Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say taking Uni slow is a privilege

122 replies

GioRioMam · 29/01/2024 00:29

Today I met up with a friend, her DD and my DD. Her DD is 24 and did the course at uni my DD has just been given a conditional offer for.
Friends daughter did the 4 year option with the year in Industry, her placement year has resulted in the job she is currently in. She then took a gap year to travel, then a masters to further specialise.
She is from a much better off family. DD will be the first in our family to do a degree, we won’t be able to fund more than the 3 years.
DD is pretty upset she won’t get to take the slower option, especially the masters, but really she needs to be working ASAP.

AIBU to say being able to take 6 years after finishing school to enter the workforce properly (friends child had part time jobs) is a massive privilege?

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 29/01/2024 06:51

Mine did a 5 year integrated masters with a year in industry. The only thing it cost us is the extra parental support for the M year - we didn’t contribute anything to the placement year as he received a salary.

You should at least consider the year in industry - tends to be very useful in securing graduate employment afterwards.

Hillrunning · 29/01/2024 06:51

You seem to be missing the point that the linger route gives a better chance over all of becoming a high earner. The year in industry is paid and you only pay minimal fees that year. So you won't have to fund in the same way but it will give your daughter hugely valuable work experience. Most people who do a master don't dive straight in, they work for a year or two to save for it. Again, because they know that it will give them a big boost. ALL University education is a privilege, I don't understand why you are curbing your child's enthusiasm to have the best start as possible

chopc · 29/01/2024 06:47

@GioRioMam you knew this before tour DD was born and had 18 years to plan for this. Why didn't you? Maybe by even having less children? I know it sounds harsh and plans don't always work out but it doesn't sound as though you thought about it before now

IthinkIamAnAlien · 29/01/2024 06:47

It seems a shame that adulthood is being defined here by some as a head down, wage slave grind ASAP.
In other countries with a skilled workforce, higher education is part of becoming an adult. We are living in a rapidly changing world, young people need all the help they can get to learn and go on learning and that includes being flexible, learning to budget and live within your income, combining work and study and looking for and taking opportunities.
Having a Masters as well as a degree is the new norm. Years in industry are usually paid and incredibly valuable. Staying in the same job, even the same industry, is it thing of the past.
We supported our kids through their first degrees though it was like having an extra mortgage, it was tough. After that they worked through their Masters and further training and now they've all got good jobs though two out of the three are doing something they could never have forseen when they went to uni.
Children need emotional support and warm, open encouragement as well as as much financial support as you can give them and it doesn't stop when they leave school.

GnomeDePlume · 29/01/2024 06:47

@GettingBetter2024 both my DDs did science degrees. DD1 was able to do a placement year. It really re-energised her love for her scientific field. She graduated with a first and is now working in that field.

DD2 wasn't able to do a placement year for various reasons to do with the university. She really wanted to do one. I think the lack of placement experience held her back in job hunting.

@GioRioMam I don't think you should close the door on a placement year. They are paid. Not necessarily hugely but enough to get by on.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 29/01/2024 06:45

I would think the 4 yr option would be the most sensible. A years placement isn't a luxury, but quite important.

Bestyearever2024 · 29/01/2024 06:43

Your daughter can pay her own way during the year out in industry and then save up for her Masters

That's what my daughter did

GettingBetter2024 · 29/01/2024 06:43

Ha yes "life" got in the way of my plans in quite a big way! I'd love to be able to support my kids through life in the way many on here are able to though.

LodiDodi · 29/01/2024 06:42

Once the economy shrinks further it will be those who've been in work in better positions, believe me. Many of the yuppie made-up jobs will be gone.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 29/01/2024 06:42

Undergraduates are worth next to nothing these days without a PG degree.

You are going to have to accept that you will need to support your DCs through both.

forcedfun · 29/01/2024 06:42

The year in industry is worth finding a way to fund. I think it makes students so much more employable.

Could your daughter take a gap year and work to help fund it? I worked hard in my gap year and saved loads but also matured loads as well. And it gave me a holiday job to go back to in every uni holiday

ruby1957 · 29/01/2024 06:41

GreyGoose1980 · 29/01/2024 06:18

I understand why you said no to the masters OP. This can be done part time alongside working. However the year in industry would be paid and sounds really important to me. I’d worry that she will miss out on job offers if she doesn’t do this.

It is the OP's daughter's choice not the OP's - let the young make their own choices as she is almost an adult at 18.

No need to plan a masters at such an early age.

Life has a way of changing any long-term plan.

Logainm · 29/01/2024 06:36

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 29/01/2024 05:55

This....

I've seen this happen so many times... Where bright kids who would do well are completely ground down by parents who haven't bothered to find out options.....

That all the narrative has been about parents not wanting /able to support... Where the REALITY is completely different...

There are lots of different funding /working methods... Don't close her down by you not knowing...!!

Yes, but the onus is on the student to research the options. My parents both left school at 13 and were adamantly opposed to me going to university on ‘not for the likes of us’ grounds — I funded four degrees myself via scholarships.

GoldMerchant · 29/01/2024 06:32

The privilege here is having parental funding to do 5 years of study that means you don't have to take significant loans or work part time or even full time alongside the study. I think you're a bit naive if you think this is the case for a lot of students, especially on masters courses. Many of them are living at home, or have taken time out to save up for living costs during study. Yes, it's not as easy as the bank of mum and dad, but it can be done.

Your daughter needs to decide whether she has the desire to do these things, and at what cost to her (not you).

GettingBetter2024 · 29/01/2024 06:32

Wow yes! It's a whole new world to me. I didnt realise they paid so well and yes would make it an option (that we hadn't considered). I'd have steered away from any extra years purely on cost.

As I said I'm not sure we can support much for uni as it is and it's a shame they can't stay home for uni here as that would be a much cheaper option!

macedoniann · 29/01/2024 06:28

GettingBetter2024 · 29/01/2024 06:19

Re the "well they're paid". Presumably a grand a month isn't going to pay for accomodation and living expenses is it? Or does it usually pay enough to cover rent/bills/etc of that year?

Macedonian thank you very much for those posts. My kids may end up in the science world and it's nor my world so it's helpful to see it's not just engineering etc.

It still amazed me that at 17 when kids apply that anyone knows what specific career route they want and as I say most of my friends did straight academic subjects (history/english/maths) etc or healthcare so ir really isn't my world hence learning from this thread! Much appreciated.

Placement years are similar to apprenticeships. The ones with industry-leading firms that pay very well. And the ones that pay the minimum (NMW is lower for those under certain ages isn't it)?

Another example is a friend's son who got a placement year with an engineering firm designing robotic arms in Bristol. 25K that's a proper FT wage.

SnowsFalling · 29/01/2024 06:23

I'd didn't take a gap year, but have done both a year in industry and a MSc.
Both cost nothing, with the exception of fees added to a loan for the year in industry.
My gap year paid enough to live on, zero input from my parents. My MSc was fully funded - fees and living expenses. Yes, I was skint, but again zero impact on my parents.
Why do you think you can't afford this route if carefully selected?
Personally, the year in industry was the most beneficial of the degree.

GettingBetter2024 · 29/01/2024 06:19

Re the "well they're paid". Presumably a grand a month isn't going to pay for accomodation and living expenses is it? Or does it usually pay enough to cover rent/bills/etc of that year?

Macedonian thank you very much for those posts. My kids may end up in the science world and it's nor my world so it's helpful to see it's not just engineering etc.

It still amazed me that at 17 when kids apply that anyone knows what specific career route they want and as I say most of my friends did straight academic subjects (history/english/maths) etc or healthcare so ir really isn't my world hence learning from this thread! Much appreciated.

GreyGoose1980 · 29/01/2024 06:18

I understand why you said no to the masters OP. This can be done part time alongside working. However the year in industry would be paid and sounds really important to me. I’d worry that she will miss out on job offers if she doesn’t do this.

Sadza · 29/01/2024 06:18

Masters doesn’t have to be done immediately after degree and usually can be taken while working full time a bit down the line. A career is a long path and there will be opportunities to gain experiences along the way. Your daughter is only 17 and being compared to a 24 year old who is already well down a career route. With a bit of time and experience your daughter might even want to specialise in a different area. You sound jealous and should encourage your daughter rather than compare.

ParsnipAndPoppy · 29/01/2024 06:17

Comparison is the thief of joy.

And it sounds like your definition of privilege is anyone with more than you have, which is actually more like envy wrapped up in an inflammatory word.

She has a wonderful opportunity and anything could happen from it.

Be proud of her and look for ways to make what she wants work, as other people here have suggested. She will learn much more from learning to be resourceful than by feeling hard done by.

Flatandhappy · 29/01/2024 06:16

Yes of course it is a privilege, but then again going to Uni is a privilege that lots of people don’t have. One of mine starts a first full time job tomorrow at the age of 25 having taken a very slow path. My Uni experience was more like your daughter’s and I remember running between part time jobs and lectures while friends spent their time in the Uni bar so I am really happy that we are in a position to make things easier for our kids. Education is hugely important to me so I will support as much as I can.

Ohnoooooooo · 29/01/2024 06:14

I'm confused - the 4th year in industry is usually paid? I don't get why she will only be able to do 3 years and not 4. I personally think more work/life experience before a masters doing a masters is the way forward anyway. It's all a bit bizarre really - you don't have a crystal ball your daughter could do so well in her placement she is both offered a job and a sponsorship for her masters - who knows? She might start uni and hate it. Why on earth and you and her lamenting about something so far in the future?

macedoniann · 29/01/2024 06:14

GettingBetter2024 · 29/01/2024 06:11

I've tried googling and it seems mainly "business management" type degrees or very scientific ones? Like engineering?

I feel like this is a whole option I wasn't aware of (I knew language students sometimes did a year abroad which again I thought was mainly the privileged option but mine aren't linguists!)

https://www1.essex.ac.uk/programmespecs/Details.aspx?prog=13864
https://www.rau.ac.uk/courses/undergraduate/bsc-hons-agriculture-placement-year
https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/undergraduate/courses/2024/structural-engineering-and-architecture-industrial-placement-year-meng
https://www.gre.ac.uk/undergraduate-courses/engsci/forensic-science-with-industrial-placement-bsc-hons

The placement is obviously going to be something career related. The humanities won't usually have one because they are not training for a profession. But some universities also have it

https://www.uea.ac.uk/course/undergraduate/ba-history-with-a-placement-year
https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/english-literature-placement-year-ba-hons-q301/2024/

Presumably because their graduates might end up unemployed otherwise.

I suppose you could shove all non-science, non-humanities under 'business management'.

macedoniann · 29/01/2024 06:12

@GettingBetter2024 a placement year in a well-paid industry is a good idea if struggling for money as these will be paid.
Also.. well, not well-paid industry but young relatives doing a farming degree had a ball on their placement year. Slightly above minimum wage, all food and accommodation paid for, and a job for after graduation.

That's why when deciding between similar unis I always advocate a placement year. If you can't get one that pays enough to live on, you just carry on.

Master's are money spinners for unis, Yes, some specialised ones are useful but the majority are often not necessary for the job market. I always find those that have at least worked before going back to do one are more employable. Of course, if it's something like AI that's going to lead to £££ crack on.