Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour should add ‘getting us back in the EU’ to their election manifesto

281 replies

bluewanda · 28/01/2024 09:08

We had the referendum, we gave Brexit a go, and nearly 9 years on, I think it’s plain for most people to see that leaving the EU was a massive mistake. Even people I know who voted for Brexit admit that now they wished they hadn’t, given the shitshow that has unfolded since. So, why not nip it in the bud and get back in the EU ASAP? If Labour would add it to their election manifesto that would speed up the process, as we’d have a mandate by the end of this year. So why don’t they?

OP posts:
Chersfrozenface · 28/01/2024 14:18

TooBigForMyBoots · 28/01/2024 13:55

My part of the country isn't Running OK thanks to the Brexit fuckwittery. The UK needs to finish Brexit and get over it before any conversation about rejoining should happen.

YABU OP.

Brexit will nrver be done.

The UK - Canada trade deal talks that have just been passed were about roling over a previous agreement the UK had as an EU member

Thf first phase of new checks on food imports from the EU starts next week, the second phase in April.

The UK came out of the Horizon research programme, now it's back in

Keir Starmer, the likely next PM, wants to seek changes to the existing Brexit agreement. If the EU is willing to be negotiate, how long will that take.

Brexit is an ongoing, never-ending proces.

Createausername1970 · 28/01/2024 14:05

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 28/01/2024 09:42

If you look at what’s happening in Europe with the migration problem that’s set to get worse and worse and worse. The countries are starting to replace their borders and elect more radical leaders that want to protect the settled population’s sovereignty as a priority.

I honestly think the European Union will adapt and change as time passes. We will probably become part of a new kind of European Governance so I think right now we sit and wait. Wars are only going to increase unfortunately, so countries that exist right now, but not even exist by the end of the decade.

I agree with this. I was very torn which way to vote at the referendum. On the one hand I didn't particularly want to leave, but at the same time I was very concerned about some of the rhetoric coming from the staunch europhiles and the plans for continued expansion but no acceptance that some of the policies were actually unpopular. It felt like it could very easily turn into a huge tinderbox.

COVID right after we left wasn't ideal, but it will be impossible to know how much difference it made.

For me personally, I wouldn't rush to rejoin as some of my misgivings are still playing out and I don't know which way they are going to go.

TooBigForMyBoots · 28/01/2024 13:55

My part of the country isn't Running OK thanks to the Brexit fuckwittery. The UK needs to finish Brexit and get over it before any conversation about rejoining should happen.

YABU OP.

jasflowers · 28/01/2024 13:45

GasPanic · 28/01/2024 12:26

Why would they ?

The country is running OK after Brexit, or at least a lot better than project fear said it was going to be. Most of the issues we have seen re inflation are due to worldwide economic issues and politics and not much to do with Brexit. A significant proportion of Europe is suffering economically.

By saying they will hold another referendum they will just alienate their voters who voted for Brexit and it probably wouldn't gain them any votes with the Labour remainers who would probably vote for them anyway. It's a lose lose.

I think like it or not the Brexit question is over. We are out, neither the Tories or Labour are going to recommend we go back in. And the EU probably wouldn't want us back anyway. It's now more about how we take our relationship with the EU forwards.

"Running OK" wasn't what Boris promised.

We are going to be ever more isolated as the rest of Europe moves on, the latest is the Stockpiling of Medicines by the EU, protecting their own supplies.

What can the UK do to make sure we get the drugs we need, its already a massive problem.
Is the Govt even planning on getting a plan together?

If inflation is nothing to do with Brexit, why is inflation in the EuroZone much lower? 2.9% vs 4%
In percentage terms, thats a big difference.

Leavers might well like to say "oh Brexit is long gone" but its not at all.

bombastix · 28/01/2024 13:45

Good luck with this happening any time soon. We will have regulatory alignment with the EU if Labour get in which is sensible.

I never knew whether Brexit could be a success because the people who put themselves forward to do and lead it were so utterly awful. The real dregs of the Conservatives; no one can say they were the best. We have actually dug a hole for ourselves deliberately. We had an unbelievable deal from the EU and swapped it for... well the z list of the Conservatives

LaTricoteuseVieux · 28/01/2024 12:52

SoDoffYourHat · 28/01/2024 10:21

It depends whether they think their target voters want back in - they won't gamble an election without some evidence of that.

I think we should rejoin and we will rejoin eventually, but not any time soon - it needs a new generation of people who were too young to be part of the referendum to be old enough to vote for it, so it can be adopted as a party strategy without anyone losing face.

Pretty much my views on this.

I think we will quietly be aligning with the EU over the next few years on various things rather than moving apart. And when today's teens are in their 30s enough time will have passed to think about it. Of course the EU and the world will look different, but then so will the UK.

Thise of us who didn't want to leave need to thank the Good Friday Agreement for things not being a hundred times worse. We would have completely isolated ourselves if not for the turmoil it caused for Brexit.

And now negotiations are still ongoing with the DUP about borders and goods etc. so we may be aligning more anyway.

Brexile · 28/01/2024 12:41

@Chersfrozenface You're right, which is why Starmer will have to approach the EU with a view to what's actually in it for them, rather than just a list of unilateral demands. This requires a major mindset shift from the UK government, as opposed to merely a "change of government" with different faces but the same approach. I hope he's up to the challenge.

Chersfrozenface · 28/01/2024 12:31

Brexile · 28/01/2024 12:14

It's worth a go. We won't get the "Swiss option" in one fell swoop for the reasons you mention, but increasing co-operation one sector at a time is a no-brainer. Surely even the more intelligent Leavers must realize this.

That's what Starmer wants to try - to seek a "major rewrite of the Brexit deal".

But as the Institute for Government and others point out, it takes two to negotiate. Starmer can "seek" anything he wants, but why should thf EU agree?

Let's take Starmer's intention to seek a new veterinary deal with Brussels to ease border checks on food. An identical proposal was put forward in 2020 and rejected by the EU.

The EU will not compromise on food or veterinary standards and will want checks to ensure them. See also the EU trade deal with Canada, where the EU does not have to accept growth hormone riddle beef.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/01/2024 12:28

bluewanda · Today 09:28

Brexit happened, we need to get over it and move on.

Why? The nation made a collective mistake. Why can’t it be given the option to put it right?

GasPanic · 28/01/2024 12:26

Why would they ?

The country is running OK after Brexit, or at least a lot better than project fear said it was going to be. Most of the issues we have seen re inflation are due to worldwide economic issues and politics and not much to do with Brexit. A significant proportion of Europe is suffering economically.

By saying they will hold another referendum they will just alienate their voters who voted for Brexit and it probably wouldn't gain them any votes with the Labour remainers who would probably vote for them anyway. It's a lose lose.

I think like it or not the Brexit question is over. We are out, neither the Tories or Labour are going to recommend we go back in. And the EU probably wouldn't want us back anyway. It's now more about how we take our relationship with the EU forwards.

Lonelycrab · 28/01/2024 12:24

And the biometric checks that will be introduced later this year. Theres going to be some very long queues of British holiday makers after that.

DelphineFox · 28/01/2024 12:17

I'm not looking forward to food prices going up when the brexit import controls come in this year

https://www.itv.com/news/2024-01-25/fruit-and-veg-prices-predicted-to-rise-in-uk-when-new-post-brexit-controls-bite

The gift that keeps on giving

Brexile · 28/01/2024 12:14

Chersfrozenface · 28/01/2024 11:51

Well, we won't be getting that. The EU finds all the bilateral agreements with Switzerland overly complicated and a massive PITA. Repeat that? No way on earth.

It's worth a go. We won't get the "Swiss option" in one fell swoop for the reasons you mention, but increasing co-operation one sector at a time is a no-brainer. Surely even the more intelligent Leavers must realize this.

Brexile · 28/01/2024 12:10

YABU unfortunately. A "Rejoin the EU" pledge has only downside risk and no upside. It will immediately antagonize not only leavers but the apathetic types who don't want any radical change. Later on, when the Rejoin promise is shown to be an empty one (because our rejoining depends on the agreement of 27-odd other countries and not merely on a future UK referendum) it will alienate the holdout remainers/rejoiners as well.

The only feasible way that you, personally, can rejoin the EU is if you vote with your feet and move to an EU country. Sadly, this is now easier said than done.

OldWiseNowTwiceTheSize · 28/01/2024 11:56

It would be the ruin of the labour party if they added it to their manifesto. Hardly anyone wants to return to the political bloc. Go ahead Keir but you will be thrashed.

As someone said further up the thread - what is so amazing about the EU just right now that you insist that the UK absolutely has to rejoin it with all the costs and losses that would involve?

DeclineandFall · 28/01/2024 11:52

They can't put it on the manifesto because the election would then turn into an informal Brexit 2 (Nexit?) to the detriment of everything else.

Chersfrozenface · 28/01/2024 11:51

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 28/01/2024 11:39

I am also a full on remainer but I don’t think rejoin is right. I would be up for a Swiss type arrangement made up of bilateral agreements in which we join Schengen, Single Market and Customs Union (which CH is not part of). So not members, but following a precedent to get many of the benefits. It’s a compromise which reflects the referendum result which was won by a hair’s breadth.

Well, we won't be getting that. The EU finds all the bilateral agreements with Switzerland overly complicated and a massive PITA. Repeat that? No way on earth.

AdoraBell · 28/01/2024 11:46

As said earlier on the thread, it wouldn’t be just going back into the EU because we want to. It would be an application and new terms etc

HRTQueen · 28/01/2024 11:41

EasternStandard · 28/01/2024 11:24

When you say closer ties do you mean SM / CU and FOM or something else?

Edited

I am not sure 🤔 I think it will be judged on how the public will take this how the EU will work with us will it impact the following election

ginasevern · 28/01/2024 11:41

Phineyj · 28/01/2024 09:16

There is probably not a perfect overlap between "people who might vote for them" and "people who think that is practical or realistic".

Labour are currently operating on the principle of "vote for us as we're not the other lot" so will avoid saying anything remotely divisive between now and the election.

I think that's the perfect answer and I'm a Labour voter and a remainer.

Lonelycrab · 28/01/2024 11:39

Yabu op.

I was massively against Brexit and think it’s been proven to be a huge mistake- non of the upsides existed (look at all those wonderful trade deals🙄) and it’s clearly come with a massive amount of downsides. But…

Theres no easy ticket to re-entry. It’s taken years for the shit dust to settle, and to open up the whole argument again, possibly for years (perhaps leading to accepting less favourable terms) will not appeal to the electorate at this moment. Maybe once the damage caused by the wrecking ball that the Tories turned into has started to be repaired the question can be asked. But first, a whole raft of problems need addressing, few of which will be solved by simply rejoining, if it were even possible.

So perhaps after one parliament of a (hopefully to soon be elected) Labour govt, but not right now. Just my 2p.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 28/01/2024 11:39

I am also a full on remainer but I don’t think rejoin is right. I would be up for a Swiss type arrangement made up of bilateral agreements in which we join Schengen, Single Market and Customs Union (which CH is not part of). So not members, but following a precedent to get many of the benefits. It’s a compromise which reflects the referendum result which was won by a hair’s breadth.

Taciturn · 28/01/2024 11:25

Because if Labour do this a bunch of (red-wall) voters would immediately switch voting intention to "Reform' which would then place Reform, Labour and Conservatives neck and neck in the polling. Not only would it be a potential election loser at a time when they are ahead in the polls, it would also risk a hung parliament.

Brexit is a very devisive issue strong enough for people to change lifelong tribes. The most enthusiastic pro-brexit votes came from traditional Labour seats, while the middle class tory voters tended towards remain. Yes, some people might have changed their minds on how they voted in the referendum, but this goes both ways, not discounting that some remainers would vote against the policy purely that it is anti-democtatic to over-turn a referendum result with less than 50% of the vote.

EasternStandard · 28/01/2024 11:24

HRTQueen · 28/01/2024 11:22

No of course not Labour need as many as possible of the voters who usually voted Labour but supported Brexit to return to win the next election

closer ties can be made after will a gradual return to the EU

When you say closer ties do you mean SM / CU and FOM or something else?

HRTQueen · 28/01/2024 11:22

No of course not Labour need as many as possible of the voters who usually voted Labour but supported Brexit to return to win the next election

closer ties can be made after will a gradual return to the EU