Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ be universal?

438 replies

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 12:03

Having attempted to apply for the new 15 free hours for my nearly two year old, I discovered you are not eligible if you earn over £100k.

My four year old also receives only 15 of the 30 free hours for the same reason.

I am not sure if the additional 15 hours from 9 months / 2 years will be income contingent.

Between this and tax-free childcare, I will lose about £12,000 of post tax income in 2024/5 tax year.

This seems very onerous!

Should tax-free childcare and ‘free hours’ not be universal? It is an expense to allow me to work, and I’m paying quite a bit of tax.

Also being applied as a cliff edge is brutal, seems to create an artificial ‘cap’ on the amount parents of preschoolers can earn.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 16:38

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 16:15

@Naptrappedmummy

Ok for how long do you think people should look after their own children after birth before other people fund childcare for them?

From 9 months upwards when SMP stops... otherwise woman (more often than not) give up work and pay less tax. It's economics.

A government investing in childcare gets significantly more back in tax take as women can continue working and people don't circumvent their taxable income to pay less tax.

Also it's not "other people" funding childcare, it's literally the higher earners paying more tax and also paying more for non funded hours (subsidising those getting funded hours) given that the funding is not enough to cover "free" hours.

Edited

I mean those not working.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 16:37

WithACatLikeTread · 29/01/2024 16:27

Most people pay nursery fees even though they are on UC. It is only 85%. Very few have it funded for them. To answer your question when maternity pay ends there should be subsidised childcare basically from one.

I have taken both my kids to playgroups. We are very lucky there but it isn't the same as a full day at nursery. It sounds like you don't even want any funded and children start school totally underprepared for it. I imagine some children will be even less likely to be able to do things if they don't have preschool to teach them as some parents won't.

Most people on UC don’t work so how are they paying?

WithACatLikeTread · 29/01/2024 16:27

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 16:03

Ok for how long do you think people should look after their own children after birth before other people fund childcare for them?

Most people pay nursery fees even though they are on UC. It is only 85%. Very few have it funded for them. To answer your question when maternity pay ends there should be subsidised childcare basically from one.

I have taken both my kids to playgroups. We are very lucky there but it isn't the same as a full day at nursery. It sounds like you don't even want any funded and children start school totally underprepared for it. I imagine some children will be even less likely to be able to do things if they don't have preschool to teach them as some parents won't.

Araminta1003 · 29/01/2024 16:18

“Surprised it took five pages to mention the poor popping out kids.”

Almost 1 in 4 children are eligible for Free School Meals. Something has gone horribly wrong.

Meanwhile, the politicians think short termist and cater to the elderly and middle aged voting base, because that is where the numbers are. We cannot carry on like this because it will destroy the country and causes security issues long term.

Look at what China and other countries are doing to incentivise people (and certain people at that) to have children and at a younger age. Some cantons in Switzerland let you deduct taxes depending on the amount of children you have. Let’s say you earn 120k and have 3 children - you get to deduct £7k per child and then only pay tax on the remainder. That is reclaimed through self assessment for higher earners.

To become more productive again, all work has to be worth it at all levels and people having children across the income spectrum have to be supported and especially at the higher ends, because that is where the kids end up with a better experience and the parents tend to input things schools cannot make up for in school hours alone. Ask any teacher or head teacher. It is stereotypical but you need 2-3 at the middle and higher income levels. The Nordic countries have understood this ages ago.

scrunchmum · 29/01/2024 16:15

@Naptrappedmummy

Ok for how long do you think people should look after their own children after birth before other people fund childcare for them?

From 9 months upwards when SMP stops... otherwise woman (more often than not) give up work and pay less tax. It's economics.

A government investing in childcare gets significantly more back in tax take as women can continue working and people don't circumvent their taxable income to pay less tax.

Also it's not "other people" funding childcare, it's literally the higher earners paying more tax and also paying more for non funded hours (subsidising those getting funded hours) given that the funding is not enough to cover "free" hours.

supernova12 · 29/01/2024 16:09

@Naptrappedmummy toddlers groups aren't someone else looking after your child

supernova12 · 29/01/2024 16:09

ProudDada · 29/01/2024 16:04

I'm not sure if it's been said, but there is no earnings limit for the 30 hours free child care in Scotland.

Scotland is wonderful.....

ProudDada · 29/01/2024 16:04

I'm not sure if it's been said, but there is no earnings limit for the 30 hours free child care in Scotland.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 16:03

WithACatLikeTread · 29/01/2024 15:58

So those children get more and more disadvantaged in order that richer children get the opportunity? Play groups are not a replacement for nursery and especially for preschool preparation for school.

Ok for how long do you think people should look after their own children after birth before other people fund childcare for them?

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 16:00

Teder · 29/01/2024 15:25

You are expecting “the state to raise them” as you believe you should have funded childcare. Therefore, you’re as bad as the people you’re criticising.

Big difference between contributing to something you use, and not contributing to something you use.

WithACatLikeTread · 29/01/2024 15:58

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:58

It’s really not my problem if people can’t get to toddler groups. It’s not society’s job to solve each and every problem for the individual. I all families with 2 working parents should receive funded childcare, regardless of earnings.

So those children get more and more disadvantaged in order that richer children get the opportunity? Play groups are not a replacement for nursery and especially for preschool preparation for school.

Charlie2121 · 29/01/2024 15:56

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 14:59

All tax payers fund the vulnerable, not just high earners. And of course people move up.and down that scale throughout their lives.

That’s simply not true. Anyone earning under about 45k isn’t even funding themselves. Only about 20% of people are net contributors. Everyone else is subsidised to some degree.

OCDmama · 29/01/2024 15:48

@ManchesterLu
It's a bit hypocritical to talk about 'life style choices' and then refer to people who have to make tough financial decisions. What if I were to say lower income families made the choice to be minimum wage?

I think it should be universal, or at least looking at overall household income. Lots of women with a high earning partner aren't eligible for enough childcare to afford to work. They'll have lost child benefit too. But what if she wants to work? What if he's financially abusive? She has absolutely no income and is entirely dependent on him. Why is that acceptable? What if he leaves her after her career 'break' and she's completely fucked when it comes to employment having been out of the workforce for years?

Wahawa · 29/01/2024 15:48

Also OP we are exploring the option of moving to other countries in middle east where there are no taxes and much better quality of life for your money. if your industry allows then you should explore that option too. Some of our friends have moved and they totally love it. No point just paying higher taxes here to be treated unfairly just because you are hardworking and well qualified to be able to earn that sort of money here. This country rewards mediocrity and laziness!

WithACatLikeTread · 29/01/2024 15:43

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:52

But then we’re just locked in a kind of emotional blackmail where we do everything to support other people’s DC not our own. And their parents just get to keep popping them out knowing other people will stump up the cash ‘because it’s mean if you don’t’. Is that fair?

Surprised it took five pages to mention the poor popping out kids.

Wahawa · 29/01/2024 15:39

OP just chuck money in pension pot till your DC are young, that will save you tax and get free childcare. That's what all our friends have done and we do. You'll have a healthy pension pot.

supernova12 · 29/01/2024 15:27

You are having children which the country needs and working.... should receive a gold medal

supernova12 · 29/01/2024 15:26

Mumsnet don't understand you pay tax and don't get the benefits from it.

If you didn't work - no income tax taken, public purse accessed... but they don't see it like that on mumsnet

hotpotlover · 29/01/2024 15:26

Unfortunately I don't earn 100k, but I agree with you - tax free childcare and the 15 hours should be available to you.

Someone posted on here that it's your choice to have more than one child in nursery.

I think that's ridiculous - as a higher earner you probably took more time to study/build your career.

When you're a certain age as a woman, you have no other choice than having small age gaps, if you want to give your child a sibling.

You also pay more in taxes, so you're giving back to society.

Childcare costs shouldn't be so high in the first place - other countries such as Germany offer childcare that is very cheap, so why can't we?

Teder · 29/01/2024 15:25

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 15:11

It’s not contradictory at all. That’s like saying because I don’t think the state should intervene in cutting your grass, I can’t have another opinion on whether they should fund the maintenance of parks and forests. Just silly.

I find it repugnant that people have children then just expect the state to raise them because they can’t be bothered or clearly can’t afford it. They’re the real culprit here.

You are expecting “the state to raise them” as you believe you should have funded childcare. Therefore, you’re as bad as the people you’re criticising.

Teder · 29/01/2024 15:23

.

PaintingPictures · 29/01/2024 15:20

I find it repugnant that people have children then just expect the state to raise them because they can’t be bothered or clearly can’t afford it. They’re the real culprit here.

They don’t expect the state to raise them, what a load of exaggerated nonsense.

Teder · 29/01/2024 15:18

Nursery772 · 29/01/2024 14:49

@Teder Is it unfair that the thresholds have been frozen for a decade meaning more and more people are excluded?

Is it unfair that the % loss to those people increases every time a new scheme is introduced?

Why is £100k the right place to have the cut off?

I didn’t comment on the cut off number. I said believe it should be total household income and therefore, raised.

It must feel like a giant issue for you but as I said, it’s less than 80k individual earners so I can see why it’s not top of the priority list for change.

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 15:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 15:08

You completely contradict yourself by saying its not the place for society to solve each and every problem for the individual yet demand higher earners have their childcare paid for.

I find the idea that the wealthy receive support whilst children go cold and hungry at the other end wholly repugnant. It's immoral.

It’s not contradictory at all. That’s like saying because I don’t think the state should intervene in cutting your grass, I can’t have another opinion on whether they should fund the maintenance of parks and forests. Just silly.

I find it repugnant that people have children then just expect the state to raise them because they can’t be bothered or clearly can’t afford it. They’re the real culprit here.

Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2024 15:08

Naptrappedmummy · 29/01/2024 14:58

It’s really not my problem if people can’t get to toddler groups. It’s not society’s job to solve each and every problem for the individual. I all families with 2 working parents should receive funded childcare, regardless of earnings.

You completely contradict yourself by saying its not the place for society to solve each and every problem for the individual yet demand higher earners have their childcare paid for.

I find the idea that the wealthy receive support whilst children go cold and hungry at the other end wholly repugnant. It's immoral.

Swipe left for the next trending thread