Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does a mother's jewelry traditionally pass to daughters or daughters & DILs?

367 replies

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

OP posts:
Meadowfinch · 29/01/2024 02:41

Is there a norm?

My jewellery will pass to my ds who can decide for himself who he gives it to. Or if I have a grand daughter before I die, I'll leave it to her.

HoppingPavlova · 29/01/2024 02:39

The general rule of thumb is daughters get their mums jewellery and watches and sons get the dads

That rule is dead. It was only in previous times where watches were a forever thing. Nowadays no son is going to want his father’s Apple watch when it will be redundant within 2 years.

HoppingPavlova · 29/01/2024 02:36

Both daughters and sons, as the theory is the sons can then pass down to any daughters that have/may have. If the sons don’t have any daughters in the future, the right thing to do is to pass back over to his sister/s. However, you will get the odd Wally who just hands it over to his wife(DIL) but it’s called not being able to control from the grave or something similar.

Jollyoldfruit · 29/01/2024 02:33

I’ve already told my dd that her db is just as entitled to my jewellery as she is.
In an age of equality why should dd’s get first pick?
When my mil died it was assumed by her dd that she could take not only for herself but her two dd’s. The other two dgd’s being the offspring of the sons didn’t count!

BobbyBiscuits · 29/01/2024 02:30

I thought that stuff was part of the estate, so would be distributed in the will? If not, and you are in charge, then I would say blood relative females first. If you like the others and don't want to fall out, maybe offer them some of the pieces once you/ other closer women have taken your favourites.

Lovelydovey · 29/01/2024 02:27

I was the only daughter. To be honest I took the jewellery and having taken what I wanted, I passed the remaining jewellery onto my SIL (so the DIL) to choose what she wanted. I also pulled out a silver chain for my niece (granddaughter). But I kept her engagement rings and pieces from my grandmother - I only passed on costume jewellery. I've yet to decide what I will do with it in my will - I only have sons.

When my MIL died the only thing I asked for were her Yorkshire pudding pans, which I still use. Her jewellery went my to my SIL and her daughters.

BarryfromWatford · 29/01/2024 02:26

MargaretSnatcher · 29/01/2024 02:00

My will is written that my jewellery is to go to my daughters, with the exception of one piece to each d.i.l of their own choosing, meaning that each d.i.l will choose which piece they want themselves.

Edited

If they get to chose before your daughters then what happens if a dd of yours has a particular attachment to a piece and your DILs take it.

As a thought my aunt, no children, identified pieces for each of her nieces.
The pieces that hadn’t been chosen by her she told us (in her will) that we had to take turns choosing, She even told us how to decide who goes first by playing Rock Paper Scissors🤣🤣🤣 she had the last laugh there.

SheGotACamouflagedFace · 29/01/2024 02:22

I think it’s quite common for the son/DIL to choose 1 item (especially if there is a grand daughter) and the rest to go to the daughters.

Perhaps different in your situation because of the watches.

Fraaahnces · 29/01/2024 02:22

Agree - daughters. Keep it in your family.

YankSplaining · 29/01/2024 02:21

I’d say pick one nice thing for each DIL - something you think she might actually wear - and give the rest to the daughters. DILs aren’t entitled to it, IMO, but it’s a nice gesture.

BarryfromWatford · 29/01/2024 02:20

DILs aren’t entitled to expect anything, unless it’s in the will.
As the items are of low value
The general rule of thumb is daughters get their mums jewellery and watches and sons get the dads.

The DILs have their own mums to inherit from
Just ignore them OP, especially as your dbs will get your dads

Flottie · 29/01/2024 02:20

I’d prioritise daughters over DILs.

Im expecting some of my mum’s jewlery when she passes but definitely not expecting any of my MILs.

My mum got a ring from her MIL (a Ruby one) but only because my dad is an only child.

Ambivax · 29/01/2024 02:11

If there were only a few pieces of sentimental value I’d say daughters only, but if there was a substantial amount I’d want to be fair to my sons, and any female children and grandchildren they might have. In your case it sounds as if they already have been fair, with your DF’s stuff.

I was surprised to be left a brooch by my DMIL, particularly as she had left other bits (furniture etc) to my DH while his sister had the jewellery. We always got on well though so it‘s nice to have.

I only have a sister so expected to split my DM’s jewellery with her, but found myself having to force a couple of pieces on her - she isn’t at all a jewellery person and only has DSs so didn’t see the point! I pointed out that her DSs might have DDs though, or wives, so she did accept some bits in the end!

MargaretSnatcher · 29/01/2024 02:00

My will is written that my jewellery is to go to my daughters, with the exception of one piece to each d.i.l of their own choosing, meaning that each d.i.l will choose which piece they want themselves.

BasiliskStare · 29/01/2024 01:57

@DeathNote11 - DF has a lovely half hunter watch - that Is ( not in the will but just by Df saying so ) to go to DBro . I suspect DM's jewellery will come to me and then I can give some to DSIL But until that happens I am not worrying too much . When my great aunt died my mother was the only one who took care of her ( dementia ) . As soon as she died all the cousins arrived and said Oh Aunty wanted me to have this ( jewellery box raided ) . People can be strange

Prawncow · 29/01/2024 01:51

I’d say it goes to daughters and granddaughters. In this case, to the daughters.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 29/01/2024 01:45

I wouldn't say daughter's were the norm necessarily but given your extra information I'd say Daughter's only. The only other proviso would be if there are any Granddaughters? DILs response would make more sense in that situation otherwise its a bit grabby of them.
If there are Granddaughters Id give at least 1 piece to each Granddaughter and rest to her Daughter's.

DramaAlpaca · 29/01/2024 01:40

My DM has informed me that she is leaving her jewellery to me and her granddaughters. Not her DIL. I have strict instructions on what to do and to whom I give various items. SIL isn't included.

I didn't inherit any jewellery from my MIL, nor did I expect or want to. SIL did give me something of MILs that she didn't want, but it meant absolutely nothing to me, to be honest.

White British, if it matters.

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

OP posts:
Stupidmeds · 29/01/2024 01:39

I don’t think it should specifically go to DIL but perhaps if they already have daughters, they feel badly as it’s their kids who would ultimately be excluded if these sentimental items only went to your friend’s daughters (particularly if they already have daughters too.)

It’s a bit miserable for one side of cousins to have a reminder of their granny but then for the other side to have nothing.

Easy to sort out if families are complete and established but if everyone is still young,
the situation is probably still too fluid.

Also depends on how involved your friend was in the lives of her sons’ families. Some DIL are close with their MIL so perhaps they do feel hurt (however, I think it’s crass to express that)

GintyMcGinty · 29/01/2024 01:39

Daughters and sons.

Followed by grandchildren.

If sons choose to gift to their wives that's up to them.

Dorriethelittlewitch · 29/01/2024 01:38

I think it must vary hugely.

I have my maternal Grandmothers jewellery even though my mum is still alive and I wasn't the only granddaughter. She gave me several pieces that my biological grandfather had given her when I was still a teen (I was in my 40s when she died). Much to my surprise, she also left me jewellery from her second husband.

When dh's maternal Grandmother died, her will divided her jewellery between her grandchildren. I have dh's share.

When my mil divided her mil's jewellery, she split it three ways as she had 3 children. Again I have dh's share.

I think in the last two scenarios, it was more about being fair to dh/his male cousins. Certainly I would have been fine either way.

Amalienborg · 29/01/2024 01:34

If there is nothing of high value but the DILs are still up in arms then presumably there is a sentimental reason for them wanting to share the jewellery? In which case I'd be inclined to include them in the share.

If not value and not sentimental either, and it's just a case of wanting to be included, then perhaps there is something other than jewellery to give out.

A lot depends on their relationship with the deceased I suppose. Gut instinct may say the daughters should have all of the jewellery but I can't imagine excluding my SIL from sharing my mother's things when she's been in the family for 30 years.

telestrations · 29/01/2024 01:34

DDs, only DILS if no DD possibly GGD on DS/DIL side as well. Even if will says split between all DC or DGC equally DDs should have first pick, unless specified overwise. I would never ever even think that I would be entitled let alone demand any of my MILs.

Can you not insist that the matter is put on hold until the DDs are less distraught, and then make sure they get what's important to them.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 29/01/2024 01:33

I inherited my mother’s jewellery. I’m pretty sure that in an earlier version of her will, the jewellery was to be split between me and my brother’s (lovely but sadly now ex)-wife. As it was, when she died, it came to me alone.

DB asked if I could give some pieces to his long term partner (not wife). My mum and I didn’t really like her. I gave them all the pieces of jewellery that DB and his lovely ex-wife had given her over the years. ☺️

My former SIL says that my mum would be so proud of me! 😂