Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does a mother's jewelry traditionally pass to daughters or daughters & DILs?

367 replies

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 29/01/2024 16:28

The situation you describe, especially with your update about the fathers watches, seems pretty clear cut that the daughters should get the jewellery. I'd be telling the DILs to swivel!

Cincinnatus · 29/01/2024 16:23

My jewellery will only be going to my daughter. I can’t risk a daughter in law running off with it.

BricksTricks · 29/01/2024 16:18

Unless it's high value, I would expect it to go to daughters or preferably granddaughters for first pick, then offered to DIL rather than sold if anything is not needed. I wouldn't expect DS to get my mum's jewellery, nor my MIL's, but he has a watch and pen I think from my dad, barometer and paperweights from my grandads and will get similar type of stuff from FIL. DH knows from the will that most of my jewellery and handbags are for my niece, sisters and then SIL/ his nieces to take their pick, only wedding/engagement ring and a couple of daily wear necklaces / handbags could be kept back by DS for sentimental reasons. These things should be worn and used if anyone likes them, but we specified clearly in the will that items of sentimental value should be taken and I would expect the order to be: DS then niece, sisters, his nieces, SIL.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 29/01/2024 16:06

Why are you making the decision? Is that something the mother has written about in her will? it seems you’ve already made your mind up. What the father did with his jewellery is irrelevant, and this is the wrong time to be making such decisions let a decent interval pass.

Claricestarling1 · 29/01/2024 16:01

It should go to the daughters and if they so wish they can then give a piece or pieces to the DILs..but the daughters absolutely should get the jewellery

Sapphire387 · 29/01/2024 15:58

I think mostly daughters, but if the relationship was close, it would be nice for the DIL's to have one piece each, to remember her by. But why are they 'up in arms'? I don't like the sound of that at all. It sounds rude and grabby.

RuthW · 29/01/2024 15:52

Daughters and granddaughters

caringcarer · 29/01/2024 15:36

Pookerrod · 29/01/2024 10:30

When my DH’s grandmother died who had some beautiful jewellery, the jewellery box was passed around the female members of the family for everyone to take something to remember her by.

It was passed around privately, in order of familial closeness. So her daughter took what she wanted, then granddaughter, then me, then my daughter.

I thought that was a lovely way to do it.

That's a very nice way to do it. I have a lot of lovely jewelry as it is my weakness. I've taken a photo and laminated of each piece and given each piece a number. I've only got one DD and she likes platinum but a lot of my jewelry is yellow gold which she's not keen on. I don't have any granddaughters. I do have lots of nieces so they can have at least one ring each and either a necklace or earrings too. I've tried to leave it to my nieces I think will like it, either because they have complimented me on a piece in the past or just eye colour. I've got 2 nieces with green eyes so I'm leaving the emerald/diamond pieces just to them, nieces with blue eyes will get sapphire or sapphire and diamond and rubies to my grandsons as maybe they will have a partner who would like them in the future. My son's gf who he hopes to marry in 2025 can have my gold watch. After my first marriage broke down and I divorced I offered my DD all the jewelry my ex had bought me because I knew I wouldn't wear it again. She didn't want it as mostly yellow gold. I gave my engagement ring and eternity ring to 2 of my nieces, several necklaces to other nieces and I see them wearing them sometimes. I really do like to see them wearing them.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 29/01/2024 15:34

Blogswife · 29/01/2024 11:40

I would have said all assets to be divided between the beneficiaries as stated in the will I.e if the will stipulates everything to be shared equally between 4 children then jewellery ( and everything else) is split 4 ways regardless of gender .

That doesn´t seem fair when one considers this:

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

As pp said, it really depends on the specific situation. What´s fair in one family might not be fair in another...

WarmWinterSun · 29/01/2024 15:31

My MIL passes jewellery to her daughters, not sons or DILs. It's a little bit of a shame as their is some valuable jewellery that she inherited, but there aren't items on equal value on the male side. I think daughters and sons would be nicer, then all the grandchildren would eventually benefit equally.

BigBoysDontCry · 29/01/2024 13:54

When my mum died there were 3 rings plus her wedding ring. None of anything more than sentimental value. Two of the 3 were jointly bought by one of my sisters and I for my mum as gifts.

3 daughters and 3 sons, numerous dil and grandchildren. My mum had already given her wedding ring to my eldest sister. The other 3 rings she wrapped individually in tissue paper and each of us picked one blind.

Dils and sons were not included or consulted. I think that's fair. I only have boys but both my sisters have a daughter. If I don't have a grandaughter then I'll give mine to the only other grandaughter who is my brother's child.

For another example, my sils parents died and she split the jewellery between her and her brother's daughter, he was a single dad and had already passed away too. Sil only has sons who are now mid 40s with no children. She'll pass the rest of the jewellery to her niece.

Families all differ in size and make up and closeness. What's fair in one might not be in another.

WavingCatsandDogs · 29/01/2024 13:50

Most decent people would not make these feelings known to a woman who lost their Mother unexpectedly.

'Up in Arms' how??

I'm trying to imagine a scenario where I tell my sister in law I want some of their dead mother's jewellery.

I can't as it's unbelievable grabby. Rude. Tactless.

I would just icily respond with 'our Mother, my decision, subject closed'

momager1 · 29/01/2024 13:41

@OVienna She is a lovely young woman. They have been together since they were 17. She works so very hard as does our son. They have one son who is 5 this year and probably will not have another. If, god forbid, they ever split, I would still love her and be so proud of the mother she is to my grandson. I told all of our kids.. if anyone divorces, unless there are abuse issues, I will still love my daughter in law and my son in law, and do the best I can to support them whilst they are raising my grandkids. I hope to god though that neither my daughter or my son divorce as they have amazing partners and I love them as much as my own. It would break my heart. Unless they abuse my kid.. then I would kill them lol. JK because I know that not only are they great people.. my kids were raised not to put up with any abuse..from a friend.. a partner..or even a parent.

cheddercherry · 29/01/2024 12:31

Unless she was close to the DIL then no, it usually would just go to her daughters. If they’re making a fuss over money and jewellery at a time like this when the family is mourning it doesn’t sound like they deserve consideration anyway since they can’t even take a few weeks before demanding a dead woman’s possessions.

OVienna · 29/01/2024 11:50

momager1 · 29/01/2024 11:25

most of my jewelry goes to my daughter. I have one granddaughter and one daughter in law. I have already told my daughter that when I pass, it is hers to do as she choses , but she has a son, as does my son and daughter in law, and should they wish to propose to their future spouse with one of my rings, I would be honored. This will be our daughters choice to make whether she keeps or gifts any of my jewelry. I am leaving one of my bracelets to my wonderful daughter in law. She has borrowed it for her wedding so I do believe it should go to her. It was her something borrowed..something blue. It is a gorgeous sapphire and diamond tennis bracelet and in my mind it is already hers. I think I may just gift it to her at some point in the future, so I can see her enjoy it!!

That is really lovely of you.

Blogswife · 29/01/2024 11:40

I would have said all assets to be divided between the beneficiaries as stated in the will I.e if the will stipulates everything to be shared equally between 4 children then jewellery ( and everything else) is split 4 ways regardless of gender .

weebarra · 29/01/2024 11:39

My mum has a lot of very precious jewellery. I think it would have been split between me, my DSIS and DBro, but DSis died four years ago.
DBro has a partner but no kids and not likely to have any, while I have three DCs (one DD).
I suspect I will get the majority when the time comes (hopefully not for a very long time), DBro and his partner will get some and my DCs will too.

Tearsofamermaid · 29/01/2024 11:36

I only have a daughter and am myself an only daughter (brother is also disabled and will never marry or have children), but would say normally that jewellery should pass to daughters and/or grand daughters. That said, it can ultimately be given to whoever the owner of the jewellery wants!

If I had a son and a good relationship with my DIL then I would be more than happy to gift her jewellery - but whilst keeping most of my pieces to give to my daughter/any future grand daughter.

My own grandmother gave all her (substantial) fine jewellery collection to my mother, who then passed it all to me. This was despite her having two sons and an excellent relationship with her two DILs. I imagine that she felt this is what was expected at the time, maybe a cultural thing? Not sure.

Mariposistaaa · 29/01/2024 11:33

I have got all my gran's jewelry except her wedding rings, which my mum has. Nobody has questioned it so mum and I haven't said anything. I am the only one who would treat it with the respect it deserves and not just flog it. Knowing this, she started giving me things while she was alive (just in case it gets lost by accident when the nurses/carers come in and tidy up, etc - bless her, she wasn't daft).

Lessstressedhemum · 29/01/2024 11:30

My mum's 3 most valuable pieces went to my sister, my daughter and I. Her other granddaughter and my eldest son's wife both got a smaller piece. My mum wanted her beautiful diamond eternity ring to go to my daughter because she had helped so much while my mum was ill. So daughters, granddaughters and gdil, but not dil because they really didn't get on and my sil didn't want anything to do with it.

BestZebbie · 29/01/2024 11:29

Traditionally, daughters only (could vary this to include granddaughters by a son, if desired) because a woman's jewellery was one of the only items that belonged to her in law, everything else was technically her husband's property. So women needed a stock of wealth, basically.

Nowadays I'd still favour daughters (because father's jewellery/watch/cufflinks would go to sons first and not usually be expected to pass to daughters/SILs), but I would probably include the son to get something too if there was a selection - expecting his wife to actually wear it, not him. Not first pick though.

If there was a lot of expensive jewellery that was going to one daughter, the sons/other siblings should get other things/money to balance it out, so they each get the same value in "keepsakes plus cash" from the estate at the end of probate - it isn't "cash splits 4 ways plus oldest daughter gets an extra box of gold".

Floralnomad · 29/01/2024 11:27

Daughters or granddaughters , unless the person giving is or has been particularly close to their DIL . My MIL has started giving bits to my daughter .

momager1 · 29/01/2024 11:25

most of my jewelry goes to my daughter. I have one granddaughter and one daughter in law. I have already told my daughter that when I pass, it is hers to do as she choses , but she has a son, as does my son and daughter in law, and should they wish to propose to their future spouse with one of my rings, I would be honored. This will be our daughters choice to make whether she keeps or gifts any of my jewelry. I am leaving one of my bracelets to my wonderful daughter in law. She has borrowed it for her wedding so I do believe it should go to her. It was her something borrowed..something blue. It is a gorgeous sapphire and diamond tennis bracelet and in my mind it is already hers. I think I may just gift it to her at some point in the future, so I can see her enjoy it!!

Andthereyougo · 29/01/2024 11:23

I don’t know but you dont have to rush it. Give all the DDs and Dils a chance to grieve and revisit it in 3 -6 months time. One thing I learned from bereavement—— don’t act in haste.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 29/01/2024 11:20

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

Edited

Then it’s a no brainier. The jewellery goes to the dd’s. Although I don’t necessarily think it’s always this clear cut.

Fwiw, my dm passed suddenly with no will. She had already distributed certain pieces that she no longer wore to me and dsis, as well as promised an item to my dd. The remaining jewellery was split between us but we did ask db to have a look through to see if there was anything he wanted for his dd. He chose a ring with his dp and asked if he could give it to his dp as an engagement ring. My dsis was very upset but I thought that my dm might be quite touched so I agreed. My df’s jewellery was given to db but that consisted only of his watch. I thought it was important that dniece had something too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread