Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Butterdishy · 01/02/2024 06:33

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 06:29

Education and Healthcare are services, not state benefits. I'm surprised you even had to ask this.
Still not convinced that anyone earning 100k+ needs access to state benefits.

Well now you're just being daft.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 06:30

CaribouCarafe · 31/01/2024 22:48

I think not providing universal affordable (or even free!) childcare is very shortsighted of the government and shows how little focus there is on investment in this country.

You can't treat an economy like a household budget (which a lot of people on this thread don't seem to get) - when you invest money into something like childcare, it opens up opportunities for parents to work harder, earn more, and provide more in taxes whilst decreasing the likelihood of either parent having to rely on benefits in the future (as neither would have to drop back in their career in order to cater for childcare).

Unfortunately, the majority of the voting base probably can't grasp the above concept so it's not a vote-winner, so government is unlikely to propose it.

People can 'grasp' your opinion.

There needs to be more investment in childcare services, both in terms of providing a good and reliable service to every user, and in ensuring those who work in the area are better paid for the essential role they carry out.

It's not just about incentives for higher paid service users.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 06:29

Butterdishy · 01/02/2024 06:03

Would you also call education and Healthcare a benefit? If you're going to argue that high earners don't need access to one thing, what else do you think they shouldn't access?

Education and Healthcare are services, not state benefits. I'm surprised you even had to ask this.
Still not convinced that anyone earning 100k+ needs access to state benefits.

Butterdishy · 01/02/2024 06:03

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 22:08

That's an interesting approach, do you feel that way about every state benefit?

Would you also call education and Healthcare a benefit? If you're going to argue that high earners don't need access to one thing, what else do you think they shouldn't access?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 01/02/2024 06:01

ruby1957 · 31/01/2024 22:03

The MAJORITY of their pay going on tax and childcare??.

I don't think so - tax is paid by everyone at 20% or 40%. Childcare is not for years and years - 2-3 years max.

They are NOT being altruistic and working for the benefit of others and not themselves. How many of them are doing important and worthwhile jobs making life better for others?

If someone is on 4 times the average UK salary they are keeping a sizeable chunk for their nice living standard, expensive house in the SE, holidays abroad and the rest.

This just shows what a huge gap in understanding about how the "system" using that term in the loosest sense " works".

People do not pay tax at 20% or 40%.
People pay 0%, 20%, 80 or 90% tax, 40% tax, 60-200% tax and 45% tax.

For anyone earning between £50K and £120K with children there are effectively 4 different tax bands 2 of them over 50%.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?
Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 05:48

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 22:34

That's an interesting approach, do you feel that way about every state benefit?

Multiple posts here have explained why it should be, if you have bothered to read the thread. If you wish to dispute the very convincing evidence base from multiple independent economic and social research papers and the evidence of published data on outcomes both economic and social over decades from our comparator countries whoch show the effectiveness of their systems that are universal, then it is perfectly reasonable to request that you provide your evidence refuting this data. I think after the Brexit fiasco most of us are not prepared to tolerate the "everyone's opinion is of equal value even if it's based on prejudice and completely contradicts the facts" mantra.

I have read the thread.
None of the comments have justified why someone on 100k+ needs what is essentially a state benefit.

CaribouCarafe · 31/01/2024 22:48

I think not providing universal affordable (or even free!) childcare is very shortsighted of the government and shows how little focus there is on investment in this country.

You can't treat an economy like a household budget (which a lot of people on this thread don't seem to get) - when you invest money into something like childcare, it opens up opportunities for parents to work harder, earn more, and provide more in taxes whilst decreasing the likelihood of either parent having to rely on benefits in the future (as neither would have to drop back in their career in order to cater for childcare).

Unfortunately, the majority of the voting base probably can't grasp the above concept so it's not a vote-winner, so government is unlikely to propose it.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 22:34

That's an interesting approach, do you feel that way about every state benefit?

Multiple posts here have explained why it should be, if you have bothered to read the thread. If you wish to dispute the very convincing evidence base from multiple independent economic and social research papers and the evidence of published data on outcomes both economic and social over decades from our comparator countries whoch show the effectiveness of their systems that are universal, then it is perfectly reasonable to request that you provide your evidence refuting this data. I think after the Brexit fiasco most of us are not prepared to tolerate the "everyone's opinion is of equal value even if it's based on prejudice and completely contradicts the facts" mantra.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 22:33

ruby1957 · 31/01/2024 22:03

The MAJORITY of their pay going on tax and childcare??.

I don't think so - tax is paid by everyone at 20% or 40%. Childcare is not for years and years - 2-3 years max.

They are NOT being altruistic and working for the benefit of others and not themselves. How many of them are doing important and worthwhile jobs making life better for others?

If someone is on 4 times the average UK salary they are keeping a sizeable chunk for their nice living standard, expensive house in the SE, holidays abroad and the rest.

Of course we are only talking about the nursery years here and not their entire life earnings.
on 100k you pay tax and national insurance of 35k. You could then need to pay an additional 6k in student in student loan so take home pay of 59k.
2 kids in full time nursery could easily cost about 45k.
so of that 100k salary you would be left with 14k. I wouldn’t consider 14% a sizable chunk or 14k enough to cover a large mortgage, holidays abroad as well bills, food, travel costs to work.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 22:29

The MAJORITY of their pay going on tax and childcare??.

£100k salary with no pension contributions made equals net pay after tax of £5,588 per month. £2,746 per month paid in tax.

Full time nursery places cost £2,000+ in many parts of the country. So with even one child in childcare 50% of their pay goes on tax and childcare. If you have two children in childcare your "rich" person earning £100k is left with £1,500 per month to pay mortgage, commuting, bills, food and everything else. And that was a conservative estimate for nursery: rates where I live (not London btw) are £2,300 pcm per child. In London it's often more.

jannier · 31/01/2024 22:25

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 18:49

They are working probably very hard on what is probably a stressful job with long hours (and before anyone starts I am not saying that lower earners don’t work hard) to have the majority of their pay going on tax and childcare. Therefore, they are largely working for the financial benefit of others and not themselves. That is hardly going to incentivise them.
this childcare is what enables them to work and pay taxes. If childcare is 3k a month then they need to earn almost 6k a month to even cover it.
all those saying that childcare shouldn’t be subsidized probably think 6k a month is a huge amount so imagine earning that and not actually seeing any of it. It’s clearly not easy to earn that amount otherwise everyone would be.

How do you work out that you need to earn £6k to cover £3k childcare? How do people earning £1k or less after childcare do it then? Are you saying you pay £3k in tax

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 31/01/2024 22:22

fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 19:19

@ThePeaAndThePrincess I was pointing out what is a common hypocrisy on MN. When someone raises higher earner parents getting their share of a child-related benefit, it’s all “you need them onside, they need to feel the benefit of the social good and not just that they’re paying out for everything and getting nothing back.”

When someone points out that healthy higher earner non-parents spend their lives paying out and getting nothing back, that same person will turn around and tell them they’ve got the benefit of roads and a justice system and they should feel grateful.

It’s a total double standard. Either all high earners need a bit of extra buy in or we should be happy with roads and laws.

Oh, and I’ve been a net contributor for years, so there no politics of envy here.

No idea why you directed your comment at me then because I was saying that single people (including those with no children) are shafted by the tax system and this needs to change. And that those higher earners with no children should absolutely have access to all of the state services that they contribute so much towards, covering their own costs of use many times over. Hence the current means-testing is a mistake and it would be even more idiotic to extend this dysfunctional system to other state services e.g. state pensions, which would impact the people you are referring to. I've certainly not said they should be happy just because they have roads and rubbish collection and educatiom etc.

The post of mine that you commented on was mocking the absurd, goady poster who always appears on threads like this and makes a fool of herself, and her assertion that she has lived her entire life without using any public services except refuse and roads. Either that or she failed to grasp that looking at one period of her life in isolation is completely irrelevant despite multiple posters having pointed this out and that she one day may be grateful that all of those nasty higher earners have funded her pension and the NHS.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 31/01/2024 22:08

Butterdishy · 31/01/2024 15:05

Could you try to justify why it shouldn't be universal then? Properly exploring all the economic consequences for society in particular please.

That's an interesting approach, do you feel that way about every state benefit?

ruby1957 · 31/01/2024 22:03

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 18:49

They are working probably very hard on what is probably a stressful job with long hours (and before anyone starts I am not saying that lower earners don’t work hard) to have the majority of their pay going on tax and childcare. Therefore, they are largely working for the financial benefit of others and not themselves. That is hardly going to incentivise them.
this childcare is what enables them to work and pay taxes. If childcare is 3k a month then they need to earn almost 6k a month to even cover it.
all those saying that childcare shouldn’t be subsidized probably think 6k a month is a huge amount so imagine earning that and not actually seeing any of it. It’s clearly not easy to earn that amount otherwise everyone would be.

The MAJORITY of their pay going on tax and childcare??.

I don't think so - tax is paid by everyone at 20% or 40%. Childcare is not for years and years - 2-3 years max.

They are NOT being altruistic and working for the benefit of others and not themselves. How many of them are doing important and worthwhile jobs making life better for others?

If someone is on 4 times the average UK salary they are keeping a sizeable chunk for their nice living standard, expensive house in the SE, holidays abroad and the rest.

Oliotya · 31/01/2024 20:27

fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 19:19

@ThePeaAndThePrincess I was pointing out what is a common hypocrisy on MN. When someone raises higher earner parents getting their share of a child-related benefit, it’s all “you need them onside, they need to feel the benefit of the social good and not just that they’re paying out for everything and getting nothing back.”

When someone points out that healthy higher earner non-parents spend their lives paying out and getting nothing back, that same person will turn around and tell them they’ve got the benefit of roads and a justice system and they should feel grateful.

It’s a total double standard. Either all high earners need a bit of extra buy in or we should be happy with roads and laws.

Oh, and I’ve been a net contributor for years, so there no politics of envy here.

What, so you think high earners without kids should get free childcare as well? Do they get a cash substitute or do they have to physically the nursery themselves?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 20:15

jannier · 31/01/2024 20:01

Why assume it's only the poorly educated who earn less than 100k....it's nice to hear how you value the services provided by nurses, junior doctors, teachers etc who give a shit about the welfare of the population so do vocational jobs rather than go for financial rewards.

Where did I say only the poorly educated earn less than 100k? Of course lots of people who earn less have also studied and worked hard. Most people who earn over 100k probably previously learnt less than 100k for many years aswell.
But that doesn’t mean that those earning over 100k didn’t study and work hard.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/01/2024 20:10

but his job is well-paid partly because it has ZERO flexibility, so can't help with much kid logistics etc.

Right. What about all those people who work in jobs with zero flexibility and can’t help with ‘kid logistics’ but aren’t well-paid?

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 20:08

Absolutely @fitzwilliamdarcy.

jannier · 31/01/2024 20:01

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 11:58

How about everyone decides that it is not worth putting in the time and investment to study and train for the jobs that make you a high earner in your eyes. Then see how much better the country is without any of those jobs being filled, feeding your children and heating your houses will become a lot harder.

Why assume it's only the poorly educated who earn less than 100k....it's nice to hear how you value the services provided by nurses, junior doctors, teachers etc who give a shit about the welfare of the population so do vocational jobs rather than go for financial rewards.

Nerurio · 31/01/2024 19:36

Butterdishy · 31/01/2024 15:05

Could you try to justify why it shouldn't be universal then? Properly exploring all the economic consequences for society in particular please.

🙈😂

Schnapps00 · 31/01/2024 19:27

@Nursery772 Agreed about the single earner, my DH does well (likely to hit 100k in next tax year if he doesn't increase pension), but his job is well-paid partly because it has ZERO flexibility, so can't help with much kid logistics etc. I wouldn't be able to work FT in an office/commute without an aupair/nanny help, therefore I earn minimal money as self-employed/school hours with 1 partly at home still. With 2 parents on 50k, they'd be a lot better off than us, to the tune of probably 10k/year, easily once we lose the TFC/free hours.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 19:25

Having children is not just for the benefit of the individual. We need new generations to come in for society to be able to continue.
yes, it is a choice and people should be responsible for a lot of the costs associated with their children but childcare is not a normal cost, it is a cost to enable them to work.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/01/2024 19:19

@ThePeaAndThePrincess I was pointing out what is a common hypocrisy on MN. When someone raises higher earner parents getting their share of a child-related benefit, it’s all “you need them onside, they need to feel the benefit of the social good and not just that they’re paying out for everything and getting nothing back.”

When someone points out that healthy higher earner non-parents spend their lives paying out and getting nothing back, that same person will turn around and tell them they’ve got the benefit of roads and a justice system and they should feel grateful.

It’s a total double standard. Either all high earners need a bit of extra buy in or we should be happy with roads and laws.

Oh, and I’ve been a net contributor for years, so there no politics of envy here.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 19:15

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 19:10

Obviously. None of that is remotely relevant to a discussion about net contributors and recipients.

How is it not relevant?

The point I am trying to make is that there are a lot of things that you receive from tax money rather than just schooling for your child and treatment on the nhs during your working years.

BIossomtoes · 31/01/2024 19:10

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/01/2024 19:00

Part of the reason they are probably healthy is because they had immunisations as a child that were developed and provided by tax payer funds. They are probably able to breathe semi fresh air due to laws and regulations introduced and monitored by tax payer funds.
they live on streets that are not overrun with rubbish and sewage filled with disease as they are kept clean using tax payer funds.
They probably are able to work because they were educated at schools which were probably paid for by tax payer funds.

Obviously. None of that is remotely relevant to a discussion about net contributors and recipients.