Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 29/01/2024 13:37

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:31

Interesting.

Why do you agree it should be capped at £100k, given you will need to earn more than £100k just to fund the nursery bill?

Should there not be some help for parents of multiples?

The main reason why our childcare fees will be so high is because we decided to have a closer age gap. Of course, we didn't expect we'd have twins and 3 under 2 but 2 under 2 was a choice.

To be fair, I wouldn't be against some help for parents of multiples but again, I'm not sure I'd agree that it should be universal.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:33

@SecondUsername4me but it’s not a cheap option for the cap, as for any earner between £100-160k they are probably losing tax take AND still funding the childcare.

It might actually cost them money - and, with the extension of ‘free hours’ more parents will start trying to reduce their adjusted net income as the loss is greater than previously.

OP posts:
BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 13:33

@SouthLondonMum22

As has been posted:

The State is WORSE off financially due to this policy.

At what point are people going to be rational and objective about the numbers?

The UK is sinking economically-speaking because people keep putting "emotion" over "rational policies".

You folks want to know why Scandinavian countries do better?

They don't put emotion over rational policies when it comes to childcare.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:31

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/01/2024 13:28

When my twins are born and start nursery, we'll be paying £6k+ per month on childcare for 3 children.

I still don't believe we should have any support due to our high income. I think it's right that it is capped at 100k, the only thing I disagree with is that two people earning 99k could still get it.

Interesting.

Why do you agree it should be capped at £100k, given you will need to earn more than £100k just to fund the nursery bill?

Should there not be some help for parents of multiples?

OP posts:
SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 13:30

£8k a month is a great household income, but you could happily spend 50%+ of that on childcare locally

In the case of twins, yes, 50% of the take home pay may very well go on childcare for 3 years (1x year mat leave, aged 1-4 in private Nursery, then into school).

However the vast majority of people who would then be paying out 4k in childcare in your suggestion are doing so because they've chosen to have multiple children overlapping in childcare at one time.

Affordability of when and how many children to have should be something everyone has to consider, not just low income families.

So what if the govt are incentivising funnelling extra into pensions? They need a quick cheap option for the cap, and this is the way they've done it.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 29/01/2024 13:29

Yes!

MrsSamR · 29/01/2024 13:28

Exactly. Financially it would have made more sense for me to become a SAHM ad childcare costs us more than I earn but we felt it was better in the long run for my future job prospects/earning potential/pension etc to keep working. But it does feel a bitter pill to swallow to pay someone else to look after my children while I work for free and we receive no government help at all.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/01/2024 13:28

When my twins are born and start nursery, we'll be paying £6k+ per month on childcare for 3 children.

I still don't believe we should have any support due to our high income. I think it's right that it is capped at 100k, the only thing I disagree with is that two people earning 99k could still get it.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:24

@SecondUsername4me you have missed the point of the example.

With the pension sacrifice, the government ends up vastly worse off. Less tax. More money spent on childcare. So why are they incentivising this behaviour?

£8k a month is a great household income, but you could happily spend 50%+ of that on childcare locally. And of course what you’d most likely do it have the lower earner stop work, which they might not have done if they had access to the hours / tax-free childcare (as described by a poster above).

OP posts:
TheCave · 29/01/2024 13:23

I disagree. I earn over £100k and I never have to worry about putting food on the table. Of course I should pay for childcare - it enables me to earn £100k+ so why wouldn't I? It should be for people who actually can't afford childcare without help. I also chose to have kids, knowing how much childcare costs. Otherwise where does it end? Do we give free childcare to people earning £1m/year? I'm very grateful for the free 15 hours. If I wanted to keep the benefit of 30 hours, I would reduce my hours or diverting huge amounts to my pension, so that my taxable income is under £100k. I looked into doing that but it's not worth it unless your salary is only slightly over £100k.

School being free is different - as our school reminds us repeatedly, it's education not childcare (the fact that it is also childcare is neither here nor there). To be honest I'm always amazed that school is free for higher earners. The teachers are fantastic and my child even gets free lunches (in London). We don't pay a single penny for it (of course, we donate to the PTA when fairs and other events are held).

The only thing which I think is crazy is the fact that you can have 2 people earning £99k and they are still eligible, whereas a single parent earning £100k is not eligible and nor is a family where one earns £100k and the other earns £20k. There should be more sensible limits for different types of families.

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 13:19

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:14

Good point.

Say I earn £130k.

I lose £12,000 of income for earning £1 over £100k.

I can get 60% tax relief on most of the sum £100-130k by getting my employer to put that income into my pension.

This would leave me with ~£28k extra in my pension, £0 tax additional tax take for HMRC, and the additional £12k in childcare benefit.

Surely they have discussed this anomaly. It’s extraordinary really. I don’t think I’ve ever seen an MP discuss it.

Take home pay on 130k is over £6,500pcm. Add in the £1,900 from a partner earning 30k ft, and that's £8k plus per month.

It's really difficult to agree with the argument that any household taking home £8k per month should receive state funded childcare.

londonmummy1966 · 29/01/2024 13:17

I agree that the cliff edge is a ridiculous system and its one of the reasons the NHS is so fucked up. I know a lot of doctors and when this came in a lot of them dropped their hours to avoid it. And don't get me started on the argument of child benefit being based on what the highest earner in a family gets - its the ultimate tax on SAHMs.

Tiredandgrumpykids · 29/01/2024 13:16

Tax commentators such as Dan Niedle and the IFS make this point all the time, but it would cost money to change the policy and a lot of voters won’t grasp that the economy would benefit from changing this, so it will be written off as a ‘tax cut for the ruch’

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 13:15

Yes, I think it should be universal. I know someone earning just over £100k and childcare costs for 2 children was thousands. Add a mortgage of £1400 on a modest house in London, there wouldn’t have been much left. She got herself just under the £100k by putting more into her pension so she could claim.

Absolutely ridiculous to say low earners should be supporting free childcare for folk on £100k a year.

Lol. They’re not. 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Tiredandgrumpykids · 29/01/2024 13:14

This country would be much better off in the long run if it encouraged high earners to work as many hours as possible due to the tax this generates. Dropping to part time permanently affects a woman’s earning ability. See the gender pay gap. This permanently reduces the nations tax take. But the politics of envy people can’t grasp such realities.

so yes OP. You ought to drop your hours as you will be earning minus wages for a salary from £100k to £130k.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:14

BassoContinuo · 29/01/2024 13:06

I don’t think “cliff edge” tax / benefit rates are ever fair. They should either phase out the entitlement or just make it universal.

If it’s making people earning over that amount put money in their pensions, it’s costing more in tax relief than they’d save by just allowing it anyway.

I’d actually support a combined tax-relieved annual allowance covering both pension and childcare.

Good point.

Say I earn £130k.

I lose £12,000 of income for earning £1 over £100k.

I can get 60% tax relief on most of the sum £100-130k by getting my employer to put that income into my pension.

This would leave me with ~£28k extra in my pension, £0 tax additional tax take for HMRC, and the additional £12k in childcare benefit.

Surely they have discussed this anomaly. It’s extraordinary really. I don’t think I’ve ever seen an MP discuss it.

OP posts:
CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 29/01/2024 13:12

While I instinctively want to agree with you as it is a very good salary, less a basic pension contribution and student loan you might be taking home ~£4,800pcm.

It is salary after pension though.
If you earn just over, it would probably be worthwhile just upping your pension contributions.

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 13:10

if it’s not important for the child why are the government investing billions in tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ for those earning up to £100k?

The vast majority of jobs earn way less than the cap. And the parents in those jobs cannot afford to pay childcare.

So you get shortages is essential jobs. Carers, retail staff, teaching assistants, admin, road sweepers, nursery staff themselves, because they all earn under 30k pa and cannot afford full time childcare to then be able to work

So, the govt funds free childcare for them, from a certain age, to enable these essential and low paid workers to remain in the workforce.

If you earn over 100k you have so much more money than your child's nursery staff/ the guy who serves you lunch/ the person who runs the garage you fuel up etc. so so much more. But you both still need to pay the same costs for childcare!

Mrsm010918 · 29/01/2024 13:08

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:01

@Teder if it’s not important for the child why are the government investing billions in tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ for those earning up to £100k?

And I’m not sure healthcare or education are a seen as a right for any other reason that we as a society value them. I’m sure people objected to paying for them too when they were introduced.

If we valued parents staying at home vs using childcare, such policies would exist to help enable this. They don’t.

Society progresses, the world changes, we change the way we do things, surely?

Education is a right, it is drafted into law.

They are investing in all the free hours to try and get more mothers out working more and therefore paying tax back into the system, earning more and claiming less in theory in benefits. There is essentially a deficit in income coming in vs money going out and they are trying to rectify this

I don't think it should be universal either. I agree with means testing it on a household basis and having a sliding scale of entitlement with how much people have funded vs how much they earn.

BassoContinuo · 29/01/2024 13:06

I don’t think “cliff edge” tax / benefit rates are ever fair. They should either phase out the entitlement or just make it universal.

If it’s making people earning over that amount put money in their pensions, it’s costing more in tax relief than they’d save by just allowing it anyway.

I’d actually support a combined tax-relieved annual allowance covering both pension and childcare.

MrsSamR · 29/01/2024 13:03

This is exactly the situation with my husband and I - he earns over 100k and I earn 30k yet I pay for childcare out of my salary (just how we do our finances, not because he views it as a woman's responsibility before people come at me!) and I have never benefited from the tax free childcare, child benefit or funded hours for my two kids. I appreciate a 100k seems a lot but he is taxed very heavily on that and pays a lot into the system so it is unfair that we receive no help in my opinion! Especially as 2 working parents on 99k each would receive it. It's a flawed system for sure.

Wakeywake · 29/01/2024 13:03

I agree with you. In fact I think childcare should be fully tax deductible as it's essential for enabling people to work, regardless of how much you earn. For full disclosure, I've not got any skin in the game, mine are teenagers.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:01

@Teder if it’s not important for the child why are the government investing billions in tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ for those earning up to £100k?

And I’m not sure healthcare or education are a seen as a right for any other reason that we as a society value them. I’m sure people objected to paying for them too when they were introduced.

If we valued parents staying at home vs using childcare, such policies would exist to help enable this. They don’t.

Society progresses, the world changes, we change the way we do things, surely?

OP posts:
shockeditellyou · 29/01/2024 12:58

If they means test this they can means test pension benefits too. Oh wait….

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 12:58

@Nursery772

Of course the benefit should be universal. Its one of the few uses of public money that gives enormous ROI.

But once again, the politics of envy rears its ugly head in the UK and MN

They think you have "more" and they have "less", so you need to be dragged down a bit for their benefit. Its all emotion with them. They don't think the scenario through.

When people say "putting money into pension" that money is not spent in the real economy quickly, thus this dampens demand for goods and services. Economic activity therefore goes down and we have less tax revenue. Thats why the £50k and £100k clifff edges on childcare damage the UK economy.

People earning £100k/year already pay in ample taxes, which are then used to subsidise the childcare of the lower earners (but in their mind it is unfair that it helps them too). They also then pay higher prices at the point of use via top ups because of their income.

Its much easier (operationally and economically) to subsidise childcare fully, and then use a sliding scale for "how much it costs at the point of use" based on income. That way high earners would end up paying £500 or so (which is what happens in Scandinavian countries) and lower earners £100 (or less).

Everybody wins.

But envy in the UK has become corrosive. It has gotten a lot worse in the last few decades from what I have seen.