Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So so guilty for all the money I have wasted

46 replies

EbonyWood · 28/01/2024 15:54

Not an AIBU as such but posting here because I know this space gets a lot of traffic and I need a bit of encouragement/advice.

I have a shopping problem. I have no savings and nothing to show for all my years working so far. Today, I decided I will finally clear my wardrobe out properly (I do it every now and then bit only get rid of a handful of things). I have so many items with tags still on, I will be donating them all. It’s just so hard because I am quite literally able to see the price tags and all that wasted money.

I am about to start therapy, I think a lot of this problem stems from low self esteem and the need to impress others.

It doesn’t stop at just clothes/shoes/bags - it’s toiletries, shower gels, perfumes, moisturisers. Mugs, cups, water bottles, pretty crockery. Everything and anything you can think, I have bought it.

I tried putting myself on a no spend January that failed spectacularly.

I don’t have the time to sell most of this stuff, bar a few bits I know that will be worthwhile.

Is anyone able to advise here? I am riddled with guilt and feel horrible about myself. I have failed. I guess it’s no different to any other addiction but I feel like addiction to buying things is always brushed off as not as serious. But in reality, it is. If I lost my job tmrw, I would have nothing apart from worthless stuff all around me.

I like to think I really care about our environment because I carry a reusable cup (but I have 5 of them) and recycle all my boxes that the crap I ordered turned up in. But in reality, it’s just not possible to be conscious and consume as much as I do and I feel dreadful about it.

many advise on how to get past this guilt and stop buying would be really appreciated. My mum was just the same as I was growing up and I don’t want to be the same as her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
minthybobs · 28/01/2024 19:39

My advice is this:

Instead of focusing on a rigid budget, start to dig into what your shopping is really about. What is behind your spending?

Shopping releases dopamine (just like wine does) and it gives us a little boost. So, in that moment when you press confirm purchase on your computer or phone what feeling in you is it serving? Is it fear? sadness? boredom? etc

Spend some time really thinking about this- what void is it filling in you and why. Then, once you have self reflected on this (do this completely non judgementally btw, you aren't judging yourself, you are just curious what its about) consider how you can fill that void by things other than shopping. Excessive shopping is often connected to grief so have a think about that too, if thats applicable.

Once you've done that, and come up with some strategies for self care that don't involve buying stuff, then you'll be ready to budget and set out some limits for yourself. You definitely need to consider your "why" though as setting a budget without examining this will mean you keep failing.

When you get that urge to buy next time, stop for five minutes, take a deep breath and go within. Ask yourself, what am I feeling right now, what is this really about, what do I need right now? My guess is, it isnt really a new pair of jeans or a new face cream. It might be a craving for love, safety, relaxation, a hug, someone to chat with you, or just a distraction from some uncomfortable feelings. Deal with that first. Shopping addiction is never really about genuinely wanting more stuff, its usually a way to self soothe.

Brexile · 28/01/2024 19:30

Oops, you work in fashion. That's tough. Can you have a capsule work wardrobe of basics that aren't distinctive (all black etc) so nobody notices the clothes aren't new? (Sorry if that's naïve.) Or limit yourself to only acquiring freebies, if you get them?

joelmillersbackpack · 28/01/2024 19:29

Just be careful if you sell these things that you don’t get a compulsion to then spend the money you’ve made.

I have a relative whose life has been destroyed by shopping addiction, they had a good job but acquired huge debts without really having anything to show for it. Lost their house and now has nothing but huge debts. Please look into counselling, I think this runs a bit deeper than just enjoying shopping.

Bargello · 28/01/2024 19:29

Take pictures of the mountain of stuff, all new with tags on, and look at them every time you think about getting the credit card out.

EbonyWood · 28/01/2024 19:28

Brexile · 28/01/2024 19:27

This. Sell off anything that you don't like and would never wear, but keep whatever is good quality and useful. Then don't buy anything else until you need to. This is what I did as a recovering ebay addict!

The only reason I’m getting rid of stuff is because I have too much and it’s getting me stressed out! I wear only a handful of the stuff I have. So the rest has to go, unfortunately!

OP posts:
Brexile · 28/01/2024 19:27

Comedycook · 28/01/2024 16:25

I also really don't see the point of getting rid of the stuff. You've already spent that money. The stuff is yours now. You need to work on not buying more. Getting rid of existing stuff seems rather pointless unless you do it for money

This. Sell off anything that you don't like and would never wear, but keep whatever is good quality and useful. Then don't buy anything else until you need to. This is what I did as a recovering ebay addict!

EbonyWood · 28/01/2024 19:26

XmaswasbadNYisworse · 28/01/2024 19:18

Any of these suggestions resonate:

  • have separate "work" and "personal" SM, so you can get a break from it away from work.
  • you mentioned that just after buying things was the only time you ever remember seeing your mum happy. Sounds like there might be something in that, quite a deep childhood pattern/conception of the world, to possibly investigate, journal on, or work through with a therapist or through self-help. Consumption doesn't equal happiness...
  • related to the above, consider the Marie Kondo "spark joy" approach - if you've still got things new with tags and never worn, then it's likely not about actually enjoying the item, but about acquiring it. So what, more healthily, could you replace that with? A nice coffee/cake, a trip to the cinema, pampering yourself in a bath/with a manicure etc, going for a run/lifting weights, what would make you feel great about yourself and in yourself? Exercise and being out in nature are both good for the dopamine hit you're getting currently from shopping, so you might be able to replace that high more healthily.
  • Disconnect all the payment apps from your phone/computer, so there's more friction between seeing and buying.
  • Put things in a basket without buying, and "save for later", or take photos/screenshots and then commit to not buying until 7 days later. If you genuinely want it, you'll still want it then. If it's compulsive, the break can help.
  • Think about what else you could use the money for. Is there a trip of a lifetime you fancy? Something big that would genuinely enhance your life? Something you feel really passionate about. Every time you feel the urge to shop, don't, but put the same amount of money into savings towards the big thing. By the time you reach the big goal, you'll likely have acquired a saving habit rather than a spending one.
  • Make lists before buying. The list only contains things you actually need, and you can only buy things which are on the list. No impulse purchases, because you've pre-empted yourself on that.

Ok - I have done is disconnect my credit card from my phone. It’s no longer on Apple Pay/Amazon.

I have deleted Zara/Matches/Net-A-Porter apps.

The difficulty with my job is that I work in fashion - so it’s in my face constantly. I have even considered quitting my job and going into another industry, just to get away from from it.

OP posts:
XmaswasbadNYisworse · 28/01/2024 19:18

Any of these suggestions resonate:

  • have separate "work" and "personal" SM, so you can get a break from it away from work.
  • you mentioned that just after buying things was the only time you ever remember seeing your mum happy. Sounds like there might be something in that, quite a deep childhood pattern/conception of the world, to possibly investigate, journal on, or work through with a therapist or through self-help. Consumption doesn't equal happiness...
  • related to the above, consider the Marie Kondo "spark joy" approach - if you've still got things new with tags and never worn, then it's likely not about actually enjoying the item, but about acquiring it. So what, more healthily, could you replace that with? A nice coffee/cake, a trip to the cinema, pampering yourself in a bath/with a manicure etc, going for a run/lifting weights, what would make you feel great about yourself and in yourself? Exercise and being out in nature are both good for the dopamine hit you're getting currently from shopping, so you might be able to replace that high more healthily.
  • Disconnect all the payment apps from your phone/computer, so there's more friction between seeing and buying.
  • Put things in a basket without buying, and "save for later", or take photos/screenshots and then commit to not buying until 7 days later. If you genuinely want it, you'll still want it then. If it's compulsive, the break can help.
  • Think about what else you could use the money for. Is there a trip of a lifetime you fancy? Something big that would genuinely enhance your life? Something you feel really passionate about. Every time you feel the urge to shop, don't, but put the same amount of money into savings towards the big thing. By the time you reach the big goal, you'll likely have acquired a saving habit rather than a spending one.
  • Make lists before buying. The list only contains things you actually need, and you can only buy things which are on the list. No impulse purchases, because you've pre-empted yourself on that.
mathanxiety · 28/01/2024 18:59

And also -
Set up a Pinterest account and 'collect' virtual clothes online.

mathanxiety · 28/01/2024 18:57

It's an addiction, a mindless habit that gives a rush of good feelings in the moment.

You don't have to beat yourself up about it though. Nor do you need to feel bad about the money spent. Be kind to yourself. Be compassionate.

You had some problem and you dealt with it the best way you could. Now you're trying to turn it around and do better - give yourself credit for your impulse to donate to charity and above all the plan to get therapy.

For a plan as you start to deal with the problem, I'd suggest:
Subscribe to SM that is uplifting and not temptation.
As examples -

  • The Latest Kate - an uplifting artist offering MH affirmations on Instagram.
  • AuriKateriina - a Finnish woman who cleans people's completely filthy homes for free, with enormous empathy and joy. It's good to see garbage being cleared away, and the kindness and understanding. Accounts that focus on cleaning will keep you inspired to keep your home free of clutter and shame.
  • Furniture rehab/ recycling, and art accounts. They may direct your mind to creativity.
  • Any Instagram accounts that focus on nature - birds, otters, kittens, dogs, parakeets, gardening, building stone or wood houses in wild places, etc. The more of these you follow, the more you'll find in your feed, and eventually you'll end up listening to a lot of lovely birdsong, laughing at funny cats, etc.
  • Any craft or activity you're interested in, like crochet or hiking or travel or architecture or the history of London, or whatever.

Then sort out what you'd like to sell and what you'd like to donate.
Bring the donate pile to the charities you've chosen asap.
List the sell pile online. If items haven't sold in six weeks, take the listings down and donate.

Allow yourself to go shopping for fun only on the last two days of any given month, and carry a certain amount of money, in cash. Leave your cards at home. DO NOT shop online.

hennybeans · 28/01/2024 18:47

I think you probably need some kind of counselling to really understand and stop this behaviour.

Two things I do to curb my which might help in the meantime:

If I see something I am tempted to buy, I take a screenshot or photo and save it to a Pinterest board. Knowing that I have it remembered somewhere takes the panic out of missing out. Mostly I never actually end up buying the thing.

Secondly, when I am getting rid of anything I don’t let myself have an easy way out. For example, boxing everything up and dropping off at a charity shop is easy. Listing each thing to sell or finding a proper home for something takes a lot longer. It makes me think when I am tempted to buy, how easy is this going to be to get rid of when I don’t want it anymore? Will it go to landfill or will someone else want it?

TheEverlovingFork · 28/01/2024 18:46

I ended up having a huge clear out. Sold some stuff but donated the rest - there was a women's refuge asking for toiletries, I put aside a small amount for me and sorted the rest into little wash bags for the refuge so I felt a bit better about getting rid.

This. When I had my big clear-out, i set a price limit it was worth trying to sell over, the rest I gave to charity and thought about how happy it might make someone worse off.

A big yes to therapy, otherwise you will fall into the cycle again.

Aozora13 · 28/01/2024 18:37

I definitely struggle with “comfort shopping” and realised I was getting more of a buzz from buying (online) than actually receiving/having stuff. Identifying this helps me check if I actually want the thing or I want the feeling of buying the thing, although it’s very much a work in progress. If you’re on insta I’d recommend My Frugal Year, she talks a lot about this sort of thing and has loads of advice in a really kind, nonjudgmental way.

Ohdearwhatnow4 · 28/01/2024 18:35

If its a addiction your doctor might be able to guild you to the right help. Therapy is a start but it could be you have a addictive personality. Could even be adhd so go to the doctors and have a chat

IDontHateRainbows · 28/01/2024 18:34

I'm a shopaholic and I developed a small ebay retail business to channel my urge to splurge so that I a) get a buzz off sourcing and selling stock and b) raise money to buy my own stuff or c) pick off the stock I want for myself and sell the remaininder to cover costs.

I sell products that I would buy cosmetics and skincare mainly.

It's the only thing thing that helped. Probably isn't as good as stopping buying stuff completely but it definitely helps me scratch the itch.

cowgirl42 · 28/01/2024 18:31

Please sell the unused and good condition items and start a savings account. That will boost your self esteem. Then every time you go to buy something put that money in to your savings first. Then really think do I need this or want it.

EbonyWood · 28/01/2024 18:30

NeedToChangeName · 28/01/2024 18:28

Hoarding disorder is a recognised psychiatric illness, sometimes connected with history of poverty

Might be worth exploring

This sounds so relevant to me. I’m going to have a look into it.

thank you everyone for your kind ideas and suggestions. I ended up putting 2 bags together and took it to a ‘thrift store’ (I should have mentioned I don’t live in the U.K. at the moment!). I will get some money back for the stuff I have dropped off once they have time to go through it all.

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 28/01/2024 18:28

Hoarding disorder is a recognised psychiatric illness, sometimes connected with history of poverty

Might be worth exploring

Comtesse · 28/01/2024 18:26

Sell on Ebay or Vinted. Why not get a few quid back?

Chop up your credit card - or at least freeze it in a block of water (available if there is an emergency but stops immediate spending). Disable cards on your phone/watch and with Paypal.

Jollyoldfruit · 28/01/2024 18:22

If you have time to browse for new stuff then you have time to sell what you don't want.

My ex sil is a shopaholic. She's wasted money all her life. When she divorced db 17 years ago she got a mortgage free house and still took out a small mortgage.
I remember she ordered a new garden table and chairs and the unopened one from last year was still in the garage.

It's an illness and needs tackling like any other addiction.

stopringingme · 28/01/2024 18:21

@EbonyWood

If they are good quality clothes, footwear and bags take them to a dress agency and they will sell them for you for a percentage.

They are out of your home and you get something back.

Hummusandstuff · 28/01/2024 18:13

If you do decide to sell a pile of stuff. Put a day aside. List it all. Buy some poly bags with self seal strips on eBay. If you don’t have packaging it won’t happen. Then when sold take to a drop off once a week where labels are printed for you. Put your dispatch day in the listing (copy and paste). Once in the swing it’s really quick and easy.
if you sell say £300 you can tell yourself you earned £100 an hour. Worth doing.

EbonyWood · 28/01/2024 18:06

It’s really interesting - we also grew up poor. My mum relied on benefits for much of my childhood. But, she always managed to find a way to shop and buy herself new clothes. She constantly had new things in her wardrobe - nothing expensive but still more than she should be buying I’m sure. And she’d make a big song and dance about showing me, telling me what she’d wear it with etc.

Our dinners were often beans or egg on toast. I might ask if we could cook a cottage pie, for example, and my mum would say no, because it were too expensive. Yet, she’d been off into town to buy something new a few days prior.

I also had to start paying rent at a very young age and buy my own basics like tampons/shampoo/shower gels etc as mum wouldn’t for me.

In all honesty, when she bought new things, it was the only time I knew her to be happy.

OP posts:
Anotherparkingthread · 28/01/2024 17:13

I am also a shopaholic. It's related to OCD, you may have other symptoms eg eating disorder, body dysmorphoa, hoarding in general, OCD is much broader than people just washing their hands.

Definately sell the things if they have tags on. I have a strict rule where I let things sit for a specific time frame say a week, if it doesn't sell I lower the price and wait again one more week. If it still doesn't sell I donate it. Once you have commited to getting rid of something make sure you do send it on it's way, if you are likely to back track just donate it immediately.

You need a clean slate to start from which it sounds like you're doing. Look at the space and finances you have and set limits on how many of any one item you can allow yourself to own and how much is the maximum value of the item. For example you allow yourself 2 pairs of jeans and say you won't spend more than 70 on each. Try clothes on in the shop. Only buy things you 110 percent love and will wear and that fit amazingly. Just because something is one sale doesn't mean you need it or that it's good value. Don't buy clothes for a fantasy version of you eg don't buy suit jackets and expensive shirts if that isn't your daily work wear or flamboyant dresses if you don't attend those kind of parties and only go to the local for a quite glass of wine. Don't buy clothes for past you, I often see things that 20 year old me would have loved and could never have afforded and I buy them but they don't suite me now I'm 35.
Look in to why you are buying these things, you don't necessarily need a therapist to help you out. I grew up very very poor and only had a handful of clothing as a child and teen because we had so little money. I am now well off, and I know a lot my reason for over spending is trying to buy comfort and security. It makes me feel safe to have things. Your reasons could be very different but once you understand them you can talk yourself down from purchases with a rational mind. 'i don't need this dress I have one very similar and I haven't worn that enough yet.'

Make a spreadsheet of your spending and it will hurt, but record everything. Food clothes etc. every single penny that leaves your account. You might find that it ties in with certain times of year, do you spend more when you have winter blues etc or lines up with work or home life stresses. You might find it's random and constant but at least you will like exactly how much you are actually spending. It's very hard to tackle a problem when you can't fully see it. It's easy to spend here and there and not realise how much it adds up.

You mentioned clothes but I also have hobbies or ideas of hobbies, and I buy books and bits for the painting I don't have time for or the gym I don't go to any more. You need to refuse to buy any more until you use what you have.

You may be able to swap your shopping problem for a healthier fix, I find yoga and running very rewarding and once you have done them for a few months they scratch a similar itch. You get a dopermine fix from the exercises and it's a much better habit than spending and obviously is much cheaper!

I hope some of that use useful, you can definitely manage it and turn it around now that you have noticed it. You just need to be very mindful.

I'm quite into minimalism and you may also find things like Swedish death cleaning helpful, lots of videos on YouTube on the subject.