Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does a mother's jewelry traditionally pass to daughters or daughters & DILs?

367 replies

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 00:50

Looking for opinions & experiences please.

What's the etiquette/norm when no instructions are left due to the death being sudden? Does jewellery usually go to the daughters only, or an equal split between daughters and DILs? No high value items. I'm expected to make a decision on distribution, I always thought it went to daughters but the 2 DILs are up in arms. The 2 daughters are too distraught to give an opinion. DILs both have mothers of their own & there was no special relationship between them & my friend.

YABU - Daughters & DILs is the norm
YANBU - Daughters is the norm

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nantescalling · 05/02/2024 16:02

Stand firm, DILs have no right to jewellery.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 01/02/2024 14:37

As he had no daughters, my DF left all my late DM's jewellery to his grandaughters. The DILs were skipped entirely.

Calliopespa · 01/02/2024 13:53

Jk8 · 01/02/2024 06:13

My point remains that there's literally no information about these women & the daughters should have known/mother should have stated her wishes beforehand.

If none of its of high value just hand it over to the girls (daughters)/children(sons & daughters) & let them sort it out

I’m not sure being an estate executor works like that. There are procedures to be followed. You don’t just pile in like a buffet meal and load up what you fancy - unless of course the Will specifies that.

CobraChicken · 01/02/2024 08:02

"Bottom line is I don't really want it, jewellery goes through fashions just as jean shapes change and I don't really want the clutter from my own mum let alone other people's. Do people quietly sell it? Or does it just get hoarded until the provenance is forgotten?"

Hmmm, yes I do wear my late mum's jewellery, along with my nanna's engagement ring (not all at the same time) but I've also been wearing the exact same style jeans for decades, so maybe that's a factor...

DisforDarkChocolate · 01/02/2024 07:48

I wear the earrings my MIL gave me early. If I had a ring I'd get it remade at some point.

SoupDragon · 01/02/2024 07:36

Does anyone actually wear all this bequeathed jewellery?

I've had some of it re-made into new jewellery.

TreeVase · 01/02/2024 07:22

I've got my grandmothers engagement ring. Never wear it, it's thin, worn out, my memory is she had a happy marriage but I'd pick the wedding photo over it.

Does anyone actually wear all this bequeathed jewellery? I don't even wear costume jewellery I bought 15years ago, let alone the ott Rocco set I bought in 1990 in Selfridge's.

My MIL has got some bits she wears a lot, it's that solid, chunky stuff that older women rock. Arguably it would suit 50 year old me more than my waif like daughters. I've also known my MIL now for longer than I have not known her. I remember her buying bits, celebrating occasions, so I guess it's a. Bit of a claim.

Bottom line is I don't really want it, jewellery goes through fashions just as jean shapes change and I don't really want the clutter from my own mum let alone other people's.

Do people quietly sell it? Or does it just get hoarded until the provenance is forgotten?

Jk8 · 01/02/2024 06:13

CobraChicken · 01/02/2024 05:14

"not sentimental enough" for the daughters to have not collected it yet???

Or...more probably (speaking as someone whose mother passed away last year) they assume basic human decency from the daughters in law, and don't realise that there's any need to rush to remove their mother's possessions.

My point remains that there's literally no information about these women & the daughters should have known/mother should have stated her wishes beforehand.

If none of its of high value just hand it over to the girls (daughters)/children(sons & daughters) & let them sort it out

CobraChicken · 01/02/2024 05:14

Jk8 · 01/02/2024 00:58

There's hardly much information given here about the daughters in law but if none of its of any real value (& presumably not sentimental enough for the 'blood daughters' to have not already have just come round & collected it) & theyve been purposely left out then I can very well imagine they are in fact 'up in arms'

As for the OP literally 15 pages of almost the exact same infomation & not a single.... thanks, it's been sorted now.... is a bit odd

"not sentimental enough" for the daughters to have not collected it yet???

Or...more probably (speaking as someone whose mother passed away last year) they assume basic human decency from the daughters in law, and don't realise that there's any need to rush to remove their mother's possessions.

Fionaville · 01/02/2024 01:16

I wouldn't expect anything from my MILs jewellery, even though we have a good relationship. It would go to her daughters and if they want to give anything to my DD (MILs granddaughter) then it would be nice, but not expected.

Jk8 · 01/02/2024 00:58

There's hardly much information given here about the daughters in law but if none of its of any real value (& presumably not sentimental enough for the 'blood daughters' to have not already have just come round & collected it) & theyve been purposely left out then I can very well imagine they are in fact 'up in arms'

As for the OP literally 15 pages of almost the exact same infomation & not a single.... thanks, it's been sorted now.... is a bit odd

Masmavi · 31/01/2024 20:56

I would have been surprised and upset if my sisters in law had asked for any of my mum's jewellery. To daughters and granddaughters if there are any. But if the DILs are acting like this it suggests something else is going on. A death can have the effect of bringing hidden family resentments to the surface, in my experience. Maybe something between the daughters and daughters in law or sons and daughters. Not your issue though.

Calliopespa · 31/01/2024 20:30

TeaGinandFags · 31/01/2024 19:17

Your bling, your decision.

If the jewellery is only costume jewellery then it shouldn't really matter. In any case, it's your decision.

The best solution I heard of was when a lady willed for her jewellery to br poured out onto the kitchen table and for her heirs to fight over it.

I think that’s actually less unusual than it sounds ( minus the detail of the table). A lot of will rattlers seem to like to draw out the process with plenty of opinions ( aka requests) being sought; and then they just throw it all open in the will so that everyone can fight again. Go not gently into that good night I guess.

TeaGinandFags · 31/01/2024 19:17

Your bling, your decision.

If the jewellery is only costume jewellery then it shouldn't really matter. In any case, it's your decision.

The best solution I heard of was when a lady willed for her jewellery to br poured out onto the kitchen table and for her heirs to fight over it.

Illbebythesea · 31/01/2024 17:54

Daughters 1000000%. My DH has a brother and MIL has explicitly said that her jewellery will go to her granddaughters (not me) why would it go to me?!

OVienna · 31/01/2024 17:29

AcrossthePond55 · 31/01/2024 17:15

Oh, I wanted to add....we didn't find out about the headstone for a year as we didn't live locally to the cemetery. DH found out when he visited some friends in his old hometown and went to see MiL's grave. He was deeply upset that his brother had let their mother lie in an unmarked grave and never said a word. DH figured out from the funeral bills & MiL's bank statements that they'd 'appropriated' the money. DH and I paid for MiL's headstone ourselves.

That is truly disgusting behaviour. So sorry.

labamba007 · 31/01/2024 17:16

I would never expect MIL to gift her jewellery to me! I'd find it rude that they are up in arms.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/01/2024 17:15

Oh, I wanted to add....we didn't find out about the headstone for a year as we didn't live locally to the cemetery. DH found out when he visited some friends in his old hometown and went to see MiL's grave. He was deeply upset that his brother had let their mother lie in an unmarked grave and never said a word. DH figured out from the funeral bills & MiL's bank statements that they'd 'appropriated' the money. DH and I paid for MiL's headstone ourselves.

Calliopespa · 31/01/2024 17:02

AcrossthePond55 · 31/01/2024 16:53

All I can tell you is how it went in my mum's family.

When Gran died, there were 2 surviving daughters and 3 surviving sons. One of Gran's DDs predeceased her. There were 6 granddaughters total from Gran's 6 children. The only jewelry was Gran's wedding and engagement ring. Mum (the eldest DD) got the engagement ring, Auntie (other surviving DD) got the wedding ring. The other granddaughters were given items of commensurate value. Both mum and her sister are now deceased so the rings went to me and my cousin as their daughters (neither of us has sisters).

Cousin has a DD and Gran's wedding ring will go to her. I have no DD and I don't (as yet) have any DGC. My mum's and my aunt's wishes were for those rings to pass down the 'direct' female line so I wouldn't give it to my DiL. If I have no DGDs the ring will go to my eldest (female) cousin's younger daughter as she has a DD to follow her and I know they would treasure it.

I think the 'problem' with passing things to a DiL is that there might be a chance that the item 'leaves the family' if there is a divorce.

But on the flip side, I got all my late MiL's jewelry. It was mostly costume but included her plain wedding band and what I believe was her mother's wedding ring. She gave it to me before she died and said I was to have it over because DH and I were the ones that cared for her and visited her daily once she went into a care home. DH & I went NC with his brother and family after we found out they used the money for her headstone on themselves.

We never heard from them until about 20 years after MiL's death when we received a letter from the other DiL asking about the jewelry. We never replied.

Edited

That all sounds very appropriate. Jewellery is particularly personal.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/01/2024 16:53

All I can tell you is how it went in my mum's family.

When Gran died, there were 2 surviving daughters and 3 surviving sons. One of Gran's DDs predeceased her. There were 6 granddaughters total from Gran's 6 children. The only jewelry was Gran's wedding and engagement ring. Mum (the eldest DD) got the engagement ring, Auntie (other surviving DD) got the wedding ring. The other granddaughters were given items of commensurate value. Both mum and her sister are now deceased so the rings went to me and my cousin as their daughters (neither of us has sisters).

Cousin has a DD and Gran's wedding ring will go to her. I have no DD and I don't (as yet) have any DGC. My mum's and my aunt's wishes were for those rings to pass down the 'direct' female line so I wouldn't give it to my DiL. If I have no DGDs the ring will go to my eldest (female) cousin's younger daughter as she has a DD to follow her and I know they would treasure it.

I think the 'problem' with passing things to a DiL is that there might be a chance that the item 'leaves the family' if there is a divorce.

But on the flip side, I got all my late MiL's jewelry. It was mostly costume but included her plain wedding band and what I believe was her mother's wedding ring. She gave it to me before she died and said I was to have it over because DH and I were the ones that cared for her and visited her daily once she went into a care home. DH & I went NC with his brother and family after we found out they used the money for her headstone on themselves.

We never heard from them until about 20 years after MiL's death when we received a letter from the other DiL asking about the jewelry. We never replied.

Woodandsky · 31/01/2024 16:30

A family member of my DHs (who had no daughters) left things to her SIL, nieces and me (nephew's wife), I saw the handwritten list of what was to go where.
When it came to distributing it my MIL gave all the nice stuff to the direct relatives and the ugly stuff to me, it wasn't in any way what was on the list for me but there was no way I was about to make a fuss, direct family definitely gets priority.

TheSnakeCharmer · 31/01/2024 16:22

Just to say that I am sorry for your loss.

TheSnakeCharmer · 31/01/2024 16:19

Perhaps you could make amends with the DiLs by gifting them some large bulky items that you wish to get rid of.

Calliopespa · 31/01/2024 16:05

DeathNote11 · 29/01/2024 01:40

Sorry for the drip feed but I think I need to mention that the sons got their dad's watches & jewellery when he passed. None were shared with daughters or sons in laws. That was their father's instructions.

Edit to also add that there are no granddaughters.

Edited

Daughters and granddaughters - especially given the treatment of the watches. If no granddaughters, daughters get the lot. I don’t know anyone who got jewellery from a MIL.

KnickerlessParsons · 31/01/2024 14:30

It's not about the DIL though is it? It's about the grandchildren, who shouldn't be penalised because they come from a son and not a daughter. It makes them sound like they are "lesser" grandchildren than any children of a daughter, with no right to inherit this kind of thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread