Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 14:18

I'm sorry but an income of 100k is a huge amount of money (even after tax) so no, I do agree that they need to draw the line somewhere to be able to provide support to those that earn far less.

It is when you’re not paying thousands on childcare. When childcare is maybe £4k for 2 kids, plus mortgage, there really isn’t much left. Think about it and do the maths. People just hear £100k and think they would be super rich, without breaking it down. And as had been pointed out it doesn’t make sense for the country either.

unicornpower · 29/01/2024 14:17

I agree. I also think it should be based off household income rather than individual. Under the current guidelines two parents could each earn 99k and still be eligible, whereas if one is earning 100k and one 12k they aren’t eligible. My husband is a high earner but thankfully under 100k and even with tax free childcare our bill is 2.5k for two children in childcare. That’s a lot of money and he’s taxed heavily. Seems very unbalanced as we aren’t wealthy by any stretch

WavingCatsandDogs · 29/01/2024 14:16

It's not free for a start.

And it doesnt even begin to cover the real cost of providing childcare.

You can afford it and it's not forever.

Changed18 · 29/01/2024 14:15

When I had kids in nursery and was self-employed I thought it was ridiculous that if I had a chauffeur I could write the expense off against tax - but not a childminder or nursery. The system just isn’t set up to recognise that working mothers are a thing.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:15

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 29/01/2024 14:10

Wow, there’s only £1000k difference between a £60k salary and £100k salary per month!

The difference in take home pay is £1,288 on a £100k and £60k salary.

IF, the £100k earner has a student loan and the £60k does not.

That would almost cover three days a week for one child under 3 at my nursery.

The impact of student loans is quite significant - another problem which will come soon to rear its head.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/01/2024 14:14

These threads always get a load of hate. However yes its fundamentally wrong to have a system where if you are on £99k, and have more than one child in childcare, you're fundamentally worse off with a 5 to 10k pay rise, than if you'd not had that pay rise. I can understand if you're no better off, but to be actively worse off, is wrong, and is going to result in a change of working behaviour (such as dropping days at work etc) that are counter productive for the economy.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 29/01/2024 14:10

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:04

£100k after tax is ~£4,800 after tax, student loan, auto enrolment pension.

You might be spending over 80% of that on childcare.

Why is £100k where that line should be drawn?

Wow, there’s only £1000k difference between a £60k salary and £100k salary per month!

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:09

Nobody out of work needs free childcare before school. Only working people should have free childcare and it should not be means tested. This country penalises work and being middle class.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:07

Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 14:02

The current system is ridiculous. I earn a very good salary and managed to get it just below £100k with maximum pension contributions when my DC started nursery.

I was then awarded a £20k bonus which meant I moved back over the £100k limit.

I was taxed at 62% on this 20k and also lost my funded nursery hours at the same time plus the tax free childcare savings option.

The net result was that I was actually worse off for receiving the £20k bonus than had I not been given it at all.

You can argue all day long about the relative merits of where thresholds should lie but there surely can’t be any circumstances where the mother of a young child is awarded a £20k bonus and doesn’t retain a single penny of it. How is that incentivising people to work?

It shouldn’t be possible that you can be worse off by earning more - especially as much as £20k more.

Ridiculous.

OP posts:
Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:04

HalloumiGeller · 29/01/2024 14:00

I'm sorry but an income of 100k is a huge amount of money (even after tax) so no, I do agree that they need to draw the line somewhere to be able to provide support to those that earn far less.

£100k after tax is ~£4,800 after tax, student loan, auto enrolment pension.

You might be spending over 80% of that on childcare.

Why is £100k where that line should be drawn?

OP posts:
Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 14:02

The current system is ridiculous. I earn a very good salary and managed to get it just below £100k with maximum pension contributions when my DC started nursery.

I was then awarded a £20k bonus which meant I moved back over the £100k limit.

I was taxed at 62% on this 20k and also lost my funded nursery hours at the same time plus the tax free childcare savings option.

The net result was that I was actually worse off for receiving the £20k bonus than had I not been given it at all.

You can argue all day long about the relative merits of where thresholds should lie but there surely can’t be any circumstances where the mother of a young child is awarded a £20k bonus and doesn’t retain a single penny of it. How is that incentivising people to work?

Natsku · 29/01/2024 14:02

Childcare/early childhood education should be affordable for every family, whatever their income level. In my country you pay on a sliding scale according to how much you earn so everyone can afford it, which is the best way (in my opinion) to do it. No one should be unable to work because they can't afford childcare, that puts women especially in a difficult position, forcing them to be financially reliant on their partner unless they have a high enough paying job.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:01

WillowBarkTree · 29/01/2024 13:52

Yes it should. Really how much money does this save? Given a tiny percentage of the population earns over 100k, and I imagine by the time you factor in women who therefore decide to drop their hours as it’s not worth it (and therefore pay less tax) it works out no different. These women may then decide not to increase hours (or instead spread over to fit round school days) again meaning less tax revenue.

I have read that 78,000 workers are thought to be impacted - combination of income level plus preschooler.

I don’t know what % of those will be salary sacrificing to get under the threshold however - or if this includes or excludes them.

OP posts:
HalloumiGeller · 29/01/2024 14:00

I'm sorry but an income of 100k is a huge amount of money (even after tax) so no, I do agree that they need to draw the line somewhere to be able to provide support to those that earn far less.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 29/01/2024 13:58

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 12:51

Healthcare is universal, school is universal- why not childcare?

Everyone can (and will) need health care. Everyone needs an education.

Not every family needs childcare, and not every family needs multiple places in childcare overlapping. It's a choice to have children and it's a choice to have children overlapping in childcare. And it's a choice you can have control over.

This makes no sense at all?

Do nurseries and childminders educate children or not? They do, so it’s the same as school.

Make it make sense before you object a fair point raised in a discussion.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 13:58

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 13:46

Additionally the £100k hasn't moved in years, if it had increased with inflation it would be nearer £150k now. Why is the correct number £100k and when won't it be?

Yes, the £100k limit for losing your personal allowance was introduced in 2010. The only change has been to reflect the change in the personal allowance - ie it applies to more income.

I’m not sure how long the £100k cap for childcare help has been in place - it predates tax-free childcare and free hours.

It’s definitely a situation which is escalating on a number of fronts:

  • the cost to those impacted
  • the increasing number of people paying it

At least 14 years of fiscal drag.

OP posts:
ShelleyPercy · 29/01/2024 13:53

Yes, nursery should be treated as any other educational institution and be universally available and free, as should university education.
The mobilisation of resources to provide such services is massive and requires huge changes, recruitment, training, infrastructure and most importantly political will.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 13:53

@scrunchmum

This is actually an important point that is often missed by many commentators.

Fiscal drag has also impacted these "adjustments" for higher earners.

£50k and £100k should be around £65k and £125k now with inflation.

So you end up paying higher tax due to marginal tax bands not budging AND you also get hit with higher taxes because the banding for childcare has not changed either.

And lower earners in the UK wonder why people feel "poor" at £100k when they have two kids.

What we need for the UK population is basic math classes. The vast majority seem incapable of doing basic math.

WillowBarkTree · 29/01/2024 13:52

Yes it should. Really how much money does this save? Given a tiny percentage of the population earns over 100k, and I imagine by the time you factor in women who therefore decide to drop their hours as it’s not worth it (and therefore pay less tax) it works out no different. These women may then decide not to increase hours (or instead spread over to fit round school days) again meaning less tax revenue.

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 13:50

*earns not want

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 13:48

@SouthLondonMum22 I think you would feel differently if you didn’t have a husband who want almost as much as you. One person on just over £100k, paying for 2 kids in childcare which is fairly normal, and an average house in London...you wouldn’t have much left.

DonnatellaLyman · 29/01/2024 13:47

I think it should be tapered (like child benefit) and on household income not single earner.

100k is about £5000 pcm. 2 children in full time nursery is easily 3500-4000 in many parts of the country (even more in London).

Lots of people struggle to pay for all housing/transport/bills/food on 1000pcm - it’s equivalent to a salary of under £14k without childcare costs - under minimum wage for a full time job.

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 13:46

Additionally the £100k hasn't moved in years, if it had increased with inflation it would be nearer £150k now. Why is the correct number £100k and when won't it be?

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 13:44

Nurseries are not just childcare/babysitting it's early years education. My daughter gets so much more from nursery than just childcare, they do phonics and forest school for example. Calling it childcare is just a con to make us think it's not worthwhile investing in.

OP I agree it should be universal, it's children missing out as much as anything else on important formative years.

CactusMactus · 29/01/2024 13:42

Make all early years childcare and education affordable and subsidised by government.
No having to apply for stuff.