Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 29/01/2024 15:07

I think it's appalling that people earning a decent wage are still getting more out of tax than they are putting in. Wages across the board are shocking low.

RatatouillePie · 29/01/2024 15:05

I appreciate many of you think that £100k is a lot of money, but what about the OTHER person in the couple!?

I returned to work with twins, and had to return just two days a week to teaching. After childcare and petrol I earned £20 a week. If I'd worked a third day I would have paid tax on the income so I would have lost £30 a week overall.

So if my partner earned over £100k, then it would mean I'd be returning to work to lose money, or giving up my career until the child(ren) went to school. That's demoralising.

And on that basis alone, the 30 hours free childcare should be available to anyone who WANTS to have a career and work.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 15:03

Spectre8 · 29/01/2024 14:59

As a childfree person I'm selfishly saying no becuase I'll end up paying more tax to fund it and I don't get any benefit otherthan a measly 25% off my council tax. 😤 there is already enough help for families. I earn half of what you do so quite frankly I don't feel you need more help whilst I will end taking home even less to fund it. Does it bither u if peoplel ike us end up taking home less money becuase of your choices? No I doubt it.

And before someone comes out with the whole they will be paying for ur pension, I'm already making sure I have enough without needing state pension cos who knows what will happen in 30yrs time

At £50k = £3,064 take home pay and £7k in tax paid

At £100k with two kids in nursery = £1,400 take home pay and £25k in tax paid

At £120k with two kids in nursery = £2,084 take home pay and £36k in tax paid

OP posts:
PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 15:03

Second section should be in bold too.

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 15:02

Of course. I definitely planned to have twins this time around.

Unplanned pregnancies happen
Unplanned situations happen such as twins

So you should know it’s not always a choice then. That’s just one reason, there are others.

I still don't expect the government to support me financially because I'm a high earner. It needs to go towards the most in need.

But you have 2 high wages going into your household.

With one person on £100k, 2 kids in childcare costing £4k + and an average mortgage, plus bills, commuting costs, food, nappies, student loan etc ...they do need it. Yes, people earning less need help too, but to just pretend someone on £100k paying £5.5k+ out on childcare and mortgage on a modest house, couldn’t do with some help is madness. And it doesn’t make financial sense to the country anyway.

As I say, my children are teens and we are very comfortable so this doesn’t impact me at all, but I can still see this needs changing.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 15:01

Araminta1003 · 29/01/2024 14:53

“The real problem now in the UK is that we have a majority of people who are now dependent on the state (54% are net tax recipients)

So of course they will vote for policies were "someone else that is not me has to pay for it"

Problem in the UK is that trend has come up against demographics and behavioral economics (put marginal tax rates high enough and people work less or change behaviors (like pension)).

So the end result will be people on £50k or above barely scrapping by (due to high marginal tax rates, childcare costs, student loans etc) while the rest (below £50k and subsidised by higher earners) keep getting poorer because the higher earners will not work more simply to get back less than 50% of their efforts.

Its complete economic madness.”

Agreed and it is also really stupid to disincentivise higher earners from having more children. It is all upside down. Everyone has a right to have children but it isn’t fair on children if poorer parents are more incentivised to have them or too many of them than richer parents who can give them a better life.
Once lots of poorer people have children the state then has to support those children, but it does not make it fair on those children.

👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻

ToWorkOrNotToWork · 29/01/2024 15:01

You’re right op, and I do not believe it is policy, just a side-effect of policies not especially well thought through, and when the problems are revealed it’s really not something any government really cares about. The problem affects quite a small number of people, and most people can’t be bothered to understand the maths. It wouldn’t win enough votes to be worth fixing it. Tax and benefits aren’t fair, which is evident when you read umpteen threads on MN.

It does feel pretty harsh when you see how incredibly expensive a good nursery is in the SE. These thresholds haven’t changed in many years and they are eroded by inflation.

The only good thing about it is you only put up with it for a few years for each child you have. It’s not surprising perhaps that many people are choosing to stay child free or have only one child. We had a big age gap so our finances could recover. Not ideal.

Spectre8 · 29/01/2024 14:59

As a childfree person I'm selfishly saying no becuase I'll end up paying more tax to fund it and I don't get any benefit otherthan a measly 25% off my council tax. 😤 there is already enough help for families. I earn half of what you do so quite frankly I don't feel you need more help whilst I will end taking home even less to fund it. Does it bither u if peoplel ike us end up taking home less money becuase of your choices? No I doubt it.

And before someone comes out with the whole they will be paying for ur pension, I'm already making sure I have enough without needing state pension cos who knows what will happen in 30yrs time

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:59

Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 14:55

The higher earners fund those who are most in need. If you don’t look after the higher earners everyone else would soon be in trouble.

All tax payers fund the vulnerable, not just high earners. And of course people move up.and down that scale throughout their lives.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:58

@Viviennemary

The lower earner is paying in £x in tax and extracting £y in benefits.

With y >>>> x

They are not subsidising anything. You dont understand that higher earners do not get a subsidy. They pay the full price from post tax income AND they pay large amounts of tax.

There is so much entitlement in the UK it is astonishing.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:58

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:50

Not all areas have such groups and the odd hour here and there is no substitute for nursery.

It's interesting you feel high earners slave away. Does that mean those lower down don't? In my experience it's quite often the opposite.

I was a high earner and was more than happy for my taxes to be used to support the most vulnerable in our society. I'm certainly not the only one who feels this way. It's called having a conscience.

It’s really not my problem if people can’t get to toddler groups. It’s not society’s job to solve each and every problem for the individual. I all families with 2 working parents should receive funded childcare, regardless of earnings.

Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 14:57

Viviennemary · 29/01/2024 14:55

The subsidised care is coming out of a pot, tax payers contribute to the pot. And the point is are people earning £100k a year a priority for tax payers money for subsidised childcare. I would say absolutely not.

The higher earners are the ones who put all the money into the pot. If they decide the system makes it pointless for them to keep earning at such levels while their children are in nursery, who do you then think will make up the shortfall to fund everyone else?

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:56

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:52

But then we’re just locked in a kind of emotional blackmail where we do everything to support other people’s DC not our own. And their parents just get to keep popping them out knowing other people will stump up the cash ‘because it’s mean if you don’t’. Is that fair?

This is so short sighted.

Do you not understand that circumstances change? Just because someone finds themselves destitute at one point does not mean that they have always been that way or will always be.

Being a high earner or benefit claimant isn't mutually exclusive.

Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 14:55

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:37

This.

Support needs to be targeted at those most in need, not high earners

The higher earners fund those who are most in need. If you don’t look after the higher earners everyone else would soon be in trouble.

Viviennemary · 29/01/2024 14:55

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:44

Lower earners aren’t funding childcare for higher earners FYI.

You need to be earning quite a bit to be a ‘net contributor’ ie paying in more than you use.

The subsidised care is coming out of a pot, tax payers contribute to the pot. And the point is are people earning £100k a year a priority for tax payers money for subsidised childcare. I would say absolutely not.

Araminta1003 · 29/01/2024 14:53

“The real problem now in the UK is that we have a majority of people who are now dependent on the state (54% are net tax recipients)

So of course they will vote for policies were "someone else that is not me has to pay for it"

Problem in the UK is that trend has come up against demographics and behavioral economics (put marginal tax rates high enough and people work less or change behaviors (like pension)).

So the end result will be people on £50k or above barely scrapping by (due to high marginal tax rates, childcare costs, student loans etc) while the rest (below £50k and subsidised by higher earners) keep getting poorer because the higher earners will not work more simply to get back less than 50% of their efforts.

Its complete economic madness.”

Agreed and it is also really stupid to disincentivise higher earners from having more children. It is all upside down. Everyone has a right to have children but it isn’t fair on children if poorer parents are more incentivised to have them or too many of them than richer parents who can give them a better life.
Once lots of poorer people have children the state then has to support those children, but it does not make it fair on those children.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:52

Beezknees · 29/01/2024 14:51

Because then you're punishing the children. It's to benefit the CHILDREN, not the adults.

Exactly.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:52

Beezknees · 29/01/2024 14:51

Because then you're punishing the children. It's to benefit the CHILDREN, not the adults.

But then we’re just locked in a kind of emotional blackmail where we do everything to support other people’s DC not our own. And their parents just get to keep popping them out knowing other people will stump up the cash ‘because it’s mean if you don’t’. Is that fair?

Beezknees · 29/01/2024 14:51

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:44

That’s what baby and toddler groups are for. And school at 4, which is younger than many other countries.

Why should higher earners be happy to do nothing but slave away to support the most ‘vulnerable’ who get the lot for free? It’s about time people took responsibility for their own lives and choice to have children. We’re all adults aren’t we?

Edited

Because then you're punishing the children. It's to benefit the CHILDREN, not the adults.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:50

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:44

That’s what baby and toddler groups are for. And school at 4, which is younger than many other countries.

Why should higher earners be happy to do nothing but slave away to support the most ‘vulnerable’ who get the lot for free? It’s about time people took responsibility for their own lives and choice to have children. We’re all adults aren’t we?

Edited

Not all areas have such groups and the odd hour here and there is no substitute for nursery.

It's interesting you feel high earners slave away. Does that mean those lower down don't? In my experience it's quite often the opposite.

I was a high earner and was more than happy for my taxes to be used to support the most vulnerable in our society. I'm certainly not the only one who feels this way. It's called having a conscience.

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:49

@Teder Is it unfair that the thresholds have been frozen for a decade meaning more and more people are excluded?

Is it unfair that the % loss to those people increases every time a new scheme is introduced?

Why is £100k the right place to have the cut off?

OP posts:
Isitjustthat · 29/01/2024 14:46

SecondUsername4me · 29/01/2024 12:51

Healthcare is universal, school is universal- why not childcare?

Everyone can (and will) need health care. Everyone needs an education.

Not every family needs childcare, and not every family needs multiple places in childcare overlapping. It's a choice to have children and it's a choice to have children overlapping in childcare. And it's a choice you can have control over.

It's a choice to get education and choice to get healthcare. You can choose to remain illiterate or remain sick.
I am so sick of the woke cult saying having children is lifestyle choice. Having children is how human civilization survives dumbfucks.

Teder · 29/01/2024 14:44

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:40

@Willyoujustbequiet why are households with a joint income of ~£200k eligible while one with an income of £101k is technically eligible for nothing?

That doesn’t seem to be targeting those who ‘need it most’ either.

This is particularly unfair and I cannot make sense of this decision. Ditto the cut off for child benefit!

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:44

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:41

No because it benefits the child through socialisation.

Also many disabled people are unable to work and are already impacted by higher costs. Their children shouldn't lose out.

It absolutely should be means tested. Help should go to those who are the most vulnerable and not high earners

That’s what baby and toddler groups are for. And school at 4, which is younger than many other countries.

Why should higher earners be happy to do nothing but slave away to support the most ‘vulnerable’ who get the lot for free? It’s about time people took responsibility for their own lives and choice to have children. We’re all adults aren’t we?

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 14:43

It's really not all about who we support and don't though. It's much bigger than that and basic economics at thatS

If someone earns just over £100k they are putting money into pensions etc to circumvent it, or cutting hours = less tax take.

If one of a couple earns over £100k and the other earns £30k (probably the woman) then the woman ends up giving up work. Again less tax take.

We have a workforce crisis in this country especially since covid where lots of people retired early. Tphe government are trying to get newly retired people back into work for example. This is a whole group of people who aren't working as it's not worthwhile for them to do so. It's nonsensical.