Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Looking after Grandchildren

90 replies

RubyRed55 · 29/01/2024 10:19

My Step daughter has 2 young children (baby and 5 yr old)
I've never really been a big 'children' person. I enjoy seeing them occasionally and I am known as nan to them which is lovely. I work part-time and DH full-time. Occasionally we have been asked if we can have GC some days during school holidays.
DH has to take annual leave to accommodate these days.
I like having them for a couple of hours -but I don't want to get involved in having them for full days during school holidays as they get older. I'm just being honest.
DH can if that's what he wishes - but it's really not for me.
My work schedule although part time can be quite haphazard and I cover job share holidays etc so I can't commit in advance anyway.
I've never wanted children of my own, enjoy my life the way it is, and don't have a close relationship with my SD.
AIBU?
If I mention this to DH, I feel like he'll think I'm an unkind person.
I'm perfectly happy GC visiting/helping out for a couple of hours here and there - but I just don't want to set a precedent for childcare during school holidays as time goes on. Maternal grandmother's work FT.
Am I awful?
How do I navigate?

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 29/01/2024 15:34

Im child free by choice and this is why i wouldnt date a man with even grown up kids because a lot of grandparents are expected to do child care now even the step ones (though not so much the step grandads i bet)

shreknjumps · 29/01/2024 15:23

Just wait and see what they do, you can't have had many school holidays so far so it might be that they don't ask for much anyway.

I'd be tempted to fill my calendar with various bits and bobs for the coming Easter holidays whilst I get the measure of how much they're likely to ask 😬

LifeExperience · 29/01/2024 14:54

I am in my 60s and will watch grandchildren for a few hours, but not full days. I had no help because we lived away from family, so I never got so much as an hour of childcare without paying for it. I have chronic pain and like my freedom to get out and about on days when my pain is less. My children, not being self-involved twats, completely understand.

Vinrouge4 · 29/01/2024 14:43

I’m a grandmother of several and right from the start I said I wouldn’t be doing any childcare. Shocked faces all around. I don’t mind the odd day here or there but I brought up three children abroad so just had to get on with it. I’m now enjoying not having any ties and being able to travel and do things spontaneously. Don’t feel guilty. Just be honest!

RubyRed55 · 29/01/2024 14:16

Pleasantly surprised and grateful of all the support regarding this! I expected to be hung out to dry, so makes me feel less unreasonable. I am happy to help occasionally for a few hours, but I don't have childcare experience and don't want to end up being allocated holiday childcare for 'full days' on my days off work. I also have elderly parents, so down the line i could potentially end up getting my plate overly full with things. I won't offer/mention anything and just go with it and see how it plays out down the line, but have the confidence to say no to full days.

OP posts:
LadyBird1973 · 29/01/2024 14:02

If you aren't particularly bonded to the kids or to your step daughter, I can well understand why you wouldn't want to spend your time doing the relentless work that is childcare!
I wouldn't have a big, full on discussion about it though - not everything has to be said out loud. I would just not volunteer to help or be available. Your dh will learn that if he agrees to do childcare then it's him who will actually be doing it and not you. No need to state out loud that you don't feel about them the way that he does because even though you are right, it might still be a bit hurtful to him to hear it said. Unless he does try to pressure you into being there with him all the time, in which case I'd say it's okay to be more blunt.

He should understand that someone who chose not to have kids , is unlikely to want to do lots of childcare.

I to also think he has a responsibility to you not to fill up all his time with the kids. He must remember he's a husband too and leave done time for you both to do things together.

hattie43 · 29/01/2024 11:38

Don't do it , simples .

CactusMactus · 29/01/2024 11:36

Just be honest.

I also don't agree that maternal grandparents MUST look after grandchildren. The only people who must look after children are parents and people paid to do so... everyone else is kindness and willingness on their part...

lookwhatyoudidthere · 29/01/2024 11:34

Can you make yourself scarce, i.e hide at work whilst your DH cares for them? He may feel inclined to do so, you neither have to blocker the request, nor be a willing participant. I’d revert to him and say ‘I’m at work on those days, hope you all have fun!’.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/01/2024 11:26

Soooooo refreshing to see a thread in support of a stepmum and especially one saying that a middle aged woman can have boundaries and doesn’t need to bend to every demand of her family!

Stompythedinosaur · 29/01/2024 11:21

Well, I think it's fine, but equally, you'll probably end up with a more distant relationship.

The only thing I think is maybe unreasonable is you thinking there is something unusual about asking her grandfather to take time off to care for his grandchildren, that seems like a pretty normal situation to me.

Bluenotgreen · 29/01/2024 11:21

YANBU but I would avoid making a Big Announcement about it. Just wait until a situation crops up where you are asked and say you cannot do it at that point.

Agree with PP, much better if DH has them in their own home.

Mothership4two · 29/01/2024 11:18

No you don't @Laiste. Sorry to hear that about your mum - that's harsh. I have never really put myself out for her since then although I would have done anything for my FIL who was a lovely man. She is mid 80s now and, fortunately, very fit, active, still drives and has a good social life, but down the road I wouldn't ever have her living with us, especially as she has three other children who could take her and I am an only child (I'm reserving a spot for my parents!). She'd also be a bit of a nightmare TBH which DH recognises. I am perfectly friendly to her and have done things to help her out but don't go out of my way (if that makes sense?) and DH does loads for her. But her attitude is my attitude.

Fortunately DPs have and will go above and beyond for both DS!

Newnamesameoldlurker · 29/01/2024 11:17

Totally agree with pp that you're entitled to your own boundaries, but you say you are worried DH will think you are unkind- he may think this. It doesn't mean you actually are unkind, but he may feel a bit hurt. Talk about it with him. Ultimately his feelings about it may be a consequence you'll have to accept if you don't want to get involved with his GC. You're not unreasonable though. Maybe to spare your SD's feelings you could emphasise the angle of having no experience with young children ie not qualified to do it, as opposed to just not wanting to (which is perfectly valid- just thinking of tact and diplomacy!)

ShoePalaver · 29/01/2024 11:11

ElevenSeven · 29/01/2024 10:20

‘No, sorry, I won’t be able to do that.’

Change subject. Walk off, anything you need to.

Don’t get dragged into it

Not sure just refusing and walking off is a great way to communicate with your husband..surely you can sit down and have a conversation about it.

RosePetals86 · 29/01/2024 11:09

Just be honest! If you dh wants to commit that’s fine but you dont have to. Maternal GM should be picking up the slack also- not step GM!

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 29/01/2024 11:09

Windymcwindyson · 29/01/2024 10:23

No need for a big speech surely? He can have them if he wants to. Imo it isn't about liking dc in general but those particular dc - who will likely bare characteristics of the man you love. Either by nature or nurture...isn't that worth investing a bit of your time?

Well no, not necessarily. If OP didn’t want her own children then presumably she wouldn’t find the company of other people’s children particularly life-enhancing regardless of any characteristics they may have inherited from her husband. Like OP, I am childfree so wouldn’t choose to spend my time looking after anybody else’s.

ShoePalaver · 29/01/2024 11:09

I don't leave my 2 with either grandma all day..it's hard work! (I suspect they are much older than you but that's not really the point - full days are a big ask) And if you don't have your own children I would think it even less reasonable. I wonder how much childcare your husband did when his daughter was young? Did he do any at all?

I would just be honest, if asked, and say that while you support your husband looking after the grandchildren, and will be happy to help i an emergency for for a couple of hours here and there, you don't want to look after them on your own for full days as it's too much, you want to keep your time free for work as needed and your existing interests. You can support by appearing for an hour here and there for example if he's getting the baby down for a nap and needs someone to sit with the 5 year old, or helping get the lunch ready while he plays with them etc. He'll be run ragged with 2 children that age so will be very grateful for any help I'm sure, as well as any time you spend in sole charge!

Also I feel like if your husband has a few days ion his own with them he'll realise why you aren't keen

Hankunamatata · 29/01/2024 11:08

If dh wants to do it he takes leave or unpaid leave.

ToWorkOrNotToWork · 29/01/2024 11:07

yanbu

you don’t even really need to justify it! you shouldnt feel obliged to care for your (step)grandchildren in the 21st century.

I’d never expect gps to provide holiday care for my kids, If they want to help for a day here or there, or have the occasional sleepover - then sure, that’s great and I very happily pack them up for a stay with them GPs. But there’s no expectation. There are zillions of holiday clubs that are fantastic for school age kids - Our local authority does a cheap one which is amazing.

I guess my exception might be if the parents were really unwell or the kids had SEN - I’d try and provide some respite support if I could

Beautiful3 · 29/01/2024 11:05

I would tell husband, " I'm sorry I don't want to commit to childcare over the holidays. You can do what you want to, but I won't be helping." That way he can't try to rope you into it. Kids that age are such hard work, I was glad when mine got to age 6.

ilovesooty · 29/01/2024 10:58

ElevenSeven · 29/01/2024 10:20

‘No, sorry, I won’t be able to do that.’

Change subject. Walk off, anything you need to.

Don’t get dragged into it

This, but don't apologise.

caringcarer · 29/01/2024 10:58

I'd let your DH crack on if he wants to use a few days of his leave caring for his dgc. You don't have to join in if you don't want to. 5 and a baby are hard work when they get to 10 and 5 they will be easier. I think my MiL found my DS a handful when he was younger but FiL always invited him alone for a week on the summer holidays because they lived by seaside. Fil took time off to care for him and take him out and about. Mil cooked meals but rarely went out with them. Now my DS is an adult and FiL has died,. Mil is living alone and in her 80's and is always delighted when my DS goes up to visit her. She is always issuing my DS invitations to visit her.

TinyTeachr · 29/01/2024 10:56

It's totally reasonable for you to choose what you do with your free time. You don't have to provide any childcare.

If your DH chooses to, that's his shout. Just don't get drawn in. It's the same as any other hobby he may wish to use his leave for.

He polite to everyone, but that doesn't mean you have to provide childcare. Say nothing unless asked, but if you are just be calm and polite and state that you aren't available to do baby sitting in the holidays.

It may affect the relationship you have with them. But as long as you aren't rude it's not likely to do much damage.

AnneLovesGilbert · 29/01/2024 10:53

You don’t need to bring it up with him or make any sort of announcement. Let him make plans he’ll honour, go out if you don’t fancy helping, decline any requests just to you.