Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does a mother's jewelry traditionally pass to daughters or daughters & DILs?

367 replies

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 29/01/2024 08:12

I'm not expecting any jewellery from my mil.

I'm a completely different shape and skin colouring.

Nothing would suit me. It would suit her daughter.

Sixgeese · 29/01/2024 08:12

When my DGM1 died her jewellery was all taken by my Aunt (who only had sons), she also took DGD1s watches and jewellery for her boys too. Her Brother my DDad (who only has daughters) was left given nothing in the terms of jewelery of either DP.

When my DGM2 died earlier this year, her jewellery went to my DM (we think that my Uncle took my DGD2s medals as they were missing from the estate) DM took a couple of pieces, then offered a pick to DSister and me, then our DC so we all had a piece from the very limited collection. They weren't valuable but being able to have something we remember her wearing meant so much.

It did hurt not being offered anything of DGM1s jewellery especially knowing that the next generation down are all boys on that side of the family. Because of this I have written in my will who gets what of my more valuable jewellery.

In this case I would have said the daughter should get most and first pick, but grandchildren also being given a choice of a piece so they would have something to remember her by, usually I would say sons too but as he already has one parents watch and jewellery it is only fair the other sibling gets some too.

Codlingmoths · 29/01/2024 08:09

JudgeJ · 29/01/2024 07:26

Sons too, no reason for daughters to grab everything.

The daughters might wear the jewellery - sons are very unlikely to. That makes it a very good reason, unless you have a son who actually will wear your earrings and necklaces?’

LadyEloise1 · 29/01/2024 08:09

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 29/01/2024 00:58

I would have thought daughter's or even grandchildren if not specifically accounted for.

I would have such little respect for DILs causing chaos when others are still grieving. WTF is wrong with some people?

This.
Daughters and perhaps granddaughters but it would depend on the relationship.
Sorry for your loss.
The daughters in law are greedy wrong.

SoupDragon · 29/01/2024 08:07

the 2 DILs are up in arms

They ought to be ashamed of themselves. Grabby fuckers.

Bargello · 29/01/2024 08:07

I wouldn't expect anything from MIL. She has an extensive - but not super expensive - jewellery collection. Her daughter absolutely should get first dibs. It would be nice if my own daughter (her granddaughter) got to choose something but it certianly wouldn't be something I was discussing with my sister in law or DH.

Toomuch2019 · 29/01/2024 08:06

Honestly whatever is "right" on paper in real
life is different for every family and the relationships that the DILs have also. I don't think you can do a one size fits all.

If it's low value as you say and they have had a close relationship with MIL I think it would be a lovely gesture

theduchessofspork · 29/01/2024 08:03

Daughters usually, especially if Dad’s stuff went to the boys.

If the DIL had an especially close relationship with MIL that’s a little different - but I’d still expect the daughters to get most of it. If there’s lots of it then giving the DIL a token thing would be nice and probably expected.

I suppose if there are only grandsons the DIL may feel the female line will get broken anyway - but they are cheeky feckers to make a fuss.

Londonrach1 · 29/01/2024 08:00

Daughters and granddaughters...not dils unless special reason.

LovelaceBiggWither · 29/01/2024 08:00

My DH's sister got the valuable pieces and he got all the pieces she didn't want. His brothers didn't want any of it. I was very surprised as I would have expected it to go to the granddaughters ahead of me (none of it is particularly valuable).

Thereislightattheendofthetunnel · 29/01/2024 07:59

My dad’s dad left his things to my dad. My dad’s mum left her things to split between her 3 daughters. Her granddaughters got a share too. All but me as I live somewhere else and I was expendable.

Then one of my aunts made a fuss becase she wasn’t getting anything from her dad so whatever shitty pieces my dad had, he split with her sisters. A CF move on her side as what he got was svery little, but it’s the thoughtlessness and entitlement what hurts.

I don’t expect anything from my MIL so they should not either. It baffles me that they are circling like vultures.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 29/01/2024 07:57

I would have assumed it just gets sold and forms part of the estate

justasking111 · 29/01/2024 07:53

I don't have any daughters. Two lovely DILs though. My MIL was burgled so there was little to share. I have grand daughters. We've started giving away jewellery now rather than letting it gather dust.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 29/01/2024 07:51

I don't think there is a norm.

I'd be massively judging the DILs for making a fuss over this.

However, if there's a reasonable amount of items, I'd give the daughters the most (and definitely the sentimental stuff like wedding ring and engagement ring if applicable), and chuck the DILs a pair of earrings each or something.

How much and what sort of jewellery are we talking? I know you've said nothing high value, but since it's being shared out I'm assuming it's not particularly low value? My mum for example has a bunch of very cheap necklaces that aren't my style and wouldn't be shared out, they'd be donated straight away. If what you're talking about is a reasonable amount of mid-range jewellery, then I think the sons should probably be included (is the comparison with the father relevant? That was left with instructions, and my assumption would be it was fewer items than the mother?)

Soupsetscared · 29/01/2024 07:46

When mum died I was left everything(only daughter) but i have given the granddaughters what pieces they want after my choice then great granddaughters.
Then I let my sil have a pick as she knew mum for nearly 50 years.
Afterwards any grandsons wife had a pick.
Nothing was of great value and a lot was worth very little.
I'll be selling the rest.

ChangeAgain2 · 29/01/2024 07:45

The jewellery goes to the daughters. DIL can fuck off. Hoe dare the argue over the deceased belongings. People die and the vultures come out.

Brefugee · 29/01/2024 07:45

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

Edited

in that case, remind them about the watches and give all the jewellery to the daughters. If you want, and privately away from anyone else you could ask them, when their grief has settled, if they want to give the DILs anything. No pressure and no obligation.

My granny, and now my mum (😢) started giving her jewellery to people who visited when she was very old. Not just jewellery, tbh, to make sure things went where she intended.

Shodan · 29/01/2024 07:45

My mother's jewellery was shared between me and my sister, even though we never were able to find the will. But- she had made her wishes known for as long as we could all remember and all our brothers agreed on this. I don't think it ever occurred to anyone that SIL might have a share, even if she'd wanted it (she and mum didn't get on).

Otherwise it would've been shared equally between all us siblings as the closest relatives.

travailtotravel · 29/01/2024 07:39

My MIL left me something specific - extensive collection. Specific pieces were named - my SIL and I. Then all to the grandkids to keep or sell. Bless her she was very proud of her collection, but it wasn't really to my taste and not as valuable as she'd have liked to believe.

TeenDivided · 29/01/2024 07:39

I was a DIL. I really appreciated having a couple of MILs brooches. Whenever I wear them I think of her. I got to pick something after the DD had said what she wanted and the more 'long standing DIL had had their pick.
I wouldn't have been 'up in arms' if I hadn't been allowed something, but I would have been sad.

(DH & I did more for MIL&FIL in their later years than either of his siblings.)

Brownie975 · 29/01/2024 07:38

Daughters get first refusal, especially on valuable pieces or those with sentimental / family attachment. In fact, as the only daughter, I would expect for it to be my job to arrange redistribution.

Anything not wanted could be offered to DILs (I would want for my SIL to have something nice / of value if she wanted it, but there would be certain items I wouldn't be willing to offer).

MotherOfUnicorns4 · 29/01/2024 07:31

I would give mine to my own DD’s and maybe a piece to each GD. I gave my DD a beautiful ring as my fingers started to swell up due to OA. She lost it in the sea 😡. So now they can have it all when I’m dead so I don’t have to feel upset when something gets lost!

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 29/01/2024 07:31

@DeathNote11 daughter and son, the son allows his wife to wear it and gives it to his daughter. if they split up then it comes back to the son

tokesqueen · 29/01/2024 07:30

Crunched · 29/01/2024 01:02

I would say daughters and sons equally. If the son chooses to pass on to his wife or his DC, that is his prerogative.

This

MrsBuntyS · 29/01/2024 07:27

Daughters and granddaughters should get the jewellery. I would absolutely not expect to get anything from MIL. SIL and her daughter are very close to MIL and I think would really cherish her things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread