Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour should add ‘getting us back in the EU’ to their election manifesto

281 replies

bluewanda · 28/01/2024 09:08

We had the referendum, we gave Brexit a go, and nearly 9 years on, I think it’s plain for most people to see that leaving the EU was a massive mistake. Even people I know who voted for Brexit admit that now they wished they hadn’t, given the shitshow that has unfolded since. So, why not nip it in the bud and get back in the EU ASAP? If Labour would add it to their election manifesto that would speed up the process, as we’d have a mandate by the end of this year. So why don’t they?

OP posts:
BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 12:45

@IcedPurple

For a generation, yes. Once the boomers die out in sufficient numbers (20 years or so), the electoral calculus will be very much in the rejoin direction.

IcedPurple · 29/01/2024 12:42

Rightly or wrongly, the Good Ship EU has sailed.

CoatRack · 29/01/2024 12:39

OnGoldenPond · 29/01/2024 12:22

@CoatRack when considering taking a decision which will fundamentally change the nature of the country and its relationship with the rest of the world, which will significantly change everyone's lives in ways that are probably not even apparent yet, forever, I think you really need a thumping, overwhelming mandate from the population!

If we can't get that mandate, the status quo should always be the fallback position as it doesn't throw everyone's lives up in the air.

So you agree that we shouldn't have been in the EU from the start then?

If you were PM, how much of a mandate would you have required for the following:
Abolition of slave trade
Universal suffrage
War/interventions for/against mid-century Germans, Iraq, Ukraine etc.
Levels of immigration over the last 20 years

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 12:31

keffie12 · 29/01/2024 12:26

@ScierraDoll why the heck don't you want Kier to be the next P.M? He will be a decent steady ship and rebuild. Totally decent guy who some people have the wrong idea about. He is a steady family man who has a moral compass.

Fine, he might come across as boring to some. He isn’t though. He is the quiet man who gets on with it.

There is a lot of depth to him. You dont see if you only look at mainstream.

If I want to be entertained, I'll go to the theatre.

Its funny how the idiots would rather have a comic for a PM than decent people with values and strong work ethics.

Even if you don't support their politics, the country will be better run with people like this in Government than so called "characters"

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 12:31

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 12:23

@EasternStandard

What an odd selection of food. Those come from Spain when they have capacity for it and produce enough. Due to climate change, there are now shortages which drives prices up and they have to ration the supply. They will first send nationally (Spain), export to EU, and then UK (so we dont get the freshest produce). Thats also why the UK needs to import a big % of its food supply.

Now, try that again with FRUIT.

Avocado?
Strawberries?
Raspberries?
Blueberries?
Bananas?

When you don't have enough people to pick the fruits, and greenhouses become too expensive, you have to import them from cheaper countries.

Thats where Peru, South Africa, Chile etc come in.

What an odd selection of food

Are you judging my fridge contents 😬 It’s not that ‘out there’ it’s just food

The corn is a contentious issue as 6 year old dd was adamant she wanted it and it’s still there weeks later

Carrots, cucumber are standard though as vegetables dc will eat. Lettuce less so bit for a particular meal

I’m not sure we go big on fruit in winter so only apples atm.

So I’ll add apples - Italy

Oh hang on Ocado easy peeler citrus - Spain

I don’t actually disagree with some of your points, maybe for another post. But looking it up out of interest

keffie12 · 29/01/2024 12:26

@ScierraDoll why the heck don't you want Kier to be the next P.M? He will be a decent steady ship and rebuild. Totally decent guy who some people have the wrong idea about. He is a steady family man who has a moral compass.

Fine, he might come across as boring to some. He isn’t though. He is the quiet man who gets on with it.

There is a lot of depth to him. You dont see if you only look at mainstream.

If I want to be entertained, I'll go to the theatre.

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 12:25

SomeCatFromJapan · 29/01/2024 12:15

I'm not that fussed about rejoining proper, but it would be nice if we could have the free movement of goods and people again, like Switzerland or Norway.

Yes a wise Government would have held back on Brexit until negotiated a EFTA style deal.

Unfortunately May did what was best for her party instead of the country, aided by the far right ERG.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 12:23

@EasternStandard

What an odd selection of food. Those come from Spain when they have capacity for it and produce enough. Due to climate change, there are now shortages which drives prices up and they have to ration the supply. They will first send nationally (Spain), export to EU, and then UK (so we dont get the freshest produce). Thats also why the UK needs to import a big % of its food supply.

Now, try that again with FRUIT.

Avocado?
Strawberries?
Raspberries?
Blueberries?
Bananas?

When you don't have enough people to pick the fruits, and greenhouses become too expensive, you have to import them from cheaper countries.

Thats where Peru, South Africa, Chile etc come in.

OnGoldenPond · 29/01/2024 12:22

@CoatRack when considering taking a decision which will fundamentally change the nature of the country and its relationship with the rest of the world, which will significantly change everyone's lives in ways that are probably not even apparent yet, forever, I think you really need a thumping, overwhelming mandate from the population!

If we can't get that mandate, the status quo should always be the fallback position as it doesn't throw everyone's lives up in the air.

SomeCatFromJapan · 29/01/2024 12:15

I'm not that fussed about rejoining proper, but it would be nice if we could have the free movement of goods and people again, like Switzerland or Norway.

ScierraDoll · 29/01/2024 12:11

Oh please let them add it, it might be the only way to keep Starmer out. Not that I think the Cons will do any better at running the country but they are the least worse alternative.
In what way has leaving the EU not worked? Admittedly we had an awful leaving deal but that was because our negotiators and Politicians rolled over at every EU demand. If we had adopted a quid pro quo for every EU proposal things would be a lot better.
Meanwhile most EU countries are failing economically and voting for populist right wing parties. Here in the UK we are very very slightly better economically and are getting ready to vote in a PM who a few years ago was telling us Corbyn was our saviour.
Covid and the ludicrous over reaction in terms of lock downs and hand outs did far more damage than leaving a failing bureaucratic economic system.

ChrisS36 · 29/01/2024 12:10

If they have a manifesto to rejoin without a referendum the Conservative Party would simply add a manifesto commitment to leave again if re-elected.
The EU would never risk going through that again.

ChrisS36 · 29/01/2024 12:08

Apply to rejoin and accept the Euro as our currency. Do you see that happening?

DdraigGoch · 29/01/2024 12:04

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 11:52

As you cannot pre enter passport/ biometric data (within EES) and the data is captured at point of entry in to the EU, i'm not sure how you think this will reduce delay?

Border control can always be re imposed at anytime, in late 2010 we were delayed entering Italy from Austria, again checking lorries for migrants.

I see a lot more empty shelves at my Supermarket than pre Covid, however, i don't know if that is due to Brexit or Supermarkets having less robust supply chains?
e.g if there are shortages within EU suppliers, they favour their own countries first, UK gets what is left.

Edited

Once you're registered, you're registered and the data will be kept for three years. So anyone making a repeat visit during that time can scan their passport, scan their fingerprints and be on their way. There will be much less reliance upon humans to check passports and add up the dates on the stamps.

The worst delays I've had at a Eurostar terminal were at Brussels Midi. Only three booths manned and no e-gates. By contrast at Gare de Nord and St Pancras I've been able to use both British and French e-gates without a problem.

ParrotCatDog · 29/01/2024 12:01

How would it benefit us to rejoin?

AndThatWasNY · 29/01/2024 12:00

I wish they would. They won't.
If it takes 10 years it will fit in well with my plans to retire in Greece and DD to move to Germany after uni. Instead I will be too old and DD will have settled here.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 11:59

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 11:53

@DdraigGoch

Next time you are in ASDA pay more attention to the provenance of the fresh food.

You will notice it comes from places like:

Peru
South Africa
Chile

Etc..

The problems with sourcing food from so far away (vs EU) is freshness. When they arrive in the UK you only have a few days before they go bad (you see this a lot now in supermarkets) vs a week previously.

That issue forces up prices. And we have less choices to boot as well.

Just because I found this interesting I have looked at my fridge items

Cucumber - Spain
Gem lettuce - Spain
Corn on cob - Kent
Carrots - Herts U.K.
Celery - Spain

Either via Sainsbury’s or Ocado

Chersfrozenface · 29/01/2024 11:59

Re EES

Well it will reduce waiting times to an extent eventually.

But not until everyone who wants to travel has either put in their details at thr gates and/,or ETIAS final gets going and everyone has realized they need to input their details beforehand and stump ip the fee

Provided the electronic gates work, of course. The gates that are supposed to reaf biometric passports at airports can bd glitchy enough

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 11:55

GasPanic · 29/01/2024 11:41

+1.

Have been to 3 different supermarkets in the past 2 weeks and have not noticed anything missing and the shelves were full.

I do expect that what is happening in the Gulf might lead to some shortages along the line, but that will probably be more stuff like TVs than FMCG like foods.

Project fear continues ...

Price rises not shortages, Asia isn't shipping less TVs to Europe, they are just going to take a few days longer to get here.

Project Fear? FFS.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 11:53

@DdraigGoch

Next time you are in ASDA pay more attention to the provenance of the fresh food.

You will notice it comes from places like:

Peru
South Africa
Chile

Etc..

The problems with sourcing food from so far away (vs EU) is freshness. When they arrive in the UK you only have a few days before they go bad (you see this a lot now in supermarkets) vs a week previously.

That issue forces up prices. And we have less choices to boot as well.

jasflowers · 29/01/2024 11:52

DdraigGoch · 29/01/2024 11:27

I don't often use supermarkets (I prefer to support small businesses where possible) but I went into the local ASDA last week and didn't notice anything missing.

Of course there was an egg shortage in supermarkets at one point but that was because the supermarkets don't pay their suppliers enough, there was no shortage in independent retailers.

EES will automate passport control and reduce the queues at St Pancras. I feel it worth pointing out that my recent train from Vienna to Amsterdam/Brussels (so all within Schengen) was delayed by more than an hour at Freilassing where the German police held it to check the train for illegal migrants - apparently now common practice. Schengen is not as seamless as it once was.

As you cannot pre enter passport/ biometric data (within EES) and the data is captured at point of entry in to the EU, i'm not sure how you think this will reduce delay?

Border control can always be re imposed at anytime, in late 2010 we were delayed entering Italy from Austria, again checking lorries for migrants.

I see a lot more empty shelves at my Supermarket than pre Covid, however, i don't know if that is due to Brexit or Supermarkets having less robust supply chains?
e.g if there are shortages within EU suppliers, they favour their own countries first, UK gets what is left.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 11:49

@GasPanic

Food is not the major problem. You can substitute foods.

Now run that supply logic again with medication.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 11:47

@Whatisaflatwhite

You keep forgetting that the UK would not be able to pass the financial conditions and it requires all 27 countries agreeing to it. Every single one. The UK has not exactly made friends over the last decade there.

The UK will only start thinking about rejoining once it hits rock bottom. This will be within the next 5 years by my estimation.

The country is already severely economically damaged, with a failing infrastructure, lots of unproductive people (old and young), and high taxes on the productive (who are now choosing to work less).

The final nail will be when about 20% of the local authorities start going bankrupt (section 114) due to social care costs.

I give it 5 years or less. Then the population will have to decide if it wants to get even poorer or not.

GasPanic · 29/01/2024 11:41

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 11:28

Same

+1.

Have been to 3 different supermarkets in the past 2 weeks and have not noticed anything missing and the shelves were full.

I do expect that what is happening in the Gulf might lead to some shortages along the line, but that will probably be more stuff like TVs than FMCG like foods.

Project fear continues ...

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 11:28

EssexMan55 · 29/01/2024 11:24

This is demonstrably not true. Occasionally there are a few empty shelves in thie supermarkets I go to, but this is not usual. Typical weekly shop can get everything I want.

Same