Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest - would you send DC private if you could?

378 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 20:25

If your DC is at a state school and you were offered free places for them at the local indie, would you accept? If so, why? If not, why not?

YANBU - Yes I would send them private
YABU - No I wouldn’t send them private

Me - yes I would, in a heartbeat (DD at state primary).

OP posts:
ZephrineDrouhin · 29/01/2024 00:26

I tried it with one of my children. He hated it and wasn't doing particularly well despite being considered very bright. The children were fairly dreadful. He transferred to a local state school. He had to have tutoring in maths to catch up after over a year there! He made long term friends at the state school. He is a fifth year medical student so I think the school did well for him. It was a school in a well to do area though and the children were often the children of professionals of various sorts.

Yesnosorryplease · 29/01/2024 00:24

No, absolutely not.

They are happy at a state comp just down the road, have friends on the bus and walking distance for meeting up/gaining independence, have lots of extra curricular opportunities and mix with a wide variety of DC from very broad range of backgrounds and can see for themselves how advantaged they are. I would hate for them to feel in any way hard done by or as if they were missing out if they were the 'poor ones'. It would be frankly gross for them to have that misconception.

They do a sport outside of school where m ay children there attend a local, large, well known, v expensive private school and in the words of DD, "most of the boys have an attitude problem." I see the way they speak to the coaches and their parents and have no desire for my DC to spend more time around them, particularly not in an unstructured setting.

Our friend's ds has been horribly bullied as part of a sports team at his private school and the school have been hopeless at dealing with it. She had to withdraw him from a residential as he was so worried no one would look out for him.

I'm sure there may be some private schools I would wish I could afford but I haven't seen them near me.

As someone who went to private school, as did all my family, I was not overly keen for my DC to go. I am actually envious of what my DC education looks like - a really local experience, feet firmly on the ground, part of their community etc.

ellenpartridge · 29/01/2024 00:00

Primary no, would not want to change from current village school. Secondary probably.

TempleOfBloom · 28/01/2024 23:57

No.
Our S London state school was great, Dc learned all sorts of social skills that neither I nor a private school could have taught them, and they didn’t need expensive Molly coddling to achieve good academic results.

Also I am lucky enough to have had the wherewithal (cultural capital, not cash) to provide a variety of extra curricular enrichment.

AlltheFs · 28/01/2024 23:50

DH was the “poor” kid on a full scholarship, he hated it. He was from a very middle class background too, not working class. His experience puts me off.

The independent schools here are Uppingham, Oakham, Stamford. DH went to one of those. I’d definitely consider it but I’m not sure.

Definitely not to private prep- the state primaries here are brilliant (tiny village schools with intake of 8-15 kids), private isn’t better in this case at that age.

If I had the funds to properly afford private senior school (and all the trappings) then yes. But not boarding. I have absolutely no desire to have DD away from home.

Arbor · 28/01/2024 23:48

Yes, and we did. We were fortunate enough that both our kids are bright and involved with school life, so they had scholarships all the way through school. We wouldn't have been able to pay for it otherwise, and they wouldn't have benefited from the opportunities and networks.

margotmargeaux · 28/01/2024 23:44

I have to make some sacrifices for mine to attend private school.......it is 100% worth it for our family

cadburyegg · 28/01/2024 23:41

No. I was privately educated from 4-16 and hated almost every minute. The snobbery, the bullying, the way I was only average academically so I was forgotten about. Pastorally the care was awful too, when I was suicidal my mum had a meeting with my y10 form tutor who said "oh cadburyegg is so quiet and good I just forget about her". I was also told I'd never do X as a career as I wasn't good enough at maths. The list goes on. I did leave with a handful of GCSEs and a bunch of good friends which I'm grateful for. Interestingly none of those friends have chosen to educate their children privately either, even though some of them could definitely afford to do so. The day I stepped into my state sixth form was the first day I felt safe in school.

I couldn't afford private education for my children. is the primary state they are in perfect? No absolutely not, it has its flaws. Do I believe that my children are safe and looked after, and educated to the best standard possible? Yes, which is not something I had at their age. I realise that not every child is privileged enough to attend a good state school, so I count my lucky stars for that. If my children would benefit from tutoring when they get to secondary school I will fund that.

We don't have a grammar system here so that's not a consideration.

forcedfun · 28/01/2024 23:32

SummerFeverVenice · 28/01/2024 23:29

Unfortunately they are running the country, and it shows.

Quite.

SummerFeverVenice · 28/01/2024 23:29

forcedfun · 28/01/2024 23:24

I worked with an old Etonian who was astonishingly stupid. He couldn't even understand the work we drafted for him. He didn't look to be enjoying life at all. All the confidence in the world couldn't conceal his complete inability to do the job

Unfortunately they are running the country, and it shows.

forcedfun · 28/01/2024 23:24

AhNowTed · 28/01/2024 23:17

Eton has a phrase for it.

They instill "effortless superiority".

Couple that with an entitlement to run the country. a posh voice, Daddy or daddy's friend to get you an internship to Goldman Sachs or a government department, and you are set for life.

That is what they are buying. Connections.

The education is entirely secondary.

I worked with an old Etonian who was astonishingly stupid. He couldn't even understand the work we drafted for him. He didn't look to be enjoying life at all. All the confidence in the world couldn't conceal his complete inability to do the job

WinterFoxes · 28/01/2024 23:17

I would and did. You get one chance to educate your child. Our area was massively over subscribed for state secondaries and my two were offered places in a failing, violent school that was over an hour away on two buses. It closed down during what would have been their exam years. DS1 was geeky bright and DS2 had SEN. We found a private school that catered for them both and they thrived there.

AhNowTed · 28/01/2024 23:17

Eton has a phrase for it.

They instill "effortless superiority".

Couple that with an entitlement to run the country. a posh voice, Daddy or daddy's friend to get you an internship to Goldman Sachs or a government department, and you are set for life.

That is what they are buying. Connections.

The education is entirely secondary.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 23:08

Removing disadvantage rather than advantaging DD.

A tutor is proactive advantage IMO

OP posts:
sanityisamyth · 28/01/2024 23:08

Absolutely!

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/01/2024 23:03

Barbadossunset · 28/01/2024 21:43

I'd ban the lot.

Ahnowted would you also ban extra tutoring, which for those who can afford it, gives their children an advantage.

In my case tutoring was because school didn't have any support for DD's ADHD and she was failing. But her behaviour was vaguely OK so her needs were ignored. I found a gem, referred by another parent of a child with ADHD and it's meant DD could just about keep up. Removing disadvantage rather than advantaging DD.

You'll never remove advantage. Just having books in the house, not having to move because of the whims of the rental market, having your own room to study or sleep, having two parents to share the homework; it's all advantage. Buying smaller class sizes shouldn't be. It's very plain that smaller class sizes is better for every child (and their teachers). So every child should have that.

SummerFeverVenice · 28/01/2024 22:58

EwwSprouts · 28/01/2024 22:53

Your DC may have worked hard at primary but it's not off their own backs that they are at grammars. It's good fortune to live in a county that has grammar schools or you chose to move to be near such schools. Most of the UK doesn't have grammars.

I did and in the same circumstances would again.

I agree, most of the U.K. doesn’t have access to a grammar school.

Dismaljanuary · 28/01/2024 22:54

😂.

I was talking about having confidence in isolation.

Confidence isn't a bad thing and from what I've seen: it's everything.

I'm absolutely sure that there are many loud, brash uneducated private school alumni around and state school similar types.

EwwSprouts · 28/01/2024 22:53

Quornflakegirl · 28/01/2024 20:32

My dc have worked extremely hard at a fairly good state primary and have both earned places to local grammars, both with a fantastic reputations and results. I am so proud that they have achieved this on their own backs and it proves that you don’t have to fork out thousands for a good education - it’s not the be all and end all.

I didn’t and wouldn’t.

Edited

Your DC may have worked hard at primary but it's not off their own backs that they are at grammars. It's good fortune to live in a county that has grammar schools or you chose to move to be near such schools. Most of the UK doesn't have grammars.

I did and in the same circumstances would again.

Westwindworries · 28/01/2024 22:51

Dismaljanuary · 28/01/2024 22:45

@Westwindworries

Confidence is key in getting jobs.

Where I currently work I see quieter, intellectual and capable people over looked for louder, brasher uneducated people.

They have confidence.

I don't want loud, brash, uneducated children, though, even if they were more likely to get good jobs!

"Send them to a private school and they'll end up loud, brash, and uneducated" isn't really selling private schooling to me....

Bornonsunday · 28/01/2024 22:47

My kids are very confident though at state schools. I think you can encourage that at home.

Dismaljanuary · 28/01/2024 22:45

@Westwindworries

Confidence is key in getting jobs.

Where I currently work I see quieter, intellectual and capable people over looked for louder, brasher uneducated people.

They have confidence.

ObliviousCoalmine · 28/01/2024 22:44

Yes

Dismaljanuary · 28/01/2024 22:43

In the olden days grammars were definitely filled with a broader reflection of society because it wasn't left to parents to sort the whole process out.

Now I don't think they refect true society because for that you would need the children and parents who don't went to be educated and for sen reasons or mental health issues can't get to any basic level of education.

Obviously a grammar now is usually children from educationally invested dc so that makes them even more narrow today.

Op I absolutely would put my dc private because my dc are very shy and need smaller cosier environment and these monolithic 70s warehouses are intimidating and horrible and scary.
I also prefer education where the teachers are more like employees and children and parents clients so there is more working together and less arrogance.

Westwindworries · 28/01/2024 22:35

No. Experience teaching at University suggests that a lot of private school pupils have confidence but don't do as well academically.

We played the long game, and sent ours to a state school.