Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so happy and fulfilled by one child that I don’t have another

35 replies

Oneanddoneortwotobethrough · 28/01/2024 10:11

I have a 2.5 year old who I adore, I’ve adored motherhood and giving them all my time and energy. As is the way of life, a second baby discussion comes up now and again and we are mulling this over. Both of us (DH and I) really enjoy our life now and the joy our DC brings us. We’ve really found our new normal and enjoying how much easier things are now but still really enjoyed the babyhood stage. I cosleep, extended breastfeed and basically cater to all needs day and night of our LO and I am more than happy to do this. I can’t quite imagine another baby coming into the mix and 1) not getting the same amount of attention as my first 2) my first child no longer the amount of attention and struggling.

Sometimes when I talk to other parents they will say they didn’t want their first child to be an only child and I know the old trope of “only kids are weird” but WHY? do people feel like this? I’m genuinely curious, where does this come from? My child is so gentle and kind with other children, shares even though it isn’t developmentally expected and has some very close cousins we see weekly and spend lots of time with.

I don’t think in real life people often willingly say (nor should they, really) regret their subsequent children but I wonder if people would be willing to share with me if they’ve had similar thoughts around more than one child and what decisions they made and how they feel now?

Did you really think about it, go for it and love having more than one? it’s hard to answer but I’m hoping for experiences of people feeling similarly.

For full context, we can afford more children and finances are not of concern for our decision making which I know is very important and an incredible privilege.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kikisparks · 28/01/2024 15:11

I think it’s a personal decision, but I feel the same as you and we’re sticking with our one wonderful (and at times cheeky and testing!) DD.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/01/2024 12:12

hotduzz · 28/01/2024 10:52

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves as you do 🤷 as a younger sibling, I think it's quite likely that my existence was measured against whether it would be beneficial or not for my older sibling.

I guess I feel that my dc has benefited far more from having undivided parental attention than my dsis or I ever benefited from having a sibling, so the idea that my entire life could have been predicated on the basis of an erroneous assumption would be pretty sad!

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 28/01/2024 12:10

hotduzz · 28/01/2024 10:42

That's absolutely fine to stay as one OP, you sound happy and measured.

Be aware that 'the brood may come later- I didn't want a second until DD was 4!'.

If I'm being brutally honest, I do believe that in most cases (yes there are scenarios where it doesn't pay out!) that a sibling is the best gift you can give you child, though.

You haven’t met my sibling 🤣🤣🤣zero relationship. Hideous person.

slowerprofessor · 28/01/2024 11:55

I felt exactly the same as you! DDis just amazing. I'm so happy with one. She's 7 now and it was the right decision for us. I'm the mother I want to be as I have time, patience, and energy. Two would destroy me! Some people can handle two no problem, but I'm not one of them. Also I have no intention on relying on her when I'm old, I'll be sorting that out myself.

IStandWithACrutch · 28/01/2024 11:50

It’s nobody else’s business how you choose your family, if you’re content then you’ve hit the jackpot.
DH has three siblings, two live abroad and the other one is about as useful as a chocolate teapot so he had all the elder care responsibilities with his parents.
Siblings absolutely do not automatically mean a shared burden.

Revelwithacause · 28/01/2024 11:45

Talking purely about my own enjoyment of motherhood (there were obviously more factors than this that went into the decision to have no.2)- I loved the baby to 3yo stages soooo much! I love the older ages too but found the early years just lovely. So with DD2 I get to go through them all again. And there is nothing more lovely than seeing your children playing and laughing together and showing each other love.

itsmyp4rty · 28/01/2024 11:36

I only have one, he's 18 now and it was the best decision I ever made. He agrees!

My sibling was the worst gift my parents could ever have given me.

Blanketpolicy · 28/01/2024 11:36

Ds(19) is an only child. The "only child" character assaults are pretty old fashioned now, I heard them a lot while I was growing up, but not in recent years as one child families are so common now. He has many lovely well adjusted friends who are also only children and they are his brothers!

We planned for two but it didn't happen for us, we accepted it as we felt very much about ds as you do with yours, ds was enough for us, and it has not been an issue at all as he grew up.

My one concern is in the future. I am one of 4 dc, and although we are not socially close we share a strong sense of duty to that family connection and did pull together to share the load when our parents aged, dad was widowed and needed more support for chronic health conditions. I know if I need them my siblings will be there for me and I will be there for them. I regret ds will not have that, I worry even if we put in place measures to try to prevent it dh or I might be a heavy burden for him to deal with alone when we are elderly and we cannot help feeling vulnerable and needy. I worry who will he turn to for help if he needs it when we are gone.

Of course there are no guarantees siblings would be there for each other, and my siblings and I have never had to call on each other for serious support, but it has always been comforting to know I had that safety net especially now we are all getting older and might need each other in some form or another.

saraclara · 28/01/2024 11:14

I couldn't imagine loving a second child as much as my first. But went ahead anyway as my DH and I had always planned for two and knew from our friends' experiences that they seemed to have enough love to go around.

And of course when number two arrived, I loved her just as dearly. And I think I was a better mother to both because I had two. I think I'd have ended up too intense and helicoptery had I stuck with one. And as I'm now a parent of adults, I can imagine being more needy if I just had one.

Number two DD chilled me right out!

PurpleOrchid42 · 28/01/2024 11:11

For me, it's worked out well, because DD1 and DD2 play together, and that makes life a LOT easier!

Boyce · 28/01/2024 11:09

I'd always hoped I'd have more than one child. However, after having my only daughter, a serious illness was triggered and I decided I wouldn't have any more.
My daughter grew up close to my nephew and niece (born in the same year as my daughter)and really didn't miss out. Now they're all grown up and the girls, having grown up in the country, daughter graduated,and niece in final year of degree, are having the time of their lives sharing a flat in London.
No-one's opinion of how many children other people "should" have matters.

Mynicename · 28/01/2024 11:01

I had DS(12) at 25 and he is an only child by choice. I kept waiting to feel ready to have another and it never came!! Once he was about 6 I told DH I was done (he was happy as alread has 2 from previous marriage) and it brought such a weight off my shoulders when I made the decision. No regrets at all, he is happy, confident and very sociable. I think that being forced out of the home comfort bubble actually might make only children more adaptable socially as they have to put themselves out there. That only thing he sometime struggles with is banter amongst his peers - he's not used to being wound up for the fun of it like siblings do so sometimes takes it to heart!
I wondered if as I get older and my 'biological clock is ticking' I might get pangs of broodiness but nope! I honestly cannot imagine going back there.

KezzabellaB · 28/01/2024 10:54

I have two (grown up) daughters who are each others best friend and they've always been that way, from the word go. So from my experience having more than one child meant they always had, and have had, each other for company, though I appreciate not all siblings are that lucky. I grew up in a family of 3 and though there is quite a large age gap between me and my siblings, I feel close to them and when we lost our parents, knew there was only them who understood truly who I felt at losing our mum and dad.
OTOH, I am married to an only child and you can really tell the difference. He and his parents are extremely close, sometimes stifingly so (to the point he pretty much tells them EVERYTHING which makes me uncomfortable). He won't make a decision without involving them to some degree, can be quite petulant and selfish on occasions and has been spoilt rotten by them both. God job I love him eh 🤣
Now that they're very elderly though, he has nobody else to rely on for their needs, other than me and obviously I'm not the same as a sibling would be. He's stressed beyond belief because they're both quite poorly and are starting to lean on him more and more and he has no one else to shoulder the load. My MIL also lost a pregnancy when DH was little and I know he's often 'missed' his sibling and wondered what they would have been like.
So I guess what I'm trying to say, in a long winded way (sorry) is that I've seen both sides, and from my personal experience, I'm glad I have siblings and more than one child. But honestly, do what suits you and your DH. It's nobody else's business after all. Good luck with whatever you decide

hotduzz · 28/01/2024 10:52

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves as you do 🤷 as a younger sibling, I think it's quite likely that my existence was measured against whether it would be beneficial or not for my older sibling.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/01/2024 10:49

hotduzz · 28/01/2024 10:42

That's absolutely fine to stay as one OP, you sound happy and measured.

Be aware that 'the brood may come later- I didn't want a second until DD was 4!'.

If I'm being brutally honest, I do believe that in most cases (yes there are scenarios where it doesn't pay out!) that a sibling is the best gift you can give you child, though.

As a younger sibling, I find the notion that I might have been conceived as a "gift" for my sister...basically as some kind of accessory to another person...deeply offensive. I truly hope that my parents didn't think like that.

Awful attitude.

SpeedyDrama · 28/01/2024 10:45

I know a couple of women who knew they were done with one. I thought I was a ‘no kids ever’ person and ended up with three, love it but it’s hard hard work. I’ve never questioned anyone about how many or few children they’ve decided to have, but I know one friend gets questioned about when they’re going to have another even 7 years down the line, I know it irritates them. But I have three boys and still get asked if I’ll try for a girl - absolutely not. You’d think being a single mother of 3 wouldn’t even raise that question but some people will try and dictate what a woman should do with her fertility regardless of the situation!

If you’re happy with one child then you’re not weird. A child needs love and provision, siblings is not a necessity.

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 28/01/2024 10:45

Honestly, I would be more worried about the idea that the child makes you so happy and fulfilled that you don’t want another one. What happens when they let you down? As they will, sometimes in small ways (none of my dc have liked art😀), and sometimes in big ways. No child should ever be responsible for their parents happiness or fulfilment.

That said, it’s fine to stop at one, if that’s right for you.

Charlie2121 · 28/01/2024 10:44

Most people I know only have 1 child. Thats because they built careers and had them relatively later in life.

They are all extremely happy and never mention wanting more children.

I guess it all depends what you want from life. Most of my social circle will be retired or semi retired before or not long after their DC start school as they are all financially secure due to 20/25 years of work.

Others prefer to have children young but that’s of course often a trade off with financial security.

People should just choose the path they prefer. Neither is better or worse than the other, they are just different and result in different benefits and drawbacks.

hotduzz · 28/01/2024 10:42

That's absolutely fine to stay as one OP, you sound happy and measured.

Be aware that 'the brood may come later- I didn't want a second until DD was 4!'.

If I'm being brutally honest, I do believe that in most cases (yes there are scenarios where it doesn't pay out!) that a sibling is the best gift you can give you child, though.

MinnieMountain · 28/01/2024 10:39

Our 10yo is an only by choice. I had a miscarriage when he was 2, but we decided we were happy as we were.

He’s happy. Rarely asks to have friends over, even though he knows he can. We’ve got time to give him attention and indulge his interests. We take him away individually as well as on family holidays. Equally we can do our own thing more- DH is coming back from a week’s skiing today.

DS is lovely with his younger relatives, I’d say he’s well adjusted.

helllothere · 28/01/2024 10:39

I've felt like this, our DS is 4 1/2 and had for the most part been an absolute dream. Our life is lovely, relatively easy, good juggle or work and social, nice holidays etc. It's taken us to this point to realise we wanted another and now I'm 14 weeks pregnant and so excited for another little one to join us. It does cross my mind that life will change again but we've had chance to just enjoy him so much and now at the point feel totally ready for another and just will adapt our life again as required.

Beyondbeyondbeyond · 28/01/2024 10:38

One child is all it takes to give you the experience of being a parent if that is something you want. Each to their own after that.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/01/2024 10:37

Of course yanbu to only want one child, but there is a huge amount of prejudice towards only children in our society. You see it on MN all the time.

My dd is an only child, not through choice but I wouldn't now have had it any other way. She is an adult now and I have no regrets at all. She has never been lonely - she has tons of friends and far better social skills than I ever had despite having grown up with siblings. She is has never wanted a sibling, and doesn't feel that she has missed out.

Do what's right for you and your family and don't worry about what anyone else thinks.

Allthingsdecember · 28/01/2024 10:36

I had similar concerns before having my second child. The difference was, I desperately wanted to have two children. Having gone ahead, I can honestly say that I have no regrets.

I do put a lot of pressure on myself to make sure that they both have the level of attention I want to give them each day though. It’s doable (and worth it), but it’s more tiring than having one.

There’s no right or wrong and only children are definitely not weird! If you’re happy with one, don’t pressure yourself to have another because of stupid people’s comments. You know what works for your family, trust your gut.

Prinnny · 28/01/2024 10:34

We have one only through choice. I can’t imagine how we would split our love and time/attention without one of the children missing out! We’re fortunate we can give DD everything she wants. All trips, clubs, parties, days out, holidays etc. She’s always made lots of friends on holiday too!