Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:43

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:40

@Willyoujustbequiet why are households with a joint income of ~£200k eligible while one with an income of £101k is technically eligible for nothing?

That doesn’t seem to be targeting those who ‘need it most’ either.

I agree the single/joint income anomaly needs changing.

Teder · 29/01/2024 14:43

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:32

@Teder

Why do people always make this mistake?

Public services would IMPROVE if you subsidised childcare properly because more people would work.

More work = more economic acitvity = more tax revenue

Thats tax revenue that could then go to public services.

This is basic economics. Have you folks not learned this in school?

I learn this in my job in the public sector. Thank you.

As pointed out, the cut off only affects 78,000 individuals. I do think the cut off should be on household income, not individual but perhaps you missed that earlier point. It’s important women are not unfairly disadvantaged.

More people working does not automatically mean the government policy and allocation of funds will change. I assume you were taught this in school?

I do think there needs to government intervention in a number of areas, including childcare. Seeing other public services, it is simply not top of my list.

HalloumiGeller · 29/01/2024 14:43

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:40

The real problem now in the UK is that we have a majority of people who are now dependent on the state (54% are net tax recipients)

So of course they will vote for policies were "someone else that is not me has to pay for it"

Problem in the UK is that trend has come up against demographics and behavioral economics (put marginal tax rates high enough and people work less or change behaviors (like pension)).

So the end result will be people on £50k or above barely scrapping by (due to high marginal tax rates, childcare costs, student loans etc) while the rest (below £50k and subsidised by higher earners) keep getting poorer because the higher earners will not work more simply to get back less than 50% of their efforts.

Its complete economic madness.

This is because wages in this country are so pathetically low and costs are so high, it is not the publics fault, but the governments. The national minimum wage should be far higher than what it is.

Nobody wants to rely on government support, its incredibly stressful, but they don't have a choice.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:41

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:09

Nobody out of work needs free childcare before school. Only working people should have free childcare and it should not be means tested. This country penalises work and being middle class.

No because it benefits the child through socialisation.

Also many disabled people are unable to work and are already impacted by higher costs. Their children shouldn't lose out.

It absolutely should be means tested. Help should go to those who are the most vulnerable and not high earners

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 14:41

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:40

@Willyoujustbequiet why are households with a joint income of ~£200k eligible while one with an income of £101k is technically eligible for nothing?

That doesn’t seem to be targeting those who ‘need it most’ either.

If there is a household with 1x person on 99k and one person on 101k then they are idiots for not putting the 1k into pension.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 29/01/2024 14:41

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:15

The difference in take home pay is £1,288 on a £100k and £60k salary.

IF, the £100k earner has a student loan and the £60k does not.

That would almost cover three days a week for one child under 3 at my nursery.

The impact of student loans is quite significant - another problem which will come soon to rear its head.

When you think about the difference between £60k to £100k, it seems massive (£40k is a decent chunk of money). However, it’s crazy how much tax etc you lose when you get to £100k and the take home pay isn’t that much more than a salary that’s 40% less.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:40

The real problem now in the UK is that we have a majority of people who are now dependent on the state (54% are net tax recipients)

So of course they will vote for policies were "someone else that is not me has to pay for it"

Problem in the UK is that trend has come up against demographics and behavioral economics (put marginal tax rates high enough and people work less or change behaviors (like pension)).

So the end result will be people on £50k or above barely scrapping by (due to high marginal tax rates, childcare costs, student loans etc) while the rest (below £50k and subsidised by higher earners) keep getting poorer because the higher earners will not work more simply to get back less than 50% of their efforts.

Its complete economic madness.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:40

@Willyoujustbequiet why are households with a joint income of ~£200k eligible while one with an income of £101k is technically eligible for nothing?

That doesn’t seem to be targeting those who ‘need it most’ either.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 29/01/2024 14:39

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 14:34

Having two children close in age so in need of childcare at its highest price such as 2 under 2 is a choice.

Because in your world things go perfectly to plan. You’re clueless. 🙄

Of course. I definitely planned to have twins this time around.

Unplanned pregnancies happen
Unplanned situations happen such as twins

I still don't expect the government to support me financially because I'm a high earner. It needs to go towards the most in need.

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 14:38

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 14:34

Having two children close in age so in need of childcare at its highest price such as 2 under 2 is a choice.

Because in your world things go perfectly to plan. You’re clueless. 🙄

It's a viewpoint often trotted out by the wealthy when much poorer families have multiple children without the means to fund them.

Why not thus way round too?

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:37

ManchesterLu · 29/01/2024 12:38

You are a high earner. If you are struggling to get by on that, that's because of your own lifestyle decisions i.e. large mortgage, car finance, etc. Why should you have a lifestyle like that, and get the same free childcare as someone who has to make a decision about whether they can afford to feed themselves AND their child this week?

This.

Support needs to be targeted at those most in need, not high earners

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 14:34

Having two children close in age so in need of childcare at its highest price such as 2 under 2 is a choice.

Because in your world things go perfectly to plan. You’re clueless. 🙄

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/01/2024 14:33

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 13:48

@SouthLondonMum22 I think you would feel differently if you didn’t have a husband who want almost as much as you. One person on just over £100k, paying for 2 kids in childcare which is fairly normal, and an average house in London...you wouldn’t have much left.

Having two children close in age so in need of childcare at its highest price such as 2 under 2 is a choice.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:32

@Teder

Why do people always make this mistake?

Public services would IMPROVE if you subsidised childcare properly because more people would work.

More work = more economic acitvity = more tax revenue

Thats tax revenue that could then go to public services.

This is basic economics. Have you folks not learned this in school?

TerrysOrangeScot · 29/01/2024 14:28

deragod · 29/01/2024 14:20

I am not exactly sure but if I understand correctly Germany and Poland work this way. Pre-schools, schools and universities are free for citizens.
However, whole educational culture is different i.e. public (on the continent private) schools are not as big percentage of the educational market.

This is the same for those in Scotland, nurseries from 3 are 30 hours. This will be given to 2 year olds in due course.

University is covered for Scotland residents at Scotland universities.

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 14:28

Im amazed only 78,000 people are affected by this, as it feels like there’s a new thread on this every other day..

It doesn’t impact us, our kids are teenagers, but I still feel it’s wrong and needs changing. It’s possible to care about issues that don’t directly impact you.

Kpo58 · 29/01/2024 14:28

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:09

Nobody out of work needs free childcare before school. Only working people should have free childcare and it should not be means tested. This country penalises work and being middle class.

Why not? Many single parents would struggle to apply for jobs if they are having to try and keep preschool children at bay (especially if their only access to a computer is at a library). Sometimes they need to be able to get medical appointments that aren't suitable to take young children along to and they don't have anyone else to leave them with. Maybe they need to have a break before they have a breakdown working 24/7 looking after their children. Sometimes its just best for the kids to have a couple of hours at a place with activities that their parent(s) can't afford to do at home so that they can learn new things and make friends and start to be ready for school.

We don't live in a perfect world, but we should be trying to help all children, rather than letting those with parents you don't approve of fail in life.

I wish that free childcare was universal regardless of income to help those who are being financially abused to be able to start earning their own money and be able to separate from their partner without being made destitute or staying as that's the only way to keep a roof over the kids heads.

TerrysOrangeScot · 29/01/2024 14:26

In Scotland everyone is treated the same for the funded nursery hours and gets 30.
It should be like that all over. Other countries have lower childcare costs and it makes for a better society with working parents. Here it seems everyone wants your last penny.

No matter what you make there will be struggles as with bigger incomes there will be more outgoings in most cases.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:26

AngryBirdsNoMore · 29/01/2024 14:22

Im amazed only 78,000 people are affected by this, as it feels like there’s a new thread on this every other day..

I would assume that’s because of a few factors:

  • the introduction of 15 free hours from age 2 meaning people are impact and also discovering they’re losing more income if multiple kids
  • Fiscal drag meaning more families are being pulled into this problem (due to cliff edge at £100k with 60% tax).
  • The shock of discovering you are being taxed at over 100% on a large sum of money for earning £1 over a threshold is definitely a conversation piece
  • Mumsnet’s user base
OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/01/2024 14:24

Also I'm not sure if people realise that nurseries in London can be double in other areas of the UK (with more weeks closures). Our nursery in another UK city was circa £1k a month, closing bank Holidays and the week between Xmas and NY. Everyone I know in London pays at least £2k a month per child (and have a week shutdown over Easter, two weeks at Xmas and 2 weeks in summer, which means the cost of family holidays are also substantially more). £4k a month out of your take home pay, is insane.

So yes £100k is a hell of a lot of money. But it's still possible to earn this and pretty much be breaking even after childcare costs have been paid.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 29/01/2024 14:22

Im amazed only 78,000 people are affected by this, as it feels like there’s a new thread on this every other day..

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:20

WavingCatsandDogs · 29/01/2024 14:16

It's not free for a start.

And it doesnt even begin to cover the real cost of providing childcare.

You can afford it and it's not forever.

And then what is your justification for the rates the likes of @Charlie2121 , where they received £0 of a £20,000 bonus because of this cliff edge.

Is that just fine then, only a few years of it? Actually losing money if you get a mid year bonus or promotion?

OP posts:
Oisille88 · 29/01/2024 14:20

we’re in the same boat, and I think it’s very unfair. My issue is not so much that earners over 100k don’t get the help, but how unfairly it is applied. Two earners on 99k each get the help, a single income household on 100k doesn’t, and starts to lose their personal allowance etc. the thresholds also haven’t moved in years, so more parents are being caught by this, especially in London. Given the likelihood the man will be the higher earner, I’d argue this policy is likely to compel more mums to give up work because paying for full time nursery is around 19k a year - which is a huge amount of money. I’d also argue that the variation in the cost of living makes the universal nature of this cap unfair (also for the child benefit cap). Lastly, I have reservations about making so many benefits earnings dependent, as the more you exclude people from state benefits, the less they are invested in those. There are also probably not that many parents of nursery age children on 100k salaries, so I suspect the cost to the government would not be so high. We also need to consider whether it’s really a good idea to disincentivise high earners by taxing them so highly.

deragod · 29/01/2024 14:20

I am not exactly sure but if I understand correctly Germany and Poland work this way. Pre-schools, schools and universities are free for citizens.
However, whole educational culture is different i.e. public (on the continent private) schools are not as big percentage of the educational market.

Teder · 29/01/2024 14:18

If you earn over £100k, you are in the top 2% of earners. I think it does not need adjusting given it benefits 98% of earning parents. It just so happens so many on MN earn the holy grail of the golden six figure salary and want funded childcare hours.

Given the state of public services, I can see many areas that needs an injection of fund and there’s a whole long list that needs prioritising before this.