Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this child abuse?

145 replies

Hah20 · 28/01/2024 19:53

DS who is 2 years old has a habit of trying to scratch DH in the face. In the past DS has got a big reaction from him for doing this. I believe this is why DS repeats the behaviour.
Today this happened and DH pushed DS off him, he fell backwards and was very upset,bumped his head but with no lump. I just want some opinions. Was that just rubbish parenting or is this classed as physical abuse?
I am very much of the gentle parenting approach and am horrified by what happened, but not sure what to do. I told DH in no uncertain terms that what happened wasn't okay and he disappeared in a sulk for the rest of the day.so we are yet to have a proper discussion.

OP posts:
Silverbirchtwo · 28/01/2024 21:28

If you get hurt it is natural to push away. I don't think this was child abuse but you need to talk to your 2 year old about scratching/hurting people and maybe your DH should make sure the child's hands are not close to his face so can't scratch him. Not nice behaviour from your DC needs shutting down.

Prometheus · 28/01/2024 21:27

He’s scratching the man in the face?! Of course DH is going to push him
away instinctively! A shame he bumped his head but hopefully he’ll learn not to scratch someone in the face repeatedly.

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 21:22

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:45

Not really, no. Making a very personal and targeted comment about me without knowing my history is very different to me expressing a viewpoint that you don't agree with.

Look you’re being dramatic, making accusations about child abuse to people who disagree with you and being argumentative. You need to breathe and just talk. No one wants the two year old hurt, obviously. Just some people believe the net suffering is greater leaving your kid to learn violence and accusing your husband of ‘child abuse’ over an accident, than a kid falling over when blocked. You might not.

Walking2024now24days · 28/01/2024 21:20

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:45

Not really, no. Making a very personal and targeted comment about me without knowing my history is very different to me expressing a viewpoint that you don't agree with.

@FrankieLet

it wasn't a punishment, it was a consequence of his behaviour.

id push a 2 year old away if it was hurting me. If they toppled over, well that's what toddlers do. It was unfortunate he bumped his head, but it was hardly deliberate!

Rainbowloverparentx · 28/01/2024 21:14

I've swiped my child, for clarity, not hit, not smacked, but I have swiped my hand up to move her hands and that has pushed her backwards onto the bed.

My DD was going through a big phase of hitting, it was the middle of the night and she wasn't happy it wasnt time to get up - she started hitting me, mid asleep so I just swiped upwards (not hitting, but making contact on my arm to her arms)

I think it also does depend on tone and after the event. In these situations, I talk to DD (4) most of the time and try to de-escalate, find other ways to get frustrations out (I found non-aggressive stamps with feet, or hard jumps) as good way of redirecting it, she the learnt about breathing and most of the time she understands the emotions now. We always debrief afterwards, why it happened, how can I be prevented in the future, how we can do differently next time, we always apologise and say 'friends again' and state we love each other.

I came from an abusive household, there is a difference between asserting your boundaries and respect for not being hurt and disrespected, when you do are not showed it from them.

I think it is age developmental, and ife wasn't always this calm and easy. We have had times like this and frustration = frustration, but the more you deal with it, it is likely to happen.

The walking out and being huffy all day, does sound as though Dad is struggling somewhere. He needs positivity and support also, this is new to him, you and your DC.

Happy to advise any further if I can

UnbeatenMum · 28/01/2024 21:12

It sounds like an accident and in future he will probably handle it differently. I wouldn't say it's abuse.

Coyoacan · 28/01/2024 21:11

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 20:02

He doesn’t have ‘one parent who’s abusive’. Dear God. He’s scratching DH and DH pushes him away. It would be abusive to expect DH to be scratched to ribbons so a TWO year old can just act however he wants. People who screech ‘child abuse’ over family accidents make me sick, as they minimise actual abuse. Teach your kid some consequences to being violent. It’s on the mum to prove to the DH that his feelings in this matter too.

Thanks for some sense.

b0zza1 · 28/01/2024 21:10

I work in a special needs school and deal with attempts at being scratched in the face frequently. I and other staff hold the children (sometimes bigger than us) when we are scratched in the face. Pushing a 2 year old seems like a completely inappropriate action, not loving at all. Also this isn't the first time the child has done this and so some thought could have gone into a response.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 28/01/2024 21:05

Pushing a child away when they're actively trying to hurt you is perfectly reasonable. It's easy to not know your own strength and push too hard. I wouldn't think anything of it.

Bubbleohseven · 28/01/2024 21:00

BluebellsareBlue · 28/01/2024 20:50

Ok, so ima retired cop who spent the majority of my service in the CID, 8 of those years was in child protection. I would not have been charging anyone with a crime as unless there have been ANY other incidents this appears to be someone acting in a way to prevent being scratched. The Pearl clutches are here though saying it's abuse without knowing any other circumstances. Tell me, if you know someone is away to claw at your face do you just let them or push them away?

Neither. I held their arms so they couldn't do it. Then told them off.

Samsond · 28/01/2024 20:59

Honestly unless he did it on purpose and or didn't immediately check your son was ok and apologise to him id just assume it was a silly clumsy accident.
My DH is a clumsy oaf who accidentally hurt both our kids loads of times when they were little. Think turning around and elbowing one in the face, or having a child on shoulders and walking under a tree with lower than anticipated branches 😬. And one time I tripped over one child's bouncer and landed half on top of him. Accidents happen.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 28/01/2024 20:58

Peanutsforthebluetit · 28/01/2024 20:22

No, not child abuse

Sounds like DS hurt his dad who acted instinctively but didn’t realise his own strength.

Your toddler should be getting told off for scratching people in the face.

What's being done about that?

Of course the 2 year old shouldn't be scratching, but come on! It's a 2 year old! Still learning! Surely that is more understandable than an adult "acting instinctively and not knowing their own strength"?!

Bubbleohseven · 28/01/2024 20:57

XelaM · 28/01/2024 20:38

Maybe they were feral because you never pushed them away so they thought it was ok to continue hurting you?

Edited

Yeah, maybe they did😀

SoIRejoined · 28/01/2024 20:54

No he shouldn't have pushed him away, and I think his reaction (sulking) makes it worse. If he didn't mean to hurt him, then surely his reaction would have been to pick your DS up and apologise. Not to go off in a sulk?

You shouldn't push people, and it's hardly surprising that a two year old gets hurt when pushed by a full grown man.

I've been in this situation myself with a child who repeatedly hurt me on purpose, it's very difficult, but you absolutely must control your temper. There's a big difference between calmly holding a child away to stop them hurting you and pushing them over.

BluebellsareBlue · 28/01/2024 20:50

Ok, so ima retired cop who spent the majority of my service in the CID, 8 of those years was in child protection. I would not have been charging anyone with a crime as unless there have been ANY other incidents this appears to be someone acting in a way to prevent being scratched. The Pearl clutches are here though saying it's abuse without knowing any other circumstances. Tell me, if you know someone is away to claw at your face do you just let them or push them away?

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:45

PossumintheHouse · 28/01/2024 20:41

I could say the exact same thing to you.

@FrankieLet

Edited

Not really, no. Making a very personal and targeted comment about me without knowing my history is very different to me expressing a viewpoint that you don't agree with.

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:43

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 20:38

Exactly the sort of over dramatic, sleazy insinuations we’d expect from someone who feels DH is ‘abusive’ if he accidentally knocks over a kid who’s scratching his face.

Sleazy? So you don't think being pushed over and risking a head injury is an acceptable punishment for a 2 year old? In which case, I don't know what your issue is with my comments because that's all I'm saying.

Either engage with the points I'm making without inventing things you think I've said and name-calling, or don't bother tagging me.

PossumintheHouse · 28/01/2024 20:41

I could say the exact same thing to you.

@FrankieLet

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 20:40

PossumintheHouse · 28/01/2024 20:38

You clearly have no experience with child abuse.

Thank you. The drama on here is shocking.

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:39

PossumintheHouse · 28/01/2024 20:38

You clearly have no experience with child abuse.

What a wild thing to say to someone you know nothing about.

Do you realise how harmful that is?

XelaM · 28/01/2024 20:38

Bubbleohseven · 28/01/2024 20:11

Yes it's abuse.

I've had 3 kids. they've come at me with all sorts in the past, big plastic bats, all sorts. I covered my face or put my hand out to get hold of their arm and stopped them that way.

I never once pushed them so hard that they fell backwards and banged their head, and my kids were feral!

Maybe they were feral because you never pushed them away so they thought it was ok to continue hurting you?

PossumintheHouse · 28/01/2024 20:38

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:32

Who's screeching?

Hard to know where to start with this ridiculous comment. A 2 year old scratching (or doing anything) is not abusive 🙄 An adult pushing a toddler off themselves so hard that they fall backwards and bang their head is absolutely abusive. It's not an accident. He pushed him, which is a deliberate action. It is not up to OP to pander to an aggressive man who can't control his temper with a baby and tell him "his feelings matter". He's an adult.

You have imagined the part where I said the toddler should be allowed to behave however he wants. I just don't think that being pushed and potentially injured is an appropriate way to discipline a 2 year old. Perhaps you disagree, in which case our ideas about how to safely raise children are poles apart and you're not worth entering into discussion with.

You clearly have no experience with child abuse.

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 20:38

FrankieLet · 28/01/2024 20:32

Who's screeching?

Hard to know where to start with this ridiculous comment. A 2 year old scratching (or doing anything) is not abusive 🙄 An adult pushing a toddler off themselves so hard that they fall backwards and bang their head is absolutely abusive. It's not an accident. He pushed him, which is a deliberate action. It is not up to OP to pander to an aggressive man who can't control his temper with a baby and tell him "his feelings matter". He's an adult.

You have imagined the part where I said the toddler should be allowed to behave however he wants. I just don't think that being pushed and potentially injured is an appropriate way to discipline a 2 year old. Perhaps you disagree, in which case our ideas about how to safely raise children are poles apart and you're not worth entering into discussion with.

Exactly the sort of over dramatic, sleazy insinuations we’d expect from someone who feels DH is ‘abusive’ if he accidentally knocks over a kid who’s scratching his face.

Missingmyusername · 28/01/2024 20:34

“I don't really like your laissez-faire attitude to the scratching either. He might be 2, but he shouldn't be allowed to hit or scratch or injure anyone, without an appropriate consequence. I agree your DH did not provide one though.”

^ Agree with all of this.

I mean the child is 2! Yes they can still hurt you by poking/scratching but I couldn’t push a two year old. I would however move away and say NO scratching, it hurts!

Numberfish · 28/01/2024 20:34

hellsBells246 · 28/01/2024 20:26

DH shouldn't push. DH is old enough to learn that he shouldn't push... etc.

Ffs, OP's h is an adult. Please don't expect more from a 2yo than you do from an actual man. 🙄🙄

DH didn’t push on purpose most likely but instinctively. DM has been asked to establish if this is a pattern but so far it appears it was an accident. People SHOULD learn to push away when others are coming at them with the intention to hurt and this is a two year old, not a baby, so should have been taught the first few times it’s not acceptable. And the two year old fully intends to hurt. Why defend a violent kid and not the DH who blocked him? Or are you one of those mums? 🙄🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread