

Frustrates me that no one seems to understand this..!

ladykale · 31/01/2024 00:09

"while higher earners have been carrying everybody and paying Scandinavian levels of tax for Albanian levels of public services. Which apparently they shouldn't even be allowed to use, anyway."

@ThePeaAndThePrincess is spot on!

Alohapotato · 31/01/2024 00:06

ManchesterLu · 29/01/2024 12:38

You are a high earner. If you are struggling to get by on that, that's because of your own lifestyle decisions i.e. large mortgage, car finance, etc. Why should you have a lifestyle like that, and get the same free childcare as someone who has to make a decision about whether they can afford to feed themselves AND their child this week?

This.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 30/01/2024 23:27

WithACatLikeTread · 30/01/2024 23:12

I can't remember who it was but if you are struggling to pay for three kids childcare it sounds like you couldn't afford to have three or do we only say that to low earners?

It may have escaped your notice but there's been significant inflation in the last few years. Salaries have not kept pace with inflation. Many people who could afford their children and planned prudently with a sensible contingency spare have had that eroded and are now struggling to fund essential costs like childcare that enable them to earn their salaries. Benefits, however, have been uprated with inflation and the minimum wage has been raised by far more than inflation over the last decade or so. The personal allowance has nearly doubled in real-terms in the last 15 years. Lower earners have therefore been cushioned against the impact of the last 15 years while higher earners have been carrying everybody and paying Scandinavian levels of tax for Albanian levels of public services. Which apparently they shouldn't even be allowed to use, anyway.