Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Oliotya · 31/01/2024 19:08

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 18:54

Which specific year? Some people are healthy childfree adults their entire working lives.

Is it usual to spawn as a healthy employed adult, and drop dead at your retirement party? Don't give Musk et al any ideas.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 19:00

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 18:54

Which specific year? Some people are healthy childfree adults their entire working lives.

Part of the reason they are probably healthy is because they had immunisations as a child that were developed and provided by tax payer funds. They are probably able to breathe semi fresh air due to laws and regulations introduced and monitored by tax payer funds.
they live on streets that are not overrun with rubbish and sewage filled with disease as they are kept clean using tax payer funds.
They probably are able to work because they were educated at schools which were probably paid for by tax payer funds.

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 18:54

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 12:24

I think that you need to look at over the course of your life and not in one specific year.

Which specific year? Some people are healthy childfree adults their entire working lives.

Zanatdy · 31/01/2024 18:52

I agree as although many will say 100k you’re so rich, in reality no you’re not most of the time. I’m on 65k and I can’t even afford a flat!! It’s all relative to where you live, if you’re the only income in your household etc. I do find schemes whereby people who don’t work and take up nursery spots get a place and working parents don’t or have to pay a lot more wrong. Not saying those looking for work shouldn’t get a bit of help to go to interviews etc but why should those who are paying 40% tax not get any help. To me it’s wrong

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 18:49

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 15:00

I've read every comment in this post, and am yet to be convinced that subsidised/free child care for those earning 100k+ is remotely justified.

Edited

They are working probably very hard on what is probably a stressful job with long hours (and before anyone starts I am not saying that lower earners don’t work hard) to have the majority of their pay going on tax and childcare. Therefore, they are largely working for the financial benefit of others and not themselves. That is hardly going to incentivise them.
this childcare is what enables them to work and pay taxes. If childcare is 3k a month then they need to earn almost 6k a month to even cover it.
all those saying that childcare shouldn’t be subsidized probably think 6k a month is a huge amount so imagine earning that and not actually seeing any of it. It’s clearly not easy to earn that amount otherwise everyone would be.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 17:52

@fitzwilliamdarcy what's your point? Bizarre post. I've outlined many of the things that everyone benefits from, the vast majority of the cost of which is funded by only 10% of the population.

These are public goods from which everyone benefits. They maintain public support while they remain universal. When you start mean-testing them they gradually become eroded, not least because the thresholds are gradually reduced in real-terms so that fewer and fewer people receive them. I'm not sure what part of this you don't understand and why you're implying that there's some kind of inconsistency in stating that those who pay the huge majority of the costs for everyone to have these services should also have access to the service they have paid for themselves. Why would this make sense for healthcare, education, but not early years education and childcare (the provision of which benefits everyone. Why do you think it is free/ much more heavily subsidised in all of our comparator countries? Our of the goodness of their hearts?).

Nobody said they were "hard done by". People have pointed out indefensible, illogical and damaging policies that harm the economy and lower UK tax revenues and therefore the money available to pay for services for everyone^^ as well as unfairly penalising individuals around each threshold. Strange that you want to support illogical policies that make everyone, including you, poorer because you can't bear the idea of someone on a higher salary also getting to use the services they fund. Should the same logic be applied to schools, healthcare, state pensions, etc?

As I said earlier in the thread the fastest way to undermine a public service and effectively abolish it over time is to means-test it then continually raise the threshold by less than inflation. If you fancy going down that road and people who earn low incomes support that then it won't end well for them given they are the most reliant on the public services they are undermining. Very short-sighted when it's quite obvious what will happen if such policies are enacted as has already been demonstrated through years of fiscal drag on the thresholds for the things where such counterproductive means-testing has been applied already. Don't say you weren't warned.

dollybird · 31/01/2024 17:06

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:09

Nobody out of work needs free childcare before school. Only working people should have free childcare and it should not be means tested. This country penalises work and being middle class.

As stated by PP, it is early years education, so all children should be entitled to have access to it

lieselotte · 31/01/2024 16:20

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 14:31

I feel like it should be universal. The high earners pay a lot more in tax and should also get some benefits from it and some money back so it is good for them to get support during the few years that their costs are significantly higher. Childcare is essential to enable them to work and maintain paying their taxes. We pay taxes to support society in general which included everyone (including themselves ) and not just part of the population.

Yes, inclusivity means just that. Not just some people.

Butterdishy · 31/01/2024 15:05

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 15:00

I've read every comment in this post, and am yet to be convinced that subsidised/free child care for those earning 100k+ is remotely justified.

Edited

Could you try to justify why it shouldn't be universal then? Properly exploring all the economic consequences for society in particular please.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 15:00

Nursery772 · 31/01/2024 14:22

@Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter

For people in general.

On average, the responses to this thread have agreed that the way the current policy is applied is not fair. The cliff edge cause significant earnings loss and actively incentivises people to work less / put money into Pensions / avoid bonuses and promotions.

At the same time, there does seem to be a significant number of people saying it being entirely universal doesn’t seem right either.

So the compromise is to remove the benefit from high earners, just do it in such a way that it isn’t incentivising people to cut hours etc.

This could remove the effective 100% tax rate families are facing on earnings between £100-130k, while also expecting higher earners to contribute a higher sum towards childcare costs.

I've read every comment in this post, and am yet to be convinced that subsidised/free child care for those earning 100k+ is remotely justified.

Butterdishy · 31/01/2024 14:32

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 14:31

I feel like it should be universal. The high earners pay a lot more in tax and should also get some benefits from it and some money back so it is good for them to get support during the few years that their costs are significantly higher. Childcare is essential to enable them to work and maintain paying their taxes. We pay taxes to support society in general which included everyone (including themselves ) and not just part of the population.

I think your last sentence there is key!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 14:31

I feel like it should be universal. The high earners pay a lot more in tax and should also get some benefits from it and some money back so it is good for them to get support during the few years that their costs are significantly higher. Childcare is essential to enable them to work and maintain paying their taxes. We pay taxes to support society in general which included everyone (including themselves ) and not just part of the population.

Nursery772 · 31/01/2024 14:22

@Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter

For people in general.

On average, the responses to this thread have agreed that the way the current policy is applied is not fair. The cliff edge cause significant earnings loss and actively incentivises people to work less / put money into Pensions / avoid bonuses and promotions.

At the same time, there does seem to be a significant number of people saying it being entirely universal doesn’t seem right either.

So the compromise is to remove the benefit from high earners, just do it in such a way that it isn’t incentivising people to cut hours etc.

This could remove the effective 100% tax rate families are facing on earnings between £100-130k, while also expecting higher earners to contribute a higher sum towards childcare costs.

OP posts:
Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 14:12

Nursery772 · 31/01/2024 13:58

Some interesting responses on this thread!

It sounds like the most palatable option to make a change here, would be to introduce a staggered removal of the costs over a greater sum of income vs the cliff edge.

That would certainly be an improvement.

Palatable for whom?

Nursery772 · 31/01/2024 13:58

Some interesting responses on this thread!

It sounds like the most palatable option to make a change here, would be to introduce a staggered removal of the costs over a greater sum of income vs the cliff edge.

That would certainly be an improvement.

OP posts:
fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 13:53

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 13:28

Not if they’re a child free healthy adult. Those people take virtually nothing out.

They didn't go to school then? Have never and will never use the NHS? Never travelled on public transport? Never walked on a pavement or driven on a road? Never used a public library or leisure centre? Won't claim a state pension? Don't benefit from living in a society with a criminal justice system and laws, and the existence of the police and fire service and ambulances if they become unwell? Don't benefit from product safety standards so they can buy food and other goods that won't kill them? Or medicines that work? Don't benefit from a country that is safe and defended (to some extent 🤣) from being attacked? Have never claimed any benefits for housing costs or unemployment? Don't have their refuse collected from their homes?

There's a Monty Python film you should watch.

Just one page ago you said:

Higher earners pay for their share many times over and subsidise everyone else as they do with the state pension, education, health etc but the fact they also get the benefit of it means they don't tend to object to that. If you make them pay for it for everyone else but tell them they can't use it themselves, that is the quickest way to undermine the service/ benefit completely.

I'd pass on your advice above to those high earners, that should stop them from feeling hard done by.

BouncingJAS · 31/01/2024 13:41

@Charlie2121

That number has also been getting progressively smaller over the last 30 years or so.

40% where net tax recipients back in 1990

That figure is now 54% in 2023

To say that trend is "completely unsustainable" when the demographics will get even worse over the next 20 years (so less people paying in and more taking out) is the understatement of the year award.

Only way this works (without a revolution) is a slow reduction in living standards while that 54% number reduces back down to less than 45%.

Won't be pretty for the population which is why improving productivity is so important. The more this is improved, the easier the reduction will be.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 13:37

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 08:03

So, care to stop utilising services as you are "making public services worse"?

I don’t utilise many public services. I pay for my own healthcare and obviously I don’t have children in education (nobody with kids in state education is putting in more than they’re taking out, use of healthcare is also concentrated in extreme old age and childhood). I don’t use social care. So my use of public services is basically using the potholed roads and having my bins emptied.

I’d also be interested to see the working for the income figures quoted although I suspect they have, as usual, been plucked from thin air.

Edited

Wow, that's amazing. You were born as a fully grown woman, never went to school or needed childhood immunisations, have lived off grid in a house you built yourself without making use of national safety standards, have never engaged with the financial system the Government regulates and had a bank account or used cash, and live on foraged food! And while doing this you've also discovered the secret to immortality and eternal health so you'll never get old or sick! You are quite some woman, for sure.

BouncingJAS · 31/01/2024 13:36

@BIossomtoes

Why do you insist on making comments like thay when you have no idea of the numbers?

Your biases are amazing to observe

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 13:28

Not if they’re a child free healthy adult. Those people take virtually nothing out.

They didn't go to school then? Have never and will never use the NHS? Never travelled on public transport? Never walked on a pavement or driven on a road? Never used a public library or leisure centre? Won't claim a state pension? Don't benefit from living in a society with a criminal justice system and laws, and the existence of the police and fire service and ambulances if they become unwell? Don't benefit from product safety standards so they can buy food and other goods that won't kill them? Or medicines that work? Don't benefit from a country that is safe and defended (to some extent 🤣) from being attacked? Have never claimed any benefits for housing costs or unemployment? Don't have their refuse collected from their homes?

There's a Monty Python film you should watch.

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 13:22

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 12:04

Not if they’re a child free healthy adult. Those people take virtually nothing out.

Official figures state that if you don’t have average earnings of around 45k per annum throughout your working life your taxes paid don’t cover the benefits and services the average person receives.

This includes not just cash benefits such as universal credit, child benefit, funded nursery etc but also general societal services such as NHS.

Only about 20% of people are net contributors at any one time.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 13:21

whatkatydid2014 · 31/01/2024 08:49

For what it’s worth I actually think the person on UC who doesn’t want to increase hours as it will make them worse off is exactly the same as my husband and I shoving extra money in our pension & taking unpaid leave to avoid losing child benefit or @Oliotya‘s husband putting extra money in pension to avoid losing tax free childcare. All these behaviours are a direct result of the way the tax/benefits system is structured and I would never blame an individual for doing what makes sense for their family. We almost all do it (whatever our level of income). Even though we benefit from the current set up I also strongly agree the way benefits/taxes are structured at a household level for some things and an individual one for others drives a lot of unfairness for single people and in particular single parent families (mainly women - might that be a reason why we haven’t fixed it?)

I completely agree. The independent economic research commissioned by the Chancellor into why UK productivity is so low (worrying that he'd even need to do so, but anyway...) concluded this is an issue at all of those levels: the system makes it not worth working full time. Yet he has ignored its findings. One can only hope he addresses this in the budget. What he needs to do is:

  1. Significantly lower the universal credit taper rate, from 55% to perhaps 35-40%
  2. Scrap the withdrawal of child benefit, making it universal again
  3. Scrap the withdrawal of the personal allowance, making it universal again
  4. Scrap the withdrawal of nursery funding/ tax free childcare, making it universal
  5. Set up a proper commission to reform the entire UK tax system and allocate tax free allowances and tax thresholds on a household unit basis like most developed countries. If couples wish to they can split their allowances in half and keep separate finances rather than transfer between them: it would be opt in to share. But this would mean single people/ parents are no longer penalised as they are now.

It's not rocket science. The first four can be enacted immediately, are not complex to change in law and all the evidence shows would create an increase in UK productivity and tax revenues within months.

The latter is not beyond the wit of humanity given that - as I said - pretty much every other developed country operates their tax system on this basis and we have systems in place already to do this because benefits are allocated on a household not individual basis.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 13:13

When the minimum wage and benefits get increased though so does everything else and obviously you will be less affected than low earners. You also know that childcare years are short and you will have a significant amount of your £100k plus salary free again in a few years unless you are planning on private school. Those on minimum wage will continue to struggle.

Nope. Both of my children have disabilities so have to have nannies before and after school and in school holidays so that I can work. They cannot use group childcare. My childcare bill therefore remains just as high as when they were pre-schoolers. Of course, if I was receiving universal credit, 85% of my childcare bill would be paid by other taxpayers.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 12:24

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 12:04

Not if they’re a child free healthy adult. Those people take virtually nothing out.

I think that you need to look at over the course of your life and not in one specific year.

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 12:04

Charlie2121 · 31/01/2024 11:20

Anyone earning the median UK income is not a net contributor. They are subsidised by higher earners.

Not if they’re a child free healthy adult. Those people take virtually nothing out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread