Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does a mother's jewelry traditionally pass to daughters or daughters & DILs?

367 replies

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 29/01/2024 05:17

Oh yes, one item each went to Mum's special nieces.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 29/01/2024 05:17

First of all: This is your decisions. The DIL’s being “up in arms” about it isn’t acceptable.

I would usually expect it to go to the biological children (with some smaller pieces potentially going to possible grandchildren).
DILs might receive some smaller items / for sentiment reasons. Especially if they were particularly close to their MIL (to you).

but it really depends on the specific situation, what you want etc.

witmum · 29/01/2024 05:12

Daughters go though the jerky. Take what they like and if there is anything left, to keep the peace, pass to DIL to share.

Daughter and Granddaughters in my family passed the jewellery box around taking a piece at a time.

user1492757084 · 29/01/2024 05:12

My mother wanted her jewellery to go to all of her family. Historical family heirlooms went to daughters and sons though mostly daughters (One was her father's fob watch chain.) and granddaughters too. Some gd shared the same initial and could wear her lockets. Other items went to SILs, especially if they had given Mum that piece of jewellery.
Nothing was tremendously valuable.
It took five years for Dad to be ready to part with them.
We all have photos and a little story about the pieces and who they are now with. The document itself is interesting and a joy to have.

My husband was left his grandmother's engagement ring.
That was a very thoughtful and romantic gesture.
So our grandson could be left the same diamonds.

Noicant · 29/01/2024 05:03

My mother in-law gave jewellery to both her granddaughters, I assume the bulk of it went to SIL. I would expect daughters tbh, I would gift to a daughter or a granddaughter but not to a DIL (unless I had no direct female descendants).

RosesAndHellebores · 29/01/2024 04:49

If there is no will, the jewellery is part of the estate and gets divided in accordance with intestacy law. The DILs are entitled to nothing.

It's tricky actually because if my jewellery goes to my dd she will receive a greater portion of the estate than ds because dh's jewellery, such as it is, is worth far less. I hadn't thought about it before.

ZephrineDrouhin · 29/01/2024 04:42

I have sons so I am hoping for a granddaughter. It wouldn't be my first impulse to consider DIL who are not blood relatives of the deceased.

DontTouchMyDog · 29/01/2024 04:39

It goes to daughters, possibly daughter's and sons. Like all inheritance, it goes to the children, not the ILs. The DIL's have no right, unless something was specifically willed to them, which it hasn't been.

It wouldn't occur to me to expect a thing from my MIL.

HomeTheatreSystem · 29/01/2024 04:17

Daughters! What are the DILs even thinking?! They have their own mothers who they'll inherit from. If the daughters don't want all of it and are happy to let some pieces go then that could be offered to the DILs but otherwise, it's absolutely none of their business. Their MIL could have specified gifts to them had she wished it but she didn't. Can't get over the entitlement of some people.

Mummyoflittledragon · 29/01/2024 04:08

Daughters only on this occasion. As @GreatGateauxsby said, they set the precedent by having everything from the dad passed down to the male line.

CobraChicken · 29/01/2024 03:55

Daughters only. The daughters in law are behaving atrociously.

If their MIL gave them items of jewellery while she was alive, that's obviously fine, but they're not entitled to inherit anything that belonged to her unless there is a will that identifies and passes specific items on to them.

Gremlinsateit · 29/01/2024 03:52

Are you the executor, OP? You mentioned that there are no high value items, but if the whole collection adds up to any value, you should not give it away - get the solicitor to treat it as part of the estate and then you can gracefully withdraw from the decision.

Traditionally I would say daughters, or daughters and sons. Shameful of DILs to be asking, especially at what sounds like an early stage in the grieving process.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 29/01/2024 03:32

It’s mean not to give the daughters-in-law anything. Let the daughters choose some pieces that the daughter-in-law can choose one each from.

Passingthethyme · 29/01/2024 03:22

Both, assuming you like your DIL ime

GreatGateauxsby · 29/01/2024 03:19

Unless directly and specifically left to DILs in will it is Bizarre, shameful & grabby.
Nd most certainly not traditional

I'm guessing your the executor.
Your friend must have had some amazing gear if they are up in arms.
It also says a lot the daughters are too distraught to even engage.

Personally I'd go via children only. Ie sons & daughters are I'd be quite firm about
A. How shameful dils behaviour is and how wrong/unfair is it is to their sisters that the sons haven't put a stop to this
B. Remind them they happily divided the dad's things with nothing going to the sisters and so THEY set the precedent on this.
C. Remind them this is NOT what the mother would have wanted (ie jewellery to go dils and for the family to be squabbling about money)

DO NOT give those things away. I'd be devastated if it happened to me and I am deeply unsentimental...

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 29/01/2024 03:17

Daughters only.

thebestinterest · 29/01/2024 03:05

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

Edited

This is norm. My dad received his dads valuables and my aunt received her moms valuables.

My aunt gifted some gorgeous diamond studs to my sister, which belonged to her grandma.

PyongyangKipperbang · 29/01/2024 02:59

Traditionally, a mothers jewelery goes to her daughters.

This comes from when married women were not allowed to own anything in their own name unless they were widows. No matter what they inherited from their parents, they were only allowed to own and pass on personal items including jewelery. Its also why expensive engagement rings, wedding rings, tiaras etc were so important as sometimes that was all a woman had to her name if he buggered off.

Let them kick off, and share it between her daughters.

ETA misread, thought you were a third dd.

thebestinterest · 29/01/2024 02:54

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

Daughters and grand children (typically daughters).

Any jewelry gift to DILs should be given whilst the person is still living or dictated in will.

personally, I would never dream of taking any of my in laws jewelry unless it was explicitly spelled out.

Nanaof1 · 29/01/2024 02:54

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

Edited

Daughter's get Mom's jewelry and if they wish to offer any of it to DIL's, then it's up to them. But jewelry is sentimental and/or heirloom and should be given to the daughters, who hopefully will have DDs to pass it on to down the line.

MargaretSnatcher · 29/01/2024 02:52

@BarryfromWatford it's irrelevant whether my daughter's are attached to particular pieces or not, my daughter in laws get to choose the pieces they want.

a222 · 29/01/2024 02:50

keep them safe for a while and once everything is a bit more settled ask daughters, if daughters wouldn’t like any then ask granddaughters

BarryfromWatford · 29/01/2024 02:49

HoppingPavlova · 29/01/2024 02:39

The general rule of thumb is daughters get their mums jewellery and watches and sons get the dads

That rule is dead. It was only in previous times where watches were a forever thing. Nowadays no son is going to want his father’s Apple watch when it will be redundant within 2 years.

That’s the rule we went by
However we did have watches, cufflinks, shirt studs, rings ( including wedding )
plus all the grandfathers stuff too. So quite a hoard tbh

JustWonderingIfImNormal · 29/01/2024 02:46

I would think daughters, unless the DILs had a particularly good relationship with the person who passed away. Maybe give a ring to the DS (imagining them putting it away for future daughters or on a chain around their neck, or obviously to do with as they wish). But, no, not direct to DIL.

Spencer0220 · 29/01/2024 02:44

I'd say it depends how close the DILs were.

My mum was gifted a diamond ring by her MIL. There was no suggestion it would go to the blood daughter.

But then my mum was very much liked by her MIL.

Swipe left for the next trending thread